Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Questions about tool rests

Posts

Questions about tool rests

#1

Questions about tool rests

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I'm fed up with my cast iron tool rests and want to take them to a machine shop to have drill rod inlaid in the top edge. One question is, what diameter and variety of drill rod would you recommend? HSS? 1/4"�? 5/16"�? 3/8"�? What effect if any does the diameter have on the performance or wearability? How do they attach the rod to the cast iron rest? And, what do you think I should expect to pay for this?

Thanks for any insights.

Ellis

Re: Questions about tool rests

#2

Re: Questions about tool rests

Greg Haugen

>Ellis, The main odjective is to have something better than "cast iron". As long as it's harder than that-it will be better. My Robust Comfort rest has 1/4" bar. I absolutely love it! The larger the diameter, "in theory", the further away the tool will be at the closest. I'm not sure how you could attach a bar to cast iron since it's doesn't weld very well and it's rather brittle. All of the rests I've seen with a bar on top are steel under it or a plastic like the ones Woodcraft sells, not cast iron. It wouldn't be good to potentially create a weak spot or crack in the cast iron and find out about it the hard way.

I'd talk to Brent English or Bill Grumbine about a comfort rest.

Just my 2 cents, and you probably deserve change.....

Greg H.

Re: Questions about tool rests

#3

Thanks, Greg

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Maybe attaching the rod is as simple as brazing or even PC7 epoxy (or something like it). However it's attached, I imagine it needs to be really solidly anchored to the rest to prevent it from vibrating.

I considered one of those Robust rests, but my banjo has a 30mm socket for the post. I'd have to come up with some kind of sleeve adapter.

Ellis

Re: Questions about tool rests

#4

Re: Questions about tool rests

robert davis

>i recently acquired a robust tool rest. has 1/4" hardened rod welded across top . it is a great improvement. everyon who has used one seems to think it is rthe greatest thing since bread

Re: Questions about tool rests

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Questions about tool rests

Mike Stafford

>Ellis, I have a Robust tool rest and as Robert said it is the greatest thing since sliced bread. I particularly enjoy the fact that when I am spindle turning I can wrap my relatively short fingers around it to support the spindle. Tools slide effortlessly over the hardened steel rod. Quite frequently I use it in reverse with the curvature toward the piece I am turning with my hand on the wrong side. It allows you to get really close to your work for tool support.

Mighty fine toolrest!!!! I betcha Brent can help you with the odd size.

Re: Questions about tool rests

#6

Re: Questions about tool rests

Norm Smith

>Ellis,

I used a 1/4 steel rod and put it on with J-BWELD. Works great. No problems. I believe that it was Alan N that recomended it.

Norm

Re: Questions about tool rests

#7

Robust Comfort Rests

Ron in Drums PA

>Robust Comfort Rests have 1/4" round bar epoxied on

Re: Questions about tool rests

#8

Re: Thanks, Greg

john lucas

>I'd call Brent anyway. He may be able to come up with a 30mm post. I think it's hard to beat his tool rests.

Ideally I would mill or grind a slight groove roughly the diameter of the rod you use. You could probably cut a V notch with an angle grinder and 1/4" thick abrasive wheel. I would probably do it by hand but if you wanted it to be perfect just rig up a fence for the grinder to ride against.

I think 1/4 or 5/16 would be fine. Rough up the underside of the rod and then glue it with PC-7 or JB weld and you should be fine.

Re: Questions about tool rests

#9

Re: Thanks, Greg

Wayne Allen (Carson City, NV)

>Ellis -- As mentioned by others, JB Weld will work fine to secure the steel rod onto the cast iron, but be aware that the toolrest will now be higher than it origionally was, resulting in not being able to get the toolrest low enough. This can be a problem depending on what lathe you have. DAMHIKT ---Wayne

Re: Questions about tool rests

#10

Re: Questions about tool rests

paul waddle

>Ellis,www.easywoodtools.com does just that-I believe it was those people who demoed at LAW a couple of wks ago. I am uncertain as there were two different suppliers there.

I agree with you,a hard strip across the tool rest will help immensely-especially when using the skew to smooth up things. Who ever was at LAW,had different sizes of tool posts and across the top, harden drill rod was epoxied. I asked about how they were attached as heating would destroy the hardness. They looked good,painted sos you couldn't tell how the rod was attached.

Besure and measure the length, and just order some hard rod-either hardened or case hardened, and epoxy them to your tool post.The diameter I saw was 1/4, and 3/8ths.. pw

Re: Questions about tool rests

#11

Re: Here's another vote for the Robust ....

Jamie D

>... from me, and the concave rest is very comfortable for my support hand on the rest. My Studly feels down when I remove the Comfort rest to use on the Woodfast, so I may have to buy another Robust rest just to keep him happy, and you ALWAYS want your lathe to be happy! (;-D)

Re: Questions about tool rests

#12

PC7 worked for mine.

Al Neighbors

>I attached 1/4" drill rod to both of my Oneway rests with PC7. If I had used pre-hardened HSS, I would never have to dress my rests.

As it is, I used some other stuff, and still have to dress my rests, but not nearly as often as I first had to.

PC7... is our friend. :o)

Re: Questions about tool rests

#13

Re: Questions about tool rests

Brent English

>Hi Ellis:

Brent from Robust here. Yes we can get 30mm stock if you need it. For those of you that have asked in the past and I've said "no" this is something relatively new.

