Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

Posts

WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#1

WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

Russ Fairfield

>There is a guy in Canada making copies of the Ruth Nilkes bottle stoppers and shipping them into the US. This is a violation of Ruth's patent protection. Ruth is getting neither credit nor royalty from him.

We should all buy the original stainless-steel stoppers from Ruth, and not an imported copy.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#2

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles pl

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Thanks Russ,

I only buy the exported versions from the US that Ruth sells

Take care,

Jim

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#3

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles pl

Ruth Niles

>Thank you, Russ. I just want everyone to know it's not Lionel Bedard, who is selling my design, he buys them from me so he is the only one in Canada "legally" selling my design.

This other guy, dfi.com, ordered a few from me last year, copied the specs and is making and selling them.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#4

Re:I'm curious Ruth, did you actually ......

Jamie D

>...file for a patent on the stopper design you sell?

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#5

Imitation is the Highest Form of Compliment

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>that being said I hope Ruth gets a real shyster lawyer and nails his butt to the wall. Though he probably doesn't have a pot to p--s in.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#6

Miscreant's Name *LINK*

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>This guy's name is Donald Fontaine. Dishonest people deserve whatever they get!


Miscreant's Website

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#7

Re:I'm curious Ruth, did you actually ......

Ruth Niles

>Yes, the patent was applied for and pending before this guy ordered from me and the patent was issued earlier in 2008.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#8

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles pl

Gary Ljostad

>Word spreads fast through the woodturning community. I hope all will heed the call, and make sure that they only buy from Ruth or her authorized sellers. In addition to making the best stoppers on the market, Ruth is a very nice person. One of the things I look forward to at woodturning symposiums is getting to talk to Ruth while stocking up on stoppers.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#9

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles pl

Norm Smith

>The only thing that these sleezy types understand is legal action. Good luck Ruth.

Norm

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#10

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles pl

Johnny Tolly

>Thanks for the heads up Barbara; it really chaps my hide when someone does this kind of thing. I have developed the Tolly designed tail stock adapter and it is also being made by a major company and they did NOT even give me the credit for the idea.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#11

Pretty cheesy, but happens all the time.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca

>Any low life with a caliper and CAD can copy anything. This really sucks, because I'm sure Ruth's operating budget is going to take an unexpected hit for legal fees. And if that guy has to COPY a bottle stopper design you can be sure his wallet is a little thin too.

Just flood the woodturning boards with this info so that Ruth doesn't take a hit. This is just lame that this guy did this.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#12

Steven Antonucci

A US Patent only protects you in the US

Steve Antonucci

>I'm not a lawyer, but a quick google seems to reveal that a US patent does nothing to protect Ruth from Canadian copies (or anywhere else). It's the web, so take any information you read with a grain of salt...

Best course of action is to get the word out and hopefully destroy his ability to market the copies...

Steve

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#13

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles pl

Sean Troy

>I just spoke to Ruth a couple of days ago and she is a sweetheart !!!

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#14

Re: A US Patent only protects you in the US

Doug in VA

>Yes a US Patent does only protect you in the US, but importing them or offering to sell them in the US would violate the patent. I AM a US patent attorney. BTW: Ruth may have applied for protection in other countries as well.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#15

Re: A US Patent only protects you in the US

Russ Fairfield

>Steve, he violate the US patent the instant that his shippment to a US address crossed the border. That was the "gottcha".

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#16

Good for you! I know the difficulty and......

Jamie D

>...costs are a big disincentive for filing for patents and copyrights, but it is the smart thing to do if at all possible.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#17

sincerity, flattery, action

John K Jordan

>On the bright side, it must be a great design to be copied. Sincerity, flattery, you know.

Write a thousand emails and snail mails to David Fontane at DFI. info@dfi-stainless-steel.com Ruth, make a small warning placard for your sales table. Hand out flayers at the symposium. Order 1000 of them then change your mind. Post on other woodturning sites. Spread the DFI name abroad. Announce this at your woodturning club meetings (good chance to show off the real thing.) Order more of the real thing.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#18

Re: A US Patent only protects you in the US

Doug in VA

>He may have vilated the patent before that. A patent gives one the right to prevent others from making using or SELLING. If he made an offer to sell in the US then that may have been the inital infringment.

Doug

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#19

Steven Antonucci

Agreed- merely pointing out US Law only works here

Steve Antonucci

>If the guy was based in the US, he'd be toast because Ruth has a US Patent. My guess is that spreading the word is the most cost effective way to quell the threat- international litigation couldn't possibly be a financially viable option!

Steve

P.S. It should prevent him from getting into any of the major catalogs, or they would likely carry some liability?

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#20

Re: Miscreant's Name

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Barbara wrote:

"Dishonest people deserve whatever they get!"

Unless of course, they get away with it! It is too bad this guy is in Canada. Otherwise we could organize a field trip to his shop to explain to him why this is a bad thing.

I've been bootlegged a few times already, and at the symposium a guy was telling me how much he loved my DVD when his kid piped up with "Yeah Dad, and you copied it!" Somebody probably got a beatin' later on that day...

Anyway, I hope he gets enough bad press that Ruth does not have to take stronger measures.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#21

Invasion Forces??

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Bill,

Are you considering Canadian Invasion Force.... Last time the US tried that was 1812... and we all know how that turned out

:-)

In all seriousness though, disregard for patent or copy right is a serious issue.

My daughters orchestra selects music sometimes based on how much royalties we have to pay to a composer to play their music. We have a saying on the board of diectors for the orchestra that older and dead composers are cheaper, so we select concert music sometimes based on How Dead they are, Really Dead is cheaper for us.

Funny world we live in, eh!

Take care,

Jim

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#22

Re: A US Patent only protects you in the US

davidwalser

>If you go to his website, which I don't recommend, you'll see that he is offering the stoppers for shipment to the US. He quotes prices in both US and Canadian dollars, lists shipping prices to US and Canadian destinations, and asks people living in other countries to inquire about shipping costs. It's clear he plans on harming Ruth by selling the patented stopper in the US.

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#23

Yea but we didn't have Bill back then:)

john lucas

>

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#24

Add here is hie email and phone#

Ron in Drums PA

>I never trust companies that don't list a good address or phone number on their website.

For your pleasure and entertainment.

Donald Fontaine

914, rue Malo

Mont-Saint-Hilaire, QC J3H 1T1

Canada

Email

info@dfi-stainless-steel.com

Phone

+1.4504678446

Re: WARNING: Imitation copies of the Ruth Niles plugs

#25

Re: Invasion Forces??

wilbur

>Jim,

You obviously are forgetting about* the South Park American-Canadian War, which turned out much better. :@)

*or is that aboot? :@)