Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

Posts

Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#1

Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

Barry Turner

>I use a Wolverine Vari-Grind to sharpen bowl gouges with the Ellsworth grind. There is one aspect I have never been clear on. When instructions call for the arm to be positioned at "notch 3", is it the top edge or the bottom edge of the arm that is the reference point? I know this is an elementary question, but I would appreciate an answer. Thanks.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#2

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question *LINK*

Ron McKinley

>Here's the best answer I know. Download this PDF file.


Vari-Grind Sharpening

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#3

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

john lucas

>Barry If your getting the shape on the edge that you want then that is all that matters. I have a bunch of bowl gouges and they all have a slightly different grind. I have not moved my Wolverine jig since I first set it. I don't even know what that is, probably somewhere around the mark you are asking about. Each gouge is different because of the flute shape and depth. The side grinds come out differently.

If you change the nose angle it will also change the side grinds. There isn't a perfect grind. Mostly people use whatever grind they have somewhat copied from others. Until you turn a lot and regrind your gouge to a certain shape for a certain reason it is best to just stick with what comes out.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#4

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

Jim Pugh, Elyria, OH

>Hi Bary, looks like I'm the only one who is going to attempt to answer your question. I use the top edge of the leg when alighning with a notch. As others have stated, once you find a grind/position that is working for you, don't change it. On the other hand, if you have a grind you want to use for a specific situation and the leg isn't in line with a notch, use a scribe to make a mark up on the fan shaped part of the jig. That way when you move the leg to your 3rd notch normal position but want to come back to that 'special' position at a later date, you know exactly where it is.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#5

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question *LINK*

John Weeks

>There is a good video on the Oneway website.


Vari-grind instructional video download

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#6

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

John K Jordan

>Barry,

The jig won't pivot enough to use the bottom edge for all notches so it only makes sense to line up the top edge of the arm with the flat of the notch.

The "notch" on the Wolverine and the number on the Tormek affect the shape of the wings, of course. If you are grinding a new profile to someone's instructions, you will find an extremely slight difference between using the bottom, the edge, or even the next notch over.

If I am trying to match the profile exactly for some reason, I'll set the extension distance, adjust the support until the existing bevel at the center kisses the stone, then rotate the jig to the side and check the wings. If the wings don't meet the stone properly, I'll change the angle of the jig a bit and try again. BTW, seldom discussed is the huge difference in profile you get depending on how much you grind on the sides vs the tip - regardless of the jig setting!

But as mentioned, only big changes make a big difference. I don't worry too much about the exact profile unless I'm using the Tormek since duplicating the exact profile makes sharpening very quick.

FYI, this page from the Tormek manual illustrates the effect of using steeper angles on the jig, or for the Tormek, higher numbers. The Tormek #5 corresponds roughly with the setting Thompson uses as shown in the link someone provided.

JKJ


img

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#7

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

john lucas

>After I found the position I wanted I drilled a 1/8" hole through both pieces. Then to realign them exactly all I have to do is align this hole or I could even insert a 1/8" drill bit if I want super precise.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#8

Yea, John!

Allen Neighbors

>I did the same, after you posted this information once before. Glad you mentioned it again; I was going to, 'til I read your post. Best idea I've heard!!

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#9

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

david

>Ron's link to Mike Hunter's photo of the Vari-grind is a good idea. Don't know what the angle is, but he recommends the tool shaft extended 1-3/4" from the holder. Kirk DeHeer, in an article in the AAW Journal, winter '06, has some recommendations I have referred many to. He advocates setting the Vari-grind at a certain angle and explains how to make templates to set the V-notch a certain distance from the wheel. He recommends a 2" extension from the holder. If you are interested in the article and can't find it in back issues, email me off line and I can send you a copy.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#10

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

Steve Worcester

>Drilling the hole is like a photograph, it captures that position at that moment. As soon as a variable changes, so do the angles. The most common variable is the diameter of the grinding wheel.

The varigrind however will not exactly replicate Davids grind because it doesn't put the gouge at the same place on the wheel as Davids own jig. You actually need to put a spacer in the pocket to lift the jig up. That said, take a known good grind, use a 2" stickout, and use a sharpee on the gouges face and slowly move the grinding wheel by hand and adjust the jigs angles and the pockets distance in and out, until it will remove the sharpee marks. Will take some practice, but it will get it damn close

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#11

geometry

John K Jordan

>>As soon as a variable changes, so do the angles. The most common variable is the diameter of the grinding wheel.

My understanding differs. Since the bevel is always aligned with the grinding wheel surface (using the Sharpie method), given the same extension distance, the shape of the grind at the tip and wings will be the same for all diameters of the grinding wheel - the only difference will be in the concavity of the bevel, more concave for a smaller wheel.

