Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Humor me

Posts

Humor me

#1

Lyle Jamieson

Humor me

Lyle Jamieson

>Humor me,

While I editorialize but I can�t help myself. I see the lengthy thread on the BOOM and the underling attitude out there is that of, �Oh well it happens all the time� Well it need not happen�EVER!! Steve, I hope you don�t take this personally cause most everybody does it, so let me point out some observations so many others can learn from your mistakes.

First the chucking method. I never use a chuck for hollow forms. The telltale remark was the reference to the �run back you got in the bottom nub� area. Come on Steve, for all those beginners out there lets call a spade a spade. You got a catch. If you had a sturdy faceplate and some support wood in the bottom 1/3 of your vessel the catch may not have caused the damage. And why get a catch in the first place?? If you had a supported boring bar system with the cutter parallel to the floor you would NEVER get a catch, its impossible. But for the sake of argument lets say for some reason you like hand held blind hollowing. OOPS, I just can�t think of a good argument for hand held blind hollowing!!??

The second observation was already mentioned in the fact you got too thin near the bottom to support the stresses of a catch. That is easily solvable with a laser measuring system. We can be in complete control of the entire wall thickness and even the bottom depth and shape. It is not necessary to take hours to do a hollow form. And the time involved in hand measuring puts you in a late night, tired, in a hurry to get done, position. The laser would have had the piece done, sanded, off the lathe, with the first coat of finish, and time to go play with the grand kids.

So what I am railing about is the attitude that this is an acceptable way to spend time at the lathe. The fear of this happening to us is stifling to our creativity and enjoyment. It�s a lot more fun to start a new piece then it is to scrape pieces off the floor to glue together. And more important then all that is the safety issue. One of those shrouds of sharp wood splinters could have ended up in your chest or arm. Can�t hit you in the face cause you had a face shield on, right??

With all due respect to Steve, we should thank him for sharing this learning experience with us.

Re: Humor me

#2

Re: Humor me

john lucas

>Not to pick on Lyle because he's right in 90 percent of what he is saying. You can cut through the side with a lazar. I think Lyle wrote the article on measuring wall thickness and you must measure perpendicular to the wall. On really rounded shapes this means adjusting the lazar to be perpendicular to the wall at different points on the vessel. If you don't do that and your turning thin (let's face it we don't always stop and adjust it everytime) then you can blow through the side. Now a lazar is great. I definitely won't argue that because it takes a huge amount of stress out of hollowing. You know where the cutter is at all times (unless your homemade rig slips, BTDT) One good method is to put the lazar dot right on the tip of the cutter. Then you can do a lot less adjusting.

I still use chucks for my hollowing unless it's a large item. I haven't had any problems with this but it could just be me, my lathe and my chucks. Anything over 8" deep and I go to faceplates.

As far as hand vs captured bar. I go both ways. I like the feel of hand hollowing. There's just something more personal about it. Maybe it's pride or maybe it's just hollowing by hand is something I told myself I would learn to do and consequently I do it to prove I still can. However on larger items there is a definite white knuckle feel because I don't hollow often enough. On those it's back to the boring bar. As Lyle said, no catches.

Re: Humor me

#3

Re: Humor me

Sean Troy

>I use the captive system for the above mentioned reasons but also, it takes a lot of stress of my back. As bad as my back is, I couldn't do hollow forms without the captive system unless they are in the 6" or less range. I also don't miss tourqing my wrist and elbo with the hand held hollowers.

Re: Humor me

#4

Re: Humor me

Pete in Holland, MI

>I did some hand hollowing & decided to build Lyle's jig this past winter. I had been keeping folks here up to date during its construction and learned a lot from them. Have turned about a dozen vessels in the past few weeks and am having fun with it. No disasters yet. As with any jig, set-up is critical. And yes, the laser needs to be repositioned as your angle of attack changes, but I am getting used to it. The jig does ease my mind as I hollow, but the threat of a plunge-thru, or a hidden defect in the wood, is there. All wood turning that most of us do is operator controlled, jigs or not, thus accidents will happen, even to the best of you/us.

I thing the mild constant fear of a "disastrophy" while turning is part of the appeal of turners. It's a guy thing.

Play safe !

Pete

Re: Humor me

#5

Re: Humor me

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>To my mind, Lyle sounds a bit condescending here. There is definitely more than one way to skin a cat and many ways to turn a vase. Maybe he's more interested in selling his technique and products.

Re: Humor me

#6

Re: Humor me

robert davis

>

Re: Humor me

#7

Re: Humor me

Don Evans

>Bruce it would surprise me greatly if that was Lyle's motive for writing!!!

