Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Humor me

Posts

Re: Humor me

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: Workmanship of risk

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Ellis. I'm not taking sides on this issue, but you just nailed the reason many of us became turners in the first place. The shapes we create are entirely up to us; we aren't constrained to straight lines created by the table saw, nor are we limited by the profile of a shaper cutter or router bit. Your reference to David Pye is right on...sometimes we must push ourselves to create works beyond our known abilities. Do we strive for safety and comfort, or do we dare to take risks?

Re: Humor me

#27

Humor me. Lyle, did you hear about ...

Ed Moore

>the nun in the taxicab? Well, maybe this isn't the time and place to tell you that one.

Thank you for stating your opinion, which is straightforward and practical. There will always be people with different views who do not express themselves well on a public forum. You have given good advice, but many folks have shown that they lack the ability to read/listen and take in what you have said, mull it over, and then apply it as it fits their needs. Their need to "have their say" far exceeds their willingness to do what I just said and to think things through before opening the mouth.

Far too many aspects of life are becoming like "Reality Shows" - which have little to do with reality. I am currently counseling a son who is dealing with a fiancee' who is treating the "marriage" like a reality show. Sheesh! Get a life! The more I read on woodturning forums the more I see "Reality Show", where folks are letting their personalities get in the way of simple discourse on a woodturning procedure. This is about a woodturning procedure - it's not a life-style nor anything which requires metaphysical analysis.

When all else fails, read "Pickles" on the comics page.

Ed

Re: Humor me

#28

Re: ??????????

Russ Fairfield

>Am I missing something here.

Reading some of these messages gives me the impression that using a captured bar and a laser light removes all risk and reduces the hollowing process to something similar to using a CNC milling machine.

I want one of those risk-free tools. Where can I buy one of them?? The one I am using does none of those things. The captured bar reduces the twisting force, and the laser light is a good caliper; but it ain't automatic. I still have to control it. I still have to have a knowledge of cutting tools and how they work. I still have all of the sights and sounds of cutting wood. I can still ruin a piece of wood with a single twitch of inattention. And, I still have to duck the flying wood when there is a disaster. The only thing I am getting out of it is that hollowing is a helluva lot easier than it used to be.

Re: Humor me

#29

Ellis Walentine

It's relative, Russ

Ellis Walentine

>That's what I was trying to say. Sorry if it came across differently. It's not a black and white issue at all. Use a captured system if it suits you. Hollowing by hand is different, that's all, and I would venture to say that it is a less controlled process than the captured systems I've seen. That doesn't make it better or worse in any absolute sense. It's up to what the individual prefers at a given moment or on a given project. Everyone's mileage varies.

Ellis

Re: Humor me

#30

Re: Humor me, critics

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Some here said I'm wrong and others say I'm out of line. I could be wrong but I doubt it. If I'm out of line it's because I rarely get in line, or blindly follow anyone. Maybe I'm not politically correct? But is this a free country, or what? Everyone should have the right to defend or condemn any one's words and tone. I considered my words carefully, gave my opinion and stand by it. "He sounded condescending to me." And speculated he MAY be more interested in selling his equip. And yes, I have met him -- even took a class with him. I have no axe to grind, but may not have the lofty opinion of him that some of you appear to profess.

Re: Humor me

#31

john,your talent is amazing

robert davis

>the next thing will be a capyured system for your microscopic turnings?

Re: Humor me

#32

AMEN, russ..you said it all

robert davis

>

Re: Humor me

#33

Ellis Walentine

Expressing points of view

Ellis Walentine

>Opinions are welcome here. That's what discussions are all about. Discussions head south when we can't conscience other points of view. Lyle said he couldn't think of a good argument for hand-held blind hollowing. Other people, including me, contributed what they felt were good arguments for hand-held blind hollowing. Not everyone always expresses their opinions perfectly well, and sometimes they're misconstrued. That's to be avoided whenever possible. We're all friends here.

I'm not sure what a Reality Show is, because I don't watch TV; but everyone has reasons for making the choices they make in this life; call it personality if you like, but I don't think anyone wants other people making their decisions for them. And if metaphysics enter into someone's choices, how on earth can that be avoided? Everything we do, every choice we make is guided by our own personal point of view.

The discussion is indeed about a woodturning procedure, but it is about two different approaches to a woodturning procedure, neither of which is exclusively right or wrong, and each of which is preferred some people for whatever reasons and in whatever situations. Discussing these motivations and differences is exactly the purpose of a forum, not some reason to be upset by it. The trick is to respect others' opinions and then decide for yourself which way you'd like to go. I don't put Lyle's system down or in any way disrespect it; most of the time, I just prefer to do my hollowing the old-fashioned way. Each to his own.

Ellis

Re: Humor me

#34

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Humor me, again

Lyle Jamieson

>I want to thank all of you that responded, all that agree and all that disagree. For those that know me I always start my demos by saying that there are many ways to turn and they are not wright and wrong but just different. I am sorry I have hit a raw nerve, I knew I would get opposing views and that is good, we get to see both sides of the coin. I dont blame people for defending their positions, they are justified. I am really not criticizing any other processes, nobody has ever called me tactful. Ive said many times that it does not matter wheather a poet uses a pencil or a computer, its the final product that makes the maker an artist.

