>I have a box elder tree that's just in the wrong place, and is shading my garden. Also, I'm looking for more wood to turn, so....
I know this wood sometimes has red coloring, sort of like spalting.
I'm wondering if this is natural, in the wood, or if it actually is a form of spalt. That is, if I cut this tree down, will my logs have the red streaks, or do I need to leave them on the ground for a while?
(That just raised the idea of having BOTH the red streaks and black spalting lines, which would look even more awesome!)
Does anyone have experience turning this wood? (I'm thinking bowls and platters, not hollow forms, vessels, or ornaments).
Should I turn it green, or let it dry, or let it spalt?
>If the tree is young and healthy, there may be no red color at all. My understanding is that the color is a response to environmental stresses. I have cut several box elders and have only found substantial color once. Good luck with the spalting, also. My experience there is that the wood tends to rot before any significant spalting occurs.
All that being said, you may find you have the mother lode of color. I wouldn't take the tree down just to get the wood, but if it's coming down anyway, it is still very nice wood to turn.
>I've heard numerous theories on the red streaks in addition to the ones already expressed here. They're largely moot - your tree has red or it doesn't. Even without color, box elder is sweet wood to turn. You may be able to find figure in the wood. It spalts like any maple, but it's lighter and softer than most maples and turns to mush more quickly.
If you do find red, be aware that the red will turn to brown in sunlight or UV. I prefer to use a finish that doesn't amber or muddy the color. I commonly use spray lacquer or Deft.
>The tree is of fairly good size, but isn't particularly thrifty, and as I said it's shading my garden.
I've not got my heart set on taking it down, but if I were to do it, I would certainly want to turn some of it, especially if the red staining was there.
I was mostl;y wondering if it was a "normal" part of box elder (like, they all have it) or if there was soemthing I needed to do to the wood (like leave it on the ground, like spalting...).
Sounds like the wood will either have it or it won't. Environmental stressers, eh?? Guess I'll have to go out there and find a way to stress the tree. Maybe call it names, or make it fill out my tax return....
Any tips on turning or finishing? is it basically maple, once it's on the lathe?
What was the line from that Tom Hanks movie - "Life's like a box of chocolates - you never know what you're going to get"?
Maybe that should be changed to "Life's like a box elder tree...."
Good to know about the finish, too - I usually rub in some oil to bring out the grain, then topcoat, but maybe with box elder this will only mess up the red.
Box Elder (Acer negundo) is a species within the soft maple group of maples; as most maples go, the wood has a fairly low density and is reasonably soft compared to woods like red oak and walnut.
Studies have shown that the red pigmentation is found in trees which have been infected with a number of different species of fungi of the genera Fusarium and Hypsizygus. It is not clear if it is the fungus generating the pigment, or if it is the tree generating it as a response to stress of the fungal invasion. I have used box elder extensively over the past 5-6 years or so, and have sold a good number of pieces turned from this species, some with vivid red color "staining". I've even had "green" (wet) blanks sprout mushrooms of the fungus Hypsizygus ulmaria while waiting (several weeks) in my shop to be turned. These species of fungi are typically NOT the same fungi causing black line spalting, so to spalt this wood effectively, another fungus (or fungi) of different species would have to invade and become established in the wood, with at least a few different strains to be able to establish adequate zone lines.
The wood is prone to tear out (end grain), so sharp tools are advised while turning (...a good rule in general!). As has been already noted, there is no effective way to preserve the red color from shifting to brown over extended time - some claim they have delayed this shift by keeping the wood out of light. Toward the end of this semester, I will be working with a natural products chemist here at Iowa State to identify the structure and class of the red pigment from box elder. Finally a good use for all of those bright red shavings!
In my opinion, the wood should be finished with products that do not appreciably change the wood's color - lacquer is my preferred finish; water-based polyurethane also works as long as it does not give a blue cast to the finish. I find that most oil finishes tend to shift the color too far toward amber, and the bright white contrasting wood against the red staining (and occasionally the bluish-grey mineral staining that also is found in box elder) is dulled or lost with an inappropriate finish. I have found that box elder dries well and quickly from roughed green blanks, does not distort appreciably when drying, and is not too bad regarding checks and stress cracks. I rarely lose box elder roughed out bowls to drying defects, including end-grain vessels that contain the pith.
Box elder is one of my favorite turning woods. Binh Pho also uses box elder in his thin-walled vessels; he bleaches the wood to remove any color, and then goes about his magical airbrushing and piercing.
I hope the information above is helpful to you......
Turn safely!
(Prof.) Rob Wallace*
(*Botanist and biology professor by day; woodturner and coach most other times.....)
>I have used two part bleach on Box Elder. The wood gets nearly as white as ivory and the red seems to get redder. (I doubt that it really does, rather the contrast is greater making it appear more red.)
When completely dry the wood is stringy and tears-out easily.
One person I know goes over the red areas with red coloring in an air brush. The result...non-fading Box Elder!
>If there is any red in the trunk, you might try digging up the stump. Last summer a friend gave me some box elder root and it had some of the most incredible color I've ever seen. It had masses of solid and variegated color where the log has streaks, at best. I finished this little piece with lacquer and so far it hasn't faded. It probably helps to keep box elder (or any wood) out of direct sunlight.
If you haven't worked with stump wood, it's a chore. I've dug several with a backhoe recently and salvaged a lot of wonderful wood root wood from one big cherry tree. Be prepared to chip away the dirt by hand or with a pressure washer, strip away bark, and still resharpen the chain saw often when you hit embedded pockets of dirt and rock.
>Wow - that's quite a response - very thorough explanation of the pros and cons of the wood. I'm printing it out right now!
Thanks so much for taking the time to wqrite such a thorough answer to my question.
Good luck with the research into stabilizing the color. Based on the images I've seen of other peoples work with this wood, it woould be very useful to have some way of keeping the red. I wonder if your findings might also apply to purpleheart.....
If I decide to take the tree down, I'll try to turn the better blanks wet, but at the rate I turn, most of it will either by dried or firewood by the time a get around to it....
Not much good with a paintbrush, let alone an air brush, so I doubt I'll be touching up the red.
>That is a stunning vase - shows off the wood very nicely.
Digging stumps, then going through all the powerwashing, stone extraction, etc. sounds too much like work to me, so I dowbt I'll be going after the stump. The tree itself will be giving me more than enough turning material, at the rate I go.