Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Posts

No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#1

No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>After seeing the post by mfoster and reading the thread, I decided it was time for me to speak my mind about the subject of plagiarism in woodturning. First off, I must say that Mfoster's hollow form is a wonderful piece of work and, as stated, is very reminiscent of Molly's work. I admire Molly's work immensely. She is doing some fabulous work and I look forward to each and every piece. But, I have serious issues with any statement of plagiarism in mfoster's piece, or in anybody's work for that matter.

It is my firm belief that once a person learns a technique from someone, it is their's for all time. My reason for this statement is, because we are human, we are all different. We interpret, see, and understand things differently. It is not possible for two humans to execute any technique the same as there are just too many variables and differences in people. Two pieces, done by two people may look the same and be virtually identical, but there will be differences. They may be very minuscule and next to impossible to see, but there will be a differences.

Now, if someone turned a piece and tried to pass it off as someone else's, well, that is something completely different. Of course, we know that as forgery (very bad).

Sorry to jump on this soapbox, but this has bothered for quite a while and I finally had to say something.

keithz

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#2

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Norm Smith

>Keith, When I saw that post earlier today I thought the same thing. I think that you are absolutely right and thanks for saying so.

Norm

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#3

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Skip Beardsley------WebKitFormBoundaryo2PSwy+o0IUR

>Well said,Keith. I had some of the same thoughts when I saw the original post. Someday I hope to be good enough that someone will want to imitate my work. If and when that happens they are welcome to do it.

Skip

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#4

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

paul waddle

>I agree,we are not robots and can't duplicate anything exactly. The rub comes in when one does a little quirk that is indigative of a particular noted turner and doesn't speak out that its the close as they could get it to look like so and sos stlye. If they sign someone else's name on their work,thats WRONG.. JMHO,pw.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#5

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

bill Crommett

>Now then will it be O.K. for me to make candle sticks like Rude Osolnik and finials like Wally ?

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#6

Re: There is a difference of opinion .....

Russ Fairfield

>It depends on whether you are the one doing the copy or the one being copied.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#7

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Keith, it's good to let it out. I read that thread as Molly's post help me try something new... we need inspiration like that once in a while. Take the work that Molly posted, the shape, patterns and finish are very appealing to the eye... this is tough to do, that's why she is one of the top professionals in the world. No one could ever copy this but maybe a black hat with burning on the band might be inspired from her work.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#8

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

john lucas

>Making a few pieces in a style that someone else originated and putting your name on it is learning. Making a bunch of those pieces and selling them as though you originated it is plagiarism, in my book. What mfoster did is perfectly acceptable, especially since he went out of his way to say he learned the technique from Molly. He created a wonderful piece that is similar to several pieces I've seen over the years, but not exactly like any of them.

When someone starts selling copies of your work, especially in your area, Plagiarism takes on a whole new meaning.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#9

Steven Antonucci

We all plagiarize someone

steve antonucci

>Some of us do it with other turners.

Some of us do it with potters.

Some of us do it with Native American Artists.

Some of us do it with African Artists.

But we all do it.

I think Mike was merely pointing out that he was trying to recognize the source of the work. Where Molly got her source is her own history. Where they got there inspiration ... (and it goes on and on).

Humankind is built upon the collective and individual experiences we all partake in. Recognizing those who came before us or influenced our work (our skills, our style, etc.) is just a way of saying thank you for sharing yourself with me.

Steven

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#10

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Eduardo sarmiento-hall

>Here is normal to do that I have ladies buying my pieces and puting their names on them and resell them in the same gallery were I sell ,here no one buys a pc program everybody uses pirate you could not sue them,Im the only one making vessels and vases(hollow ones) in peru and they try to copy mi desings ,but I just shrug and smile after all turning have centuries old and almost everything is been done so a spindle turner will not make legs?someone has done it before him no?my2cents

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#11

Well said, Keith

Cyril Griesbach

>

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#12

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Carole Valentine

>Are you kidding??? They buy your work, put their name on it (after obliterating your name, I presume) then sell it in the same gallery where your work is displayed????? I just can't believe that! How can you just shrug that off, Eduardo?

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#13

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Lee Buck

>I've tried several times to reproduce Rude's candlesticks. It certainly made me appreciate the difference between nailing it and just getting close. I've given them to friends who were artists and designers and told them about Rude and suggested they look up his work. I didn't pretend the design was mine and I exposed them to his work. As I write this I'm taking a break from copying John Jordan. It won't be as good as his work but I'll learn something and if it goes on my shelf I'll tell anyone who admires it who John is and where they can see his work. It certainly won't cost him a sale or damage his reputation. That seems alright to me.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#14

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Thanks Keith for your thoughts.

