Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Posts

Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#1

Mike Stafford

Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Mike Stafford

>Jamie Donaldson sent me a nice big stick of very spalted live oak a while back and I had to decide what I was going to do to use it. I finally decided to use several gallons of CA and sanding sealer to consolidate the wood. I rough turned the blank and soaked the wood with sanding sealer and/or CA and repeated the process as I turned closer and closer to finished dimensions.

I found it difficult to cut a decent flange on the body of the box and turning the lid thin was almost impossible as it became very chippy. I decided to use something contrasting thus the wenge. It is a piston fit lid and is snug enough to stay in place if you lift the box by the lid yet not overly difficult to remove.

The box is 2 1/2" tall and 3 3/4" in diameter. I would appreciate your thoughts on replacing the lid with another wood such as blackwood. Maybe you have some other wood suggestions.

Inspiration for this form was taken from Matthew Hill's wonderful boxes which I admire greatly. He probably makes the most beautiful boxes out there.

All comments appreciated...


img

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#2

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Ron McKinley

>Looks great as is Mike.......Ron

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#3

Bob Moffett

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Bob Moffett

>I like it just the way it is.

Bob

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#4

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Don wilcut

>Great box, Mike.

Have you started on the platter box yet?

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Mike Stafford

>No platter boxes yet but that doesn't mean there isn't one in the future, Don. I did turn a platter from one of John's cedar blanks just so I wouldn't forget everything I learned.

Now I need to figure out a way to photograph my platters. My photo set up is too small for the platters. You don't really need a big photo cube for boxes. Bet you didn't know that....;-))

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#6

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

david

>Mike, as a fan of your body of work, I think that this particular piece would be enhanced with a lid that had more substance to it--by way of mass, or perhaps a finial of some sort. No problems with the use of the Wenge, but IMHO and for what it's worth, the bottom seems to overpower the top.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Mike Stafford

>David, you and my wife are like minds. I knew I should have listened to her. A man can get into trouble by not listening to his wife....

Thanks David.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#8

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>love it

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#9

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Cyril Griesbach

>Very nice. No need to change anything.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#10

How are your photoshop skills?

David Walser

>I agree with the other David (and your wife) that the bottom overpowers the top. I can't decide if a darker color top, but the same shape and size, would be an improvement or not. I tend to think a darker wood would give the top more visual weight and would do the trick. I really like the box's shape, so I wouldn't want to add a finial if a change in color would work. So, if you could simply use photoshop (or its equivalent) to post a picture with the box with a black top, that would be both interesting and helpful.

If black or much darker brown works, perhaps you could just dye the wenge?

Note: I really like the box as is. Right now it just gives off the same vibe as a fat man wearing a too small hat. (Think Oliver Hardy of Laurel and Hardy fame.)

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#11

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Don wilcut

>Mike, just divide the platter in four equal parts and take four photos. That should do it.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#12

Mike Stafford

Almost non-existent....

Mike Stafford

>I don't have Photoshop or the skills needed to manipulate the color as you suggest. I do have two big boxes of crayons if that will help....Thanks Carole and Molly!

My wife's suggestion is that the lid needs a higher dome shape. Her objection is in the height of the lid and not the color. My thought was that the lid was not dark enough.

I hate to cut into one of my larger blackwood blanks for a lid but I may if I decide that I can't live with what I have.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#13

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Ken

>You did that wood proud,Beautifull piece

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#14

Mike Hunter

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Mike Hunter

>Probably too late ... is there anyway to turn this into an Orts Bowl? It is a super piece of wood.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#15

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Dick Coers

>I think the choices of wood are brilliant. The wenge is dark with tan stripes, the oak is just the opposite. I studied the shape and wonder if the lid had been slightly larger in diameter, it might have offset what seems like a long neck to me. I really like it.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#16

Re: How are your photoshop skills?

Carole Valentine

>Mike, I really don't think it's the color so much. Here is a photoshop with a darker lid. There is something about the shape of the bottom that bothers me just a tiny bit but I just can't say what it is. (I know that's a great help! LOL) It could be camera angle, but I think it might be that the oak part seems a tad to tall or too puffy at the top? At any rate, it is subtle enough that I can't put my finger on it! :) Will fool with it a bit in PS tomorrow and see if I can figure it out.


img

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#17

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Mike a very white plain wood like holly would make a striking contrast.

John

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#18

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

GaryG in MD

>Mike, I love your work, but I'm going to have to take the minority opinion on this one. I don't like the top. To my eye, the top and the bottom just don't go together. The bottom is spectacular. I think it stands alone. I would like the bottom better as a bowl. JMO, Gary

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#19

Mike Stafford

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

Mike Stafford

>Remove the lid and it is an orts bowl Mike. This box happens to have an infitting lid so there is no flange on the top of the body.

Re: Spalted live oak and wenge box....

#20

after reading all the above,

Thad

>I love the piece, but think the woods do not fit one another (though I'm sure it is a perfect fit);)

The spalt pattern is too random to fit with what I see as straight grain in the wenge, and the spalt dominates the grain in the oak (at least from what I can tell from the image.)

What about an oak top a bit larger, with pyrography or carving to help it blend with the body?

My 2 cents,

Thad