Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

lacquer over danish oil?

Posts

lacquer over danish oil?

#1

lacquer over danish oil?

Steven Kubien

>Morning everyone,

I think the message-title says it all. Can I put spray lacquer over danish oil? I used the oil to bring out the colour in some peppermills (cocobolo for one and a maple/walnut lamination for another) and now I wonder what to do to get some shine. More coats of oil and buff? Oil/varnish/thinner homebrew? Lacquer? I am worried about the natural oils in the cocobolo, along with what I added being compatible. Have I screwed this up?

Thanks for your help,

Steve Kubien

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#2

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

Russ Fairfield

>Screwed up?? Probably not.

Give the Oil a few days to a week to cure in a warm room. Then thoroughly buff the surface with 0000-steel wool. Do the 1st coat of lacquer with a brush, make that a heavy sloppy wet coat, and then wipe it off until it is dry. This brushed coat will remove any residual oils on the surface, and leave a clean primer coat of lacquer that is ready for spraying.

I have no idea why the old wives tale about using an oil finish to accent the grain still endures. The truth is that lacquer, put on a wood surface that has been sanded to 400-grit, will do a better job of accenting the grain than any amount of oil ever did. And it does it without the blotching you will get from the oil.

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#3

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

gary clarke

>Russ, does this hold true for water based lacquer as well?

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#4

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

Russ Fairfield

>The answer is that, it depends. Waterborne lacquers have always suffered from 2 problems - a blue to gray cast that gave the wood a muddy appearance, and that multiple coats didn't melt together. That remaining in separate layered coats gave intermediate planes to scatter the light to where they were never as bright as a nitrocellulose or CAB-Acrylic lacquer.

HOWEVER, things are changing. The blue haze problem has been solved by new technology, and the biggest breakthrough is a waterborne lacquer that will melt into the same lacquer under it. With these lacquers, there is no difference. The only problem is they aren't available on the shelves at the local Woodcraft or paint store. They are available by the gallon from the manufacturer. I suspect that will be changing soon.

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#5

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I have been using General's HP Poly for a couple of years now and it is a waterbased poly acrylic blend that looks and sands and buffs up just like nitrocellulose. I have had great success with applying it over the top of wet oil, yes WET oil. You will have to try a sample with the oil you are using but I use it with Jasco brand tung oil and give the oil enough "drying" time for me to lay out the rags and remove my gloves. One advantage of this is that the oil seals the wood so the water based finish dosen't raise the grain and it kind of lubes it so the brush glides really nice over the top of the oil.

I have used this on a bench in a high traffic comercial area and it is still looking great a year later.

Robin

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#6

Re: A suggested product *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>The only one of these I have tried is the ColorTone Waterbase Lacquer

Clear gloss topcoat, available from Stewart MacDonald for about $30 a quart. It ain't cheap. It is a clear acrylic waterborne lacquer that has 100% burn-in between coats without a time limit on the recoating.

I like what I see so far. It does burn-in between coats, there is no blue haze, and it is clear. It also has a high solids content and builds well, fills the wood well, and levels well with either a brush or spray application. I have only used it for a little over a year, and that isn't long enough to have any observation on whether it will yellow or become brittle with age.

Meanwhile, I still use the nitrocellulose lacquers because I know how to use them, and I am adicted to the fumes. I still have 2 gallons of Deft to use up, but I do prefer the new Watco brushing lacquer for both brushing and spraying because it is a clear liquid and Deft no longer is, there is a higher solids content than Deft, and it seems to level itself on the surface better than Deft when applied with a brush, and it doesn't need as much thinner for spraying.


Stewart MacDonald waterborne lacquer

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#7

Re: and Yes, it can....

Russ Fairfield

>Yes, it can be used over other finishes, including oils, shellac, and other lacxquers. That too is an improvement over the waterbornes of the past.

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#8

Thanks for the help

Steven Kubien

>I love that I can ask a question in the morning, come back and have answers late in the afternoon. Fantastic.

Thanks a heap

Steve

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#9

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

Kirk (KC) Constable

>WATCO natural seems to 'deepen' the color on many woods... which is why I use it when I use it.

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#10

danish oil on cocobolo

John K Jordan

>I had a "bad" experience with danish oil on cocobolo. I make a lot of little finger tops and usually use shellac-based friction polish. Once I tried danish oil. Over the next year, that one turned almost as black as ebony, while another with friction polish kept the bright cocobolo colors.

I have not yet repeated this to verify. I want to apply various finishes on areas of the same cocobolo board and see what happens over time, with and without light and air.

JKJ

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: danish oil on cocobolo

Mike Stafford

>John, my experience with oil on cocobolo has been much the same as yours. Cocobolo is naturally oily and the applied oil never dries resulting in a sticky gummy mess.

I use a varnish or a lacquer based product.

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#12

So now what do I do?

Steven Kubien

>Ya know, there was a little voice in my head teling me that D.O. and cocobolo was not a good idea. I should've listened. So, can I remove the oil with mineral spirits or do I need to sand/turn it away?

Thanks,

Steve

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#13

Re: So now what do I do?

John K Jordan

>I haven't tried "un-oiling". Since cocobolo is not an open grain wood, I suspect oil would not penetrate too far. I would probably try to remove wood if possible.

I did not cut into my darkened piece to see if the effect was only skin deep, but that would be another good test.

A few pieces of the cocobolo I have seem to be quite old and the outside is as dark as walnut. When I cut through, the darkening extends 1/4" or so into the wood, gradually brightening towards the center. This makes me think that that darkening is more due to interaction with the atmosphere (oxidation?) than from light or anything else. Perhaps oil on the surface accelerates this. Perhaps heat also plays a part.

I didn't have any problem with the oil finish getting gummy, but I think I wiped it off, perhaps while spinning on the lathe (which may have generated heat.) There are too many variables!

JKJ

Re: lacquer over danish oil?

#14

Re: danish oil on cocobolo

Ron McKinley

>I use Danish Oil on cocobolo all the time and have never had the problem you describe. I live in the desert and always buff it out running the lathe at 2,000 rpm. The next day I put it through the Beall Buff system......Ron