Re: Galen, thanks for a ...
Sean Troy
>Another vote for waiting and see. I enjoyed this issue and if they do go to six issues a year, that gives more opertunity to cover more bases.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Galen, thanks for a ...
Sean Troy
>Another vote for waiting and see. I enjoyed this issue and if they do go to six issues a year, that gives more opertunity to cover more bases.
Get your comments in before she gets here.
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>I like the article that John Jordan wrote... humm might have to take a class to see how he does that.
A little unknown fact - Ruth taught John everything he knows... right Ruth... I bet he was a good student.
Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed
charlie belden
>There's a pertinent question at the end of all this if you want to skip the in between.
==================================
I guess taking pen in hand - at 2:30 am - after FINALLY being able to lay/lie (never can get which one is used when) down, thumb through a magazine and try and sleep (two days of sniffle, drip and run, with coughing and weezin' thrown in - AFTER recovering from food poisoning) didn't put me in the most receptive mood or rational state of mind.
So - my initial post was focused on my Hot Button issues which I allowed the magazine to poke - multiple times. I think, in part, it was about my mental state when going through this issue. When I'm going through an ART magazine, and recently I've been picking up American Crafts magazine which focuses on artists using craft mediums, I'm in an art frame of mind and I'm looking for and at all the imaginative things people are doing with subject matters, materials and techniques from a multitude of disciplines and mediums. My expectations are similar to, but distinctly different from my expectations when going through Fine Woodworking and other woodworking specific magazines I also devour on a regular basis.
I guess the best analogy for my reaction is that I feel I was Trojan Horsed . I thought I was getting one thing - and while laying/lieing? in bed, was assaulted by a bunch of Trojans hidden in the magazine. (no - not THOSE Trojans, the guys with the funny horse hair topped helmets Trojans).
I'm of two minds with the "If You Don't Have Solutions To The Problem - Don't Complain About The Problem".
Even though the kid who yelled "Hey! The Emperor's naked!" didn't kknow a damn thing about how fabric is made or how it's put together for clothes, or what was or wasn't in vogue At Court at the time - the lad did note, and express that there was a problem that was obvious - at least to him.
On the other hand, a guy - or gal - who has to point up every thing he - or she - thinks is WRONG, WRONG, WRONG - and never has anything else to contribute to the mix - is never going to help improve things.
My personal guidelines are - never intentionally do any harm - acknowledge and appreciate help when offered and/or given - and try and pass on some of what I've recieved from other helpful people. Do Unto Others and Pass It On When You Can.
Now one of the many things this forum, and similar other forums, do/does is discuss issues - here basically about all things turning - to share differing views and perspectives in hopes that all will see things a bit clearer and with a better understanding of the subject as a result.
Judging by the amount of response, and the very brief period in which they were made, this particular topic is on people's minds.
One of the things that came up is the apparent need for relevant content and the solicitation of potential articles for the magazine. And that gets into What's That Involve? Never having been published I have no idea. Perhaps someone who has Been There, Done That could provide some info based on their experience. What are some of the requirements in terms of word count, accompanying illustrations and diagrams, etc. Do they have editors that'll clean up poor grammer and sentence construction and correct spelling errors or does what's being submitted need to be almost Press Ready - or it's a No Go?
Does the magazine have a certain style - to which articles should adapt? A technical journal wants facts and figures to support any statement - no opinions or personal biases obvious - just the facts mam - and only on the subject of the article.
Woodworker West magazine often has an ongoing sectioin which covers a subject in discrete parts and in great detail - spread over three, four or five issues or more. Given some of the subjects, and the page constraints of each issue, this permits a more thorough and useful coverage of a subject than can be had within a one to three page per issue constraint.
Seems folks here could provide feedback and suggestions on someone's proposed article - before it gets submitted - hopefully saving the magazine editor some time and energy - neither of which she probably has much of in reserve.
As for Fear Of Rejection - it ain't fatal. And I've been a participant of the usenet newgroup rec.woodworking for quite a while before finding this forum - so I'm not very thin skinned and got my Nomex suit for the occassional flame wars that occur over there.
As for me submitting articles - I jump around woodworking quite a bit, getting into a subject or technique deep enough to understand most of the How and Why - and document what I've learned so I don't have to keep re-inventing the wheel if and when I get back to using that procedure/technique/method again. My personal website is my filing cabinet of stuff from my journey - nice and safe and accessible - where I can't lose things easily.
Since I've got a lot of the stuff a potential article could use I'd already started putting together what might end up as an article on How To Unlearn How NOT To Be Creative - with turnings as specific examples - most I've turned.
