Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Posts

SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#1

SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Carl Barton

>I am a inpass. I made a really nice segmented cookie jar, all turned, sanded etc. In fact it looks pretty darn good and for the first time I made no major mistakes(only my third segmented turing).

I figured I would try to make a segmented lid vice using a 8/4 piece of stock. This is where I am getting myself confuse. I am cutting my segments from a 5 9/16 wide stock, I want a 7in outer ring, 10 segments for the ring. I have tripled checked my math and I came out with an 18 degree angle with the long side of the segments at 2 7/16 in length.

So I cut my segments, not twice, but three times this morning (wasted alot of stock). Still my segments are not fitting, I have almost a 1/2 in gap when I put them together. The segments are 2 7/16 in length, and 3 13/16 width. I have checked all my measurements,and angle on my chop saw three times.

Is there something I am not doing right when making long width segments than when one does from a segmented ring that is only 1 3/4 in width?

My thought was as long as you had the angle and length correct you could made the width of a segment as wide as you wanted.

Carl

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#2

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Stuart Johnson

>Using Woodturner Pro I show:

Row Details

Segments:10

Board Thickness: 2"

Outside Diameter: 7"

Inside Diameter: 0

Calculations

Segment Edge Lenght: 2-1/4

Board Width: 3-1/2

Miter Angle: 18 degrees

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#3

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

paul waddle

>I wish I could help.I too, am getting interested in segment turning,but you are more advanced than I. Perhaps there's a dvd someone can recommend for us both..

I plan on cutting the segments on a band saw and sanding smooth. Do know of jig plans that will give the desired cutting angle and then the supplimentary angle by butting the first to a fence? Hopefully something that will rotate such that different angles can be cut?? pw.

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#4

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Nick Tuzzolino

>Paul: If at all possible, PLEASE buy either Curt Theobald's "Segmented Turning" Double DVD set (wfww.curttheobald.com) or Malcolm Tibbets's intro DVD. Better yet Malcom's 2 DVD set, at tahoeturner.com. Both about the same price. I have both and consider them the bibles for segmented turners. They have certainly made things a LOT simpler for me. Best wishes.

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#5

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Carl Barton

>Thank you to all. Maybe the calculator I am using is not work for me although I used if for the other ten rings I did and it worked out fine. I joined the local woodturners group here in VA so maybe I will get some pointers from them at the next meeting.

I have both Curt Theobald DVD's and Malcolm Tibbetts book, both a great help in getting started.

Thank's to all.

Carl

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#6

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Carl Barton

>PS,

Stuart how do you like the Wood Turner program? I was thinking about getting the entire package he offers, including one or two of the cones he has.

Carl

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#7

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

paul waddle

>Thanks Nick for the dvd info. I just love this WC,pw

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#8

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Stuart Johnson

>I have all three of the programs and like them all. I'm also the first to admit I don't use them anywhere near to their capacity.

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#9

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville

>I plugged your sizes into my CAD program and got exactly the same dimensions as Stuart. The length of the two long sizes are (or should be 3-11/16"

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Carl, The witdth or thickness of your stock should be irrelevent. a full circle is 360 degrees, divided by 10= 36. Again, divided by 2 (for each side of a segment), or 18 degrees. Double check the accuracy of you chop saw; I wouldn't go by the machine's scale, make a few practice pieces first, then the final assembly after tweaking the saw as necessary. A one degree error makes a glaring gap.

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#11

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Carl Barton

>Keith,

I figured it would not make a difference with the width. The funny thing is, I did seven rings already the day before and all those rings came out fine. Then I did the ring for the lid today, three times and it did not come out right. I know I must have done something different than the other day, just can not figure if out. So I put things away for the day and mowed the lawn and odd stuff around the house. Maybe it was just not a good day for turing. Thank you for the advice.

Carl

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#12

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Carl Barton

>Harry,

Thank you. I guess I need to go back and check my chop saw to insure everything is right. I just cut seven rings the day before and everything came out great, so I am thinking something must have moved on me. But I did check everything before I started today, I guess I must have missed something.

Thank you.

Carl

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Keith Tompkins

>Just thought of something....perhaps the thickness of the material is causing the blade to deflect, affecting the cuts.

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#14

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

bill Crommett

>Carl: I learned that I. too, can make small errors that multiply. So I made a small right angle trial square so that I could detect any errors before I had ruined too much timber. Any errors will show up on 1/4 of the circle.

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#15

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

Carl Barton

>After re-checking all my measurements and chop saw settings, I think what I did was brought my saw blade back up before it stoped spining. This is the only thing I can think of that might have caused my problems. When I did my other segments/rings I recall I did not bring my blade up until it stopped. Seems like I recall that was not a good idea to do that. But when it came to the lid I was make I was so close to being done with my project I cut and brought my blade back up without letting it stop first. Making a larger segment for the lid may also have caused some defeltion as you mentioned.

I guess I will give that a try and see what happens.

Carl

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

#16

Re: SEGMENTED TURING HELP

jim miles - Charlote NC

>Carl:

AS Keith says- the length is irrelevant to whether the joints match up. Your angle is off somewhere. Do some test cuts on scrap wood and adjust slightly until you get it right before cutting good wood. Also the books will show you how to put the error on opposite sides of the circle, glue up the ring, then saw through the joint with the error, reglue and save the ring. I find more accuracy with a segment sled on a table saw. For a beginner I would suggest you pick a number ( 12 is good ) set up jig for this, get is dead accurate and glue it down. 95% of what I do is 12 segment from small to big ( 24" diam ) hollow forms to bowls. Learn to do simple things well before you graduate to complicated pieces. Good Luck!