Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Thread Chasing

Posts

Thread Chasing

#1

Thread Chasing

Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville

>I am seriously considering thread chasing tools. These would be used primarily with lidded boxes and some small urns. But, and this is my problem, the tools are offered in 10, 16 and 20 threads per inch. Is there a best size? I seem to recall reading that with 20 TPI the threading job was easier. Is one size more useful in softer woods?

Lots of questions and I hope some of the usual good answers,

Harry

Re: Thread Chasing

#2

Re: Thread Chasing

john lucas

>Harry I read the same thing and I am going to learn thread chasing this month. I think mine are 16tpi but I'll have to look. I bought them on a sale about a year or more ago. My understanding is that hand chasing is very difficult or impossible in soft woods. That's why I bought the Baxter threader which uses a powered cutter.

I'll write up my thought on hand chasing later in February when I feel like I have it down. I'll be interested in what you learn as well.

Re: Thread Chasing

#3

Fred Holder's book

John K Jordan

>In his book "Making Screw Threads in Wood", Fred Holder has an excellent section on his experiences with learning to chase threads and what he discovered about different types of wood and how to work with some marginal woods. This book covers other ways to thread and I consider it well worth having on the shelf.

From all my reading, the 16 TPI seems to the the most commonly used.

We watched Mike Mahoney chase threads last week - it's so helpful to watch the action.

JKJ

Re: Thread Chasing

#4

Re: Thread Chasing

Greg Haugen

>Harry,

Allan Batty's DVD is also an excellent resource. As already mentioned, Fred Holder's book is very good.

There are several "school of thoughts" on threading. Some prefer the coarser threads since they're more pronounced but the do require a faster movement since they "cover more ground per rotation" than say a 20 tpi. Which is where they come in, 20 tpi are also common since they have a slower rate of movement and are fine enough to hide in most any piece without being over powering. A 12 TPI would be pretty big on a small delicate box, per say. Some prefer a "sharp pointed" tooth tool or a "rounded" tooth tool, it's PP (personal preference). As long as I'm talking about tools, they can be purchased or made with good quality bolts. Mark St. Leger (markstleger.com) has a double ended set that he makes that comes with a handle and sharpened ready to go. I've heard very good things about them.

As far as the wood, close grain, fairly dense is preferred. "Boxwood" has been mentioned as THE wood to thread. The only source I've found that has it regularly, and even a couple of different species, is Mitch at Exotic Hardwoods of Latin America. It's not cheap, often used as a collar on another turned piece, so practice the technique on something else. I've used Kiln Dried hard maple to practice on-it's not the greatest but it works and easily obtained.

Hope this helps as a "starter".

Good Luck.

Greg H.

Re: Thread Chasing

#5

Re: Thread Chasing

john lucas

>Greg it might have been you but I remember someone saying that PVC was good to practice on. Since I have lots of that I'm going to give it a try anyway. It's certainly cheap enough. I also have some boxwood and Osage that I've been saving just for this project. I will of course use some softer woods once I get the technique down just to see what I can get away with.

Re: Thread Chasing

#6

Re: Thread Chasing

Greg Haugen

>It wasn't me about the PVC but it sounds like it would work and like you said, it's cheap enough. Osage orange is another good threader.

Have fun.

Greg H.

Re: Thread Chasing

#7

Steven Antonucci

my experience

steve antonucci

>Chasing threads isn't very difficult if you have everything you need AND have seen it done before!

The most critical thing that you need is a lathe that can be run very, very slowly. Slower the better! If your minimum speed is 500 rpm, don't waste your money.

Like anything in turning, it's a matter of seeing it done right, and then being able to do it yourself. Practice on some non critical pieces before you try to thread something important.

Steve

Re: Thread Chasing

#8

Re: Thread Chasing

Rich Egan

>I've had some luck threading bubinga. You need something hard and almost grainless, like PVC. Softer materials cause the top points of the thread to crumble off. Coarser threads are also deeper, and more likely to break off. Get a 16 or 20 tpi set and start there. Fred Holder has a good formula for dimensions.

Re: Thread Chasing

#9

Re: Thread Chasing

Bob Macgregor

>I saw a video online a few months ago, but couldn't seem to find it again now. This one shows some chasing, though:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jslgNh5b-S8

Re: Thread Chasing

#10

Re: Thread Chasing *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Since my book, Making Screw Threads in Wood, has been quoted a bit, I guess I better post to this thread. To learn to chase threads, you need two things: a good set of thread chasers and wood of the proper hardness. I suspect that the person who recommended using PVC to learn to chase threads was me, because I highly recommend it for learning to use the tools.

For wood, you need a hard, dense wood like boxwood, African Blackwood, and some of the South American rosewoods. However, if you mount the wood so that the grain runs perpendicular to the axis of rotation, it is possible to hand chase threads in the softer woods. I've hand chased 16 tpi threads in soft white pine with the grain oriented so that there is some side grain and some end grain in the threaded area.

