Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

lathe tool sharpening

Posts

lathe tool sharpening

#1

lathe tool sharpening

paul waddle

>Any one out there "flat" sharpening lathe tools? If so,what type of belt sander/grinder are you using. And one last question,does anyone use the side of the grinding wheel to sharpen skews-what angle?

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#2

Re: lathe tool sharpening

john lucas

>It's not safe to use the side of the wheel to grind. They aren't designed for that. You can do some light grinding but I wouldn't put any force on it at all.

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#3

Re: lathe tool sharpening

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I have always sharpened my chisels, knives, plane irons on my stationary 6" X 48" belt sander, followed by hand honing on a sheet of 320 grit wet dry sandpaper laid flat on the table of my UniSaw. I will really hone it on a piece of glass with a lubricant.Sharp enough to shave with.

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#4

JL

Re: lathe tool sharpening

JL

>I use waterstones on my skews. I did do a concave on them first with my Tormek.

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#5

Re: lathe tool sharpening

Greg Haugen

>Paul, the only thing I "sharpen" on the side of the grinding wheel is a pencil. Hey, it works great.

As far as "flat grinding" skews, I don't. The main reason is it would make "honing" a lot more difficult. By having the "concave" (there's another term for it but it's escaped me at the moment) honing is much easier because only the edge and the heel of the grind are getting honed, the two main parts. I don't care if the middle is, I want the edge to be ultra sharp and the heel to be "softened" so it doesn't bruise the fibers. With that said though, skews like ovals, etc. I think are best done either on a tormek system or simply on flat stones. There's not enough mass there to have a decent amount of bevel and then concave it on a 8" grinder. For things like that I think "flat" is the only way to go and by only using water stones/hones it's a different process than a grinder and diamond hone. As far as gouges, I don't know if there would be a big difference. I know Sorby came out with the belt system that is very expensive. It obviously works though.

Just my two cents.

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#6

Steven Antonucci

Echoing John Lucas' point

steve antonucci

>Side of wheel= bad idea! (weakens the wheel and increases the chance of catastrophic failure)

Before I owned a Tormek (also known as the Dark Time), I used a belt sander held in my bench vise. Does it work? Sure, it'll remove as much metal as you want, probably even more.

I used "used" belts. Once they have been used on metal, I wouldn't use them on wood again. A 220 belt is pretty fine for grinding, but getting consistent results is difficult because you are freehanding everything.

If you are a new turner, you probably will stay a new turner using this approach. Your tools will always be shaped wrong, and nowhere near as sharp as they could be. If you want to save yourself a bunch of headache, buy something that is purpose made for sharpening lathe tools and never look back.

Steven

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#7

Re: lathe tool sharpening

Al Neighbors

>Paul, I use a 6x48 belt sander, with a 120 Grit belt, that I modified for sharpening lathe tools. I turned the belt vertical, and remounted the motor so the belt would travel "up". I sharpen all my spindle gouges, v-points, three-point, and skews on it. Plus all my hand chisels.

I mounted a "table" at the front, with holes drilled at appropriat distances, with a vee block, to keep the bevels constant.

Technically, the bevels are not really "constant", because as you sharpen the bevel, you are very, very, gradually, changing the bevel. But I've used it this way for a couple of years, and only recently changed the position for one of my skews and one spindle gouge.


img

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#8

Re: lathe tool sharpening

Doug Black

>The Jool Tool will allow you to flat sharpen a skew, polish it to a fine shine. We had a demonstrator use one of our shop skews to show the process, in the end it looked like a piece of jewellery! It will also sharpen carving chisels, gouges, knives and scissors easily. Not cheap but really easy to use.

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#9

Re: lathe tool sharpening

paul waddle

>Thks Steve,I can see your point when using the stone. The concavity makes things easier. I doubt if a flat skew will prevent anymore caches for me,but I have to try SOMETHING! I believe a lot of turners have disdain for absolute sharpness,they like the burr. I may forget about this,or I may look into the knife makers tools.pw

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#10

Re: lathe tool sharpening

paul waddle

>I like that set up Al. You've got two sanders,how many lathes? ha ha.Good idee about running sander upwards or is it (backwards)_better post a sign tho,somebody might be "helping" you and get a surprize..pw

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#11

Re: Side grinding wheel

GalenV in Iowa

>John

I had a side grinding wheel for a long time that was used with my drill bit sharpener. Think it was maybe called type 6.

In learning how to grind my lathe tools this past year I was surprised to see nobody was using this type wheel but instead a belt sander if they wanted flat face. I did see a few using the side of a type 1 wheel and I admit to doing light grinding there now too.

Me and the skew are still having battles. I do fine (95%)on practice but when I need it I screw up (100%). Guess more time needed.

I have an oval skew and when I have used a friends conventional rectagular I seem to do better. Trying to decide if I learn to master the oval or go buy a rectagular. Not sure why I read the oval skew is better for the beginner.

Got any suggestion which way I go, change skew or just more practice with oval?

