Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Posts

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#26

Wrong

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>You miss the whole point of what I said. What you are talking about is forgery, not plagiarism. Forgery is illegal.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#27

Re: Questions..............

john lucas

>Ruth A few years ago there was a competition online, and I made an inside out wine bottle with a goblet in the negative space. On Wow a French turner(whose name escapes me) had made something very similar and I was accused of copying. We both had wine bottles with inside out turned glasses in the sides but his glass was different. It was pure coincidence. We had both been doing inside out turning and arrived at a similar product for that competition. I was able to document the inside out turning that I had been doing over the years and prove that it was coincidence and we became friends swapping e-mails for a time.

It proves what you say about how small the world is becoming and 2 people could easily arrive at the same thing without seeing each others work.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#28

Re: Wrong

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Wrong about what? I'm not discussing legal issues. I trying to say something about integrity.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#29

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

John K Jordan

>Keith,

I agree with your thoughts and am humored at times by those who are bent out of shape when someone's piece has elements similar to pieces by another turner, famous or not. One thing we sometimes forget is there is very little new and unless we've never left the cave we were born in, not one soul can claim to be uninfluenced by others. I've even seen some very old pieces in books similar to some "signature" pieces today.

Concerning names and claims, though, I am very careful to use "John K Jordan" rather than "John Jordan" on my work!

JKJ in East TN

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#30

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

John Roth

>This similar issue has come time and again in wood carving, particularly my specialty, chip carving, where many of those new to chip carving copy patterns verbatim out of published work. The copying is OK because the author has given permission to use the pattern. The problem arrises during competition, and I have been a judge. A common criterion for judging is originality, and if I see a piece in competition that is obviously recognizable as a copy of a published pattern, I will score low on originality, although may score high on technique, etc. I believe if one derives a concept or design from known published work, some credit ought to be given to the originator of the work, something like "This is my work but I got the idea from ...." That is fair and nobody would object. Claiming you originated the design when you knowingly copied it is not right.