>You actually need to put a spacer in the pocket to lift the jig up.

As long as the existing bevel is aligned with the grinding wheel surface, changing the position of the pivot in space only moves the contact point to a different spot on the wheel. To change the geometry of the jig, the pivot arm length would have to be changed - adding a spacer would simply move the pivot point to a new point in space, changing nothing in the geometry.

The critical variables for this type of jig appear to be the extension length, the jig angle, and the length of the pivot arm (fixed for each jig I've seen except for the Tormek). A bigger and less controllable variable, of course, is how much you grind on the wings vs the tip.

JKJ


img

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#12

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

john lucas

>I have wooden jigs that I set the distance of the Oneway V to the stone. This way no matter how small the stone gets I get the same grind.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#13

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

Barry Turner

>I bought a Crown PM 5/8" gouge with the Ellsworth grind and played with the vari-grind setting until I could duplicate this factory grind very closely.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#14

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

Barry Turner

>Thank you very much. How dare you be so presumptious? Just joking. Actually, I was aligning the bottom of the leg with the notch and just felt this was probably wrong. Thanks again.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#15

Re: geometry

Gordon Seto

>The wheel is round, the tool bevel is always tangent to the wheel.

The reason why the Ellsworth jig has to be raised is the jig is a rectangular block. If you don't raise it up the bottom of the block will have no clearance and hitting the wheel guard. The front bottom of the Varigrind is missing.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#16

Set leg at 23 degrees works well *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>American Woodturner (AAW Journal) Winter 2006 Vol 21, No.4 "Sharpening" by Kirk DeHeer is a thoughtful, thorough, description by an experienced teacher. He concluded that good hand grinds give an approximately equal included angle all the way around. With experimentation he found that setting the Wolverine arm at 23 degrees did the trick. He welded it at that angle! This has worked well for me on all my gouges for the last several years. The link shows a nice YouTube video on grinding with this approach, and also using Kirk's storyboard to maintain a precise angle in the face of a shrinking grinding wheel.


Sharpening per Kirk DeHeer

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#17

Re: Set leg at 23 degrees works well

Gordon Seto

>I think that is over simplified. The flute shape has not been put into consideration. We can't get the same grind with a U & V bowl gouge with identical jig setting.

The leg angle determines the length of the side grind. Some like them short like the traditional grind; and some prefer a long side grind. We all get used to our own grind.

Having the jig fixed at a certain angle has great merit in a class setting. The instructor can concentrate more on teaching. If the class is furnishing the turning tools, it would save a lot of steel if students are not changing the grind constantly.

All the signature grinds from the famous turners are not the same. What works for them is not their grind alone.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#18

Kirk says leg angle determines

Jerry Hall

>included angle, not length of side grind. Surprising to me, but I think in my experience it is true. A V flute no doubt will have a more widely varying included angle. I think it is a good thing for us to seek an included angle with minimum variation along the edge, so the feel of the tool is more consistent as you utilize different portions of the edge. As you say we can learn to cut with most anything. But this might be a good starting point, especially as you say in a class.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#19

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

Eric Knutsen

>Barry,

Are you using the Wolverine Jig or did you get Ellsworth's shapening jig? If you did, even that has to be manipulated slightly in the cradle to achieve the correct grind. I have the jig and spoke to Ellsworth about it. He said you can get a grind very close to his but not perfect, from the Wolverine jig. Just an FYI.

Re: Wolverine Vari-Grind Question

#20

Re: Kirk says leg angle determines

Gordon Seto

>If you look at the drawing (from Tormek manual)that John K Jordan posted, the principle is similar for Varigrind. When the leg is locked at almost parallel to the tool (JS 0), the nose angle can vary but the side grind are all very short. The nose angle can be obtained by varying the distance of the jig to the wheel. Similarly when the leg is set at the other extreme, almost perpendicular to the tool shaft (JS 6), you can also get varying nose angle, but the side grind will be very long.

My conclusion is, no matter at what jig leg angle setting, we can get all the nose angle we want by sliding the jig in and out.

If you lock down the leg setting to one position, you eliminated one variable. You can only get the grind in a horizontal row from the drawing.

I believe the AAW sharpening dvd also said the leg sets the nose angle which I don't agree. But who cares? It is just theory.

Bill Grumbine had a bowl gouge clinic at our Club. Club members brought their problem gouges for him to tweak. He didn't even measure the stick out; he hardly changed any angle. I was surprised some of our Club members didn't know how a grind should be, when to stop grinding, and where to grind more. It was the shape of the grind more important than the actual measurement. Afterward he let members tried their newly shaped gouges on a bowl blank before leaving.

As long as we have our own jig setting, what the jig does is mainly repeating the same grind without wasting a lot of steel.