>Regardless of how one wishes things should work to benefit the creator of intellectual property, there is absolutely nothing wrong with loaning, borrowing, looking at, smelling, touching, reading, or viewing books, magazines, or videos. You can even invite your friends over for a viewing or reading. This is not stealing.
Those who feel the author should be additionally compensated when viewed by others should do so - feel free to send another payment each time you loan or show it to a friend. Those (like myself) who love to own such things to view and read again and again or to have on the shelf for reference should buy them. I have many hundreds of books.
I have also borrowed many books and videos. If I like them I purchase my own copy. Some are of so limited usefulness (to me) or so bad I'm very glad I borrowed instead of purchased.
I've also borrowed some old books and videos at I hated to give back since they are out of print and unavailable.
This raises an interesting thought for those who consider it wrong to loan:
If the Drozda video, for example, was no longer available and you had a rare copy, should you share it or hide it away? If you had that video and tired of woodturning, do you think it would be OK to sell or give it away (or should you destroy it)? If you sold it, would you send the money to the author since you already "used" the information? If you gave it away, would the author be cheated?
>Our public library offers me access to books, magazines, newspapers, VHS tapes, music CDs and more theatrical and 'how-to' DVDs than I could look at in a lifetime. I have borrowed DVDs by Alan Lacer and Richard Ruffin, plus other turning DVDs by craftsmen whose names I don't remember. Borrowing these materials is not only legitimate and ethical, it is actively encouraged by our community and the state-wide consortium that makes the borrowing of these materials possible.
I usually read, or sometimes simply scan, the books for ideas or a bit of particular information. I usually watch the DVDs for the same reason. Occasionally, though, I actually buy a book or DVD I want to add to my library for repeated use. To save money, though, I typically buy the media on the used book market, which means no additional revenue for the artist/author.
If borrowing an item from the library instead of buying it makes me unethical, then I am a member of a very large and honorable group dating back to Benjamin Franklin (credited with the first lending library in the colonial U.S.) and steel magnate and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie who donated millions of dollars for the purpose of establishing free lending libraries in communities all across our country.
I do not see borrowing a DVD from a friend as being any different than borrowing one from a library. Borrowing is not illegal nor is it unethical, regardless of the source. COPYING, on the other hand, is neither legal nor ethical. I believe Paul's request was to borrow, not copy. His request does not deserve the venomous comments it has generated.
I have enjoyed WC tremendously over the past few years because this was one of the few places on the internet that people could ask questions or make observations and not be attacked. I hope that does not change, but things do change. I enjoy reading most of the posts here, but I have to be honest and say that I have skipped reading the Turning forum specifically here many nights after a personal experience a while back. I still remember the feeling I had when an innocent, personal observation earned me enough vitriole to last a lifetime. To see others attacked for expressing feelings on the same topic just a couple of weeks ago, and now this thread attacking someone for doing nothing more than asking to borrow a DVD tells me that things do change, and, like many groups or organizations, it only takes a few to start the storm blowing.
Paul deserves better. WE deserve better. Reading or posting here should make one feel a part of something good, not something to approach with dread.
Philosopher's hat off. I want to go to bed feeling good, not like I just got chewed out at work.
>I am amazed at some of the words posted here. It is very interesting to say the least. :)
Just for your information, I have loaned many tapes and DVD's to lots of my turning friends. I always thought I was promoting woodturning. Silly me... I guess I have over 50. I have learned something from every one.
I do not make copies, I just tell them to remember where they borrowed them.
Also, If I had the one you needed, I would loan it to you in a heartbeat.
>sharing and trying to do someone out of their rightful fee. It's all about tone. Most of us will happily share our DVD's and tapes with friends. I choose not to copy them nor to share the copies. Somehow we must each figure out where to draw the line. I will share knowledge, but I resist helping someone avoid paying "their fair share". I don't personally know Cindy, but I know Jimmy Clewes, Bill Grumbine, and a few others, and I regard them and the others with DVD's and tapes in this large fraternity as my friends. And I resist cheating my friends out of their money.
>Well Ed, I suppose there is a difference but I'm not sure that I see it. If Paul belonged to a turning club and the club has a library, perhaps supported by AAW, (Our club received a grant from AAW and most of went toward supplying our library) and Paul borrowed a DVD from the library, would that be okay? If so, I'm having a hard time seeing the difference if he borrowed it from me or someone else or from the library.
>and determine the intent. Possibly he did not express himself very well and we have misunderstood. And possibly not. His original "no, no" suggests that he knew he was stepping in something.
A couple of scenarios:
1. A club buys a DVD, makes a single copy, puts the original in a safe place and releases the single copy for club use. This is absolutely fine according to how the AAW and the "fraternity" seem to work.
2. A club buys a DVD, makes five copies, puts the original in a safe place and releases five copies for club use. WRONG!!! That club is cheating the artist who produced the DVD. They owe the artist for four copies and they should be ashamed of themselves.
When I worked for the federal government there were STRICT guidelines for the use of computer programs that were purchased. I don't distinguish between computer programs and DVD's for the purpose of this discussion. In a nutshell, if 100 machines will be running that program, then 100 copies must be purchased. (Obviously there may be deals for such a large purchase.) This is consistent with a library releasing a copy for use. But that library should NOT release more copies than it purchased. This is a simple concept and those who deal with such situations understand the ethics involved.
Frankly, it was the tone of the original post that generated the negative responses.
>below that begins "Wally, read the original post ..."
I think you and I are in agreement about clubs that make more copies of DVDs and tapes than they purchase. These clubs are cheating the folks who produce these works and I refuse to sugarcoat it.
I didn't read any harmful, or even sneaky intent in Paul's original question. Rather, I assumed almost the opposite -- someone rather delicately asking for a favor from his adopted on-line turning family.
I read it about like this made-up example: "It may be a no-no, but should I impose on a more experienced turner to show me how to use a skew, or learn by trial and error?" I don't sense any trickery or deception, but just a touch of polite reservation.
If my club had a Cindy Drozda DVD, I'd definitely borrow it without spending the $35 + shipping, and probably write a critique for our club newsletter, too. Borrowing these tapes, books, and DVD's increases the exposure the maker had intended in the first place. I borrowed a Raffan VHS tape years ago, was impressed with his teaching style, and ended up buying all his books, and I suspect this is pretty common.
I think Paul has been treated a little harshly here, and I agree with Wally that borrowing or lending a book or video is fine. If you really want to learn more from repeated viewings, or if you think this turner teaches well, you might buy the DVD, and consider buying their other stuff, too. Wouldn't hurt Cindy a bit. In fact, if I borrowed her DVD and was really impressed, I'm likely to tell all my turning buddies, and help her make additional sales.
This is a lot of flap about nothing, IMHO, and pretty poor treatment of one of our own, too. Lets all agree to put this behind us, knock off the name-calling, and play nice with the other kids in the sandbox.
>>Frankly, it was the tone of the original post that
>generated the negative responses.
Ed,
I think it is important to remember that unlike face-to-face communication, tone and intent do not come across well in the written form. It is too easy to misinterpret.
As a long-time moderator on a world-wide technical forum, I developed my own policy - when in doubt, give the benefit of the doubt. If a shred of doubt remains, give more benefit of doubt. Even when hit with a post that made me mad, I eventually discovered things went better if I sat on it a while before responding.