I use my own turnings, not because they are particularly that good, but because I know where the idea came from and how an idea was turned - into wood - step by step. My hope is that a reader will come away with "If even this idiot can do it - and now that I've got an example of how it can be done - maybe I ought to finally get around to trying it - and surely do it at least as well - or better."
Now one of the shortcomings of "fixed media" (print, videos, DVDs and the like) - is that they are more or less linear - and fixed - with relatively long Lead Times.
The Web's hyper text (that .html at the end of many web pages stands for Hyper Text Markup Language) is a much more flexible media - permitting "vistors" to bore down to details if they wish (and you've taken the time to provide mutliple levels of detail/content) or skip the included links and merely browse the top level of information. It also allows the original content to be easily and quickly modified based on feedback from visitors (if, of course, you make it easy to e-mail you comments, suggestions and constructive criticism).
The shortcomings of web articles is that you can't fall asleep with them on your chest, or take them in The Reading Room for a quick read (your legs fall asleep before you can get through a really long article or one that requires some studying) - or dog ear a page so you can find it when you go looking for something in particular.
OK - to the point - or a suggested point.
What can WE do to help improve the magazine?
or
How can WE help Ruth make the magazine better?
ps - John - blind wedged tenons are sort of self adjusting too, and the old but still available spoon bits let you start a hole and then drill it at almost any angle - and change directions a little if you need to. Them wood joiners sure were clever folks and much of what they came up with to solve problems are hard to improve on - even today.
Re: Ed- I'm aware that Betty was a ....
Jamie D
>...previous editor, but the publishing industry has undergone monumental changes over those years. And some things don't change, including the value of feed-back, but one would seldom be expected to go searching for it rather than have it brought straight to their attention.
Jamie, I have no idea what ...
Ed Moore in SW Virginia
>I would tell Betty if I were sitting down talking to her. I'll let others do that.
I hate politics at all levels. Are there now "ins" that were "outs", or vice versa?
I was very pleased with the previous editor and am having trouble justifying the change.
Ed
Re: It's a matter of opinion. *LINK*
Russ Fairfield
>If you don't like what you read, then you should be writing the articles you want to see. The Editor can only publish those articles that are submitted.
If you don't like "art" of woodturning that the AAW is promoting, there is a flegling organization called "Conventional Woodturners Association" (CWA) that may be more to your liking. They can use all of the help they can get.
http://www.conventionalturners.org/index.htm
Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed
keith tompkins
>I've got a different perspective than most who post here, I suppose. Take a serious look at what is driving the explosion in today's woodturning community. Excuse the grammar, but it ain't chair legs or table pedestals. After all, how many spindle duplicators do we see displayed in the vendor areas at woodturning shows? I suggest taking a walk through an AAW instant gallery; paying close attention to the work presented there. ART TURNING is what is driving the interest in turning; wood turning's growth is the envy of the craft community. That's just the way it is; that is where the magazine's main focus should be.
I do not believe the main focus of the AAW journal should be articles geared to the beginner turner. I understand that some turners may live too far away to attend group meetings, but that is where hands-on guidance is available. In addition to that, there are dvds covering all aspects of turning, turning classes at stores such as Woodcraft, classes at craft and art centers, and private lessons available. Too much emphasis on beginner articles will inevitably lead to loss of readership; in most cases, customers who have been loyal subscribers for many years will fall away. Seems to me that it's just not fair for new turners to have too much influence on article content....it reminds me of someone moving to a house near a busy airport, only to attempt to have the airport closed down because thy can't stand the noise. Fine Woodworking Magazine found this to be true a few years back when they tried to increase market share by catering to the newbie woodworker. They nearly folded; only returning to their original format saved them from folding; their base had left in large numbers. When Reader's Digest took over American Woodworker, they destroyed the soul of the magazine, in my opinion...I won't even glance through it. I believe the emphasis of the AAW Journal should be inspiring each reader to strive towards a higher goal, both new turners and seasoned veterans by taking a balanced approach which includes articles on basic AND advanced subjects. And, to promote the growth of turning by encouraging turners to use ALL of their skills and experience.
I can see why many may not be overly thrilled with the article on Garry Knox Bennett, but I think the idea was to shake us out of our comfort zone, and consider possibilities outside our myopic view of art or craft. Wendell Castle is not known as a turner either, but his work has probably influenced my work more that any other craftsperson.
I, for one, have given Betty my opinion on the subject, and have submitted ideas for future articles on both advanced topics and basic tool techniques.
Don't mess with this topic
Joe Pack
>I expressed an opinion on this topic some time ago and got blown away...first and only time it ever happened to meon WoodCentral. AAW is an "electrode" topic...polarization just happens. Just go to the Conventional Woodturners link and check out what they have to offer.