Your comment was uncalled for, Lyle does sell boring bars, yes, I have one of them with LASER mount and I love it. It does as advertised.

But back to Lyle, I've only known his post to be like many others, a guy who is interested in turning and promoting knowledge in this field. I've never met him in person, although I would like too.

I've been turning for 37 years and seen many progressions in this arena from making accessory yourself (I've still got the scares to prove it, from home make jigs).

I don't know how long you've been at this, but I vividly remember the days (1970's) when there wasn't much information, maybe an article in FWW once every 3 months and that was it!

Now here we are with tons of info and quality tools, jigs, accessories galore to choose from and make things safer.

Be appreciative of these advantages you have now.

Don

Re: Humor me

#8

Re: Humor me

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I too think your remarks are out of line Bruce.

I happen to agree with Lyle. There is a better way if we want to take that path.

I don't feel that a vase hollowed without a captive system is any less than one hollowed without.

Most of use motor powered lathes rather than turner powered. Is our work any less because of it. Captive systems are just another improvement that has been developed to make a task easier and more accurate.

Re: Humor me

#9

Steven Antonucci

I'm going to humor you...

Steve antonucci

>You may not know it, but we met at Totally Turning a few weeks ago. Sort of. I stopped by your booth twice to talk to you, but you were trying to pay the bills, so we never got to talk.

I fundamentally agree and disagree with every word you say. How can that be? Let me explain...

First, anyone can do it. The instant gratification of being able to hollow through a "small" opening is both a good thing and a bad thing. I think that making it safer and less physically demanding is great, but hand held hollowing can be equally safe and isn't physically demanding if you know what you are doing. I was standing at the tailstock end of my lathe when this blew, and nowhere near the line of fire. Using a captured system puts me back along the ways where I am much closer to the line of fire if I cut through the side wall.

Secondly, I think captured systems are "sterile" experiences. I started turning because I enjoy working with my hands. The more that I mechanize, the less I want to do it. For me, the process is the exciting part, not the laser-like precision I can get from a captured system. Are there a few ridges on the inside of my vessels? Probably, but they were made by human hands- the same way you can feel the thumb prints inside black indian pottery. They aren't imperfections.

Lastly, if I was looking to make a captured system or a mechanically assisted hollowing setup, why would I want one that costs more than my lathe? If you understand what needs to be done, building a rig to do what needs to be done could be accomplished for under $50 out of shop scraps. It wouldn't be powder-coated or pretty, but who cares? The only thing the wood sees is the edge of the tool and how it's presented (Thanks Russ for those words of wisdom...)

I may just get bored enough to make one. I'm guessing it's about a half day's work...

Steve

Re: Humor me

#10

Thank you for being you

David Walser

>Lyle,

I've posted on this and other forums that my favorite woodturning video is your Bowl Basics the Easy Way. The reason this video is my favorite is illustrated by your post, above: You have firmly held opinions and share them clearly and forthrightly. After watching your video, the viewer knows not only what you believe but also why you believe it. Such clarity is wonderful. It provides more than mere information; it's an opportunity for true education.

Having said that, while I'd love to take a class from you and I'm sure I'd enjoy the chance to just chew the fat with you, I'd never allow you to use my shop to make a video. You'd point out to the world all the short comings of my lathe, my tools, my set up, etc. While your well-intentioned constructive criticisms would be truly educational -- and I'd be a better turner for them -- I doubt my fragile ego could withstand such candidness!

Re: Humor me

#11

Re: Humor me

Cyril Griesbach

>I agree with Don on this. I've met Lyle a few times and talked with him on the phone several times as well. I know that he's firm in his beliefs but I'm sure he also knows that there are several ways to accomplish the same result. Yes he does sell his captive boring bar system but he'll also gladly tell you how to make your own Jamieson system. He's simply trying to help and like Sean my back, carpel tunnel and arthritis love my captured system...but that's me. I also know the Steve prefers hand hollowing and that's him.

Re: Humor me

#12

Steven Antonucci

Few more thoughts...

Steve antonucci

>I think that it's also important to know a little bit about the specific situation that started "Boom."

1.) I was tired. I shouldn't have tried to finish it that night, but in my haste, I made a mistake.

2.) Chucks are fine. If you look at the picture,, you will see that the jaws held the piece just fine and it wasn't the issue at all. A faceplate into end grain is cretainly not the world's greatest idea in my book, since the screw have almost no holding power. Did I mention that the wood was spalted? Yeah, I think I might have...

