Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

Posts

Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#1

Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

charlie belden

>The latest issue of American Woodturner has me a bit confused. I looked on the AAW website trying to find the Mission Statement or some statement describing the purpose of the organization. Haven�t found either so far.

It would seem to me that AAW�s primary purpose, or rather its initial purpose was, to promote wood turning in the United States of America (rather than The Americas, or North, Central or South America - but that�s a whole �nother subject). As such, it would provide information about turning to persons considering taking up turning, provide a vehicle for existing turners to share information on tools, supplies and techniques, as well as ideas for turnings and a place for turners to show off the pieces they�ve made.

What I�m getting from the magazine is more and more focused on promoting wood turners, a relatively few wood turners, to museums, galleries and private collectors. And to accomplish that - turners and the things they turn - must be described as ARTISTS and ART, respectively. The place where the turning is done must be referred to as The Studio, NEVER The Shop, and the turner must be a Studio Turner, though I think Turniste sounds better and rolls off the tongue easier. A theatrical gesture when saying Turniste adds to the mystique of the term.

Now to add to my confusion, I expect a wood turning magazine to be about turners,, turning and turnings - which are recongizable as such, even if it takes some closer examination and some thought to find the connection to turning.

So when I find three pages devoted to Garry (note the two Rs) Knox Bennett, who the article notes sees wood turners as merely �twirlers�, and who doesn�t �turn� - at all - I have to ask WHY!?

And when six pages of the current 66 actual pages of content issue of the magazine is devoted to the Tapered Mortise and Tenon and goes into great detail on the How and Why it�s so useful for attaching legs to tables, chairs and stools, especially when a blind wedge straight sided mortise and tenon joint is simpler to do and avoids some of the shortcomings of a tapered mortise and tenon joint, especially a through mortise and tenon joint - I have to wonder WHY devote so much space, or any space for that matter, to this subject. If you�re going to make something that requires joinery - joinery is covered in any number of �woodworking� magazines. And frankly, very few furniture makers use simple tapered mortise and tenon joinery to connect legs to a table top, chair or stool seat anyway. Even Windsor Chair makers don�t use it.

Then there�s a five page article �Wood and Color - Some History�, followed by five pages of a pretty critical critique of a show �A Perfect Marriage Wood And Color�, the critique questioning the selection process, the curator who put the show together and the apparently crappy catalogue for the show.

So of the 66 pages of �content� - 3 pages to GKB and 10 to History and show critiqueing and another six pages on �tapered M&T� that�s 19 pages of my time gone with no apperent benefit - close to one in three pages of the issue not about turning, or even turners, prominent, unkown or prominently unknown. And if you throw in the four pages for �Antique Piecrust Crimper� . . .

I like seeing Craig Nutt�s vegetable themed furniture. His stuff is fun to look at - though I personally couldn�t live day in and day out with most of his works. But turning doesn�t play much of a role, if any role at all, in his stuff so why the photo of his bench seat?

Now John Jordan�s TWELVE well illustrated page article - �Turned and Carved Hollow Vessel� has more than enough detail to get anyone considering doing carved hollow vessels well passed a Trial and Error process development - and then some. The 19 pages aforementioned could have been better used for an article with similar detail and quality.

If I�m picking up a wood turning magazine I expect the content to be about turning and turners - not history lessons or art critic critiques. But hey, I�m just a guy who likes to spin wood, apply a sharp tool to it and see where things go from there - cause it�s fun - so what do I know? And they�ve already got my money so . . .

The marketing folks have spoken - ART sells better than "turnings".

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#2

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

Don wilcut

>Charlie, I agree with you 100%. Now we wait.

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#3

To each his own -and that's good.

john lucas

>Personally I like all the magazines but I can only get so much of the "here's another project you can do" articles. Occasionally I like a dose of here's what else is going on in the woodturning community. If you read Betty's editorial in the beginning she did say that she was going to try and reach all turners, that includes those of us who are interested in the art side, the selling side and the craft side.

I thought it was refreshingly different. I look forward to the next issue. I'm sure there will be some beginner projects along with advanced projects, just like this issue. You have to remember that the AAW represents everything from Pen turners, and box makers to ornamental and segmented turners, artists and collectors. It is a huge chore to find something of interest to them all. Consequently the magazine will probably have a different look each issue just like it has the last year or so.

By the way Craig Nutt does a lot of turning. I've known him for years and photographed much of his work. Although it is heavily carved much of it touches a lathe at some point. Craig sees the lathe as just another carving tool to be used when needed.

