>Years ago, I attended a talk by noted furniture maker, Thomas Moser. I remember that he said that -- EVEN UNDER WATER -- his tung oil-soaked rags got hot. I've been storing my oily rags in a bucket of water and never had any problems. But that talk by Moser has always haunted me. Is it, or is it not, safe to store oily rags under water?
>Seems unlikely that they would even get hot, since oxygen is required for the oil to cure. Certainly would not ignite if under water since there is no available oxygen to feed spontaneous combustion. FWIW I store my oily rags in a metal container with a metal lid. This limits the oxygen available, and should contain any fire if it should ignite.
>Think about it. Water boils at 212 F; whereas, the ignition temperature for cotton sheeting is 464 F. Unless all the water is boiled off by some heat source, there is no way for the cotton rags to ignite.
>My first thought is that it is impossible because of the lack of oxygen to enable the curing process. However, strange things can happen.
While I have very little concern about this, IMO, good practice says that a metal container with a lid is the way to go if you are going to keep the rags indoors.
I put my rags in a large coffee can that is half filled with water and then put its plastic lid on. The coffee can is stored in a metal container with a lid which in my case is an old metal shop-vac cannister which has had the holes patched over.
>Won't get into the water question. Anytime I use oil and rag when I'm finished I lay it spread open on the concrete floor several feet from anything. Because it's not bunched up it probably would not get hot, with nothing around it even if it does burst into flames it won't start a fire. By putting every oily rag out like that I don't have to remember if it's the kind of oil that might start a fire.
>No way would I go through the mess of having to submerge the oiled rags in water....rarely do I generate that many rags, and I'd never use a covered metal can that had "To be emptied daily"..... always thought they were a fire hazard. Besides, keeping out the air only delays the curing process; does the oil actually cure under water?
I do the same as John and spread the rags & paper towels out flat, however not directly on the concrete floor - I have a dedicated piece of sheet aluminum that I spread the rags out on, which lies on the concrete floor of my shop (or garage). It doesn't get the concrete messy with oil finish; the aluminum quickly dissipates any heat generated and allows rapid "curing" (polymerization) of the oil because there is good air contact with all parts of the rag. I've never felt any warmth when I've treated the rags in this manner. I HAVE deliberately wadded up oily rags and started a fire spontaneously (in an old BBQ grill out in the back yard) just to see that it would work - it DOES!! (Yes, I was that "pyro-kid" at Boy Scout Camp whose fires were often 3 or 4 times the size needed to get the job done; started council fires with magnesium powder, etc.)
Another guy I know takes his used oily rags and hangs them outside on a "clothesline" made of metal wire until they're cured; when they're good and stiff, he just throws them out.
I think the water treatment is overkill unless you're generating LOTS of oily rags....
>They go right in the garbage when I am done. The garbage is a disposable supermarket plastic bag, and it goes right out to the garbage. Never had a second thought...
>Steve I watched a video on an oily rag tossed in the garbage. It burned the bag and would have burned anything else nearby. That's when I started spreading mine out.
Spread them out (outdoors) to dry overnight, THEN throw them in the trash. I actually had a linseed soaked rag ignite when I pulled it out of my rear pants pocket when it became uncomfortably warm.
>When I lived down south, I used to throw them in the gravel drive outside my shop. Next day I picked up the dry rags and tossed in the trash. Up here in the north, I spread them out, only one layer thick, on the concrete laundry sink. Still toss the dry rags next day.
If they're spread out, they can't hold enough heat to build ignition while drying.
Metal can, under water, whatever, they've got to dry some time. Get them dry safely and they're harmless.
>I do the same Ray. If only a couple of small rags or paper towels, I may not light them until later. If they do combust on their own, they are in a container ment to handle fire.
>In my woods class at the high school where I teach we have a can with a lid that is made specifically for oily rag storage. A couple of weeks ago the students had filled it so full of oily rags that the top didn't close tight....it was about an inch up. The rags had started to burn and the smoke was rolling out of the can. That made a believer out of them. When I was in college I also saw a pile of oily rags crumpled up in the middle of a concrete floor burst into flames. They need to be properly taken care of. For any non-believers, I can tell you that you are taking a huge chance if you don't do something to deprive them of oxygen.
This is precisely why the "oily rag can" is an accident waiting to happen.... These are supposed to be emptied "every day" - which often does not happen. If large amounts of rags are collected over a short time, emptying at the end of one day may not even be soon enough! Even if you do empty the can at a reasonable time interval, what THEN do you do with the oily rags you've removed from the can? You're right back at step 1 without the problem being resolved!
With 20% oxygen all around us, it's simply not very efficient to rely on "depriving oxygen" to the rags with any kind of a user-friendly container. Since the polymerization of "drying" oils is an exothermic process, it is far easier to allow the heat to dissipate to the point where it never reaches ignition temperature of the oil. If no heat, then no fire, even in an oxygen environment. Allow the oil in the rags to polymerize without heat build-up (laying them flat, hanging up to dry, etc.), and the problem is solved.
I'm surprised that the 'oily rag can' is still permitted as a solution to disposing of oil-containing rags.... In my opinion it only makes matters worse by collecting more and more combustible fuel in a small volume, and serves to contain any heat build-up and concentrate it so that the temperature can easily rise. It just doesn't make sense.
>I usually don't use rags, per se, but let's consider paper towels as the same. I usually do what John does -- isolating single sheets to dry where they will do no harm, and disposing of them after they are cured (about 2 - 4 days).
How many people just burn them? This can't be environmentally sound, but when I've used a larger batch of PT's, I sometimes use them to start the wood stove, or toss the cured ones into a bucket and burn them. As an environmentalist, that creates a dilemma -- make some pollution?, or risk burning down the barn? Dunking them in water doesn't really solve the problem -- now you have toxic, gunky water to get rid of, too.
Has anyone figured out the impact of burning some of these polymerizing oils? There must be some real nasty stuff in there. I usually use synthetic Urethane Oil from Craft Supplies, and recently used up a can of Watco Danish Oil. For most bowls and food items, I use Tried & True, which is non-toxic right out of the can (polymerized raw linseed oil and beeswax), and doesn't worry me in the least. Any oil that polymerizes must generate some heat in the process, so these rags may also be a fire hazard, but I have no qualms about burning them if loaded with Tried & True (or T&T, hmmmmm....).
T&T Original is used in very small quantities, so there isn't much waste. It is slow to cure, and produces a low-luster sheen, much like Walnut Oil or other softer finishes. It is not a good choice where high gloss is wanted, but that isn't the sort of finish I usually look for. I might just stick with the non-toxic finishes in the future and avoid the environmental problems altogether.
>A friend of mine who works in woodworking shop recently told the story about how it was the shop's SOP to put oily finish rags in one of those fireproof metal cans designated for such waste. However upon opening it one time to add another rag it flashed immediately into a fireball as the heat was still generated in the can and all it needed was the oxygen which was supplied when the lid was opened.
He says that now they spread all the rags out on the driveway or sidewalk to dry in the sun before putting them in the waste can.
I have always spread them out in the sun to dry. When they are hard I throw them in the trash.