3.) It wasn't too thin to support the cut. It was too thin to support a catch/run back. Without knowing what tool I had in the vessel, it gets pretty hard for you to diagnose the cure being a "captured bar". I had a straight bar with a cutter at a slight angle, and I should have had a straight bar with a straight cutter. I didn't have one that was long and thin enough to go through the 5/8" opening, and I should have taken 5 minutes to drill a hole in a piece of 1/2" rod and glue in a cutter. The angled cutter hit the nub on the backside and pushed the whole tool to the right. When you've got a 1/2" bar 10" over the rest through a hole with 1/16" on either side in a piece of spalted maple with cracks in it, there is no room for error.

One thing I noticed about how you sell you product is that you have an answer, but you don't ask a lot of questions. (witnessed in Saratoga Springs 2x firsthand) If I were in your place, I might have started this thread by asking how a captured system may have saved this piece instead of offering the wrong answer. I didn't mismeasure, so a laser isn't the answer, and I didn't have a catch because the cutter wasn't level. Listening is the number one skill required in sales...

Steve

Re: Humor me

#13

Re: Humor me

charlie belden

>With all justly due respect, as is the case with any generality, there are caveats and exceptions to your Catches Are Avoidable - If You Use A Captured Hollowing System With Laser.

1. Not all turners a) have big lathes and b) turn medium (8 to 10" tall) to large (10+") hollow forms.

One of the problems I found, as a JET mini/midi users, is the space required by many of the captured hollowing systems out there.

With a chuck on one end eating up 2 to 3" of horizontal capacity, and only 12" inches to start with, and another inch or two for whatever "captures" the tool, you're left with 7 to 9 inches of form. Add in an inch or two for maneuvering the tool and you're down to 5 to 7 inches. Add room for parting off and you're in the 4 to 6" range.

Some captured hollowing system makers are reworking the "captured" part of their system to extend beyond the end of the lathe's ways (sp?) to increase horizontal capacity - the MiniMonster for example. And yes, some turners with older systems are making this modification themselves. Personally, I'd rather turn than modify a captured system I bought.

2. Captured systems are almost useless when doing small hollowed Christmas ornaments and small boxes - like the small delicate finialed boxes Cindy Drozda does. Maybe someday a captured system will be developed for doing small hollow forms like this - but at the moment, hand held tools are the only thing that is practical for these types of pieces.

3. A laser is useless, or more accurately, more trouble than they're worth, when turning things like Christmas ornaments and other small hollow forms with relatively tight radius curves (1/2" to 3/4"). You'd have to keep adjusting the laser to the part of the cutting edge (or scraping edge) that's doing the cutting.scraping - which keeps changing as you make a tight radius cut.

While on lasers, if the laser/tool support isn't rock solid, the "dot" becomes a large vibrating blur - and you're back to either thick walls if you play it safe - or suddenly no wall at all if you're a risk taker.

4. Setting things up properly for the tool to work as designed and intended may not be as quick and easy for a newbie, as it is for the tool's designer or for anyone with experience with the system. If there are insert cutters, the angle they're inserted and then held can be critical, guess wrong and it either won't cut - or - can be Catch Prone.

Then there's the "captured part" and tool rest height. Neither usually have a "fine adjustment" feature. Get either set too high or too low - and the cutter won't cut, or it'll be proned to catching. Some captured systems don't have any vertical adjustment - at all.

For 4 to 6 inch diameter by 3 to 6" long hollow forms I really appreciate the MiniMonster I have. But for little stuff - hand tools and eye hand control is the only way I know of that'll work.

5. Chucks, jaws and stress induced splitting.

While it's true that chuck jaws, when used at their maximum capacity, either for inside or outside gripping, CAN "bite" into the wood at each jaws two contact points, and potentially start a split, if used almost "closed", minimize this by maximizing their contact area with the wood, thus reducing the risk of splitting.

Don't get me wrong, I really appreciate that the captured hollowing systems that are available can enable even a relative newbie to turning get into hollowing without the fear of an inside catch - they don't eliminate ALL the things that can go wrong when hollowing. But they aren't the Silver Bullet solution - for all hollowing cases.

Re: Humor me

#14

Steve Kubien

not likely

Steve Kubien

>Bruce wrote, "Maybe he's more interested in selling his technique and products. "

Technique? Maybe but his technique involves a captured boring bar system, a laser and faceplates.

Products? I saw no mention of which captured rig we ought to use and to the best of my knowledge, Lyle doesn't sell faceplates.

I have never had a hollowform come out of my chuck (bowls? yes) so I am still getting used to using faceplates on form. I have never had a catch, serious or otherwise, using my captured system. I use a laser and yes, I have gone through the side of a piece but that is MY fault for not adjusting the laser properly.

Sorry, but I have to stick up for a someone I think is being done wrong and who I consider a friend.