Galen

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#12

1"x 42" belt sander...with limitations

Steven Kubien

>Hey Paul,

My gouges all get done on a 1x42 belt sander with the belt moving upwards. I use the unit Lee Valley sells because I got it dirt cheap and had a motor kicking around. I rigged up an arm with a sliding block so I could use a Vari-Grind holder-thingy. It works nice for gouges. Scrapers are done by putting the table nice and close to the belt. Easy. Skews on the other hand.....

The design of the table that comes with this unit is no good for skews. In order to angle it high enough, the platform winds up too far from the belt and the tool edge ends up unsupported by the platten behind the belt. So, I sharpen in waterstones or a diamond stone. PITA! Soon, I will be investing in an actual grinder so I can get a nice hollow-grind and honing will be a snap.

Using the side of a grinding wheel? Not in my shop.

Steve

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#14

Re: lathe tool sharpening

Ed Wujciak

>I've been using an 80's vintage 1"x42" sander grinder for years. When I started turning, it was all I had, so I used it, mostly badly. Since then, I've actually figured out how to use it and get good results. Also I have no room for a grinder and I'm too cheap to replace something that actually works fine. I made an adjustable rig to hold a Wolverine for gouges and a jig to hold a skew. At this point, I'm totally satisfied with the results, though it takes a little longer than I like to go from setup to setup. Oh well, it's a hobby and I'm in no big hurry. I use 120 to 180 belts (the blue ones are best). I can't compare to using a regular grinder because I've never owned one. One advantage of my rig is that, since it's a belt against a platen, it's always in the same place. No angle changes due to a shrinking wheel. No wheel dressing either. Works for me.

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#15

Ed, could post...

Steven Kubien

>...a picture of the jig you made up for skews and how it relates to the unit itself?

Thanks!

Steve Kubien

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#16

Re: 1"x 42" belt sander...with limitations

Ed in Leaside

>Odd ... I have grinders but sharpen my skews on a Veil sander. Maybe you should attend the next "Lunch in Leaside". :)

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#17

Lunch in Leaside...

Steven Kubien

>Ed, you know I would but it always seems like when these events I scheduled, I am already slotted to have little Japanese men beat the sh*t outta me. I know I have been saying this for a while but I will have to just come by your place some time during the week....

Steve

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#18

Re: 1"x 42" belt sander...with limitations

Tom Johnson OH

>Steve,

I also have the Lee Valley sharpener running in reverse. Could you please post pictures or elaborate on your holder for the vari-grind? Thanks.

Tom

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#19

Here you go

Steven Kubien

>The two stacked washers are expoxied on to give the arm a place to be sit. In front of that is a recessed 1/4 x 20 bolt used to lock the block in place...or allow you to move it. The aluminum track is now held by a few wood screws, not a holdfast.

HTH


img

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#20

another view 

Steven Kubien

>


img

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#21

Re: Ed, could post...

Ed Wujciak

>the short answer is....probably not. I have no camera and, in a word, I'm kind of an analog guy in a digital world. What I did was fabricate a carrier based on an idea I "borrowed" from a picture posted a few months ago by John Lucas (thanks John) on this forum. It slides left and right on a toolrest and holds the skew at the "skewed" angle against a block on the right and the left (so you can grind both sides of the tool). You have to adapt the idea to work with whatever toolrest you have on your grinder. Perhaps John could chime in and link to the picture he posted. It was a kind of an "aha" moment for me. Good Luck

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#22

Two ... OW1640; VL100

Al Neighbors

>

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#23

12" disc sander...

Michael Stafford

>I have a Shopsmith that still serves me as a drill press. When it is in the horizontal mode I used to attach the 12" disc on the headstock end of the power unit and with a Shopsmith jig mounted to an auxiliary table sharpened all my lathe tools. I continued to use this jig and method for my skew chisels even after I bought the Wolverine system. The flat disc did a commendable job but it sure was expensive as the silicon carbide discs rated for metal were not cheap and did not last long. Of course the Shopsmith jig was also best suited for Shopsmith tools.

All of that seems long ago and far away now. I think the Wolverine system is the main reason I am able to turn. If I had continued using the Shopsmith tools and sharpening I do not believe I would have ever progressed beyond the bumpy stick and coaster stage.

I am sure there are wonderful systems out there that use flat discs or belts to sharpen but I have no experience with them.

And, as so many others have said, Do Not Sharpen on The Side of a Grinding Wheel!!! When it breaks and flies apart it is worse than a grenade.

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#24

My skew jig for the Wolverine

john lucas

>If you have a tool rest or can fabricate one for the belt sander this jig I made would work fine. I milled a a slot in the tool rest so that a metal bar in the bottom of the jig would have a place to ride. You could just as easily put a lip on the front edge of your jig to ride on the front of the tool rest.

Then it's just a matter of making the angle for the angle you want on your skew. It won't work for a curve skew edge but I prefer mine flat anyway.

The new Sorby belt sharpening system uses a tool rest jig that is similar to this. There belt tilts back at an angle which makes using it for skews and chisels easier.


img

Re: lathe tool sharpening

#25

Re: My skew jig for the Wolverine

Ed Wujciak

>There you go, Steve. that's the one. Thanks John for your (frighteningly) quick response.