Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Thought for an educational section of this site

Posts

Thought for an educational section of this site

#1

Thought for an educational section of this site

Pete in Holland, MI

>Ellis -

I have been hanging around this site now for a couple years now and have really been enjoying & learning from it. Several of you have been here longer. There seems to be several regular questions that pop up from new lurkers looking for everybody's 2 cents worth, but eventually, those idea givers may start to get tiring, repeating themselves over & over to every new person coming along.

I suggest having a section in the turning thread that could be used to store folks ideas & such, and become a good resource/solution area for people to look into, before asking the same questions over & over.

Some topics that would be worth creating a research/solution source for may be things like: Vacuum pumps - what to look for & where to buy, vacuum couplings built, vacuum chucks, bearings for vacuum couplings, tool carts, weight boxes, tool rest designs, tail stock swing-aways, boring jigs, chuck choice, lighting, alcohol/boiling/waxing/microwave drying, etc.

I am envisioning a site, with various topics in the glossary. Under each topic, the "experts" would be asked to give their 2 cents worth in a thread, including pictures & such so this would be their one-time opportunity to describe the topic. Once newbies would find or be directed to this area, THEN more specific questions could be asked of the group.

I know there is an archives on this site, but nothing as a formal reference library.

Thoughts anyone ?

Pete LaBelle

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#2

Re: It's already there

Russ Fairfield

>Good idea, but......

What you describe has already been done in the "Articles" section that is accessed from the menu at the left of the message window. Most of the responses that I post are already in the Finishing Secrets, or Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ's), and the other articles in Russ's Corner, also available from the menu.

The problem is that nobody, especially beginners, read these resources because it is a lot easier to just ask the question than do the research. I am afraid that adding one more section of FAQ's will just be one more place they won't look.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#3

Believe Russ is right (as usual...)

david

>

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#4

Re: It's already there

David Walser

>In fairness to all those who fail to find the answer in the articles and other sections of the website, this place isn't the easiest to find your way around. WoodCentral provides great information and comradeship, but it can be a tad bewildering. The failure to find the answer is not always due (entirely) to laziness.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#5

JL

???

JL

>The side bar seems to work for me. I agree that it would be nice to have a better (and more global) search engine for the entire site though.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#6

I HaveTo Disagree

Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d

>I find it very easy to navigate this site. You have to spend a little time looking around and investigating what is available. It never ceases to amaze me how many questions are asked when the answer is already available.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#7

Re: I HaveTo Disagree

David Walser

>

...You have to spend a little time looking around and investigating what is available. It never ceases to amaze me how many questions are asked when the answer is already available.

Oops. I didn't mean to offend anyone nor did I want to start a debate about which forum has the best format. WoodCentral has a lot of information. Under the best of circumstances, at times it's going to be hard to find what you want amongst the abundance. For example, a search for "lacquer" in the "WoodCentral Articles" section yields 136 entries spread over 4.5 pages. Sure, a more targeted search would yield a more manageable number of hits, but targeted searches sometimes require the very knowledge the person searching for the information lacks. Scrolling through the articles is not much better. There are dozens of articles related to turning with nothing more than their title to give a clue to what they contain. A detailed index might help, but even that would go on for pages -- and might intimidate a lot of readers who have a vague idea what they want to know but aren't sure what are the proper terms to look under.

So, all I was trying to say is that when someone may posts a question that could have been answered by reference to something in the articles section, the person asking the question may not be lazy. He or she may not have been able to find the right article or they might have been unaware the articles might even address the topic.

We were all new to WoodCentral once. One of the great things about this site (in addition to the wealth of information) is the welcoming nature of the people who populate this community. It's great that so many are willing to answer newbies' questions -- even if that answer is a pointer to the right article on the topic.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#8

I guess no question should be posted

Stuart Johnson

>If you stop and think about it just about every thing and every question has been posted and answered. So I guess we should all just do searches and not post questions. Instead of answers we should just tell the poster to search the site or use google or yahoo.

In reality the same questions are asked over and over. They are usually answered and many times the answer along with some additional information is posted by someone that asked a similar question earlier.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#9

Re: I HaveTo Disagree

Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d

>David, you did not offend at all. I just have a different opinion; that should not make you feel bad.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#10

Excellent suggestions, Pete

Ellis Walentine, Host

>One of the drawbacks of our messageboard software is that we don't have the option of "sticky" posts, as a lot of the other software packages have. So, if you want to learn about vacuum chucking, for example, you have to dig back through two archives -- the current (last 10,000) messages and the ones before that. If you want to search our articles, you need to go to either the home page or the articles index page and enter your search term there. My problem is that with about 4,000 web pages to index or catalog, it is a task that far exceeds my ability to do much about it, except for possibly introducing a new search utility. But, that search utility would still not be able to properly access the archived messages, and if it could, the results would be overwhelming.

