Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Choosing a lathe

Posts

Choosing a lathe

#1

Choosing a lathe

Steve Fowler

>My wife wants bowls...big salad bowls or platters...and small individual salad bowls. I'm looking at the JET JWL-1442 VSK and the Nova 1624-44 as my choices. Affordability is the question--these are in my price range. Any help greatly appreciated.

Re: Choosing a lathe

#2

Re: Choosing a lathe

David Walser

>As a practical matter, the largest bowl you can turn is about 1" less than the lathe's swing. (Even with rounding the blank on the bandsaw, some portion of the swing size needs to be reserved for rounding the blank.) That means the Jet will allow you to turn a 13" bowl or platter, while the Nova will allow a 15" diameter turning. If your wife insists on something larger than 13", then the Nova is the way to go. If she is happy with 13" and smaller diameters, turn on both lathes and pick the one that "feels right" to you.

That's my 2 cents. Where do I go to collect?

Re: Choosing a lathe

#3

Steven Antonucci

Not exactly true

steve antonucci

>The headstock on the Nova will rotate to give you much greater capacity than 16". I've turned 23" (precariously) on my Nova.

Steve

Re: Choosing a lathe

#4

Re: Not exactly true

Steve Fowler

>How about the quality of each?

Re: Choosing a lathe

#5

Steven Antonucci

I've had my Nova for 9 years

steve antonucci

>And the new ones are even better than my old Nova 3000.

I think it's a no brainer. If you catch the sale at Woodcraft right, they sometimes throw in a Super Nova II chuck with the lathe.

Steve

Re: Choosing a lathe

#6

Re: I've had my Nova for 9 years

Steve Fowler

>Have you had to add extra weight for stabilizing it?

Re: Choosing a lathe

#7

JL

Re: Choosing a lathe

JL

>Realistically speaking, what is the largest platter size that will fit in your cabinets? Most upper cabinets won't take much more than a 12-13" platter. The lower cabinets will take larger, of course.

The Jet 1442 would need some weight stabilization, IMO. So would the Nova. So with the Jet, add a ballast box. The Nova, you could mount to a heavy cabinet or buy the cast iron stand and add a ballast box. My problem with the Jet is the Reeves drive. I don't like them that much. The Nova 1624-44 has more power and is a variable speed. If I had to choose, I go for the Nova (or a Jet 1642 EVS :)).

Re: Choosing a lathe

#8

Re: Choosing a lathe

Dave Andeson (PacNW)

>Buy a Jet 1642evs, I have the 1 1/2 HP for 5 years and 0 problems. If you want to turn lager than 16", just slide the head stock to the end and use a floor tool rest. The ability to turn off the end of the lathe means you can turn without bending over the lathe bed. The variable speed is invaluable. Once you have it you are spoiled forever.

Just 2cents Worth

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: Choosing a lathe

#9

adding weight to a 1624-44

Steven Kubien

>I bought my lathe used (3 months old at the time) and the original owner used longer bolts where the lathe meets the legs. From this he hung 4 heavy chains and suspended a steel frame/shelf for weight. I've probably got around 300-350 lbs on it. If I go big and unbalanced, things get exciting. Its a good lathe and I have no trouble recommending it.

Doesn't the Jet you mentioned have a reeves drive? I have heard nightmarish things about those (but I have no personal experience). Changing spped on the 1624 is easy, especially if you remove the top cover like I have.

Go with the Nova

Steve Kubien

Re: Choosing a lathe

#10

Steven Antonucci

Cast Iron legs

steve antonucci

>I bought the cast iron legs after having it on a very large bench top for years. The legs have a few spot that you can cut 2x stock to make a quick shelf. If you do this, you can stack sandbags until your hearts desire. I made a small box in which holds about 200# of gravel from my driveway. Works great.

between the two lathes you mentioned, the Nova is the superior lathe by far. You can see my setup in the pic attached below.

S


img

Re: Choosing a lathe

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Cast Iron legs

Brad Vietje

>Steve F.,

I'd go with the Nova, too. Its a pretty rugged and very capable lathe given its relatively light weight. I'd add the cast iron legs and shelf as Steve A suggests. The Jet 14" is not in the same league as the Nova 3000 or DVR, or its bigger brother, the 16" Jet.

Steve A.,

What's with the second headstock? Are you into some new, cutting edge techniques that involve spinning wood in three dimensions at once? Cool!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Choosing a lathe

#12

Re: Cast Iron legs

Steve Fowler

>Thank you--looks like I'll be getting the Nova...but, as a retiring fire marshal, I am a bit concerned about the wiring on the wall in the background.

