Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

Posts

100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#1

100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

John K Jordan

>I've been cutting up a long 3.5" x 10" walnut slab on the bandsaw. At least I think it's walnut although I was told it was something else. One end is beautifully figured. The slab is so heavy I can barely lift a 6' section.

The reasons I think it's walnut: under the microscope a transverse section looks like walnut from the pore and ray structure, tyloses and all. The tangential macro surface looks like walnut. It has a chambered pith, a distinctive attribute of walnut. It clogs my sinuses exactly like walnut although it doesn't have much smell. It's certainly the right color. The density is a little on the heavy side for the walnut I'm used to: 42.6 lb/sq ft, although within the accepted range. However, I don't think it is good ol' TN black walnut - heavier and a little finer grained.

I was told it was used as a fireplace mantle since perhaps the late 1800s, possibly originating from California. I wish I knew the history - I found one lead bullet embedded, probably after the wood was partially dry based on the discoloration.

To the point: this thing is hard as rock! I made perhaps six ripping and four crossection cuts on a 24" section of the slab and now a brand new 1" Starrett bimetal blade is too dull to cut anything. How is this possible? Does any kind of walnut contain a high percentage of silica? Does very old walnut get hard enough to quickly dull bimetal blades?

JKJ

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#2

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Old Walnut does get hard. I've recently cut and turned several bowls from a 32 year old walnut burl. Frequent trips tto the sharpening station.

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#3

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I have a few planks, 2" thick I got from an old house in N.C that was going to be burned down. They were used as headers in the walls and the owner said the house was over 200 years old. I have cut some on my Unisaw with carbide blades and everytime I do I am afraid my neighbors are going to call 911 due to all the smoke. Even the router burns it. Tough stuff.

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#4

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

Michael Stafford

>I thought it was redwood burl....Old walnut gets as heavy as lead. A while back a friend gave me some beam sections that had been reclaimed from an old warehouse that were walnut. That stuff was so hard as to be unusable and it had been treated with some kind of chemical to prevent insect infestations. See, the beams were in a tobacco warehouse.....

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

keith tompkins

>HI John, I have some old stump wood from a large walnut. Air dried, hard and heavy. Compressed by the weight it had to carry?

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#6

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have cut walnut from old old trees. One was at least 250 yo. I would get only about 2 cuts/band. That was when I was not hitting old bullets. The silica content in those old slow growing walnuts seems to be very high.

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#7

sounds like paradox walnut

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>There is a very misunderstood type of walnut called Bastigone walnut or paradox walnut. Both names refer to the same tree which is a natural cross of an english walnut (juglans regia) grafted onto claro walnut (juglans hindsii) root stock and claro walnut. By natural cross I mean an open pollination of the flowers that will become the english walnuts and pollen from a nearby wild claro walnut tree. I can't remember the percentage of the nuts that germinate that will become paradox walnut trees and a recent conversation with an orchard manager indicates that it may be higher.

The paradox is that the wood is in between english and claro in color which is what one might expect but it is harder than either parent. From the couple of examples I have seen the figure and marbled color is more like claro than english. It is highly sought after by those who know what it is, to the point that you will find a lot of wood advertised as Bastigone walnut but the pictures suggest otherwise.

It sounds like you may have a slab or this stuff.

Robin

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#8

Re: sounds like paradox walnut

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Robin, that is very interesting. I had never heard of this. How long have they been grafting the two different trees?

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#9

Re: sounds like paradox walnut

John K Jordan

>Interesting. This wood is hard and heavy, but the figure is not marbled - the color is a uniform brown with a edge towards the red.

I've read about some of the walnut grafts but didn't know about the hybridization. I suspected that this might be a hybrid or a species local to a specific area.

Barbara's comment about the 250 year old walnut is also interesting.

I did try turning some yesterday and it turned cleanly but did dull the tools quickly. The grain is fine. This slab had the pith down the middle with many radial cracks and a little ring shake, so I'm only getting small pieces (which is what I prefer!)

JKJ

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#10

Re: sounds like paradox walnut

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I really have no idea when the first grafting of english onto claro occured but judging how poorly english walnuts do on their own root stock in most parts of california I wouldn't be surprised if the Spanish missionaries started grafting english onto claro back in the late 1700's. By the way english walnut orginated in Persia.

Robin

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#11

What's the difference?

Carole Valentine

>Just wondering what the difference is between the Black Walnut we have here on the East Coast and Claro Walnut which seems to be a West Coast thing?

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#12

Re: What's the difference?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Claro walnut is much sought after by people who make gunstocks for it's beautiful color and figure. It can come in rich browns with streaks of orange and red and black. Del Stubbs, once a true woodturning artist (don't know what he's doing now) lived in Chico Ca. where a lot of it grows. At one time I was fortunate to have a pretty good stock of it. It often resembles French walnut which is very fine grained (for walnut)

Wally

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#13

Re: Claro Walnut

Russ Fairfield

>One is "juglans hindsii", and the east coast walnut is "juglans nigra". Hindsii was discovered by an Englishman in about 1840. Claro is a mid-20th Century name given to the wood by gunstock makers so they could get more money for it.

Read all about it -------------

The English Botanist Richard B. Hinds, while on a voyage around the world that lasted from 1836 to 1842, discovered a new species of walnut growing in the Sacramento Valley in northern California. In honor of his discovery this new species of walnut was named Juglans Hindsii. The name Claro was first introduced by the gun stock industry in the mid 1960's, and refers to the species of walnut discovered by Mr. Hinds. This name was chosen to differentiate California Claro walnut (Juglans hindsii), from its eastern Black walnut cousin (Juglans nigra). The word claro is a Spanish term meaning clear, light, or bright. Claro is the most colorful of all walnut, no doubt due to the mineral rich soils found in the Sacramento and San Joaquin Valley, as well as southern Oregon. The first substantial stands of Claro were found growing in the following three locations:

The valley of Walnut Creek in Contra Costa County

The banks of the Sacramento River, particularly at Walnut Grove

The Wooden Valley east of Napa.

It was from these original groves that John Bidwell began propagating California Claro walnut at his Rancho Chico Nursery, located in Chico California in the late 1800's. The Bidwell family donated the property for the building of Chico State University. The Bidwell mansion now serves as a museum located on the grounds of the university.

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#14

Thanks Wally and Russ

Carole Valentine

>

Re: 100 year old walnut? hard as stone?

#15

Re: Claro Walnut

Ed Karch

>When I lived in Corbet Canyon near San Luis Obispo CA in the 70s, the walnut groves were being converted to wine grape. They would dozer pile and burn the English walnut tops. The Hindsii rootstock was dug up and exported to furnature factories in Italy.