Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Posts

Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#1

Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Chris Andrew

>I'm curious to hear from those of you that turn bottle stoppers if you have received any feedback regarding the finish on the wood and how well it does (or doesn't) hold up to handling.

What kind of finishes do you use/recommend? How does it hold up after being put in a refrigerator where it's likely to become moist from condensation?

It's relatively easy to get a beautiful finish on these but it doesn't take much moisture before that finish is dull and unappealing. I'd just like to hear from those people how much of a problem this is...or isn't. Maybe there is a finish that stands up to this use. On the other hand, maybe most people just ignore it. If so, do you ever get complaints about it.

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#2

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

John K Jordan

>I asked that question a year or so ago. One person said to just buff the bare wood. Someone else used lacquer. I didn't hear how these worked in the long-term.

Today I looked at one I made from Ebony I gave as a present last year which has gotten some use. I buffed the wood, no finish. It was still shiny today.

A demonstrator at our club who makes and sells stoppers said he sticks to a CA glue finish, applied while the piece is slowly turning with a tuft of manmade fibers held in hemostats.

JKJ

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#3

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

john lucas

>Because of where I sell my stoppers I get no feedback. I do get to look at the ones I have given as gifts. Hut finishes and plain wax don't hold up well. Lacquer has worked best for me. I haven't tried the CA.

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#4

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Tommy Holmes

>I quit using friction wax on small pieces after I had some get wet and ruined the finish on them. I've using lacquer now. It's only been a few months so I don't know how it will hold up in the long term. I like the the look of the lacquer finish better than the friction wax anyway.

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#5

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Carole Valentine

>I have just used Waterlox wiped dry and then buffed after it's cured. I have no idea how it holds up over the long term, but the one I have used for a year seems fine. I had a couple of bare wood ones and they got ignored. People seem to prefer the oiled ones - probably because the oil pops the grain. Wouldn't lacquer would be a bad choice for a wine stopper since alcohol is the solvent for lacquer?

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#6

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Skip Beardsley------WebKitFormBoundaryo2PSwy+o0IUR

>I have used friction polish in the past and now use nitrocellulose sanding sealer and something like Deft.

I have a couple here at the house which are at least three years old and they look like new.

One of the secrets to keeping the finish on the stoppers is to drink the wine fast enough so the bottle and stopper don't sit in the fridge too long.

BTW the solvent for lacquer is lacquer thinner or acetone not alcohol. Alcohol is the solvent for shellac.

One of the things I do now, which I like, is to put the sanding sealer on quite liberally and they put the wet rag on the piece with the speed turned up to about 2500 rpm and hold it there until the rag dries. Produces a nice smooth surface for the final coat.

Skip

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#7

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Carole Valentine

>Right about the shellac...I got that straight in my head after I hit the post button. Duh. Time to go to bed!

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#8

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I only use an oil finish (usually 2 coats) then buff. The final buff is with a microcrystaline wax. I never have used one in the refrigerator as red wine is my choice. The stoppers I have used for years look good and I have not had any negative feed back.

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#9

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Brian George

>I've been selling in craft shows and have nothing to follow-up on, but I use a gel polyurethane wiped on while the stopper is on the lathe. Everyone of my sales are unconditionally guaranteed with my business card included. I have not had any come back at all for the last year.

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#10

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Barry Turner

>I use Crystal Coat, which is a friction polish containing wax/shellac. It seems to hold up pretty well, but I'm not sure many of my customers actually use these things.

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#11

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

Ed Davidson (Colorado Springs)

>Wood is good but plastic is fantastic...no finish worries, ever.


img

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#12

Nice!

Chris Andrew

>Ed,

These stoppers are really nice! I envy your lack of worries about the finish holding up. Excellent work.

Chris

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

#13

Re: Bottle Stoppers - finish & feedback

John K Jordan

>The problem with shellac is it dissolves in alcohol which seems risky around bottle stoppers. Does crystal coat hold up if you drip wine on it?

JKJ