AAW is an established organization that pleases many. Conventional Woodturners will hopefully please others as it gets established.
Dick You Are Not the Last
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Mine has not arrived yet either which is unusual. It usually arrives within several days of the first arrival notices posted.
Couple things...
Ellis Walentine, Host
>Charlie, I haven't spoken with Betty since she took the helm of American Woodturner, but I am sure she has a lot of work to do just to get back up to speed with the magazine's current technology and production methods. That is the kind of transition that doesn't take place cleanly or immediately in the magazine business.
I can't speak to Betty's approach as editor, although I'm relatively confident she'll be relying on the mechanisms that are already in place there until she overhauls the system in a way that is more logical to her. It could take a few issues before that system kicks into high gear.
A couple comments relative to your musings...
"...the apparent need for relevant content and the solicitation of potential articles for the magazine. And that gets into What's That Involve? Never having been published I have no idea. Perhaps someone who has Been There, Done That could provide some info based on their experience. What are some of the requirements in terms of word count, accompanying illustrations and diagrams, etc. Do they have editors that'll clean up poor grammer and sentence construction and correct spelling errors or does what's being submitted need to be almost Press Ready - or it's a No Go?"
I would not recommend submitting a complete manuscript to any magazine (unless it possibly is fiction or a technical piece). The preferred method is to send a query letter with your article concept and as much explanation as you can get into a one-page letter. This allows the editor to weigh your proposal, decide if/how it fits into the editorial lineup within a reasonable time frame, and, if so, direct you as to what aspects of your proposal are of the most interest and how many words and photos she/he feels the magazine can allocate for the article. That is a decision that is totally up to the editor. You might as well not start writing until you get some direction regarding length and focus. Sometimes an editor will want to completely refocus your proposal, say, from a project article to a technique article. This will completely change the way you approach the subject matter.
"Does the magazine have a certain style - to which articles should adapt?"
All magazines have a stylebook that defines their style. Betty is probably revising the American Woodturner stylebook as we speak.
"Woodworker West magazine often has an ongoing sectioin which covers a subject in discrete parts and in great detail - spread over three, four or five issues or more."
This is a device that works for some magazines, particularly ones where the circulation base isn't likely to change much from issue to issue. For magazines where "conversions" and renewals are always in flux, this is not a sound strategy, as some significant proportion of the readers will not be around for the next installment. Better to put the whole article in one issue. If it takes up too many pages, it is the editor's job to narrow the focus so that it fits the book and the editorial objectives.
Seems folks here could provide feedback and suggestions on someone's proposed article - before it gets submitted - hopefully saving the magazine editor some time and energy - neither of which she probably has much of in reserve.
This assumes that our feedback is informed by the editorial interests of the magazine, which will never be the case. We can guess, and advise would-be authors, but we can't know what ground Betty or the AAW wants to cover in a given issue (or year of issues).
"My personal website is my filing cabinet of stuff from my journey - nice and safe and accessible - where I can't lose things easily."
I'd send Betty an e-mail and point her to your site and ask her if she sees anything that the journal might want to explore with you.
"Since I've got a lot of the stuff a potential article could use I'd already started putting together what might end up as an article on How To Unlearn How NOT To Be Creative - with turnings as specific examples - most I've turned."
By all means, submit it as a query, but expect the editor to come back with her suggested slant or scope that would be more in line with her editorial needs.
Writing for magazines is easier than you may think. Far less is expected of you than you realize. It's the editor's job to guide you and bring in the article. In the business it's called "acquisition" and it is a critical part of the editor's mission. They can't rely on "over-the-transom" submissions to fill the book. They need to impose their own will and editorial objectives on the process. My hunch is that Betty has her ear to the ground and knows who's saying what. Her biggest job is to balance all that with the magazine's mission, and her interpretation of that responsibility will be the mark she leaves on the magazine.
I vote to give her a big attagirl, tell her what we like and don't like, and let her do the rest. I know she wants to do a great job, and I think she can.
Ellis
For Those Who May Not Know
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Ellis was the editor of American Woodworker back when it was an outstanding magazine. When Reader's Digest came on the scene and Ellis left, the magazine went south. That is close to the time that he and Jim began Wood Central.
Interesting point- I actually liked most of it
steve antonucci
>Keith-
Here are some metrics taken from my club. The numbers are close to right.
I belong to a club that has about 90 members. Roughly, 60 attend the meetings, and it's almost always the same guys. Approximately 40 are AAW members.