I guess this is not the place to address all the technical issues like set-up, laser vibration, back rest position, home built issues but Id love to chat with any of you at Provo or Albuquerque about what I have done to solve these issues or any other subject you want to chat about.

I will say that captured systems can be used on any lathe to do any shape. I did a workshop in NY with 10 students, 10 mini lathes, and 10 happy campers walked away with hollow forms done with captured bars and lasers. I did 100 Christmas ornaments in a week and it was the boring bar and laser that made it possible. I made a game out of it and can hollow a 2 1/2 inch diameter ornament ball in 41 seconds to 1/8 inch wall thickness through a 7/8 inch hole. I used a half inch boring bar with a Michael Hosaluk adapter in my handle. And I have a much deeper respent for Cindy's finials.

My bowl gouge grind is better than John's or David's too!! WRONG, we use them differently. One is not better or worse, right or wrong, just different. Thats a good thing.

Re: Humor me

#35

Brad Vietje

Gosh -- what fun!

Brad Vietje

>Hey all,

I think we can all agree to disagree on some of the finer points.

One other factor that related to Steve's BOOM! is that spalting can weaken wood to the point that its strength is severely compromised. When there are strong linear spalt patterns along or between growth rings, an end-grain turning can fly apart just from vibration. Plastic wrap and tape can be very helpful here.

BTW: I'll be demonstrating hand held blind hollowing at the New England Wood Turning Symposium in two weeks in Southern NH. I'll also demonstrate a little about using stabilized boring bars and laser measuring, but I feel a lot like John Lucas -- I *like* doing it by hand, and use boring bars and faceplates from about 8" and up.

I have a great deal of respect for Lyle and his contributions to the turning world, but there are more than one way to do just about everything.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Humor me

#36

thank you again for your contribution to woodturni

robert davis

>never thought of captured for little stuff. my next adventure..looking forward to seein u again in kc, you were our guest on your first visit when u demoed at marinos.

Re: Humor me

#37

Steven Antonucci

You may have the wrong impression of my response

Steve antonucci

>Lyle-

I have nothing against "cheater bars" (I'M JOKING!)... I think hollowing systems are great and solve a lot of issues that I struggled with for years. I chose to hand hollow because I enjoy the connection I feel to the work.

My original response to your post was based upon the fact that you ordained "captured systems" as the way to avoid the problems altogether without actually understanding the problem. I wasn't looking for an answer, and I COMPLETELY understood what I had done wrong, and it would have happen with any captured system on the market because they do not restrict motion from left to right along the tool rest. My run-back wasn't a catch as much as it was that I was on the wrong side of center...

I am all for making things easier and more repeatable (and safer). I don't have a negative opinion of captured systems, other than I prefer to use hand held tools. I have also never been considered a shrinking violet, and I was merely correcting the facts of the case since I was present when it happened.

Now if you have any secrets for hollowing 1/8" thickness 10"+ over the rest through a 1/2" hole, I am all ears.

Steve

P.S. Won't make Provo or Albuquerque, but I'll see you in Hartford next year...

Re: Humor me

#38

Re: Workmanship of risk

charlie belden

>Consider the potential application of captured hollowing systems and the risks involved in hollowing as the overhang of the tool beyond the tool rest increases. For an experienced turner, experience will evaluate the risks based on knowledge and perhaps a bad experience or two, and an informed decision as to whether to try or not can be made.

But for a newbie - to hollowing, or deep hollowing, the lack of any feel for what is risky and what is considerably less risky can lead to either disaster, or at least "unpleasantness" - or not taking the perceived risk, even if the perception of the extent of the risk is overblown. The Risk Averse will probably never even try hollow forms beyond maybe a bird house or christmas ornament. UNLESS - they have a safe, or perceived safe, way to try it. Captured systems provide an opportunity to try something fun that some might kiss off trying otherwise.

As for the workmanship of risk - it's getting a pleasing outside shape that's the risky part since turning is a subtractive process. Doing the inside requires only following the outside, and to be honest - really thin walls aren't often actually necessary for the piece to work. Non-turners seldom take calipers to a piece to quantitatively measure the wall thickness and any variations therein. And the weight of the final piece is very seldom a real issue.

But I must admit that there is a certain tension and a touch of excitement seeing how close to disaster - ok, not disaster - but more like OOOOPS! - I can come - sometimes.

Re: Humor me

#39

Don Pencil

Re: Now bow your head for the man's prayer

Don Pencil

>AMEN!!!!!!

Re: Humor me

#40

Re: Humor me, critics

Ed Moore

>Bruce,

You certainly have the right to express your opinion, which is what Lyle did. The problem arose when you accused him of motives that may or may not be valid, but you are not entitled to say what his inner motives are. That's out of bounds.

You do not need to have a lofty opinion of someone in order to extend common courtesy to them and allow them to state their opinion. There are several "big names" who others kowtow to on a regular basis and in my opinion what they say has more use in growing roses than most other fertilizers. But as long as they are civil I will show them common courtesy even though I may stick out my tongue and point to the back of my throat in private.

Ed

Re: Humor me

#41

Dick Hines

Re: Humor me

Dick Hines

>Good Lord. I go away for the weekend and everyone is all up in arms.

As the good man Rodney once said " Can't we all just get along".