Cheers,

Steve

Re: Humor me

#15

I'm not picking on Lyle, Good guy

john lucas

>I was just trying to state some differences. Like any tool it can be abused and not work perfectly.

As far as boring bars for small lathes, check this one out. It's my Jamieson Mini for my Dremel lathe. It's complete with a light for judging the thickness of thin wall vessels. :)


img

Re: Humor me

#16

Don Pencil

Ladies & Gentlemen, PLEASE!!!!!

Don Pencil

>My dearest woodturning friends,

In a sense you are all correct. Every comment here is no doubt valid. I certainly think so.

For every turner who swears a captured system is the only way there is one who swears to the same about hand held systems. There is an equal split within the ranks of each type of these systems as to which one is best.

There are those who hang on every word that flows from Lyle's mouth and an opposing group who think differently about his teachings and thoughts. I personally think he has some really great ideas and teachings and some that are not so. I know that he feels the same. We all have an opinion on what works well. While some things really don't work, most do. Turners are as diverse as the volume of tools and techniques available. What works for you may not be of much help to another. Let's not be so quick and/or headstrong as to this way or that one.

There sure are a lot of turners out there that think my ideas are nuts. My wife keeps reminding me of it for some reason.

Oh yeah, remember, nothing works right every time and in the great wisdom of Red Green, "if it's not broke, your not tryin' hard enough" and "when all else fails, play dead".

Be Well, Don

Re: Humor me

#18

Great Post Don!!

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>

Re: Humor me

#19

Now bow your head for the man's prayer

Jason Clark

>I'm a man.

But I can change.

If I have to.

I guess.

Re: Humor me

#20

Re: Humor me

Jerry Whitaker

>Sorry, Bruce....but you are wrong. On his website, he tells you how to make his captured system but I bought mine because I didn't have the time to make one. This is one of the nicest guys you will ever run into. He is hard to get to talk to at symposiums due to the fact that he is surrounded by so many people asking questions. If you stand around and listen, any question you have will eventually be answered...or, if you skip one of the rotations, there will be fewer people around him and you will have a much better chance to talk to him. He spends much of his time letting people actually use his hollowing system on the spot. It like a free mini-class.

Re: Humor me

#21

You can turn light bulbs!? AMAZING!

charlie belden------WebKitFormBoundary+dAQ5DpvMC13

>

Re: Humor me

#22

Hey, if you can turn Robots, why not. :)

john lucas

>

Re: Humor me

#23

Ellis Walentine

Workmanship of risk

Ellis Walentine

>Hello Lyle,

As some have already mentioned, people are different. Your methodology is the only way that makes sense to you, and that's your prerogative. Others feel differently. To be fair here, this is not about right and wrong, correct or incorrect; it's about what feels right to each individual. Why it feels right is for only the individual to decide, and the decision may be influenced by a lot of different things, including a need for fail-safe results and time savings; but, for some folks who are not in a hurry or risk-averse, or who simply enjoy the feel of a tool as an extension of their hands and eyes, or the tactual feedback of a sharp cutter in a choice piece of wood -- or, for that matter, the pride of knowing that they have produced a superb piece without jigs or fixtures -- their choices may be different, and that's okay, too. I suspect that includes a lot of hobbyists who are more interested in perfecting their skills than in producing reliable results in the shortest period of time. We all have different needs and expectations.

David Pye, one of the great apostles of craftsmanship, was keenly aware of the continuum of control that runs from the workmanship of risk to the workmanship of certainty. He felt that some of the finest work in history was accomplished without the use of soulless machines, but rather by the hand and skill of the maker. Factories don't care whether their production workers enjoy the process of making their product, but many hobbyists do care; and they don't care if it takes a little longer or results in more failures or uneven walls on their vessels.

Personally, I prefer hand-held methods for most of the reasons that I mentioned above, but I have used captive tooling for instances where it made sense to me. This pot, for example, that I turned at Bill Grumbine's picnic a couple years ago, was too deep to turn comfortably with the gouges and scrapers available, so Bill set me up with a captive system that allowed me to finish the piece to my satisfaction. Ultimately, I feel it is up to the maker to come up with the design solution that works best for him/her and the situation at hand, however flawed that reasoning may seem (or prove to be).

My 2�

Ellis


img

Re: Humor me

#24

Steven Antonucci

Amazingly well said.

Steve antonucci

>

Re: Humor me

#25

Steve Kubien

Re: I'm not picking on Lyle, Good guy

Steve Kubien

>Good grief John, what WON'T you try to build! There are those who like to work with wood and those who like to tinker in their shop but never actually produce anything. You are one of the fair few who can actually do both!

Steve