Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

Posts

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#26

Re: Invasion Forces??

davidwalser

>My son's "greatest fear" is that Canada will invade the US. He claims that, if Canadians would just quit obeying the treaty requirement that they end every sentence with "eh", they could easily sneak their entire army across the border and we could not tell them apart from US citizens.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#27

NAFTA

Ralph

>Doug

My recall, backed up by a 30 second web search, is that NAFTA makes enforcing a US Patent in Canada, well, much easier.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#28

A Centralien invasion of Canada?....

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca

>Hmmm, that has a nice ring to it, and the bastard (can I say this here?) sure merits it. But, as we've learned, those invasions can get real pricey in a hurry. And...they don't pan out.

I'm thinking just choke that sucker in the market place to the point he'll have to give his freaking copies away. I mean totally free. But there STILL won't be any takers.

Like Bill says WE are going to have to be the ones that help Ruth out.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#29

Keith Tompkins

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles pl

keith tompkins

>Russ, I have several patents. The last one cost me over $15,000 in initial fees, then there are maintenance fees, etc. Just my opinion, but that's the least of it....trying to defend a patent will bankrupt anyone except a major corporation. I've been in the same situation as Ruth.....and couldn't afford to defend my own patent. A US patent, especially a design patent, is all but worthless. It's far cheaper to advertise, and use the guy's own product against him.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#30

You mean on The Plains of Abraham?

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>If the scales tilt the other way that fateful day, we mainers would be Quebequois... sniff...

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#31

Have Bill, Will Travel

John K Jordan

>Bill,

I should have thought of getting you to come visit here a couple of years ago when a lowlife dirtball scumbag was sweet-talking and conning my 80yo sister-in-law with advancing stages of Alzheimer's. He was after her bank accounts and her river-bottom land but ended up stealing only a couple of grand and some guns before I was able to run him off.

I always thought he would straighten up and see the error of his ways and live a good life if simply the right person had a little talk with him.

JKJ

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#32

patent cost, yikes

John K Jordan

>>...several patents. The last one cost me over $15,000

>in initial fees, then there are maintenance fees, etc

Yikes, I knew it was expensive but I didn't think it cost that much. I guess I'm spoiled - all of my patents were paid for by the government Lab I worked for. Of course, the Lab owns the patents and distributes just a pittance in royalties, but hey, can't complain.

As for defending those, the Lab is so big a letter from the legal department would probably do the trick.

JKJ

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#33

Re: patent cost, yikes......not mine

Ruth Niles

>The brothers who own the machine shop that make my stoppers and I got a patent together and it was less than $6,000 which we split the cost. I doubt I'd have a patent if it cost more than that! : O

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#34

contact info *LINK*

John K Jordan

>I see he also sells pens and bottle stoppers. Maybe someone would like to ask him for some corporate or commercial references, then send each a little note. Recognize any in the photo?

Other contact info from the Donald Fontaine woodturning web site:

Donald Fontaine Inc.

914 rue Malo

Mont-Saint-Hilaire, Qc

J3H 1T1

Phone: 450.467.8446

Fax: 450.467.9912

Email: info@donaldfontaine.com

Funny thing - the first google hit I got for 'donald fontaine' was for a lawyer.

JKJ


img

donald fontaine's turning website

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#35

Re: patent cost

arkie

>Unfortunately, you are about to find out that obtaining a patent is the cheapest and easiest part of the process. Defending that patent by prosecuting infringements is a costly and time-consuming thing, yet, if you don't, you may find you have abandoned your hard won patent. Not a lawyer, so ask one before acting on my comments.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#36

Invade Canada? The US? Puuuulease!

Steven Kubien

>All we would have to do if the US decided to cross the border would be to hand them hockey sticks. They would know what to do with them and would just leave, bewildered. (Anyone watch the World Junior Tournament?)

Have fun everyone!

Steve Kubien

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#37

Re: Miscreant's Name

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Bill, if you do decide to invade, let me know. We can turn it into a Multilteral force -- as I am Canadian.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#38

Talk to your patent attorney

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I was involved with a patent defense back when I was working. It was an interesting experience and cost our company a big bit of change. But the offender was a large corporation and the patent was worth a fair amount of money. The damages settlement happened several years after I'd left so I don't know the exact amount, but it has to be in the millions.

