Need Cindy Drova dvd
paul waddle
>Is it a no no,but got ask,can someone lend me a Cindy Drova finnial dvd for a couple of days? I'll pay for everything. pw.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Need Cindy Drova dvd
paul waddle
>Is it a no no,but got ask,can someone lend me a Cindy Drova finnial dvd for a couple of days? I'll pay for everything. pw.
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd
Carole Valentine
>If you know it's a no-no, why do you ask? You can order it from Packards and support the a fellow turner and artist. BTW, you won't find it by looking for Cindy Drova. It's Drozda.
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd
paul waddle
>Thank you for settin me straight Carol,but I don't want to build a library,just wanted some info for a couple of days. I'm sure Cindy can survive without my 35$.pw
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd
don lewonczyk
>Not one to miss a chance to tick someone off but anyway most of us that buy instructional DVD's only look at them a few times but your helping the person who created it, the seller of it and yourself. I don't mind sharing things like wood or information but when it comes to tools,farm equipment,etc, I draw the line. Most of my stuff was hard to come by and if I screw it up it's my problem. Im not saying your tight, just frugal, but if your willing to pay all expences to borrow one, way not buy one? DonL
Carole is right!
Ed Moore in SW Virginia
>If you need the info that the Cindy Drozda DVD provides, then have the class to buy it instead of trying to cheat Cindy out of money she deserves. Your statement that Cindy doesn't need your $35 is very revealing. There are things that we as woodturners shouldn't do, and your "question" about no, no, no shows that you know that this is one of them. Maybe you SHOULD start a library and begin by buying a book on ethics.
JMHO
Ed
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd
Rob Wallace
>It appears you wouldn't pay $ 35 for the information you expect to get out of the video, so it can't be that valuable, can it?. If this is the case, then give up on relying on information from others with more experience, and go it alone.
By buying her DVD, you are not building a library, you are paying to get access to the experience, hints, and techniques from an expert that may save you much more than $ 35 in the long run through time saved not having to 'learn alone', wasted wood, and inferior results.
Amazing that anyone would post such a request on a national (or international) forum. Boggles the mind.....
Rob Wallace
Here you go buddy
Ron in Drums PA
>Click here for Cindy's DVDs
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd
Lyle Jamieson
>Another issue is the creating a library. Cindys DVD and most good instructional DVDs are a tremondous resourse to have at your disposal for many years. She will cover many more topics and techniques then we can obsorbe in one setting. As you develop your turning skills your needs and abilities change. Things you see and use from a DVD today will be different then you will need or use in years to come. Dont believe me??? Go back ane re-visit an old DVD/Video you saw a year or two ago and see how much more you get from it now.
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd - is my club unethical?
Dave Schell
>To play devil's advocate here, the woodturning club I belong to has a nice library of DVDs that the members can check out each month. Is this an unethical practice as well? Trying to understand the difference between members sharing their videos versus clubs doing it.
This is a fair question.
Ed Moore in SW Virginia
>Here, we are heavily into the personal opinion realm. It is my opinion that the practice of clubs buying DVD's for the club library is an established one that is accepted by almost all and encouraged by the AAW. Does this practice impact negatively on monies earned by the artist? Unfortunately, I think it does. However, it may also lead to a few sales by club members who watch the club tape and then decide that they want their own copy. The flip side is that a club may purchase a DVD for the library that an individual may not choose to buy.
Professional woodturners/demonstrators need to do things to enhance their reputations and thereby increase their popularity for demonstrations. Teaching at Arrowmont, John C Campbell Folk School, Anderson Ranch, Marc Adams, etc, does this and that is why turners accept the low pay and teach at these fine schools. Producing a DVD also establishes credibility and increases popularity. Jimmy Clewes comes to mind as one who has risen nicely in the ranks of demonstrators/teachers due partly to the popularity of his DVD's. I think that Cindy has also benefited from having her DVD's out there. My point here is that having one's DVD's in a club library enhances the turner's reputation and increases the chance of snagging a demo at that club. So, it is somewhat of a two-edged sword that cuts both ways.
