Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

What's your idea of "elegant?"

Posts

What's your idea of "elegant?"

#1

Ellis Walentine

What's your idea of "elegant?"

Ellis Walentine

>Hello folks,

I'm really excited about the turning contest that comes due in September. I read the fine print (uh, I wrote the fine print) and I'm not eligible to enter the contest, but that hasn't stopped me from thinking about the loosely-defined term "elegant." What is elegance anyhow, and how does it evidence itself in a turned object?

I was looking at the sample pictures on the contest information page, and it's clear that a lot of wildly different forms might be described as elegant. We purposely left the contest definitions vague so as not to prejudice anyone's creative process or personal definition of elegance. I guess the judges figure they'll know it when they see it. But, I think we need more examples to mull over. Do any of you have photos of turned objects you consider elegant? Any descriptions or aspects of elegance that might be informative to someone considering entering the contest?

I think that discussions like this might help us recognize not only elegance, but also some of the "inelegant" forms and concepts we (speaking for myself) labor with for lack of a better understanding of what elegance is all about.

Ellis

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#2

JL

Can I enter furniture?

JL

>

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#3

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Ellis,

Great question! I look forward to the contest.

To me, elegance always implies a smoothness of form. I think an elegant piece just "flows" nicely. I don't think of hard, sharp angles and think "elegant". They can be part of the piece, but not a defining element of the piece. It can be thick or thin, but I think it has to flow. Supple and smooth.

Not to put anyone on the spot, but by and large I think Wally's pieces are elegant.

Great stuff, cannot wait to see what others come up with.

Mike

Wood time is Good time in Apex, NC

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#4

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Good question Ellis,

For me it's Form fitting Function, without the function being the dominating aspect of the design...

Take care,

Jim

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#5

Steven Antonucci

If I want to touch it, but don't because I am...

Steve antonucci

>somehow "held back" from it.

Slender

Curvatious

Fragile

Refined

Whatever wins, I'm guessing it won't be charred and chainsaw sculpted...

Steve

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#6

ebd

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

ebd

>Of the 11 pieces shown only 4 at most are elegant in my not so humble opinion. Some are seriously bland and are included only because of the turners "name". Some are just plain tacky. Also, just because something is difficult technically doesn't qualify it as elegant. Nor does being over the top bizare, in fact quite the opposite. Sorry to be so honest.

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: If I want to touch it, but don't because I am.

Rob Wallace

>Steve A. wrote:

"If I want to touch it, but don't because I am......somehow "held back" from it.

Slender

Curvatious

Fragile

Refined"

Kind of sounds like a really hot "supermodel".....Elle McPherson, Christy Brinkley, Kate Moss, etc....

..... am I sensing some kind of connection here??

Rob Wallace

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#8

Steven Antonucci

Drop Kate Moss from the list...

Steve antonucci

>but yeah...

When I think of elegant, there's a certain amount of "unattainability" that goes with it. It's almost better to look at than to touch, and an allure that you "may not be worthy" of having it... whether it's fear of rejection or self doubt. Almost as if by touching it, you might "ruin it".

I don't know that I have "elegant" pieces in me (by my own definition). It's going to be interesting to see...

Steve

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#9

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville

>All of Cindy Drozda's work.

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#10

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Oops....I thought it was about turnings by elegant people. Now that I think of it, I don't qualify either way. :-(

Tom

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: If I want to touch it, but don't because I am.

Keith Tompkins

>Notice how Steve seems to be describing feminine characteristics. People tend to personify objects, so it is natural to think in terms of masculine and feminine when viewing them. When we think in terms of femininity, the words Steve mentioned come to mind, while masculinity brings up thoughts such as muscular, angular, stocky, brutish, etc. So, if the goal is to create an elegant object, then striving to create an overall feminine appearance would seem logical. Artists and craftspeople have been emulating the female form for centuries; the furniture of Thomas Chippendale is a prime example of this.

I turned and carved this piece after observing a manikin draped with a ruffled dress.


img

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#12

I've never been described as elegant or eloquent.

john lucas

>

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#13

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

charlie belden

>When I think of elegant I think of Audrey Hepburn. Not a classic beauty, certainly not "stacked", somewhat fragile at first glance but with a quiet strength and goodness that becomes obvious, not ostentateous or provocative but fairly simple and plain, yet beautiful in her unique way - and evocative. She had a balance to her life - which tended to lean towards others rather than to herself. She had the ability to draw you in - or draw you out. And given all those qualities, I most admire her most for her genuine caring for others - her kids and kids who need help and someone to care - and her work with UNICEF.

But when I think of elegance I also think of Einstein's E=MC^2 - a very complex concept, boiled down to it's simplest yet complete essence. Math and science are full of elegant equations and concepts.

When I think of 2D images many oriental brush paintings come to mind - sumie. With a few quick brush strokes just enough of an idea or scene is provided the viewer to evoke their filliing in what's not on the paper - based on their own life experiences and mood at the time of viewing.

When I think of poetry and elegance I think of Haiku. Like sumie brush paintings, the boiled down essence is provided in a very few words or syllables - again evoking thoughts and feelings from the reader by leaving room for interpretation and perception.

Clay Foster's recent Ripples piece meets my criteria of elegant, though his pieces aren't normally thought of as delicate or fragile, two other words often associated with elegant.

Most of Cindy Drozda's pieces, especially her finials, are elegant.

Bin Pho's earlier pieces were, I believe, really quite elegant. His more recent works have become more like theatrical sets - in miniature.

The German turner Schreiber's dynamic turnings are also elegant in their appaarent simplicity.

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: I've never been described as elegant or eloque

Keith Tompkins

>No John, you are not! But, you are a handsome devil!

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#15

Ellis Walentine

Good points

Ellis Walentine

>I like the metaphor of the ruffled dress, Keith. It helps that your carving is elegant in its own right.

Ellis

Re: What's your idea of "elegant?"

#16

Ellis Walentine

Understatement....

Ellis Walentine

>... seems to be the unifying principle in your examples, Charlie -- a Zen-like quality of suggesting something rather than hitting you over the head with it.

Good examples. Thanks.

Ellis