Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

New PM3520B has a *tick*

Posts

New PM3520B has a *tick*

#1

New PM3520B has a *tick*

Ron Solfest

>I've been mostly lurking here for a while but now am in some need of help.

I have a ~2wk old PM3520B that I've only played with a few times. I've turned about a half-dozen bowls on it, all walnut I have from a couple of downed trees. This morning I was turning 2 mostly green 10" bowls and suddenly I noticed a *tick* while turning the second bowl.

I can't identify exactly where it's coming from. It's noticeable immediately when I turn it on and speeds up as the lathe speeds up. It doesn't go away by running the speed up. I can turn off the lathe and unplug it and still get the tick by turning the handwheel. In fact, I can even isolate it to a specific position by slowly turning the handwheel and make it tick by turning it back and forth a few degrees. Sometimes there's a double-tick. After spinning it, I can reisolate it, but not on the same spot as before.

I think I hear it loudest when the belt cover is open and I'm snooping around in there with a flashlight. I can also here the tick ring when my ear is by the motor fan but I think this is just the fan blade vibrating from a tick emanating elsewhere.

If I unload the belt from both shafts, neither shaft will tick. I don't notice any play in the shafts. Does anyone have any ideas what it is? Do I have a bearing problem? (I HOPE not).

Thanks for any help!

Ron

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#2

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Charles Watson------WebKitFormBoundary+ATeQdvhmFc4

>The lathe we use for club demonstrations started making the same noise. It had something to do with the RPM readout or the spindle lock.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#3

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

John Irvine

>check to see it the driven belt pully on the headshaft is tight I believe there are two set screws holding it tight

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#4

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Check/tighten the Allen screw on the pulley.

If that doesn't do it, then make sure that the spindle lock indent is clear of the pulley.

Ed

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#5

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Sean Troy

>Is this happening when a chuck is on the spindle? If so, try the test whithout a chuck mounted. The (loose) jaws on a chuck have made this noise for me before and drove me crazy trying to figure it out.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#6

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Ron Solfest

>Thanks for the ideas, but no winners yet.

The pulley set screws are tight, and I've pulled the front speed panel off and can see that it's not the speed sensor nor the spindle lock. I've also pulled the motor fan shroud and it's not there.

No chucks are on the spindle.

A new piece of info is that it is always isolated to a particular position of the motor spindle. I marked the motor spindle pulley and it always ticks at the same spot. Again, this only happens when the belt is on and tensioned, if I remove the belt I can rotate the motor with no sounds.

The next step I can think of is to pull the motor and examine the shaft, but given it doesn't tick without a side load from the belt I don't think I'll be able to tell anything (besides the fact I don't relish the idea of lifting the heavy motor off.

Any other ideas/suggestions? I think I'll wait a few hours before I yank the motor.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Keith Tompkins

>perhaps it is a seam in the belt?

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#8

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Ron Solfest

>Thanks but no such luck. I checked the belt and pulley surfaces and repositioned things a couple of times. The tick stays consistent with a particular position of the motor shaft. If I bear down to put more side load on the belt I can turn the tick to more of a creaking, again around a few degrees of the same motor position making the noise in both forward and reverse (by hand). Even if I just tighten the motor lock with only the motors weight on it I get the tick, although not as consistently.

This noise just started this morning after only a few total hours on this new lathe :(

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#9

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Bruce

>Mine does it from time to time. I have found that shavings can get down in the indexing holes near the spindle. I am able to clear the holes with a shot of air. Might be worth a "shot".

Bruce

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#10

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Ron Solfest

>Thanks Bruce, I'd already tried that too - didn't fix it.

Do you add any downward force when tightening the motor or strictly uses the weight of the motor? I'm starting to wonder if I just need to leave the belt looser so there's no side-load on the motor shaft. If I do this I usually don't have any ticking (but it doesn't eliminate it completely).

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#11

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Can you tell if the shaft key is in line with the pull of the belts? With what you have given, I am wondering if there might be a little too much play in the shaft OD and Pulley ID?

If not, I think I would contact PM.

Did you say that you had taken the fan shroud off of the other end of the motor, and turned it while off?

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#12

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Ron Solfest

>Don't think there's any play between the shaft and pulley. Seems like a tight fit and the hexheads are in tight.

Yes I did remove the fan shroud and turn it by hand, ticks still there.

If I turn it on slow and unload the belt (lift up on the motor, let motor weight settle it down, and lock it there) it seems to work without ticking very often.

If I then run it and loosen the motor mount and apply *any* downward pressure I start getting the ticking again. Any others experience this?

I think your right and I need to contact PM.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#13

Dick Hines

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Dick Hines

>Ron check to see if the spindle locking collar is loose. I have had the set screw work loose in my 3520A a couple of times. It that is the ticking is comming from take the spindle lock button out a use a allen wernch to tighten it up. If you can't get the buton out you can use an allen wrench through the pully door.