Many people look at Gary Knox-Bennet and decide they don't like him based on a few pieces they see in a magazine. I was one of them at first. He is an extremely good artist with an incredible imagination. We can learn a lot from him even if all you want to make are bowls. I think you have to look outside our field if you want to improve your work. There is a whole world out there to help your creativity. We should take advantage of it. Look deeper at Gary's work and then make a decision of whether to like it or not.

I've made quiet a few chairs and stools over the years and taught a workshop on stool making. The tapered mortise and tenon has been proven over the years to be a superior joint. I've seen a 100 year old windsor chair that a guy put up on one leg and then balanced himself on top of the chair. Nothing gave, twisted or creaked. That's rigid. A straight sided tenon will expand and contract and eventually loosen. The tapered tenon will slip deeper into the seat if it shrinks and will not come loose.

I always enjoy your input and this is no different. I realize we are all different and consequently we can't please everyone all the time. As magazine editor I'm sure Betty is aware of this. Although I did enjoy this issue and you didn't I think we need to watch it for a year and see if we still feel the same.

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#4

Re: I agree but

Norm Smith

>are you suggesting that there shouldnt be any foreign members in the AAW? Have you written the AAW to complain about the magazine? I believe that there is some expierementing going on but yes , the spring issue is very disappointing. However this is the first issue that didnt enjoy. I will make my feelings known.

Norm

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#5

The jury is still out

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>John,

A lot of good points have been raised in this brief thread and it remains to be seen which are valid over the long run.

What concerns me is that there is an undertone which suggests that there is an agenda, hidden or not, that we aren't aware of. Has the market said that color artists are wanted, and natural wood turners need not apply? Will select artists be promoted? For me, the jury is still out.

What struck me as odd involved the article by the blind turner. Of equal interest is Bob Rosand's perspective on teaching him - where is that? And am I correct in sensing a lack of appreciation on the part of this turner for Bob's effort? I didn't see a "thank you" anywhere for the support he has received from others.

Ed

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#6

Perfect time for a new.....................

Ruth Niles

>This is the perfect time for a new Woodturning magazine. After reading so many diverse comments, if the AAW put out 6 issues and each was 300 pages, it would not please everyone.

I am not being "smart" here, I am very serious. Charlie, you would be the perfect one to do this, you make some very good points in the majority of your posts of so many different subjects.

We have Woodturning Design that has different articles than AAW but it appears there is still a want or need that is not being satisfied. Another magazine would solve that and you would get a lot of subscribers. Go for it!!!!

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#7

Re: The jury is still out

Barry Elder

>No matter the editor of the AAW Journal, we all have our likes and dislikes. Wanting and expecting "instant gratification" is what has destroyed our economy. Relax and enjoy your woodturning! And I can't help but wonder why this critique was not placed on the AAW Main Forum?! I have much time to enjoy this and future issues of the Journal and I hope you will have the patience to also enjoy.

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#8

Steven Antonucci

There are no "wrong" articles... just a mix

steve antonucci

>I think that the magazine had a very eclectic mix of articles, and frankly, not every one was going to appeal to everyone!

I think "they" (or is it "we"?) need to understand that the ability to make 100% of the membership happy with 100% of the content is never going to happen. Having a mix of paractical vs. whimsical, projects vs. theory, conventional vs. artistic will always be a balancing act. To a new turner, perhaps the John Jordan article wasn't interesting? To an experienced turner, perhaps a pie crust maker is trivial?

I think that the one danger I saw was the inclusion of less "common man" turner's work. I think that the magazine needs to stay grounded in the very simple fact that 90% or more of the membership are NOT professional, artistic studio turners. There needs to be a connection with the audience for what they want to see- and if that means more "user projects" or "regular guy work", then so be it.

Personally, I'd like to see a regular feature dedicate to the "weekend warriors" who are working in their garages and basements with $300 lathes producing Christmas gifts for the family. It could be jigs and tips, or small projects, or how do you solve this problem...

Steve

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#9

Re: There are no "wrong" articles... just a mix

Mike Brazeau

>Steve - I think you have made an excellent assessment. I personally enjoyed the fresh look to the Journal this issue, but felt it was too heavily oriented to the artistic aspects of work that starts on the lathe or was done in a workshop where there was a lathe . As I said before in another post, John Jordan's article was extremly well done and I liked the Pie Crust Crimper. I would love to get my wife back making pies when she finally retires from real estate. As a fairly experienced and competent turner when it comes to technique, I just cannot see myself drawn to the artistic world. Five hours with a wood burner or dental tool are just not appealing. That doesn't mean I wouldn't use a small amount of texturing or colour to enhance a normally utilitarian piece, so I enjoy reading articles about the ones who do and possibly seeing something that can be used. The Collectors of Wood Art have helped create a niche market in the USA, that with time and boom times again (the eternal optimist in me) will continue to help turned wood items to gain general acceptance. The content is dependent on input from the AAW comunity, so I guess it behoves us all to share all knowledge and put fingers to keyboard and get snapping digital pictures. A little less forum time and put it into articles?