I own many different thread chasers and can cut threads with all of them, but for some reason the Ray Iles Chasers sold by "Tools For Working Wood" in Brooklyn seem to work better than all of the rest. They are available in 16 tpi, which incidentally, is the normal thread to use for threaded boxes.

I hope this little bit helps. You can contact me direct on specific questions related to hand thread chasing or making the Chinese Ball.


More Woodturning Website

Re: Thread Chasing

#11

Thanks Fred-I have your book and it's great

john lucas

>

Re: Thread Chasing

#12

Rob Wallace

Re: Thread Chasing - TRY CORIAN...

Rob Wallace

>Our last turners meeting (on Jan 25th) was on thread chasing and use of the Baxter Threading jig. Fresh in memory information, and experiences.....

The members of our group with the most threading experience showed us that to learn and practice threading, few things are better than Corian (or other solid surface material). Small pieces can be glued to inexpensive wood blocks, turned round, and then the male & female threads cut very easily.

Off-cuts or sink cut-out pieces of Corian can often be found either free or for a few dollars at a counter top manufacturing or installer's businesses. This material will provide many, many opportunities to practice threading. It's often also offered on eBay, but this acquisition route is likely pretty expensive for practice stock. Additionally, threaded inserts of Corian can be glued-into recesses in vessels, urns, etc. and function superbly as the threaded portion for lids, finials, etc.

One helpful aspect of hand threading technique is to have a lathe that will slow don to between 100 and 300 rpm - many lathes bottom-out at 500 rpm, which makes chasing pretty difficult to learn at this speed. Slower speeds work better....

Cheers,

Rob Wallace

Re: Thread Chasing

#13

Re: Thread Chasing

Paul Waddle

>Hi John,hope you don't mind as I'm always asking you something. It may seem over simplistic,but why not turn the lathe over by hand and use the threader,maybe a wedge thingy like when you broach slot inside a hollow. . It seems necessary to get the threader started perpindicular and neek up on the threads thata way. ha ha.pw.

Re: Thread Chasing

#14

Peter Lamb, in SC

Re: Thanks Fred-I have your book and it's great

Peter Lamb, in SC

>Mark St.Leger has 16tpi chasers and he is also very helpful to beginners

Re: Thread Chasing

#15

Re: Thread Chasing

JohnKyler

>18-20 is likely better to try first.

I can say I'm visual and liked Allan Batty's DVD on the subject I picked up from Crafts Supply.

Secondly, Allan's class was also good.

Hands on and muscle memory is key in threading.

I need to go out and practice again.

John

Re: Thread Chasing

#16

Re: Thread Chasing

Paul Waddle

>Hmmm,I wonder if one could use the captured hollow form boring set up-probably the elbo type to help with threading. Use a couple of hose clamps to secure the thread tool to the boring bar and just commence and see if practical. I wish I had an elbo hf boring tool like the Mini O . Perhaps one of you who are predisposed to R&D could report... pw.

Re: Thread Chasing

#17

Re: Thread Chasing *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I think that I mentioned it in my book, if not, anyone have a copy of the June 1997 issue of Woodturning Magazine (the GMC Publication). I had an article in that issue telling how I turned my Carba-Tec lathe with my left hand while I chased threads with my right hand. At that time, all of my lathes, except the foot powered one, had minimum speeds of 500 RPM. I then tried thread chasing on my foot powered spring pole lathe and discovered it was even easier. Then I went back to the Carba-Tec with it's 500 RPM and discovered that I could chase threads on it too. So practice helps!!!

I normally chase threads at 350 to 400 rpm for 16 tpi theads. When I was in New Zealand in 2003 I was demonstrating thread chasing at one of the clubs. The wood I was using would only hold threads of 8 tpi threads, which incidentally the softer the wood the coarser the threads need to be to stand up. They brought out a lathe with 650 rpm. I said, "Wow fellows, I don't know if I can chase threads at that speed, but I'll give it a try." It turned out to be one of the best demonstrations I've ever done. Soren Berger came up to me and said, "I've had a set of chasers for 10 years and haven't had the nerve to give them a try. I'm going to go home and see what I can do." The next time I saw Soren he was demonstrating hand thread chasing.

To give it a try, I've chased threads successfully at 1,000 rpm, but do not recommend it because things happen awfully quickly.


More Woodturning Website

Re: Thread Chasing

#18

Re: Thread Chasing

Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville

>Thanks to all of you for the information. I have ordered Fred Holders book. I have the DVD where Mike Mahoney chases threads in an urn and our club has the video of Alan Batty chasing threads. I'll try to borrow it at the next meeting. So, right now, I'll keep my money in my wallet until I get a little more information. Thanks again!