>When a piece explodes on the lathe, it is not very presentable. Have many of those, but not worth a photo. I was on the white diamond buff when the top of this 8" x 8" NIP piece caught on the upper half of the rapidly spinning cloth wheel. So close, yet disaster can strike at any time, and all the time spent is for naught. Time spent finishing usually dwarfs the time spent turning. Sort of reminds me of the signature missing puzzle pieces that Art Liestman does, so I thought I would share my grief...
>Interestingly, that's exactly how I make my pieces. You just didn't get lucky with the breaking pattern. Keep trying! I have to break dozens of pieces to get the right shape holes. :)
>As one who likes to turn green to final thickness, I have to keep telling myself: 1) Pine is a SOFT wood. 2) Wood flexes more when it is wet. 3) Have to allow for sanding away tool marks and scratches. I asked around for advice when I turned my first NIP bowl. An experienced turner said he turned to 3/16" to allow for sanding. The exploded piece from the white diamond buff would have survived if the walls were more substantial.
Sorry about the "last stage" tragedy - been there - done that....
There certainly seems to be enough of the bowl left intact that some judicious carving and/or piercing might salvage this piece from being a total loss.
'Twere it me with this piece, I could see a sinusoidal carved bowl rim that starts at the top of the rim on the intact side, swoops down to include the space created by the "eliminated" pieces, and back to the rim. Perhaps some modifications to the existing rim to blend into the needed carved area, and you're there. I've saved and sold more than one similarly damaged piece by simply modifying one or more of the major features a bit to accommodate the offending areas.
Remember, expertise in this game is knowing how to recover from one's mistakes, and to make it look like the resulting form was originally planned that way. You still have a lot to go with, so use this as a 'creative opportunity'...it would be a shame to lose the NIP piece and all of the time you have invested in it.
"'Twere it me with this piece, I could see a sinusoidal carved bowl rim that starts at the top of the rim on the intact side, swoops down to include the space created by the "eliminated" pieces, and back to the rim. Perhaps some modifications to the existing rim to blend into the needed carved area, and
you're there. I've saved and sold more than one similarly damaged piece by simply modifying one or more of the major features a bit to accommodate the offending areas. "
Took the liberty of tweeking the original photo to show something like what Rob described - a picture being worth a thousand words. I skipped the sinusoidal idea and just did about half of that idea.
Opens up the piece so you can see some of the outside and some of the inside - simultaneously - from the side
Sorry to see the broken piece. I've had the same experience with other pices, but fortunately, all of the NIP pieces I've gotten from you have survived!
Like you said, it is pine and it is soft!
Take care,
Mike
Soccer instead of lathe time this weekend in Apex, NC
>There is a great design opportunity here, not a disaster. I just did a major search because only last week I saw a beautiful bowl that was cut out with either piercing or burning around the back side and down both sides in the front. I can't find it, it was either in del Mano or another gallery site. That wood and form is too lovely to call it a waste!
Thanks for the photo - pretty much exactly what I had in mind; wish I had that kind of photo-altering skill! I'd have started the 'rim drop' back a bit further, but this is the same idea.... Sinusoidal rim would break-up the "hard" line a bit, and make the interaction between inside and outside somewhat more complex.
BTW - If this proves we think alike, you should be very afraid.... seek help now....!
The PhotoShop tweeking really isn't that difficult.
Bring the image into PS with Cut & Paste
Select - with one of the Selection Tools (rectangle, circle, straight line polygon or freehand "lasso") the area you want to work on.
Copy the selected area
Paste the selected area - and it automatically goes on a new layer so it's now separate from the original image.
Select the Clone tool (rubber stamp icon) then pick a Brush Size for it from the Brush menu of choices.
Clone over what you want removed - filling in the removed old image info with the cloned pixels.
When you're done "removing" select the Dodge tool and a small brush size to lighten one side of the new rim.
Choose the Burn tool and a small brush size and darken the other side of the new rim.
You're DONE!
The trickiest part is trying to draw - with basically a pencil stuck in a potato (mouse). I've got a pen tablet, but wore out the nylon "lead".
I don't think running a sinusoidal wave all the way around the piece would be a good idea - you'd lose a knot or two - which is the appeal of NIP apparently. I'd stick with "modify just what needs to be fixed" rather than change the whole piece just for symetry reasons.
As for like minds thinking alike - the descriptors for suggested changes to recover from the results of The Incident were pretty clear - at least to me. If this kind of thinking is insane - count me in. When you start doing pieces that used micro-robots perhaps you should seek help.
As for the AAW Symposium, I have enough trouble making 5 year interval class reunions and after being involved in doing a three day free rock concert - for about 80,000 - I've O.D.ed on crowds - even a large crowd of wood turners.
And flying lost it's luster after 17 hour to and from europe - even when it meant trucking around for a month with my youngest who'd been in Munich for a year and had been to most of the places we went to together.
Seeing Michaelangelo's The David , up close, was my motivator. I'm sure there will be some very good turners and plenty of nice turnings to see - but not up to The David. Son and I both swore we could see his chest move - breathing.
Enjoy - and post pics - please.
ps - tweeked the image some more to make the change you have in mind - I think