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#10

Re: There are no "wrong" articles... just a mix

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>For what it is worth - my experience has been that the 'common tuner' as you put it, or any other who considers themselves as amateur, is intimidated by that amount of public exposure.

Oh, no! not me, my shop is a mess.

Oh, no! I'm not that good.

Oh, no! Who'd want to read an article about/by me?

Oh, no! These jigs and stuff. Shoot everybody already knows. This is nothing new.

And more of the same.

So here is a thought for all. Why not take your gripes and suggestions directly to Betty - and then volunteer to be part of the solution. Let the editorial staff decide whether others would be interested.

When I met Betty and sat and chatted for a while, I found her to be sincerely interested in making the magazine interesting and relative the majority of its readers. She was then seeking folks to write articles. You might be one of them. Bear in mind, you will need to be able to accept literary criticism and focus, not on what you think, buy rather on what your reader would enjoy, learn from, be challenged by, and open to.

Having said that, there is a valid reason for not getting involved. Wider notoriety has a price. You are fair game for criticism by the largely unqualified. Fact of life.

Airing them here is OK, but if you want to be taken seriously and not viewed as merely a B&M'er, then seriously consider what I offered above.

If not, please consider being quiet. This world needs a whole lot more lifting up than tearing down - and it needs to start someplace. Here is just fine. There is plenty of room for fair and qualified dissension, but not negative, mindless and less than helpful commentary.

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#11

Re: What Carol said, and this disclaimer.....

Jamie D

>... to remind all that this was Betty's first edition as the new editor. I believe she would be well pleased to have this discussion brought to her attention, not taking place behind her back. As with any first edition, the ideas for future development are a matter of evolution, and we should help her with our constructive opinions in the development of those stories we want to read. Turners are a VERY ecclectic group, and we can't cater to all people all the time.

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#12

Well Said Carole

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#13

Two Very Solid Posts

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#14

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

Cyril Griesbach

>I liked the issue and I disagree with Charlie and agree with Carol. I also like the variety of responses to the thread. Thank you John, Mike, Ed and others.

Charlie, you're a prolific writer. Some of it good and sometimes even interesting. I think you should actually consider starting your own woodturning magazine. Quarterly would be fine especially if it came out between the other quarterly offerings currently available which would help to increase circulation. I'm certainly not opposed to signing up.

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#15

Amen Carol and Jamie!! Perfectly Stated!!

Greg Haugen

>

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#16

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

Dennis Yoder

>I know for a fact that Betty is trying very hard to produce a balanced publication. Just after she was given this enormous job, she made a special trip to attend the Fall Fest in Indy at Ray Thompson's. She came to talk to everyone who was willing about the new mission and what people wanted to read in later editions. I think that we should hold judgement until a years worth of editions are on the table. She would appreciate everyones input and contributions on future topics and balance of content. Dennis Y

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#17

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

JohnKyler

>I found the issue to be a good one. I liked the article on the tenons. But the POP article was in my opinion too many pages and had nothing to do with turning except he uses other peoples work. A single page say close to the back would be better. I don't consider myself a "twirler" either, I'm a woodturner or craftsman.

You cant please 100% of the people 100% of the time. But I liked most of the issue. I follow the Pareto principle. I hope it doesn't go too far to the artsy side, but I don't want it full of pen turning either. Balance is good.

John

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#18

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

Jim A. Rutten

>My idea, and I say this after reading several of Charlie's posts and being entertained and challenged, is what if Charlie wrote a recurring column for American Woodturner. I would certainly read it.

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#19

Jamie, WC is behind no one's back.

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>This forum is open and widely read by many turners and all the AAW directors know about it. If Betty doesn't choose to read some of these posts then that is her choice, but this is definitely not behind someone's back. Private posts would meet that criteria.

This is not Betty's first edition. She was editor before, so this is the first edition of her second term.

I did not knock this edition. Simply again, the jury is still out, so let's not jump to conclusions. I simply pointed out some things that I found a little puzzling - things that an experienced editor might have avoided.

I certainly don't expect to agree with every choice by any editor, but we all have some level of expectation along those lines. The noise I am hearing is from some who are nervous about that level. There is a gap between what was published in this issue and what Betty wrote in her explanatory column.

Ed

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#20

A Magazine Critque....All Negative..

