Turning Speeds Again.....(Long)
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>I reviewed the replies on the post I made a couple of days ago on turning speeds. I think nearly all, if not all of those who replied are experienced turners. I was surprised at the wide range of speeds used by all of these turners. They ranged from about 800 RPM to 3800 RPM. This on bowls and hollowforms. Spindle turning ranged from about 1200 to as fast as the lathe could turn.
Today I rough turned 2 hollowforms. Both from blanks that I've had for awhile so they're nearly dry. One is about 5 x 8 inches, the other 4 x 7 inches. I decided to do some experimenting. After I brought the blanks into round I shaped the blanks using a wide range of speeds. (This was fascinating so the HF's are smaller than they might have been) My slowest speed was 800 RPM. Because I'm used to turning at a much higher speed, 800 was almost frustrating it was so slow. The highest speed that I used was about 2400. That would take some getting used to but the results, smooth, easy cutting, etc. were very good.
Two pieces probably isn't enough turning to really form any definite conclusions. At 800 I found myself forcing the tool because the cut was so slow. I found it difficult to form a nice even curve and the surface wasn't very smooth. At 1200 it felt better. At 1600 (near my usual speed) the cutting was smoother and because I could move the gouge faster with little effort, the curve was better. At 2000, especially on the smaller piece, I still felt comfortable and the cutting required very little effort and was even smoother. At 2400 I felt a bit uncomfortable with the larger piece. I tried some light finishing type cuts and was impressed at how smooth the cuts were with almost no effort. All of this was done between centers.
When I did the rough out hollowing I went through the same range of speeds execept 2400. I chickened out there but I'm going to try it later on another piece. I found that with 800 I was again forcing the tool and felt sort of frustrated. Just way too slow for me. I felt that 2000 was a bit too fast for me for hollowing. I usually hollow pieces this size at around 1600, so of course that felt very comfortable.
When hollowing, higher speeds aren't as big a deal as turning on the outside of the piece. At the very center of the piece the surface speed of the piece is very low. In fact, you need to move the tool more slowly the nearer the center you get to give it a chance to cut. That nubbin at the very center is because you don't give the tool a chance to cut unless you stop the tool.
For the present I'll probably stay with my usual speeds of 1600 to 1800 RPM for pieces of this size, but I will experiment with somewhat higher speeds.
There is no doubt in my mind that higher speeds do give smoother, easier cuts with less effort than do the slower speeds.
At no time did I feel that the speeds that I was using were unsafe, even though 2400 made me a bit uneasy. I'm sure that I could get used to it for pieces under 4 inches. I'll try it on some small pieces. Both pieces that I turned were sound wood with no splits or cracks.
I've been turning finials at about 2500. I'm going to go to 3000 and see how I like it.
Wally



