Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Posts

Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#1

Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I reviewed the replies on the post I made a couple of days ago on turning speeds. I think nearly all, if not all of those who replied are experienced turners. I was surprised at the wide range of speeds used by all of these turners. They ranged from about 800 RPM to 3800 RPM. This on bowls and hollowforms. Spindle turning ranged from about 1200 to as fast as the lathe could turn.

Today I rough turned 2 hollowforms. Both from blanks that I've had for awhile so they're nearly dry. One is about 5 x 8 inches, the other 4 x 7 inches. I decided to do some experimenting. After I brought the blanks into round I shaped the blanks using a wide range of speeds. (This was fascinating so the HF's are smaller than they might have been) My slowest speed was 800 RPM. Because I'm used to turning at a much higher speed, 800 was almost frustrating it was so slow. The highest speed that I used was about 2400. That would take some getting used to but the results, smooth, easy cutting, etc. were very good.

Two pieces probably isn't enough turning to really form any definite conclusions. At 800 I found myself forcing the tool because the cut was so slow. I found it difficult to form a nice even curve and the surface wasn't very smooth. At 1200 it felt better. At 1600 (near my usual speed) the cutting was smoother and because I could move the gouge faster with little effort, the curve was better. At 2000, especially on the smaller piece, I still felt comfortable and the cutting required very little effort and was even smoother. At 2400 I felt a bit uncomfortable with the larger piece. I tried some light finishing type cuts and was impressed at how smooth the cuts were with almost no effort. All of this was done between centers.

When I did the rough out hollowing I went through the same range of speeds execept 2400. I chickened out there but I'm going to try it later on another piece. I found that with 800 I was again forcing the tool and felt sort of frustrated. Just way too slow for me. I felt that 2000 was a bit too fast for me for hollowing. I usually hollow pieces this size at around 1600, so of course that felt very comfortable.

When hollowing, higher speeds aren't as big a deal as turning on the outside of the piece. At the very center of the piece the surface speed of the piece is very low. In fact, you need to move the tool more slowly the nearer the center you get to give it a chance to cut. That nubbin at the very center is because you don't give the tool a chance to cut unless you stop the tool.

For the present I'll probably stay with my usual speeds of 1600 to 1800 RPM for pieces of this size, but I will experiment with somewhat higher speeds.

There is no doubt in my mind that higher speeds do give smoother, easier cuts with less effort than do the slower speeds.

At no time did I feel that the speeds that I was using were unsafe, even though 2400 made me a bit uneasy. I'm sure that I could get used to it for pieces under 4 inches. I'll try it on some small pieces. Both pieces that I turned were sound wood with no splits or cracks.

I've been turning finials at about 2500. I'm going to go to 3000 and see how I like it.

Wally

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#2

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

John Jordan

>Wally,

There's no doubt that all else being equal, a bit more speed can help your cut. I think most of it is what you are used to. If I halved my speed, I would feel the same as you-likewise if I increased it a lot.

The key thing is your "comfort level". You're very skillful, and can use common sense. and you intuitively know when something is wrong. My concern is less experienced turners "don't" have that sense and high speed may get them in trouble.

I don't think you have to worry about those finials hitting you in the head. :)

John

John

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#3

Thanks for the report, Wally.

Al Neighbors

>What kind of lathe are you using? My 1640 Oneway doesn't go to 3000.

I'd like to speed it up for small spindles and pens.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#4

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree John. In my classes I wouldn't allow those speeds for inexperienced turners.

Hey John, I missed seeing you at Desert Roundup.

Wally

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#5

Re: Thanks for the report, Wally.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have the big Oneway Al.

Wally

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#6

Unsafe Speeds.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>John's post made me realize that I should have mentioned that turning at higher speeds shouldn't be done by beginners or turners with little experience. As John says..."turn within your comfort level". And always carefully inspect any blank for splits and cracks before you crank up the speed.

Wally

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#7

Re: Unsafe Speeds.....

Carole Valentine

>And keep your ears open...sound is a great indicator of impending disaster (but not the only one). If you don't have the experience to recognize the audible warnings, you are best off staying with lower speeds until you do.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#8

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Greg Haugen

>John stated it perfectly in his post with two statements; "comfort level," and "intuitively know when something is wrong". I think these two things are more important than any number. With digital readouts, etc. I think some times we're too dependent on the number and not listening to our gut, the wood, and the other sights and sounds involved with turning.

It was a good and interesting post Wally.

Greg H.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#9

Re: Unsafe Speeds.....Thanks

GalenV in Iowa

>I am gald this string of messages gave me a better insite to turning speeds beyond what I read in books. I could not even imagine why my Jet 1220 had a top speed of 3975 rpm. The belt will not ever touch this set of pulley in my turning life time. I tried turning a pen at the 2630 rpm and wondered why as it seems I could turn a pen just as well at 1800 rpm. I was not in a race or anything. The finials I have tried did not seem like a faster speed would help.

I do know that the low end of 500 is too fast for a few of the unbalanced green turnings I have done but I am stuck with that.

I have wondered if anyone had looked at a possible change to the motor pulley to slow the entire range down. It could be it is already the smallest pulley set you can get.

Thanks again and being slow is not always bad.

Galen

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

keith tompkins

>Hey Wally, I misspoke earlier. I was thinking 3800 rpm, when i just checked my lathe, the top speed is 2870, so that's the speed I hollow end-grain pieces. I apologize, 2800, NOT 3800.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#11

Ok, but why?

Steven Kubien

>Interesting thread(s) Wally. The question I have (for everyone) is why do higher turning speeds equal a better finish (for those like Wally who do see this)? It seems to be true for me but I don't know why.