Have I sufficiently muddied the waters? [grin]
Ed
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd
Don Tewell in Central Illinois
>I agree. I have a modest library of DVD's and just reran one of Jimmy Clewes. Learned a couple of things I missed the first time. I periodically review DVD's, maybe not in it's entirity, but something specific that I am wanting to brush up on. Well wortht the money I've paid for them.
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd
Carole Valentine
>Excellent point Lyle. I have gone back to the DVDs I have many, many times. As ones skills increase, things on the DVDs that may have been beyond his or her horizon at first begin to come into play. You may even reach a plateau. When that happens, reviewing instructional DVDs can often be like turning a light on. I would say the same for all of my turning mags. I never throw them away because months or years down the road, I can always browse through them and pick up some knowledge that may not have made sense to me or I didn't have the skills to try when I first got the mag.
Re: This is a fair question.
Dave Schell
>Ed said "However, it may also lead to a few sales by club members who watch the club tape and then decide that they want their own copy." One could argue that if someone lends Paul a copy of their video, he may enjoy it so much that he will a buy a copy for himself. If no one lends him the copy, he may never buy a copy - and thereby actually deprive Cindy of another sale.
I think legally speaking per typical copyright licenses, it is perfectly acceptable to loan someone a copyrighted work for their own personal consumption. It is not acceptable to make an unauthorized copy of a work and Paul was never suggesting he was going to do that.
Have none of the folks that responded so harshly to Paul's request ever borrowed or loaned a Hollywood movie DVD? or even a book? These too are produced by artists, deserving of their fair share.
Re: Need Cindy Drova dvd - is my club unethical?
paul waddle
>That IS precisely where I got the idea. Call me anyname you want,but I'm really not that bad.. I guess I shouldn't ask questions either..
I withdraw my request,I only wanted to know what type of tool to use,a skew,round skew, or a small gouge..pw
I have over 20 years of magazines that I cruise
john lucas
>I'm always amazed at something I learn from an article that I know I read when the magazine was new. The second time around you discover little things that weren't important back then but now make all the difference in the world.
Re: This is a fair question.
Carole Valentine
>The copyright laws are baffling to me in this respect. I have rented movie DVDs, which I *think* results in some part of that rental fee going back to the artist as a royalty, which is the way I think it should be, yet I can borrow a DVD, or a book, from the local library or turning club at no cost. Why is that? Is there something special about movie DVDs? There are internet sites where you can rent turning DVDs and many other instructional DVDs, but it is my understanding that the artist has no say about whether these sites rent their work or not and they get no compensation. Makes no sense to me. Bottom line is that I have come to feel that in the relatively limited scope of the turning community, we should support the artists who who are willing to share their skills with us. If they cease to reap any return from their efforts, we may eventually find ourselves with no DVDs to argue over!
Intellectual property...
Mike Stafford
>Intellectual property is one of the hardest things to protect. Anyone who goes to the effort and expense to produce a video must have their rights protected.
Having said that, I am guilty of loaning my videos to a couple of friends. And my club has an extensive library of videos that I have never checked out. Instead I have bought the ones I am interested in.
I feel badly for someone who is making their living or supplementing their income by making this intellectual property and selling it and then have people ripping them off by making counterfeit copies. I would like for someone who knows what is legal with regard to lending to tell us all. I think we all know what is moral.
I could be wrong. It wouldn't be the first time...
Re: Woodturning clubs and videos
Russ Fairfield
>My experience with the woodturning clubs buying videos hasn't all been good. Most clubs are fine upstanding people, but like life, there are a few bad ones.
While the clubs buying a video for their library is a common practice, there are many clubs who buy the video and then make multiple copies for use in their library, keeping the orioginal in pristeen condition. There are still other clubs who buy a video and actively encourage their members to make copies for their own use. I ran into one club that makes copies of popular videos for every member. The problem is that the clubs doing these things see nothing wrong with it.