Your situation is different. Your patent attorney will know the options and probable success and cost of each.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#39

Re: Have Bill, Will Travel

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>John, over the years I have had a couple people joke around with me about not paying for whatever it was they were buying - bad check and all that. My response has always been that I am fine with that as long as they understood that I was my own collection agency. I couldn't afford a collection agency, so if the check bounced, I would be coming to their house personally.

I have actually had a couple of checks bounce - two in 15 years. One guy made good on it right away with all sorts of apologies, which was a good thing, since he lived in Alberta. The other guy was local, and I told him I was coming to his retail shop. He was literally shaking when I walked in the door. And I didn't even raise my voice. ;-)

I count Ruth as a good friend, and if she needs help, I will be glad to help her out.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#40

Suing is not.........

Ruth Niles

>First, I sincerely want to thank all of you for your support.

I am not looking to sue this hockey puck for money. That's just not me, even if I could afford to do so. I don't know what the guys at the machine shop are going to do though.

Yes, I want to protect my patent but it's only potectable in the USA.

It is illegal for this guy to sell/ship over the border. The Customs people said when we get proof he shipped to the US (which we have a package), it's their jurisdiction and "we will take care of it." Don't know what that means but it scared me!

It's sad when you discover a woodturner who is unethical and a blantant thief. He could have changed the design enough to get around the patent.

A good example is Arizona Silhouette. Bill saw the need for stainless stoppers and designed one that is just good healthy business competition. When a new customer asks if I offer highly polished or longer stoppers, I tell them no, but go to Bill's site, he has what you're looking for.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#41

Re: Suing is not.........

Fred

>Just let us know, Ruth, if you need someone from the US to buy from him so he can get busted.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#42

Steven Antonucci

I thought the same thing

Steve Antonucci

>If he started see a lot of orders from the US, he wouldn't know which ones were "real" and which ones were "setups".

Someone places a large order and alerts customs, order get nabbed, he gets stuck for the materials... he might learn something?

The hard way!

S

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#43

Re:I'm glad to know that you took.....

Jamie D

>... the thankless steps to file for the patent Ruth, and I hope you will be able to resolve this act of theft in a satisfactory manner. I know only too well the process and expenses involved because I spent 5 yrs. in Federal Court prosecuting 3 publishers for willful copyright infringement, and I would never have been able to protect my legal rights without the support of a well known intellectual property attorney who offered to represent me (and my 2 assistants) on a contingency basis. It is unfortunate that the deep pockets often win out over the little guy, or gal, but I was resolved to enforce a principle, and believe that each time we stand up to big money we strike a blow for the little but good people in this world.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#44

The bottom line is...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>What happened is a shame and shouldn't have happened in the first place... what was this guy thinking.

The entire woodturning community is self regulating if you think about it, we don't need courts to decide the fate of a company... we decide. People and companies come and go every year... in time this guy will be gone. A bad apple doesn't seen to last long around here.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#45

Re: The bottom line is...

Jerry in INdy

>Be sure to get the work on the WOW forum so as many people as possible get the word

Maybe we should flood his in box with our comments about his integrity.

Jerry

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#46

Re: A US Patent only protects you in the US

JohnKyler

>Doug,

With your expertise, do you think Ruth might have any chance getting with customs and alerting them as to possible patent/import violations?

Or would Ruth be required to provide shipper and destination information for them to investigate?

Just curious...

And if you don't wish to answer please don't and I understand.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#47

Hockey Puck???

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Nice shot!!

;-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#48

Re: Hockey Puck???

Bob Macgregor

>Given M. Fontaine's address, shouldn't that be "palet"?

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#49

Re: Hockey Puck???

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Maybe, or rondelle....

Mt. Ste. Hilaire is such a pretty place really too, wonderful place to find very rare minerals, it's an igneous intrusion.

Take care,

Jim

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#50

Ric Taylor

Is there a Canadian........

Ric Taylor

>Is there a woodturner hanging around here who is also a Canadian attorney who might at least be able to rattle the low-life's chain?

Ric