Re: Choosing a lathe

#13

Get the Jet 1642

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>The 2 HP 1642 is our club demo lathe and it has served us well. I don't know the difference in cost, but it is worth it. It is essentially a smaller version of the Powermatic 3520, which yields more bang for the buck than any other 20" lathe. I think that the 1642 EVS plays the same roll in the 16" range. I wouldn't touch a lathe with a Reeves drive at this point.

I have used this lathe and I like it.

Ed

Re: Choosing a lathe

#14

Spare headstock??

Stuart Johnson

>Can the cast iron legs be used with a ways extension?

Re: Choosing a lathe

#15

Re: Choosing a lathe *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I've been using NOVA lathes since about 1997 when I got a Nova 3000. I used that until about 2002 when the NOVA DVR came on the market. As soon as possible, I purchased a NOVA DVR. The Nova 3000 was an excellent lathe, the DVR was a significant upgrade. I believe the NOVA 16-24/42 is simply an upgrade of the ole NOVA 3000, with a better tailstock and slightly heavier bed. I would highly recommend the NOVA lathe over the Jet if they are in the same price range.


More Woodturning Website

Re: Choosing a lathe

#16

Re: Choosing a lathe

Ron McKinley

>If you can afford it go with the DVR XP. You'll love the continuous variable speed with no belts and no pulleys. I've got mine mounted on a heavy workbench that also holds a Jet Mini with extension. The legs are 4" x 4" and it's about 24" wide x 60" long. It contains 2 drawers and a big cabinet space underneath for storage of heavy items and I've never had a problem with it wanting to move around. The low end speed is 100 rpm and I believe the upper end is 3,000 rpm and it's continuously variable over that range........Ron

Re: Choosing a lathe

#17

Steven Antonucci

Wiring isn't as bad as it looks

steve antonucci

>This is an old picture, and since then, I've tightened it up a bit. If I ever sell the house, it comes out in 5 minutes.

Never even tripped a breaker.

Steve

Re: Choosing a lathe

#18

Steven Antonucci

Second headstock is a repair

steve antonucci

>Nova warranty through Woodcraft is excellent. Tim Geist sent me a replacement with no questions asked. Told me that it would cost more to ship than it was worth, so I used it as ballast. It's on a shelf in the shop somewhere nowadays...

Wonder if I could knock together another poorman's lathe out of the stuff I've got laying around?

S

Re: Choosing a lathe

#19

Steven Antonucci

Yes, but you lose the red chip deflector(I think?)

steve antonucci

>All of the new stuff has different bolt patterns. If I had the extension, I'd have someone fabricate the chip deflector out of 1/4" steel plate.

Made things real easy to sweep out.

Steve

Re: Choosing a lathe

#20

Question about the DVR XP

Carole Valentine

>I notice the XP has ways that come all the way down to bench level...no gap. My DVR has a slight gap, but not big enough to put my hand under the ways to sweep out shavings (I neglected to put it on blocks to raise it up more above the stand) Why in the world would they design it like that? It looks like if you don't have it on an open stand where the shavings can fall through or on blocks, it would be a real pain.

Re: Choosing a lathe

#21

Re: Question about the DVR XP *LINK*

Alan Trout

>I love my DVR if you can I agree that is the way to go for a nice powerful, compact, lathe with good capacity. Here are some pics of my rig on the Nova web site. This is mine at the top of the page.

Good Luck

Alan


My Lathe

Re: Choosing a lathe

#22

Re: Question about the DVR XP

Carole Valentine

>Alan, do you have any close-ups of the details on that stand? More specifically the swing away part? Did you post pics here a while back or in another forum? If so, I can search them out. That is a beauty. I don't suppose there is any chance you sell those? BTW...I love my DVR too (not XP, though.) It's always done anything I asked of it.

Re: Choosing a lathe

#23

Re: Question about the DVR XP

Ron McKinley

>I put mine on 3/4" strips so I can vacuum out the chips.....Ron

Re: Choosing a lathe

#24

You told me to...

Ron McKinley

>I should have mentioned that I did that on your advice. When I saw that you had one I wrote you and you complained about that so I put mine on strips. Thanks for the advice.....Ron

Re: Choosing a lathe

#25

Re: You told me to...

Carole Valentine

>LOL! You're welcome. I forgot about that, Ron. At least with the DVR they left some space under the ways...with the XP they took THAT away! Doesn't make any sense.