Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

Posts

How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#1

How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

Alex Yeilding

>I've just completed construction of a stand for my mini lathe. At 300lbs (including lathe) on a 28"x35" base, it feels rock-solid. However, testing with out-of-balance stock, I'm surprised at how much flex is in the structure. Before I start stiffening the structure, I thought I should check to see what is "normal".

I am checking with a 12" piece of "white wood" 2x4, mounted on both ends 1" from one of the short sides. The lathe/stand really jumps (though not enough to walk) when I start it, then vibrates very noticeably (to touch--harder to discern by eye). This is at 500 rpm. As I start increasing speed, the lathe/stand starts to "walk" at about 1000 rpm (if it doesn't first throw the workpiece across the shop).

I would expect that with heavier wood of greater diameter, it would be easy to get this degree if imbalance even if I do my best to statically balance the workpiece, but maybe not.

If I stiffen my structure, doesn't that mean the lathe would start "walking" sooner, as more of the energy is transmitted to the feet?

So much to learn! Great to have this resource of experienced folks.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#2

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

GalenV in Iowa

>A picture of your stand would be helpful.

When you say the unbalance causes your stand to flex then you need more rigid connections at your joints or shorter spans for the members you are using. You should remember if you double the speed of your unbalanced load the load is increased by a factor of four. The centrifugal force goes up by the square of the speed. I assume you would not normally run an unbalnced load at 1000 rpm but instead 500 till you get it better balanced. Since your unbalanced load must be resisted by the anchorage of the base the best way is to anchor the feet to a solid floor. If not anchored then wider foot pattern and/or more mass near the feet.

There are those that try to put more mass on the rotational axis but as far as I can see it is still just adding weight directly over the feet and yes the unbalance load is a smaller portion of the weight on the feet.

Just my opinion on the subject.

Galen

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#3

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks, Galen.

Sounds like your vote is that noticeable vibration at 500 is too much for that load?

How about a SU drawing in lieu of a picture. Actual is very true to this drawing. Box beam top is of 2x12 SYP, sand-filled, and base is of tripled 2x4's, with a 2x10 stretcher. Have also added 3/4" plywood trapezoids on each end, reaching from the ends of the sled feet to the bottom board of the box beam. I've put 3/32" cork sheet on the bottom of the lathe and between the pads that the lathe rests on and the beam, in the theory that it would absorb sound-frequency vibrations while not having any effect on the larger vibrations.

My best result so far is, surprisingly, putting temporary "feet" under the sled base directly under the vertical legs. That gives me only about a 10" base, so it seems like that would be too tippy (I need to remember to run, not try to catch it if it starts to tip!). But it has had the least vibration so far, which makes me suspect the sled base. But the sagulator says that a 20" span of 4" deep x 3.5" thick should not have much flex.


img

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#4

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Rick_Allen

>The feet are to big. Make the contact surface for the feet small and adjustable.

get four 1/2" x 4" bolts. Drill a 5/8" hole threw each foot. Epoxy a nut into the underside of the feet at the holes. Do the same at the top side.

Use the bolts in each foot to support the lathe.

You can sharpen the bolts slightly and use small (1"x3"x3/8") plates to interface between the floor and the bolts which are supporting the lathe. Adjust the bolts so that each bolt provides equal support.

These small contact points will provide terrific stability for your lathe and stand.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#5

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

John K Jordan

>Alex,

A friend of mine has done large, unbalanced turnings outboard on an old "lightweight" Delta lathe. He used clamps to fasten the lathe to the shop wall, in effect adding the mass of the shop to the lathe.

Some worry that this may overstress the bearings, but I'm not convinced forces on the bearings of an unconstrained lathe are less.

JKJ

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#6

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Walter Ahlgrim

>It has been my experience that trees flex in the wind and nothing made of wood is truly rigid.