Of the 60 that attend, almost all of them are conventional turners. Our show and tell is usually a myriad of bowls and conventional turnings. There are a few guys, like me, that do some "unconventional" work.
I appreciate the fact that there are a variety of perspectives in the world, but I don't think that "art turning" is really as dominant in driving the AAW membership as you think it is. It's just getting the most publicity. Over half of our club doesn't belong to AAW, and I have to wonder how many lathes there are that don't belong to clubs?
I'm not suggesting that Betty produce something bad or evil. I actually enjoyed most of the articles. I just think that the first issue didn't address the majority. It was a noticable departure from the old format, and some folks preferred the old format.
Let's see if enough people think one way or another...
Steve
AAW Bylaws *LINK*
Ed Davidson (Colorado Springs)
>Charlie,
Here's a link to the AAW's Bylaws (Mission Statement).
AAW Bylaws (pdf)
Re: Interesting point- I actually liked most of it
keith tompkins
>Hey Steve, perhaps the conventional turners are not showing up at the symposiums, which gives the impression of overwhelming interest in artsy stuff. It seems every turning club has a few outstanding turners who influence the others to some degree; I'm sure many in your club are influenced by your work.
MOST important, call her Betty not Ruth!
Ruth Niles
>
Did I Miss Something?
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>
Excellent points, Keith.....and Steve
Ruth Niles
>The AAW Journal should inspire and educate and present limits worth aspiring to achieve. Anyone who does anything wants to get better, learn more, try this, try that. Keith, you make an excellent point about the artistic aspect of the magazine. I have no desire to be a known turner but I do want to try new stuff and am thrilled when I do something that was in the magazine and it looks half way decent.
Steve, I can relate to all those "plain" turning members, I'm one myself. You said your instand gallery is full of plain bowls, etc. Good, that means those guys know how to turn bowls. If they want to just keep turning bowls, that's wonderful. If they want to see what else they can do...........well, now we look at the AAW Journal and see where we can try to go from here.
Please don't get me wrong, I think there should be beginner articles and turnings that you're not sure are turned and professionals showing their technique (ala John Jordan) and one of everything.
As Keith said, if you cater to the beginner, after he's no longer a beginner, he cancels his subscription.
Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed------WebKi
Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar
>The organization name should be changed from American Woodturners Association to American Wood Art Association. One more issue like the current issue, and I will be gone. I could live with 50% art emphasis, but not 90%. And what happened to the Tips Section by John Lucas?
------WebKitFormBoundary7Q9BGI9+5RvD48kr
Tips pages will be back.
john lucas
>The tips pages will be back. Betty has already assured me she wants them and volunteered to do some more.
Re: So Emmit, you set your sights low?
Jamie D
>
Re: Ooops, misspelled Emmett! Sorry!
Jamie D
>
Re: Don't mess with this topic
keith tompkins
>Hey Joe, I'm sorry that happened...human nature, I guess. I don't understand why there must be a wood art/ pure turning debate. It's too bad, it really hurts us all when one group cannot accept the other. Taking the side of the artsy types generates a lot of flak as well, believe me.
That was uncalled for
Dick Coers
>
Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed
Bill Howatt
>If you'll permit a comment from a North American instead of a United States of America American:
Overall, I find the publication to be interesting and inspiring. No, the artsy stuff is not really where my strong interest lies at this moment but I do appreciate the skill that goes into creating these works. The magazine obviously cannot be everything to everyone and certainly some issues appeal more to me than others.
Normally the journal of a professional organization is the flagship publication describing the member's finest work, it is not a publication for beginners but it also should contain information that encourages/helps beginners develop their work to have it appear in the journal one day.
As was mentioned in another post there are many venues for learning the basic skills. For many of us, the Journal is a window on the best, on what is being done to move the craft forward in various directions (whether we like them or not), on the views and careers of the turners who have pulled themselves to the top of the mountain.
There is always room for improvement but improvement usually comes from positive, constructive comments not from a negative view that does nothing but tear the structure down.
Bill
Kind of Ruth-
steve antonucci
>I think that the AAW needs to recognize that there is a progression in every turners development.
I watch guys who are tearing wood off instead of cutting envy guys who can cut slightly better, but have no sense of shape. Next, the sense of shape comes, but there's nothing artistic. Artistic comes, then original...
The AAW just needs to recognize that there are a lot of guys who pay the bill with 80% of the membership that aren't named turners, and never will be. They are in it for the love of the hobby., and we need to keep them entertained too :-) Something for everyone...
And I will reiterate that I thought the first issue was good, which means it didn't have enough in it for the 80% (because I hate "project" articles!)
Steve