I agree with you and others that this gets a bit too much attention for my liking to tell you the truth. I frequent many forums and the topic of plagiarism seems to find a home almost exclusively only on the turning forums. I am not sure why it seems to be a torch that some turners feel a passion to hold, but it leaves me wondering what is the thought of being so unique that others cannot borrow and enhance on an original idea to create another one. I see furniture makers and tool makers building on past designs all the time, and I never see a heated topic rise on those forums as it does with turners...

Now I wish every one would stop coping my pens.. LOL :-)

Have some Easter ham, eat some chocolate and enjoy what you make.... I think some times some take this too seriously.

Thanks for some clarity Keith,

take care,

Jim

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#15

Reselling your work------WebKitFormBoundaryAAgGAA8

Jack Savona

>I assume that if someone is buying your work and ABLE to resell it for a profit, your prices are way too low. If they can't resell it, your prices are at the market level (and you've made your sales to THEM).

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#16

I Don't Mind If....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>somebody copies my work, but if his copy looks better than mine, then I'm gonna object!

Wally

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#17

I'm SO with you Keith!! Well said.

Molly Winton

>

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#18

LOL! Don't think you have a worry, Wally!

Carole Valentine

>

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#19

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

mfoster------WebKitFormBoundary6h+hF1gNvuvabq+x

>Well I guess I have to chime in here. I also agree with the majority of what has been said. I didn't really intend on stoking a fire, merely tried to give credit to Molly for the idea of the piece. As Steve said, it is certainly not Molly's work, but the idea of it is.

What prompted me to post as I did was that I had another turner copy many of the segmented pieces that I posted on the internet, without really giving credit to the source. He had emailed me and asked if he could copy one of my pieces, but then went on to copy several more. It would have really irritated me were it not for the fact that the copies were not very well done. It took me a while to come to grips with this, and now I've come to feel comfortable with others using my work as inspiration. Like others have said in this post, it really is a form of flattery. I just intended my post to make it really clear that Molly's work was my inspiration. Probably should have softened it some like "Molly inspired work".

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#20

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Yes,"Molly inspired work" would have been better(IMHO).

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#21

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Sorry to disagree with just about everybody else, but if you copy, say, an Art Leistman's puzzle form, or one of his Mondrian series, I believe that's a form of something improper. I chose these two examples because these two styles are so unique. I mean, if you just want to copy to learn, I suppose that's o.k. But if you take it seriously and begin to pass these items off as something personal, new, innovative, etc. , then you are moving in the wrong direction.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#22

Questions..............

Ruth Niles

>Eliot just used Art Leistman's work as an example because it's unique. There have been an awful lot of "unique" turnings over the years.

What if someone else can do it better? more detailed? Does this mean that no one can do puzzle motif on a hollow form? Puzzle motif at all? because obviously jigsaw puzzles (maple leaves, acorns, etc., etc.) are not unique.

There are a lot of turners out there who are not in the AAW, do not do demonstrations and do not post on the internet. What if they are doing exactly what Art is doing. Can they claim he copied them?

I do believe my coffee scoop is a unique thing. A little over 17 yrs. ago after seeing 150-yr. old antique seed scoops, I thought "if I make one 1/8 cup, it's a perfect coffee scoop". They are a big part of my livelyhood yet anyone is free to make and sell them. Last year I could not fill an order for a couple dozen to a shop that's been selling them for 12 yrs. so I gave the owner Pete Teubel's contact info (he makes wonderful copies of my unique design : ) !!). I figured if the shop liked his and just wanted to sell his, then I need to make mine better.

It's a BIG planet, the internet makes it feel like everyone is in your backyard but they aren't.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#23

Re: Questions..............

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hey Ruth,

While you are in my back yard, can you cut my lawn for me please.

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#24

Re: Questions..............

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Well... there's no question that the line between merely copying, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, being inspired to follow in one's footsteps with something similar, and hopefully more interesting, beautiful, intricate, etc., is a difficult one. And to some extent, we all follow someone or something. Still, I claim that outright copying is something that can be seen. It's something like the notorious comment about pornography-- hard to define but you know it when you see it. For what it's worth, at the Louisville AAW Symposium a few years ago, there was a serious panel discussion by notaries like David Ellsworth and others on this topic, and the conclusion was NOT that everything goes. There is a line, albeit difficult to define.

Re: No such thing as plagiarism in turning!

#25

hundreds have already done it

robert davis

>