Walta


img

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#7

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

GalenV in Iowa

>I would have to agree with Rick that your large square feet will most likely never set well unless your floor is a perfect level surface. It more likely will always rest on a corner or edge of a pad and not be as stable as you would like. Your temp pad right under the columns tell me the four pads are not setting firm. A leveling devices with a smaller contact would help. I would still use a dense rubber pad to keep from sliding on your hard floor surface. Not metal. Not sure about the nuts being set in epoxy for leveling but tee nuts give you metal threads in wood either the drive in type or you can get holes in the flange for screws to hold.

I would not put your thin cork pad between your lathe and stand. It is good practice to have a solid surface. If you need to shim if your wood surface is not flat use metal shims only where needed to keep from twisting the lathe bed. Your sand will help deaden the sound.

Not sure where you had flex in members. Your upright legs look to just butt to the upper box beam and the leg spreader. These need a good solid connection or I can see they could shack loose. I assume you are fastened into the end grain and can become loose with vibration or stand shake.

Again just ideas

Galen

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#8

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

GalenV in Iowa

>How long did it take for the epoxy to set to hold the nickle in place?

Besides a good heavy cast stand, how you got that thing anchored?

I'm not going to believe your stand is on casters!

:>)

Galen

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#9

Re: How much vibration

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks, Walter. That is just the information I was looking for. I know that my mini lathe will not become a Nova, no matter what kind of base I build for it. But if you can swing something like that with almost no vibration, I should be able to do the same with an off-center tubafor.

It has been my experience that trees flex in the wind and nothing made of wood is truly rigid.

Well, I'd change that a little since nothing is truly rigid--it's just a matter of degree. But your point is right on. And I made this out of dimensional lumber because of my preference for the medium, without proper consideration of its flexibility. A well-designed plywood structure (like Charlie B's) might have given me more stiffness, and plywood might be part of my fix. I might also dump the sand and fill the box beam with concrete, which would give me another 60 pounds (although weight is not the issue now, I don't think). I could anchor mounting studs in the concrete, letting me attach the lathe very rigidly. And if that is not enough, working my way down, I could replace the legs with a plywood form filled with concrete.

Oh, well. A work in progress.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#10

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks, Rick. Well, I guess my sketchup drawing isn't THAT realistic. in fact, the front feet do have levelers, consisting of 5/15" "elevator bolts" (bolts with a 1.25" diameter head) in tee nuts. But I don't see how the size of the contact point affects vibration. Can you explain that. Also, what size lathe do you have, and how much vibration, however you measure it. Walter's seems a bit too good to be true, but I'm wondering what others have achieved.

Alex

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#11

Re: How much vibration is acceptable

Alex Yeilding

>Galen,

I have foot levelers, and adjusting them properly makes a BIG difference. But still too much vibration IMHO. How about your experience? What size lathe, and if you spun a test piece like I described, how steady would your lathe be?

Not sure where you had flex in members. Your upright legs look to just butt to the upper box beam and the leg spreader. These need a good solid connection or I can see they could shack loose. I assume you are fastened into the end grain and can become loose with vibration or stand shake.

A lot of the flex is in the box beam. It is very rigid against bending in length, but vibrates a lot in the front-to-back direction. The endcaps are joined with sliding dovetails, and only partially glued, to allow for seasonal wood movement. But that also allows for unwanted movement. Not well-thought-out on my part. I'll try supplemental plywood endcaps to see if that fixes that problem.

