Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Posts

At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#1

At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>In my opinion most turners turn at speeds that are too slow for best results. At the Desert Roundup symposium I attended 2 of Cindy Drozda's demos. At one of them she turned a 3-sided vessel. which means that she changed centers to achieve the 3 sides. This also means that the blank was unbalanced. The blank was about 4 inches in diameter. She cranked the lathe up to 3000 RPM! The lathe was a 16 inch Jet and it wasn't weighted down. She did a beautiful job.

I live in a retirement community and we have a community woodshop that has 8 lathes. I have my own shop but I visit the community shop frequently (I taught classes there for years). I have observed that most turners are over-cautious and turn at speeds that are way too low for best results. Most don't crank it up to over 1000 RPM.

Most of my own turning is under 10 inches in dia. and I regularly turn bowls and vessels at between 1500 and 2000 RPM, depending on the wood. Spindle turning can run up to 3000 RPM. I find that at higher speeds I get better, smoother cutting, and I really believe that there is less chance of an accident.

Of course safe turning has a top priority so we have to use some common sense when selecting speeds. Don't crank up a segmented vessel to 3000 RPM!

What speeds do you turn at?

Wally

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#2

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I turn most items at the top speed of the lowest range on my Jet Mini VS, which I think is 1800. If a piece is off balance, I turn it down until the vibration is manageable. I sand at 500.

keithz

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#3

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>When I was teaching classes at Woodcraft we used Jet Mini lathes. For beginners, I set the belt to get 1200 RPM. For more advanced classes I set it at 1800. The students were turning bowls with a dia. of about 7 inches. (Of course beginners sometimes ended up 5 inch bowls)

When I hand sand I use speeds at near my turning speed on most woods. Slower on exotics. When using my inertia sander I use it at my regular turning speeds.

Wally

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#4

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Sean Troy

>I agree Wally. I tend to turn at higher speeds when safe to do so which is most of the time. I'm talking finish turning not roughing a 100lb. blank. You get much cleaner cuts, avoid most tear out and can usally start sanding with 220

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#5

Steven Antonucci

Good question

steve antonucci

>I have steadily been increasing my speed over the years as I have become more comfortable in front of the lathe. I slow down for demos since the squeamishness of the front couple of rows is pretty distracting, but also makes for a bit of my comedy routine ("Hey you in the front row- ever see me demo? Of course you haven't or you wouldn't be sitting there...")

I find that unless my lathe is shaking mercilessly, I am always turning faster. Routinely, 1000 rpm on the big stuff (15") or 1500rpm + on the smaller stuff. Even when hollowing, I have been running the lathe a lot faster...

Steve

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#6

Re: Good question

john lucas

>I have been increasing my speed over the last few years but I know I still turn at speeds much slower than most. Even inside out turning which has 4 open sides don't require high speeds if my tool control is good.

I do believe that most beginners push the tools too much. If you combine that with slow speeds they don't get very clean cuts. By increasing the speed of the wood they effectively move the tool slower per revolution thereby getting a smoother cut. I find they also tend to move the tool in gross movements rather than smooth body movements. Having the lathe speed up helps smooth out those cuts as well.

I guess I got into the habit because my early lathes were all not very stable and I didn't know how to select wood so I had the lathe walking and wood blowing up. All this adds up to wanting to run the lathe under 500 rpm for safety's sake.

Now that I have a good lathe and I try to only turn sound wood I am more comfortable with higher speeds.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#7

Re: Good question

Texian

>Bet I'm still slower than you, John, but similarly working my way up. Sometimes I simply forget to turn up the wick when it is appropriate to do so.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#8

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Cyril Griesbach

>Excellent question, Wally. I'm beginning to get faster as well. Currently I'm working on an off center spindle project that I have to demo at our club next month. The off center is only about a quarter inch each way and I'm going max on the low speed pulley of my PM3520...about 1250 RPM. As the piece gets thinner some of the woods I've tried flex more than others so I wonder if I should be going faster or slower. When I spin things up to 1250 it goes through a brief zone of vibration just as it hits top speed and settles out just fine. I don't do a lot of spindle work and I know that most who do really crank it up. I guess I'll have to give it some more speed this afternoon and see what difference it makes.

However I sure will appreciate any suggestions.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#9

JL

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

JL

>Roughing spindles - ~1000 rpm.

Shaping spindles - ~2000 rpm.

Sanding spindles - ~2500 rpm and higher.

Bowls - about half of that.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#10

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>As fast as I can...

:-)

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#11

What if...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>the blank has a hair line crack that isn't seen until it's to late. I'm surprised there hasn't been more accidents, I see some (not here) that say it's safe to rough a larger bowl at 1,500 - 2,000 rpm's! BS... one day we'll have a post about a death because the bowl blank came apart. I know of one professional who was knocked out when a blank came apart at a safe speed... less than 800 rpm.

Tools cut the same at lower speeds, woodturning is not a race and has to be done safely.

Personally I like slower speeds.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#12

Re: What if...

Greg Haugen

>I agree with Doug, and definately go against the majority it seems in this post. When I teach bowl turning I use the Nish/Mahoney rule of thumb, "diameter X RPM's should equal 6000-9000." Last fall I spent a day at Alan Lacer's. We made some hook tools and used them, he also showed me how raising different sized burrs on scrapers (which was his recent article in the Journal)can be used. Our speed never went above 800 for a 4" diameter end grain piece. The cuts were "glass" smooth. Speed can be a factor in vibration/chatter, especially with spindles and thinner walled pieces, since the centrifugal force can throwh the piece out of round.

I try to keep my bowl turning speeds in the "safe" range. I core bowls with a Mcnaughton slower than I turn with a gouge.

Spindles rarely get 2000.

