Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed
charlie belden
>The latest issue of American Woodturner has me a bit confused. I looked on the AAW website trying to find the Mission Statement or some statement describing the purpose of the organization. Haven�t found either so far.
It would seem to me that AAW�s primary purpose, or rather its initial purpose was, to promote wood turning in the United States of America (rather than The Americas, or North, Central or South America - but that�s a whole �nother subject). As such, it would provide information about turning to persons considering taking up turning, provide a vehicle for existing turners to share information on tools, supplies and techniques, as well as ideas for turnings and a place for turners to show off the pieces they�ve made.
What I�m getting from the magazine is more and more focused on promoting wood turners, a relatively few wood turners, to museums, galleries and private collectors. And to accomplish that - turners and the things they turn - must be described as ARTISTS and ART, respectively. The place where the turning is done must be referred to as The Studio, NEVER The Shop, and the turner must be a Studio Turner, though I think Turniste sounds better and rolls off the tongue easier. A theatrical gesture when saying Turniste adds to the mystique of the term.
Now to add to my confusion, I expect a wood turning magazine to be about turners,, turning and turnings - which are recongizable as such, even if it takes some closer examination and some thought to find the connection to turning.
So when I find three pages devoted to Garry (note the two Rs) Knox Bennett, who the article notes sees wood turners as merely �twirlers�, and who doesn�t �turn� - at all - I have to ask WHY!?
And when six pages of the current 66 actual pages of content issue of the magazine is devoted to the Tapered Mortise and Tenon and goes into great detail on the How and Why it�s so useful for attaching legs to tables, chairs and stools, especially when a blind wedge straight sided mortise and tenon joint is simpler to do and avoids some of the shortcomings of a tapered mortise and tenon joint, especially a through mortise and tenon joint - I have to wonder WHY devote so much space, or any space for that matter, to this subject. If you�re going to make something that requires joinery - joinery is covered in any number of �woodworking� magazines. And frankly, very few furniture makers use simple tapered mortise and tenon joinery to connect legs to a table top, chair or stool seat anyway. Even Windsor Chair makers don�t use it.
Then there�s a five page article �Wood and Color - Some History�, followed by five pages of a pretty critical critique of a show �A Perfect Marriage Wood And Color�, the critique questioning the selection process, the curator who put the show together and the apparently crappy catalogue for the show.
So of the 66 pages of �content� - 3 pages to GKB and 10 to History and show critiqueing and another six pages on �tapered M&T� that�s 19 pages of my time gone with no apperent benefit - close to one in three pages of the issue not about turning, or even turners, prominent, unkown or prominently unknown. And if you throw in the four pages for �Antique Piecrust Crimper� . . .
I like seeing Craig Nutt�s vegetable themed furniture. His stuff is fun to look at - though I personally couldn�t live day in and day out with most of his works. But turning doesn�t play much of a role, if any role at all, in his stuff so why the photo of his bench seat?
Now John Jordan�s TWELVE well illustrated page article - �Turned and Carved Hollow Vessel� has more than enough detail to get anyone considering doing carved hollow vessels well passed a Trial and Error process development - and then some. The 19 pages aforementioned could have been better used for an article with similar detail and quality.
If I�m picking up a wood turning magazine I expect the content to be about turning and turners - not history lessons or art critic critiques. But hey, I�m just a guy who likes to spin wood, apply a sharp tool to it and see where things go from there - cause it�s fun - so what do I know? And they�ve already got my money so . . .
The marketing folks have spoken - ART sells better than "turnings".