Yes, the box beam is screwed to the tops of the legs, but this is a secondary source of vibration (can feel it with a finger on the joint). I probably should use bolts to draw it very tight there.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#12

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I can help you a bit. Believe it or not, the size of the contact points makes a big difference. The reason is deeply rooted in mechanical vibration theory. What's going on has to do with mechanical impedance matching. The closer the mechanical impedance of the lathe is to the mechanical impedance of the floor, the better the transfer of vibration energy will be from the lathe to the floor. The mechanical impedance of the floor is more or less infinite, especially if the floor is attached firmly to the Earth. And -- here's the tricky part -- the mechanical impedance of a CONE( with point down) is essentially infinite AT THE POINT. So what you want to do is mount the lathe on some kind of points, as Rick Allen described. The cone is what's know as a mechanical horn. A mechanical horn serves the same function as does a sound horn in the theory of sound impedance matching. (That's why a bull horn or a horn-loaded loud speaker in audio is so efficient.) Now there is a catch: any vibrational energy in the floor will be just as efficiently transmitted upwards into the lathe! So, when you turn, don't wildly jump up and down!

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#13

Cone feet

Alex Yeilding

>Wow! That's interesting. Does the size or slope of the cone matter? Is the cone an approximation of a rotated hyperbola, as I believe it would be for a speaker? How about the small pads Rick mentioned? Do they act as part of the floor in this interaction?

I'm on a poured concrete basement floor, pretty close to the footing, so I'm not too worried about vibrations from the floor.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#14

Re: How much vibration

Bob Macgregor

>I think putting some plywood gusset plates on the ends and maybe up and down the sides...joining the legs and ballast beam/box with good overlaps...would stiffen it up a lot. Of course, this still won't keep it from jumping around when spinning a really out-of-balance piece, but it shouldn't flex much.

BOB

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#15

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

john lucas

>I think they have about covered it. I made a huge wooden stand for my Nova 300 and filled it with sand. It still vibrated like crazy with out of balance pieces. The reason was the wood to metal connection. I sold it to a friend and we added metal plate to the top of the stand and it helped but didn't eliminate the problem.

Even my Powermatic with 300lbs of gravel in the bottom will vibrate at higher speeds with out of balance work. Granted it's much less than then Nova and starts at higher speeds but this thing is solid cast iron and weighs 1000lbs with the gravel.

Every lathe has a point that vibration becomes a problem unless you have something like the old Nicoles lathes or the VB 36 or other really massive lathes.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#16

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Bob Macgregor

>Yeah, and with those bigger, heavier lathes, the siesmometers at the local college go crazy whenever you turn a big, out of balance blank!

BOB

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#17

Re: How much vibration is acceptable

GalenV in Iowa

>Alex

My lathe is a Jet 1220. Started turning with it just setting on a wood topped steel frame bench with no anchorage. My first green bowls I tried to use clamps to hold and then bolts when the clamps vibrated off. Too much of a sounding board anyway. I went to the Jet metal stand and it took a pretty off balance piece to rock the stand at low speed. If it did I took the blank back to the band saw and took off more wood that I knew I would turn off. Jets stand did really surprized me on how stable it can be. I might get some shake but I can quickly take off wood to smooth it out. I added a wood shelf by square u-bolts to the lower cross brace and a craddle for the tailstock to rest in while turning bowls. It just sit there and adds weight but never shook it off the shelf.

Went through the wood stand for the South Bend metal lathe I had and it was rock solid but then you very seldom run out of balance metal pieces. I just knew a steel stand was they way to go on the wood lathe if I ever intended to move it. The metal lathe stand was probalby twice as heavy as the lathe to move being of wood.

Hard to beat metal for rigid base.

Galen

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#18

Re: How much vibration is acceptable

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks, all.

I didn't get much of a feel for how much vibration is "normal", but definitely got confirmation that I was probably seeing too much, and some good ideas for addressing the problems in my design.

Now, I need to sit back and decide among a) trying to fix what I have, b) starting over and building to a new design, or c)springing for the Jet metal stand.

If I go with (b), any thoughts about concrete as a medium? Just make two concrete slabs to use as "legs", with a stretcher across the back to hold them vertical, and the lather attached directly to studs sunk in the concrete?