I sand spindles at 1400 or less and bowls at 500 (lathe speed with a drill/mandrel).

I just don't see a point in cranking it up.

Just my two cents....

Greg H.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#13

Re: What if...

Sean Troy

>Bowls or turnings comming apart shouldn't be a concern if your standing out of the line of fire like you should be anyway. :)

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#14

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Stephen Mushinski

>With variable speed lathes it is easy to adjust the speed to what you want. For me when using a mini lathe I turn often faster than I should just to not change the belt. Bad habit. As for the number Wally, I am not sure as I look at the wood and for vibration and make it go as fast as I can and feel comfortable. Most likely faster then most but not at speeds that Jimmy Clewes demo's at.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#15

Re: What if...

john lucas

>Doing a pull cut on a bowl it is sometimes hard to stay out of the line of fire. It's one of those things that sounds good and I try to do it as much as possible but sometimes you just have to get over the pieced and watch the profile as you turn to get that perfect curve.

I know I'm one of those who stresses, stay out of the line of fire, but sometimes you just can't, or at least choose not to.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#16

Dick Hines

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Dick Hines

>I try to turn as fast as I feel safe. Or to put another way, when I have to chase the lathe around the shop I will turn the speed down a RPM or two.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#17

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Wally,

I think I am one of the cautious,

200rpm unbalanced work

700 rpm big bowls and platters 14" - 16"

1000 rpm small bowls and vases

1500 spindles

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#18

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Ron McKinley

>The same as Jorge except for spindles I go to 2000......Ron

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#19

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

GalenV in Iowa

>Thanks all:

I thought I knew where I was going with my turning. Try to increase the speed I have been turning at and decrease when sanding.

Now after reading all this my head is spinning and my lathe is not.

Hum!

Faster speed = more spectacular catches

Slower sanding speed = less burned fingers though

Still interesting as a newer turner to know there is more than one answer, just a little harder to know if there is really a right and wrong thing to do.

Galen

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#20

Re: What if...not if - did

Fog Tanner

>I keep a copy of the "safe limits" charts from Raffan's book on the wll behind the lathe. I use those as the upper end of what I am doing. If I exceed those sizes I use the Dale Nish rule of thumb RPM = 9000/dia in inches as the max and 6000 as the min.

I have had a small 6"-7" bowl explode due to a crack. The RPM was within a "reasonable"/safe limit, but as you mentioned there was a slight crack and when the rim reached a 1/6" thickhess the whole rim blew apart. I have never found the pieces, but managed to finish what was left. I keep it on a table close to the lathe as a reminder. I also found the edge on my Thompson was unaffected by the detonation - good steel...

I have also had the tenon break on a 17" bowl I was coring at around 50 rpm. I normally run the speed around 400-600 depeneding on the size of the blank, but thanks to Mike Mahoney I have taken to slowing down to around 50 at the bottom of the cut. I still had a 17" blank jump over the gate and into my arms at that speed. I had just removed a little 6" bowl so it was still the majority of the blank. I am just glad that it didn't happen when I was at 400 - I would probably not be writing anymore.

These are two of the reasons I live in an Airstream (and looking for a surplus flak jacket) when turning. It is not if, but when - and I see no reason to push it when I am not doing production work and since there are no nucleur missels on the way....

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#21

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

John Jordan

>Rarely over 800-1000 rpm. You're a good turner, Wally, but not everyone is. At more modest speeds things are more relaxed, so the turner relaxes, and once the tension is gone, one can make relaxed cuts. It doesn't take me long to get something done-every cut or movement I make counts. As the years have gone by, the speed has gone down, my efficiency has gone up.

I never let students turn fast in class. It may not scare them, but it does me. :)

You're still my hero, Wally.

John

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#22

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Wally,

I cannot remember that last time I went over 1200 rpm for anything. I seem to get great cuts with a sharp gouge at those speeds.

If I am not getting good cuts at that speed... I sharpen the tool. But I did cut my turning teeth at the watchful eye of John Jordan. :)

Thank goodness for that great starting point.

Dave (slow hand) Peebles

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#23

I'm A Bit Surprised.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>at how many experienced turners are turning at such slow speeds. I made this post after watching Cindy Drozda turn a 4 in. dia. hollowform at 3000 RPM, a speed that I wouldn't even think of doing.

From my own turning I am convinced that I get better results, smoother, easier turning at 1600 RPM than I do at 1000. I don't consider that I'm turning at dangerous speeds at all.

Someone mentioned that getting whacked by a flying or exploding vessel wasn't a matter of if but a matter of when, when turning at high speeds. I started turning 70 years ago and have turned thousands of pieces. I've had flying bowls and can remember at least a couple of exploding pieces, but I've always been out of the line of fire. But then who knows, maybe the next one will get me. But then I might cut my finger off on the bandsaw too. We all take a chance when we turn on a power tool.

Wally

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#24

Re: I'm A Bit Surprised.....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>My post has nothing to do with you Wally but has alot to do with a video out that talks about roughing at speeds of 1,500 and 2,000 rpm. It scares me that some new turner will say he does it so I will too and have a terrible accident. Bowl blanks will come apart and they hurt at low speed let alone higher speeds. Safety glasses and a face shield only take so much of the impact.

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: At What Speeds Do You Turn?.....

keith tompkins

>HI Wally, I turn the whole spectrum of speeds. For end-grain hollowing, I find high speed works better, esp. when using the detail gouge. I usually turn those pieces full speed, about 3800 rpm. Hook tools don't require such speeds, so I turn half that speed Finials and delicate work is high speed as well. For demo's, I keep the speed lower for safety's sake. On the other hand, for those having trouble with the skew, I find the skew will cut very well at very low speeds...if not, it's dull. That's a good way to learn the skew without fear. My lathe is usually on the second or third speed for normal work.