Ellis, I hope this doesn't conflict with your commercial posting policy, just wanted to clarify your concern.

Brent

Re: Questions about tool rests

#14

Re: Questions about tool rests

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Ellis,

As you may have noted in prior posts, I am a Robust owner and love the new toolrests that Brent has been putting out.

I have a Oneway 1018 and decided to epoxy a piece of 1/4" round bar to the toolrest. I used PC7 and it has been super.

I recently got a Jet 1220VS and am strongly considering using PC7 to epoxy a rod to those rests. It's worth the trouble.

Ed

Re: Questions about tool rests

#15

Re: Thanks, Greg

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I've got a Poolewood Euro2000, which has a lot of extra room in the post hole to lower the rest. I figure I'd only be raising the bearing surface by about 1/8" if I use a piece of 1/4" drill rod.

I think one of my buddies has a ball mill for his Bridgeport. Should be a piece of cake.

Thanks,

Ellis

Re: Questions about tool rests

#16

Re: Thanks, Greg

Carole Valentine

>Brent could probably accommodate your 30mm post requirement. I love my Robust tool rests. The concave rest like the Robust is what I prefer.

Re: Questions about tool rests

#17

I'll approach him. Thanks, Carole.

Ellis Walentine, Host

>

Re: Questions about tool rests

#18

consider keeping the cast iron

Robin Corell in Atascadero

>I am always surprised by the noumber of high end lathes and aftermarket tool rests that are made of steel or some other non cast iron material. Having had a tool rest break I can say first hand why they are made out of cast iron, It is the weak link and a safty feature. I suppose it could be argued that my catch was due to inexperiance since it happend while I was an apprintice. I worked in a shop where we had a 11' diameter faceplate lathe powered by a 440v 15 hp motor. A co worker with nearly 20 years experiance was tuning and had a bad catch and broke a 24" tool rest. Can you imagine what would have happend if the tool rest had been welded steel?

I guess it could be argued that on low end lathes the cast iron tool rest is a way to save a couple of pennies. But how about a top of the line Oliver paternmakers lathe with a cross slide, does anyone really think the tool rest was made out of cast iron as a way to save a couple of pennies? keep in mind many of the foundries that pour cast iron also pour ductile or even tool steel.

You may think my post is over the top so I will end it with one last story. I have a friend that broke his jaw while turning on a lathe with a tool rest made from welded angle iron. he had a bad catch and something had to give and since the tool rest couldn't easily break what gave was his grip on the end of the tool.

Robin

Re: Questions about tool rests

#19

Re: Questions about tool rests

John K Jordan

>I left my cast tool rest alone and made another one - ground a concave on the top of a 1" steel rod and welded a slightly smaller rod across the top. The most time-consuming part was grinding but I'm sure I made it better than needed.

But as for your question, you can braze steel to cast iron with an oxy-acet torch and probably a mapp gas torch (but I haven't done that). I read once that the tool rest should be softer than the tools to keep from damaging the tools.

The last time I had a shop braze something for me they charged me $5.

Rather than a rod, you might even braze a thin flat strip of mild steel to the top, then radius it with a file.

JKJ

Re: Questions about tool rests

#20

Re: Questions about tool rests

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Not to be a pain about it, but what's wrong with the standard tool rests? I use two that came with my mustard monster and the little one that was supplied with my Jet mini, and I haven't had the slightest problem. I do make a point of filing off any nicks, sanding, and using a power wire brush on them so that they are smooth and slick. I know that people add a hardened rod across the top, but I just don't see what's the big deal. I'm not knocking it, necessarily. What are the advantages? Mine work perfectly.

Re: Questions about tool rests

#21

Re: Questions about tool rests

john lucas

>Mine don't mark up very much but they do require a little dressing every now and then. What I like about the new tool rests is the shape. I have never liked the shapes of my powermatic tool rests. I bought the bestwoodtools tool rests and they never ding and are good and solid. I thought I would try the Robust tool rest and I think I like them better.

Re: Questions about tool rests

#22

Re: Questions about tool rests

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>I too have the mini and keep the rest filed and smooth. Then at a club meeting I got the chance to try a rest on the mini that had the steel rod affixed. The difference in smoothness was surprising, like silk.

Enough so for me that I am looking into redoing mine and adding a couple of different lengths all would the steel rod. The club member has a 2" (amazingly helpful), a 4", the original modified 6", a 9" and a beefed up 12".

Re: Questions about tool rests

#23

Eliot, the reason I glued...

Al Neighbors

>the rod to my toolrests is that I was constantly having to dress them to get the nicks out of them. I could dress them, and begin a piece, and before I got into the finishing cuts, would have to dress them again. Now I can do two or three complete pieces before having to re-dress the rest. There is a distinct advantage to having a 1/4" drill rod glued to the top edge.

Re: Questions about tool rests

#24

2" tool rest

John K Jordan

>Carol,

What's the advantage of a 2" long tool rest? Can it fit places where a 6" can't?

JKJ

Re: Questions about tool rests

#25

Re: 2" tool rest

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>He was using it to show us how to turn bird houses. It could get in close with the tool supported directly over the post most of the time. Also, when working out at the end of the rest, you usually have to contend with the other end of the rest getting in the way. Made sense to me.