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#19

Re: Cone feet------WebKitFormBoundaryu0Cs+Rrz3x7UQ

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>The shape of the cone matters in that it determines the frequencies of vibration that are more efficiently transmitted. Also the cone material matters. A revolution of a hyperbola would be an acceptable shape -- but not because speakers sometimes have that shape. The cone is really a mechanical transducer, and certain frequencies are passed better than others. Any type of hard pad placed under the points of the cone, in effect, become part of the floor. But the best transmission would be directly into , say, a concrete floor. If I were to go this route, I would just use pointed metal spikes directly into the floor (or into some kind of hard plate firmly attached to the floor.) In my opinion, the worst arrangement would be some kind of soft , rubbery, type of material under the lathe. You're not trying to isolate the vibrations but, rather, to transmit them down into the floor.

------WebKitFormBoundaryu0Cs+Rrz3x7UQqVJ

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#20

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Walter Ahlgrim

>My first stand lots of sand and plywood and performed poorly. This stand was designed by an engineer that builds rocket test stands the doors inside locks and dams. The goal is to put lots of steel as close to the spindle as possible and attached a firmly as possible to the spindle. I have jack that lifts the stand to remove and install the casters. I don�t turn anything large on the casters.

Walta


img

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#21

Re: How much vibration is acceptable

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Alex,

Obviously I don't want to get in the way of the engineering process, but I can't ever remembering needing to turn a 2x4 mounted off-center as you describe. 8^]

It might be that your stand is perfectly acceptable in real-world conditions, especially if you are willing to pull an unbalanced piece and trim it a bit like the other person discussed.

Gary

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#22

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Barry Turner

>Your lathe stand appears to be much more solid than mine. Let's not forget that the idea is to mount your stock so that it is reasonably centered and balanced. When roughing an unbalanced blank, start on the lowest speed. I think if you do that carefully, your current lathe stand will be more than adequate.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expecte

Keith Tompkins

>Just a thought...could the problem be as simple as the speed is too high for the piece of wood being turned? 500 rpm is way too high for any unbalanced piece with any size at all.

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#24

Lathe stand fixed --confession of an idiot

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks for the help here. I have stiffened my lathe stand by:

Using sharpened 1/2" feet (thanks Rick and Eliot -- never would have come up with that on my own)

Added 2x10 stretchers between front and back legs. held in with 3/8" all-thread.

Replaced #10 2" wood screws with 5/16" 4" lag screws holding beam to legs.

Added angle iron to stiffen beam in its weak direction.

Got rid of cork isolation pad.

Much stiffer now.

Here's a picture. The dados on the inside of the legs are for a storage shelf to be added. Those on the outside of the left leg are for a small shelf there. (That's my story, and I'm sticking to it! )

Now, the "confession of an idiot" part:

I was originally worried about an off-center mounted 2x4 causing too much vibration at 500rpm (my lathe's slowest). Well, I made all those improvements, and it still vibrated more than I wanted, though impoved. Then I went to adjust the speed for a turning I wanted to do, and found that I was on the pulleys for the middle speed range! The vibration I was getting was at 1100 rpm, not 500, or roughly 5 times the energy. Now it is rock solid, even with the 2x12 cutoff shown in the picture (Just for testing--I'm not going to put my body in the line of fire of that piece, much less touch it with a tool.) Whether my stand without these improvements would have been good enough, I'll now never know.

Two things I notice with these single point feet:

When it starts to vibrate, there is no subtlety--it makes a racket. Probably a good thing--I shouldn't be at that speed.

I also notice that I get very definite resonant frequencies. For instance, with my off-center 2x4, it is perfectly smooth at 500-600 rpm, then starts to vibrate rather wildly, and calms back down at 900.


img

Re: How much vibration is acceptable/to be expected?

#25

Steven Antonucci

If the top section is "boxed", fill it with sand

Steve antonucci

>I can't tell from the picture if the top section is a box, but if it isn't, then you should make it one and fill it with sand. Leave the sand in the bag since it will leak oot of little cracks from vibration if you try to dump it in free.

Steve