No such thing as plagiarism in turning!
keith zimmerman, Normal IL
>After seeing the post by mfoster and reading the thread, I decided it was time for me to speak my mind about the subject of plagiarism in woodturning. First off, I must say that Mfoster's hollow form is a wonderful piece of work and, as stated, is very reminiscent of Molly's work. I admire Molly's work immensely. She is doing some fabulous work and I look forward to each and every piece. But, I have serious issues with any statement of plagiarism in mfoster's piece, or in anybody's work for that matter.
It is my firm belief that once a person learns a technique from someone, it is their's for all time. My reason for this statement is, because we are human, we are all different. We interpret, see, and understand things differently. It is not possible for two humans to execute any technique the same as there are just too many variables and differences in people. Two pieces, done by two people may look the same and be virtually identical, but there will be differences. They may be very minuscule and next to impossible to see, but there will be a differences.
Now, if someone turned a piece and tried to pass it off as someone else's, well, that is something completely different. Of course, we know that as forgery (very bad).
Sorry to jump on this soapbox, but this has bothered for quite a while and I finally had to say something.
keithz



