Humor me
Lyle Jamieson
>Humor me,
While I editorialize but I can�t help myself. I see the lengthy thread on the BOOM and the underling attitude out there is that of, �Oh well it happens all the time� Well it need not happen�EVER!! Steve, I hope you don�t take this personally cause most everybody does it, so let me point out some observations so many others can learn from your mistakes.
First the chucking method. I never use a chuck for hollow forms. The telltale remark was the reference to the �run back you got in the bottom nub� area. Come on Steve, for all those beginners out there lets call a spade a spade. You got a catch. If you had a sturdy faceplate and some support wood in the bottom 1/3 of your vessel the catch may not have caused the damage. And why get a catch in the first place?? If you had a supported boring bar system with the cutter parallel to the floor you would NEVER get a catch, its impossible. But for the sake of argument lets say for some reason you like hand held blind hollowing. OOPS, I just can�t think of a good argument for hand held blind hollowing!!??
The second observation was already mentioned in the fact you got too thin near the bottom to support the stresses of a catch. That is easily solvable with a laser measuring system. We can be in complete control of the entire wall thickness and even the bottom depth and shape. It is not necessary to take hours to do a hollow form. And the time involved in hand measuring puts you in a late night, tired, in a hurry to get done, position. The laser would have had the piece done, sanded, off the lathe, with the first coat of finish, and time to go play with the grand kids.
So what I am railing about is the attitude that this is an acceptable way to spend time at the lathe. The fear of this happening to us is stifling to our creativity and enjoyment. It�s a lot more fun to start a new piece then it is to scrape pieces off the floor to glue together. And more important then all that is the safety issue. One of those shrouds of sharp wood splinters could have ended up in your chest or arm. Can�t hit you in the face cause you had a face shield on, right??
With all due respect to Steve, we should thank him for sharing this learning experience with us.





