Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Cherry as a turning wood....

Posts

Cherry as a turning wood....

#1

Cherry as a turning wood....

Michael Stafford

>JKJ's questions regarding turning cherry when and how soon brings to mind a question I have.

Is cherry really a good turning wood? I remember reading an article where a famous turner said that cherry is too brittle for bowls. I have turned a number of cherry bowls that were very thin without a problem. Of course I haven't dropped one on the floor yet either.

In the last few days I was doing some production turning of a box style that I am going to be demonstrating and I dropped a lid on the floor and it chipped a nice piece out of the rim. Now this is not the first time I have dropped a lid on the floor but it is the first time I have had a lid chip. And since you are bound to ask the rim was between 1/8" and 3/16" thick.

So is this chipping I experienced symptomatic of the brittleness of cherry a famous production bowl turner referred to? or something else?

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#2

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Greg Haugen

>Maybe if you don't drop them to get that "texture" there wouldn't be an issue. :-))

I haven't had an issue with Cherry bowls. My bowls are mostly "utilitarian" in design but also have done some natural edges. It's also one of the best selling species and one of my favorites. I also like to use the sapwood for good contrast. For that fact alone I'll do anything I can to make it work. I've turned, "practiced" on, quite a few cherry boxes but also haven't dropped one though either. An end grain box would possibly take impact differently than a face grain bowl though too. I would say it moves more than other woods. I'll caliper rough turned bowls of cherry to make sure it's as close as I can get it. I'll also leave them at a minimum of 10% if not more. I'll rough boxes and let them sit for a long time. I thought David Lancaster uses alot of cherry in his bowls. Some of my favorite vessels are of cherry from John Jordan. Since he turned them, I'd bet they're turned green and not super thin since he also carves on them.

I think it comes down to the grain balance, how it's prepped/roughed, etc. I even think sometimes the region matters, our Cherry is different from PA. cherry or anywhere else.

It's one of my favorite woods to turn; end grain, face grain, green, or as dry as can be.

Greg H.

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#3

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

John Jordan

>Cherry is promo turning wood and one of my favorites. It turns easily and I don't find any unusual problem with checking. One thing that is a bit unique for cherry compared to other normal hardwoods is that the sapwood moves more than the heartwood. If you include a lot of sapwood, you will get a fair amount of movement in green wood-and possibly cracking if the more stable heartwood restrains the sapwood. The sapwood also stains very quickly when the weather warms up. The heartwood will last a LONG time if you keep the logs covered. The heartwood is quite stable and bug resistant, and does not discolor to any extent.

Big trees are usually best.

If you think cherry is not for production bowls, look up David Lancaster's website. He does THOUSANDS of large cherry bowls a year with no problem.


img

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#4

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

paul waddle

>Cherry makes excellent ring boxes and holds threads very well for me. I burn it when I route it,but maple(hard) does the same. I wish to turn bowls,but I've got to buy a "varigrind" or wood tool jig to sharpen my bowl gouge first. I've been living with dull tools too long! pw.

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Dick Hines

>I don't know if cherry is good turning wood or not. I know I like turning it.

I do know that I will sell 5 cherry bowls to 1 walnut bowl. The ladies love the cherry bowls.

This makes cherry a good turning wood.

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#6

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Michael Stafford

>I don't think that cherry is not for production bowls Mike Mahoney thinks that. I am not an expert on what makes a good wood for bowls and what does not.

I don't think cherry is a particularly good wood for boxes. As I said I find it to be brittle and not hard enough. I prefer more dense and resilient hardwoods. Sure you can turn any wood into a box but I just happen to think that there are many better suited than cherry.

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#7

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Ken

>I'll take all I can get,I love turnin it,I know I sell a heck of a lot of em at the show I go to.

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#8

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Lan Brady

>Mike,

There is a big difference between the Piedmont grown Cherry and that grown in colder mountain climates. Ours has wind shakes, the good stuff does not. I cannot tell a difference by looking, but I have cut in Greensboro and in Cullowhee. There is a difference.

Lan

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#9

Bob Moffett

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Bob Moffett

>I have turned a lot of cherry bowls and boxes, more bowls than boxes, and never had a problem. Cherry is one of my favorite woods to turn. Most of the cherry wood that I get is from piedmont N.C.

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#10

Ahh.. Utah Cherry

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>It may not be good in the Western states, but it is my favorite here in Ohio. :)

This is the problem with using a common wood name. I would bet that the Cherry from around the country reacts in totally different ways. I would prefer we use the latin terms to discribe what woods we are talking about... but I have enough trouble with english.

So mine is Ohio black Cherry..:)

I love the stuff!!

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#11

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Cherry or at least English Cherry can prove to be a bit difficult when thin but I think that is applicable to many woods.

The Cherry I have used in the past held its edge AND bounced quite well without chipping!

The more Cherry the better in my book!

None of the pieces shown are much more that 6 inches long and are obviously turned end for end with branchwood.

Regards, Peter.


img

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#12

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

Carole Valentine

>Mike, I use our wild black cherry a lot and it is my favorite. Almost all of my utility bowls that I actually USE are from cherry and they take a beating. I turn boxes and hollow forms and other things from it as well. It is also a good for carving, IMHO. As for brittleness, I don't feel that it is any more so than a lot of the other woods we turn. I had a cherry HF ripped out of my hands when I was buffing and thrown with much force onto the concrete floor in my old shop. No cracks or chips - just a nice dent where it hit the bed of the buffing lathe on the way down. If you drop any piece and it hits just right, you can get damage.

Re: Cherry as a turning wood....

#13

Chuck Jones - West TN

Cherry is susceptible to "Wind Shake"

Chuck Jones - West TN

>The brittleness and chipping could very well be from "wind shake" (as Lan mentioned earlier). I have sawed a lot of cherry and have had a couple logs that were virtually useless due to wind shake. A while back I came by a beautiful 12' x 18-20" log that I was sure would be a real winner. I did not salvage a single board from it. At the slightest impact the boards would come apart at the growth rings. It was a sight to see. The old timers call it wind shake and I assume it is caused by, well, being shaken by the wind, but I have not seen a scientific explanation of it.

From my experience it is rare, but happens. I have a couple thousand board feet of cherry stockpiled and a considerable number of turning blanks. I love it, both for furniture and for turning.