I strongly agree that a lot of our topics have been hashed over more than once, and well, in the past. The intrepid can find those threads. But, there is another dimension to this, and that has to do with timeliness and community. Everything changes over time. Products, techniques, attitudes, perceptions. Current discussions are the life blood of this site and should be welcomed. If someone recalls a previous discussion of that topic, they are free to refer back to it for the reader's convenience. (I've been to other sites where they post these ominous instructions telling visitors to look up their question in the archives before asking it in the forum, and I've always felt that to be very alienating.)

I've been talking with a couple people in the publishing business about a compilation of the "Best of WoodCentral," because we've really had some world-class discussions here that deserve to be edited and preserved in some kind of organized fashion. Presumably, this project would include an online archive as well, which would do everything you folks are speculating about.

All I need is a way to pull it off. We don't have much budget for ventures. I rely on volunteers and friends to help produce the articles and shots and reviews that you read and enjoy here. If everyone who visits here could contribute something, anything, occasionally, we might be able to finance a major project like this, but there aren't enough hours in my day to do it myself.

In my couple decades in publishing and my fifteen years online, I've decided there are two kinds of people: those who prefer the immediacy of the forum experience and those who enjoy sifting through the archival record. Both kinds of people are welcome here and we try to accommodate everyone the best we can. Sometimes I wish we had the human and capital resources of a larger parent corporation -- like magazine sites do -- to absorb some of the costs of ambitious and creative new ventures, because I have a lot of them I'd like to initiate. But, the bottom line is that WoodCentral's core value lies in the currency and civility of our interactions with each other. It doesn't hurt that there are so many knowledgeable people who participate in our discussions. But, organizing the incredible depth of information here is a very worthwhile ambition, and one that often keeps me up at night. I keep wondering if we could establish sort of a "cloud computing" model or something, where you folks could each contribute your notions of what's important, or somehow rank or edit or research some of the good information of the past that has eluded or outrun our ability to condense it into articles. That would be the height of community.

Dreamin' on. I do appreciate any and all input on how to improve what we do here. Someday it may all come true.

Best,

Ellis

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#11

Hey Ellis! I have a suggestion>>>>>

Barry Irby

>I know it has been discussed here ad nauseum, but we need an easier way to post photos. I find it challenging and Daunting. I don't take the best pics to start with and then to have to sett eh width to X and the height to Y, well I just don't get it. To make it worse, I have to trim the wick in my scanner and make sure the kerosene is fresh. If I'm not careful, it melts the crayon on my pictures.

My suggestion is some sort of auto sizing feature that would accept most any size and format and scale it back to the best size. (And sharpen the image, improve the colors, fix the contrast, and while it is at it improve the form of my turnings.)

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#12

Re: Resizing pictures

Dinyar Chavda

>If you're using Windows XP, there is a really easy way to resize your pictures.

Go to http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/Downloads/powertoys/Xppowertoys.mspx

Each of the powertoys are listed along on the right edge--I use several of them. The one you want is "Image Resizer". Download it, and install it. Then, when you want to resize any picture, just right-mouse-click on the picture, and one of the options is "Resize Pictures". Click on it, and you'll get 4 size options. A little experimentation will show you what the best option is to fit WC's limits. All four options give you decent pictures. Try it.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#13

JL

You still have to sort the wheat from the chaff..

JL

>It is easier to do that in a thread as opposed to a search.

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#14

Re: Resizing pictures

wilbur

>And in case there are any Mac users reading this thread, the ability to resize pictures is built into OS X.

Open your picture using the Preview program. Use the File --> Save As option from the menu. A little window will pop up. Change the format to JPEG, if it isn't set already. Then use the little Quality slider to change the file size to close to 80KB, which is the WoodCentral picture size limit. Save your picture, and you're ready to upload.


img

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#15

Not just Lurkers or Newbies but me, too....

Ruth Niles

>Personally, I am one of those lazy people and when I have a question or problem, the first thing I do is post it. I may try a search, most likely not.

Yes, the same questions are asked over and over and will continue to be thus. (like that "thus"?) : ) But isn't that what a forum is all about?

I do read the articles and check Russ's Corner when there is something I need to re-read that I know is there, and there is some great reading in that Corner.

Help keep this forum going and ask those questions for instant answers and suggestions. works for me

Re: Thought for an educational section of this site

#16

thank you ellis, wc is #1

robert davis

>