Excellent suggestions, Pete
Ellis Walentine, Host
>One of the drawbacks of our messageboard software is that we don't have the option of "sticky" posts, as a lot of the other software packages have. So, if you want to learn about vacuum chucking, for example, you have to dig back through two archives -- the current (last 10,000) messages and the ones before that. If you want to search our articles, you need to go to either the home page or the articles index page and enter your search term there. My problem is that with about 4,000 web pages to index or catalog, it is a task that far exceeds my ability to do much about it, except for possibly introducing a new search utility. But, that search utility would still not be able to properly access the archived messages, and if it could, the results would be overwhelming.
I strongly agree that a lot of our topics have been hashed over more than once, and well, in the past. The intrepid can find those threads. But, there is another dimension to this, and that has to do with timeliness and community. Everything changes over time. Products, techniques, attitudes, perceptions. Current discussions are the life blood of this site and should be welcomed. If someone recalls a previous discussion of that topic, they are free to refer back to it for the reader's convenience. (I've been to other sites where they post these ominous instructions telling visitors to look up their question in the archives before asking it in the forum, and I've always felt that to be very alienating.)
I've been talking with a couple people in the publishing business about a compilation of the "Best of WoodCentral," because we've really had some world-class discussions here that deserve to be edited and preserved in some kind of organized fashion. Presumably, this project would include an online archive as well, which would do everything you folks are speculating about.
All I need is a way to pull it off. We don't have much budget for ventures. I rely on volunteers and friends to help produce the articles and shots and reviews that you read and enjoy here. If everyone who visits here could contribute something, anything, occasionally, we might be able to finance a major project like this, but there aren't enough hours in my day to do it myself.
In my couple decades in publishing and my fifteen years online, I've decided there are two kinds of people: those who prefer the immediacy of the forum experience and those who enjoy sifting through the archival record. Both kinds of people are welcome here and we try to accommodate everyone the best we can. Sometimes I wish we had the human and capital resources of a larger parent corporation -- like magazine sites do -- to absorb some of the costs of ambitious and creative new ventures, because I have a lot of them I'd like to initiate. But, the bottom line is that WoodCentral's core value lies in the currency and civility of our interactions with each other. It doesn't hurt that there are so many knowledgeable people who participate in our discussions. But, organizing the incredible depth of information here is a very worthwhile ambition, and one that often keeps me up at night. I keep wondering if we could establish sort of a "cloud computing" model or something, where you folks could each contribute your notions of what's important, or somehow rank or edit or research some of the good information of the past that has eluded or outrun our ability to condense it into articles. That would be the height of community.
Dreamin' on. I do appreciate any and all input on how to improve what we do here. Someday it may all come true.
Best,
Ellis