>Have been turning some green walnut and using it to practice various techniques. Due to a previous lung scare, I always use a Trend Airshield when turning or sanding. The last few days, I have been extremely itchy along the line where the Trend unit meets my neck. Where the elastic seals the unit basically from just below my ear all the way around the neck. I have been using the Trend for at least 5 months and never expereinced a problem. Is it possible to be allergic to this one wood? Have turned many other woods and even Coco which is supposed to be highly allergenic and never had a problem.
Next question...have been experimenting with form and tool technique turning small goblets. What tools are used to hollow out the cup end of goblets? Can this be done without buying/making special hollowing tools?
>Ed, I'd say that it is possible that you are reacting to the walnut and that is not all that uncommon. Most folks that react to walnut do so over a period of time so maybe you're just special.
On the goblet question I assume you're talking about turning the end grain which is best done with a scraping tool. You can easily make your own and there are many references here and elsewhere on the net on how to do this. Still, I recommend the Hunter tool and once you get a feel for the Hunter you'll understand why.
Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d
Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d
Guest
Re: Newbie Questions
Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d
>I have heard that some people have a skin reaction to walnut. With your respiratory history I would suggest you avoid Black Walnut. I also have read that if you are sensitive to something, the more you expose your immune system to it, the more sensitive you become and the longer you avoid what causes mild allergic reactions, theore you are able to have casual exposure without a reaction. I have certainly found this to be true for me and Poison Ivy.
>Cyril..thanks for the help. I started to think along the allergy lines this morning after being up half the night sratching my neck...!
Have actually been working with this wood for about 5/6 weeks and started to get this reaction about a week ago. Never associated the two until this morning.
I will look into the Hunter tool. Is that something that the normal turning supply sources carry?
>Thanks for the info Peter...I didn't pay any attention and had not realized that the face shield was removable but it does stand to reason. Although I have been using the Trend for about 5 months and only starting having the itching problem a week ago when I started turning a lot of this black walnut. Guess I will just have to narrow it down between the Trend and the walnut.
>Steve...I remember you telling me about coco allergies but no one had ever mentioned walnut so when the itching started..I never gave the wood a thought. I am fine around coco but it would appear that I cant handle walnut for some reason.
Just went down to the shop to check out the face seal on the trend airshield pro and really can not see any dust or debris that could be an irritant. Am guessing it is the wood
>I've used a 3/8" spindle gouge with the wings ground back to hollow goblets and little boxes for years. I cut from the center out towards the outside, cutting up to about 10:00 O'clock is a clock face were on the end of the goblet.
You can also use a small round nose scraper with fairly good results. Again, I recommend working from the center toward the outside.
The best tools for the job is either the Hunter tool or the Eliminator with the 3/8" carbide disk or less. The Eliminator is available with a 1/4" carbide disk, which is fantastic for hollowing the end grain on the goblet bowl.
Make sure you do the hollowing of the goblet before you turn the stem. In fact, the entire bowl portion should be finish turned and sanded prior to turning the stem. Once this is done, you can put a tennis ball in the mouth of the goblet and bring up the tailstock with a live center to help support the wood as you make the stem thinner and thinner. If you don't have a tennis ball, wad up some soft material, cloth, paper towel, etc. and put this in the bowl of the goblet and then bring up the live center in the tailstock to give some support. The tennis ball works best.
>First experience turning walnut sent me to the ER...no problem w/breathing but I was about ready to take a belt sander to the itching. I still have scars where I broke out around my watchband.
Also have problems w/some of the rosewoods.
I have still worked with it in a limited way--but I use a breather, rubber gloves, long sleevs tucked in, dust collector, etc. Then I IMMEDIATELY shower and change clothes. Sometimes I STILL have a small reaction in a couple of places. But if it I had breathing problems I wouldn't take the chance.
>I used it for years before my first reaction. The reaction was so bad that I will never turn it again. Prior to that event, I had never had any reaction.
Since then, walnut has been worse too. Why do you think I bring walnut to all of the club functions? :-)
>It is the juglans oil that causes contact dermatitis. Some species have a higher oil content than others with juglans regia(english walnut) being on the low end and juglans hindsii(claro walnut)being on the high end. Juglans nigra (american walnut) is closer to english than claro in its toxic content of juglans oil. I have a friend that can work with american walnut with no allergic reaction but he is very allergic to claro.
About a year ago I had a bout of contact dermatitis that left me with what looked like chemical burns/blisters all over my fore arms. This was a reaction while milling green claro during the summer. I have since noticed that my reaction is strongest when it is hot enough that I sweat and the sawdust mixes with the sweat on my skin. I also react stongest to green walnut dust.
At last count I have 109 2" thick slabs of claro that on average are 72"x24" and a few of other sizes as well. so far I have not had any contact dermatitis while working with dry walnut, but I wear long sleave shirts when working with it just incase.
>...green butternut is another story. Same family of trees but the butternut made me itch, watery eyes... No problem with it when it was dried and re-turned. Cocbolo doesn't bother me at all either.
>Ahhhhh........cocobolo! Damn that stuff! So beautiful! Just like a beautiful girl.....who is only 15. So pretty, but you know you can't touch it.
Seriously, I can turn a couple of cocobolo wine stoppers and head straight for the shower.......and still get a reaction. Sometimes, it's a day or two later, but I still get a little redness and rash. A little Cortisone 10 cream usually clears it up.
>I have the saem sort of reaction with cocobolo. Much worse when it's hot and I'm sweaty. Makes the sawdust cling more, I guess. Try Cortisone 10 cream. Showering immediately after working with this stuff helps, but does not prevent a reaction.