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#12

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Wally, I didn't get a chance to respond in the other thread, but I tend to turn at higher speeds. My criteria for myself and others is, if the lathe isn't shaking, and the turner isn't shaking, then the speed is fine. I like going fast because it is fun. I also get a better surface most of the time.

Steve, to answer your question about why higher speeds equate to a better surface, every cut is a spiral. The faster the surface of the wood, the easier it is to get tighter spirals, which means a better surface. It also allows the turner to move at a more comfortable pace across the wood, matching the travel of the tool to the speed of the wood. Smoother motion means a smoother surface and a fairer curve. If the wood is moving slowly, the turner must move the tool across the wood more slowly, which requires more control and a steadier hand to keep the tool from gagging on the wood.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#13

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The Nish/Mahoney rule of thumb, "diameter X RPM's should equal 6000-9000. Your 5 inch diameter hollow form times 1,600 RPM equals 8,000 which falls in the range. It's when the diameter increases and the rpm's don't decrease is when there is a problem. Example;

12 inch diameter times 1,600 rpm equals 19,200 which should be slowed down OR 12 inch diameter times 2,000 rpm equals 24,000... that number jumps real fast. Finials or pens won't even fall under the guidelines... a 1 inch diameter times 3,000 rpm equals 3,000 but I think the rule is for bowl turning.

The formula above is a basic guideline to keep the outside surface speed the same.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#14

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Steven Kubien

>Well, that makes sense. Thanks Bill

Steve

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#15

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

john lucas

>I'll add that when the speed goes up you are actually taking a smaller amount of wood per pass of the tool. This along with the closer spiraling leaves a cleaner surface. There are also many other factors. The shape of the edge touching the wood and how broad that edge is (within limits of course).

Then there is how move the tool. If you use your body for tool control you get a much better flow. There is sort of a rhythm of flow that you learn and we all probably do this differently. That will affect how fast you want to move through the wood.

Then there is the white knuckle factor. There is a certain speed that makes you nervous. I personally choose not to go beyond that and simply developed the body movement to deal with the slower speeds. I think it's worth trying higher speeds on something safe. You might find you like it and it works for you. I'm in this for fun so I do things at my comfort level.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#16

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>I'm guilty of violating the speed limit, but never with students. I used the math and came up with a number of 12,800 -14,400 for a 12" bowl. Of course, that is when it is round and running true. Then again, I have had 18" blanks running at a combined number of 16,200. When I do my winged and banana bowls though, the mass is smaller but the speed is greater. I am running them around 18,200 (not rpm, the final number). It actually makes it safer, as long as the wood stays on the lathe!

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#17

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Ed Conhaim

>Am turning on a Jet 1236 that was purchased used. Although it has variable speeds, there is nowhere on the lathe that tells what setting equals what RPM. Is there any way to find this out? Thanks

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#18

Thanks for all the input

Don Orr

>I think I'm going to try some experiments myself. I've been in a slump for a while and could use some motivation.

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#19

Surface Speed....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>What we are really concerned with here is not RPM's as much as surface speed of the wood. Most of us wouldn't turn pens or finials at 800 RPM and we wouldn't (I hope) turn salad bowls at 3000.

I would like to know at what speeds Jim Shaver turns pens, and Ruth Niles turns a 2 in. spindle, and Michael Stafford turns a 3 in. box, and Russ turns a 12 in. salad bowl.

Safety and tool control are a top priority in turning. What is a safe and reasonable speed for one turner is not for another. I think that we would all do ourselves a favor by doing some experimenting with various speeds. You may find that your turning improves by finding another "comfort level" speed.

Wally

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#20

Steven Antonucci

Ed- don't get hung up on the numbers

steve antonucci

>I think the message is that you need to be comfortable with the speed of the object on the lathe. Whether it is 800 or 8000 rpms is irrelevant.

I used to think 800 RPMs was about as fast as I could hollow. Now, I'm more comfortable at 1400. It's a matter of getting used to it, then stepping out of your comfort zone for a bit, and getting used to it again.

Bill's rule of thumb is a pretty good starting point. If the lathe isn't moving, it's probably OK. One thing to add- once you get round, you can increase speed. If you still get catches, I'd add RPM's slowly and not max out my comfort zone.

Steve

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#21

Steven Antonucci

Rules to turn by:

steve antonucci

>1.) RPM on a balance piece > RPM on rough out.

2.) Never turn the speed up past your comfort level.

3.) more RPM's results in a better cut if you are capable of making better cuts- if not, more RPM's result in more spectacular catches.

4.) The number of the RPM's is not important- it's a relative thing-sometimes you need to go faster, other times you need to go slower.

5.) No matter what the speed is, know what the line of fire is and don't be in it.

6.) A big piece of wood carries a lot more potential energy than a smaller peice of wood, and understanding what can happen if you are struck by a 40# bowl blank vs. a shattered finial tip should weigh heavily on your mind when you chose your speed.

7.) Just because I do it doesn't mean you should.

I'm sure there are more.

Steve

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#22

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

Barry Elder

>Doug, I realize the Nish/Mahoney thing is well known, but I'm a conspiracy nut and I think it is a government plot fostered by NASA in order to keep you from orbiting a 12 inch bowl should it dismount from your lathe through your shop ceiling or window!! (Har! Har!)

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#23

UFO sighting in Texas-could be a bowl

john lucas

>

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#24

Jet 1236 ...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Reeves drive points: 550, 900, 1250, 1650, 2600, 3000

Wally

Re: Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)

#25

Hey Bill.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Should I be afraid to sit front row center in Phoenix?

Wally