The one that really lights me up is when someone with one of these 2nd or 3rd generation copies has problems with the video and expects me to replace it.
Think it's copyright, IP isn't the issue
steve antonucci
>I'm not a lawyer, but I think the main issue is around copyright. We all sit through the notice at the beginning of a DVD that describes the "legal use" of the materials (private viewing, in your home, etc...)
If Paul obtained an original license (DVD) for viewing the material, whether he borrows it or buys it, he has the right to view it because the DVD is thing that is licensed, not the viewer. That's why you can rent a movie at Blockbuster- because they have to give you the original DVD.
In any case, the maker still retains IP rights. I can't use their materials as my own, in whole or in part, without their permission.
Funny thing is that they put copiers at the library, where the smae rules apply...
Steven
Re: Intellectual property...
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont
>Hey Mike,
I will join you in being guilty of lending and owning "copies" given to me of other people's DVD's etc. Perhaps we should have an Amnesty �No Ask" return day to get the "copies" out of our possessions and clean our guilt over this.
:-)
I can't be alone on this?!!?
I would with IP daily in my work, protecting what you "own" is indeed difficult and as the world shrinks daily it becomes almost impossible to control if some one really wants to copy your IP. Every thing from Soup to Nuts ... it just gets expensive defending it.
Take care,
Jim
that part I can answer
john lucas
>Use the tool you are most comfortable with. You can turn any of Cindy's finials with a small spindle gouge or detail gouge, skew, round or flat. When I 've been turning a lot I tend to use a skew because I get cleaner cuts and more consistent curves. When I haven't been turning a lot I can turn with fewer screw ups with a spindle gouge or detail gouge.
As far as shapes, just look all around you at everything you see. Commercial products have often gone through very lengthy tests about everything from how the bottle looks to what's in it. consequently they have often had many artists look at the shapes. I look at lamps, perfume bottles, ceramics and especially antiques of any sort. Jewelry is also a good source for finial shapes.
Re: Think it's copyright, IP isn't the issue
Mike Stafford
>You could be right, Steve. I will admit I don't know the legal terms or legalities. My only reason for calling it IP was that a DVD seems to be a transfer of knowledge. I could be wrong about that also but like I said it wouldn't be the first time...
Re: that part I can answer
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>I can answer it too. I don't think cindy would mind if I tell you that she uses a small spindle gauge -- not a skew.
Re: This is a fair question.
Keith Tompkins
>Hi Carole, Actors have unions and lawyers to help establish royalty fees, similar to musicians, turners don't . Copyright isn't all that complicated, you purchase an item such as a CD, movie, or painting or photo. It's yours.You can sell the item, give it away, even throw it out. You cannot do anything with the product to make money with it, or duplicate it without permission. (some excemptions, such as for educational purposes) However, the artist retains all rights to their art. They have the right to to anything they please with the work they have produced. An artist CAN sell their rights to their own work, for instanse Michael Jackson owned the rights to Paul McCartney's work! Elvis ALWAYS owned the rights to all the songs he recorded. Copyright protection does't end with the death of the owner, the family retains rights for 70 years, I believe. Disclaimer: I'm not a lawyer, but the library at the craft center where I teach has a two-volume set on Art Law. I've read both...what an exciting life I have!! :)
No Way, Paul
Brad Vietje
>Paul,
First, you asked a perfectly good question -- no name calling needed. I loan books to friends, and then maybe they'll buy other books by the same author if they like them. Chances are, you'd like the video enough that you'd want to buy it someday, or maybe another by Cindy. Every time we mention that video, Cindy Drozda's name recognition is enhanced.
I don't see what the big deal is.
As Lyle and John and others have pointed out, you might go back to that DVD, or a book some time in the future, and get a lot more out of it -- I know I do.
Best wishes on making great-looking finials, and please don't stop asking questions here.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT