Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Stuck bottle stoppers

Posts

Stuck bottle stoppers

#1

Stuck bottle stoppers

Ponch

>I recently turned my first set of stoppers. They came out great, but got to tight on the mandrel. I had a real time trying to unscrew them from the mandrel once they were finished. I even tried a little oil in the drilled hole before screwing them on the mandrel. Any Ideas of what I am doing wrong?

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#2

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I am assuming the mandrel that they have gotten too tight on is threaded. Sometimes I have a similar problem. I just grab the stopper with a piece of 600 grit sand paper in order to get a better grip. I do this when my lathe is turned down to a very slow speed in reverse. I have been able to get it off every time. The combined torque of my hand and the lathe gives me extra power.

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#3

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Jim Stoppleworth

>Thanks for the neat idea Barbara. The stopper too tight to easily remove off my screw chuck happens many times. The best luck I've had to date was to use a rubber gripper tool(and at best that was hit and miss.) Although that might work with the lathe on at very slow speed.

Stoppy

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#4

Steven Antonucci

Like that idea too...

steve antonucci

>My lathe doesn't reverse though...

I have been told that I have a pretty good grip, so I haven't really had this issue. I do recall having a tough time unthreading them, so I started tapping the stopper blanks with a handheld tap before threading them on, and that really wored wonders...

Steve

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#5

Rubber Glove

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Barbara,

I like that idea!

I tend to use a rubber glove and that gives me the grip I need to twist a stubborn bottle stopper right off the mandrel. I got that idea from those floppy rubber disks they used to sell that would help you open a stubborn screw top jar.

Dominic

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#6

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Stop by your local medical clinic and ask them for a couple of used latex bands that they use for drawing blood. My brother, the paramedic, put me onto these. Just wrap one around anything you need to unscrew and you have instant grip (works great on lids)

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#7

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Ponch

>Great ideas Thanks Ponch

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#8

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Barry Irby

>I have used one of those strap wrenches like you use on a oil filter.

You might try making a washer out of a milk jug to prevent this.

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#9

Miniature jar wrench....

Michael Stafford

>Sears makes a set of rubber jar wrenches. I keep them in the shop just for this purpose. The smaller one will work to remove your stopper from the mandrel without marring the finish. Works great!!!

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#10

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Texian

>After getting them off the mandrel, did you have any trouble screwing them onto the stoppers? Seems like oil might cause the wood to swell, making removal more difficult, but maybe not.

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#11

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Barry Turner

>For getting a turned stopper off the mandrel, use one of the rubber strap wrenches like they use on oil filters. For preventing this in the future, try drilling a slightly larger hole. Drill bits are available in 1/64th inch increments. You may have to vary the hole size a bit depending on the hardness of the wood you are using. Candle wax on the threads of the mandrel before screwing on the blank can also help.

If you want to fix this problem once and for all, drill and thread the hole in the blank first. You can buy a tap (3/8"-16, I believe) and matching drill bit at Lowe's. You also need a tap handle. I haven't had a stuck stopper since I started threading the holes in the blanks.

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Miniature jar wrench....

Dick Hines

>I have been useing some rubber shelf material. You can get it at grocery stores. Works when you need to return a small bowl too. Just put a couple of layers over your chuck and run up the tail stock.

I know a guy who ues a tap threader in his stoppers before they are put on the mandrel. This cuts the treads before you screw the blank onto the threads.

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#13

Roger in MO

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

Roger in MO

>My mandrel (3/8 bolt minus the head) has enough thread length that I can place a 3/8 nut on it before inserting it in the wood block. I tighten the block against the nut before turning. When complete I can use a wrench on the nut to loosen it. I also tap the hole in the block. Roger in MO

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#14

The pros and cons of taps

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I'm another recent bottle-stopper neophyte. Since the wood I was using (blackwood) was very dense and brittle, I was afraid that the bolt itself would split the blank, even with a poor-man's-tap grind across the threads, so I tapped holes in the blanks. If anything, the tapped holes are too loose. Plus, if you are starting with a rough or dense blank, the forces of roughing the blank can be enough to strip the threads since the tap has removed the material between them.

It's a balancing act, and I imagine it differs with the density and toughness of your wood.

Ellis

Re: Stuck bottle stoppers

#15

tapless

John K Jordan

>I turn stoppers a way that does not require gripping tightly by thread or mandrel. (picture below, posted before)

I hold the wood tightly in the chuck to drill and turn the bottom end and shape and finish the outside or most of the outside. Then if needed, I reverse and jam onto a small dowel-like tenon turned on a waste block to shape and finish the very top. This requires little gripping to hold the piece.

In the case illustrated, even reversing was unnecessary since I could finish the top by hand.

JKJ


img