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I've belonged to AAW since the very beginning. Over the years there have been many disussions over the contents of American Woodturner. I can't remember any of it that was more completely negative then your post Charlie. Why not a contructive criticism? I saw very little about what you think would improve the magazine. Nit picking comments about art vx. craft, studio vs. shop. Garry (note the 2 R's) Knox Bennett...(what is that about?) promoting cetain turners, are not very valid complaints IMO. A lot of what you said was wrong, such as the whole second paragraph. You should do some research one just what the AAW does do and what it stands for.

Was the magazine perfect? Certainly not, but I think that it was a good first effort for Betty. There is a fairly wide variety of articles IMO. An easy turning project, furniture and spindle turning, some good photos, which everyone wants to see, even if they're beyond the skills of most of us. It's impossible to satisfy everyone with every artlcle.

I think that every past editor of the magazine has stated that one of their biggest problems has been the lack of articles submitted for publication. I've admired your writing skills and you imagination Charlie. Why don't you submit an article similar to one or more of the many posts you've made here. You have come up with some very good, thought provoking subjects. When Betty was the editor several years ago she even talked me into submitting an article.

I suggest that you contact Betty Scarpino. Voice your complaints. Ask her about what sort of articles she would like to see included in the magazine. Then get busy.

Wally

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#21

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

robo hippy

>I seldom find any of the turning magazines to present much of a learning experience for me. I have been turning for 11 years now, and do not know everything, but the biggest learning experiences have come from club meetings and the turning forums. I felt this way when I first started getting the magazines. Same with general woodworking magazines. I guess I should get off my butt and start writing for some of them.

All of the magazines could use a 'letters to the editor' section, and I don't think any of them have one. Discussion and feedback are best done this way.

I really wouldn't want the job of being the editor. Really difficult to find new things to put in print each month. The AAW magazine does seem to focus more on the 'Art' aspect than it does on the practical aspects, but then how many articles can you do on grind angles, or drying methods.....

robo hippy

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#22

Re: AAW Magazine - New turner long prospective

GalenV in Iowa

>I am new to wood turning and actually the first issue of American Woodturner I have ever read. First of all it blew me away that you could read an entire article without it being lost in advertisements and pages hidden away in back pages. Great!

Until I see another issue my thoughts are, what does Betty mean by including articles on basic techniques? Will they be on my level or to a professional is her �basics� over my head?

I liked the article on the symposium as I hope to go to Albuquerque for my first one and see my sister as well. It gives me a little more background as to what to expect.

Wood and Color is of interest because I am trying to understand how turning has become more of an art form. Wood burning, piercing, carving and color all appear to have gone away from turning as I learned it many years ago. My first reaction to color is if you are trying to duplicate copper or ceramics why not work in that medium. Carving on some pieces I have seen have over shadowed the fact that they were ever even turned. Is it still considered a turning or now a carving?

The article on mortise and tenon is really back to a basic way to attach turned legs and I should have learned that over 45 years ago when I made a coffee table in �shop� class. I used commercial brackets to screw on legs. Not really true woodworking at its best.

The article on faceplates is very informative for a new turner, but probably lacking in interest for experienced turners. I have yet to use a faceplate but knowing more I would feel more confident to try.

The article on John Jordan and his turning gave me more background on who�s who in turning. It was good to see a turner NOT using captive turning tools and laser pointer for hollow form. Makes one feel on the same level when you see vise grips to hold a drill bit!

The extra tenon he used to help support the turning on a smaller faceplate I have not picked up even on Wood Central comments. What I did miss from the written article is some of his thought process. When did he decide on the shape? From observation of the tapered blank or possible a shape he has used before? It seemed after he had it formed the article indicated the owner had requested spiral flutes and smooth. Would he need to have been thinking that when rough turning and maybe it was. Did the owner see a similar turning he produced, maybe as a signature type shape, to direct what he did?

Anyway long story but I found the magazine very interesting from a new turner�s standpoint.

Just like I enjoy the comments I read on Wood Central.

Galen

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#23

Dick Hines

Re: A Magazine Critque....All Negative..

Dick Hines

>I just wish my AAW magazine would show up. I bet it has been in Wood Craft and the book stores for weeks.

I am begining to think I have wood turner working in the post office.

"WHY AM I ALWAYS THE LAST TO KNOW!!!"

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#24

Steven Antonucci

Just sent a note to Betty. Let's see what happens

steve antonucci

>

Re: Got the AAW Magazine - Disappointed

#25

Galen, thanks for a ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>fresh perspective. I hope that you find articles in the future that whet your appetite and keep you enthused.

There has been a lot of discussion over the past few years about what should and should not be in the journal. Added to this is the discussion about what is appropriate for display in the Instant Gallery at the Symposia. Answers have been either non-existent or insufficient, but we plod onward. And maybe we are better off without answers.

Ed