If the screw is loose take it out and put a drop of BLUE Lock Tight on the threads and run it up. Do not use the RED!

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#14

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Gary Ljostad

>Ron I had a similar problem on my older 3520a. Tightening the bearing race nut on the main shaft, under the hand wheel fixed it.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#15

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I don't have a Mustard Monster but I had a similar problem with my Oneway. I found that the motor pulley had moved on the shaft away from the motor a bit so that the belt didn't line up with the headstock pulley. I got it lined up and the problem went away.

Wally

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#16

Ron, a friend had this same ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>problem with his new PM3520. He called the local PM rep, who came out to see what was wrong.

I just called my friend who had this problem and he said that the rep thought that the screws were tight, but that in desperation he took the pulley off and relocated it on the shaft - I assume that it was a rotational adjustment - and that when it was reinstalled and tightened good the noise went away.

Not long after that there were other reports on this or the AAW forum about the same problem with the screws and the noise.

Ed

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#17

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I had the same problem with mine. I called PM and they said it was the bearings. They sent new ones and I installed them (they would have if I wanted). That fixed it. A year later the same thing. New bearings and it was fixed. Note: I turn full time and very large items.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#18

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Russ Fairfield

>A common source for the sound you describe is a loose drive pulley. It may not be enough to notice or move it by hand, but it will definitely do it under power, and once each revolution of the shaft. I don't know what the 3520 has now, but the earlier models had a drive pulley that was keyed to the shaft and a set screw to hold it in position. Pull the belt back and check for the set-screw. There may be 2 set-screws in the same hole. One to the shaft or the top of the key, and another on top of it in the same hole to lock it in place. In that case, you will have to take the top screw out to get at the bottom one so you can tighten it.

If this doesn't fix it, look for the same thing on the motor shaft.

Before calling Jet and asking about replacement bearings, you might run the lathe at highest speen for about an hour. This will be a break-in, and any ticking sounds might go away after things have had a chance to get warm and run for awhile. If that doesn't fix it, call Jet.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#19

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Cyril Griesbach

>Ron, I had a very similar tick on my PM when it was new. I called a tech rep and he told me to check the pulley alignment because the tick might be a result of the belt not aligning up and one of the belt ribs was possibly not in line with the pulley groves. I followed his advice and solved the problem. I believe this is in agreement with what Wally Dickerman and Ed Moore have suggested.

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#20

Several ideas *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>Go down page of link to "Head Stock Noise"

I recall a similar noise and traced it down to the upper pulleys being out of alignment with the lower pulleys. The Allen screws were loose. As I recall, I used a soft wood board as a lever and rubber mallet to ease the upper pulleys in line and then of course tightened up the screws. In taking a look just now I noticed that it has shifted a bit in the last 2 years, so I guess this is something that needs to be looked at every so often.


Mustard Monster Site Mechanical Page

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#21

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

JohnKyler

>Let us know what you come up with. All the ideas I had have been suggested.

I know a lot of the flat belts I have been seeing lately have had one of the grooves with a slight wave in it that has been causing a tick noise. But doesnt sound like that is the case here.

John

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#22

my Jet did that

John K Jordan

>Ron,

My Jet 1642 did that. I finally traced it to some gunk in the grooves in one spot on the inside of the belt. It was not visible. I cleaned it out with a small pointed tool. The tick went away.

JKJ

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#23

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

robo hippy

>My 3520A developed several ticks over the 8 years that I had it. A couple of times it was because the pulleys got loose and out of line. A couple of other times, it was nothing more than a burr on the pulley wheel where the spindle lock engeges.

robo hippy

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#24

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Ron Solfest

>All - Thanks for all of the ideas but it looks like I'll need to call PM and get them to look (either that or run it for an hour to try and 'wear' it out), I still can't identify the source.

It's definitely associated with the motor shaft not the spindle since it's associated with the same orientation of the motor shaft regardless of which speed the belt is on, shifting everything around, etc. Therefore I don't think it's my main bearings. I did check the spindle lock, tighten the screws on the spindle lock mechanism, tighten all set screws on both pulleys and everything else I could think of.

The pulley's appear to be aligned properly. I've cleaned the belt and pulley's with a semi-stiff brush but am pretty sure it's not related to stuff with the belt as it's clearly a metallic tick or creaking. Very sharp and I can isolate it to ~30deg or so of turning the shaft even very slowly back and forth.

I'll contact PM tomorrow if I get a chance between meetings etc (my day job is a little more structured than turning). Unfortunately this route will take a little while I'm sure. Not sure if I'll wait for it to get resolved to turn more, I might just reassemble everything and turn with the belt fairly loose and just not be too aggressive if I get impatient.

Ron

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

#25

Re: New PM3520B has a *tick*

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>When I had that problem, PM told me to keep turning until the parts got to me, that it wouldn't hurt it at all.