Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Posts

Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#1

Steven Antonucci

Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Steve Antonucci

>Without stretching too far around to pat myself on the back and hurting myself, I consider myself to be a pretty competent turner. I can usually figure things out pretty much by watching a video on Youtube or reading abook, but I have found one that is going to require some advanced form of training.

The Kelton Bowl Coring tool.

I just spent far, far too long coring an ambrosia maple practice block. I have found out that my Nova can make pig noises when the tip catches. I have broken every tenon clear off at the chuck. I have ripped screws out of a face plate. By shear dumb luck, I did end up with a few moments where the tool looked like it was doing what it should be doing, by I can tell you now, it wasn't a "one handed Grumbine" cut.

And, oh yeah- the instructions [Rant ON:]

Who in their right mind can charge what they charge for that tool, and only include a paragraph on how to use it? They might as well put a piece of paper that says "Good luck, sucker..." or nothing at all. No video on their website. No DVD. Amazing...

[:Rant Off]

I am sure that there is a right way and a wrong way (several wrong ways, no doubt). If I don't figure out the magic words, you can keep an eye on the classifieds...

Steve

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#2

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Paul Zerjay

>I am still in the exact same boat as you and I've had this tool for maybe six months. A little luck here and there, but with the thing giving me fits, and nothing to show for it, I seem to put it away and forget about it. I can't even find anyone in my club to come give me some pointers. Thanks for bringing this thread up. I'm going to watch it closely.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#3

Stene, sorry, but I giggled

Norm Smith

>when I read your post. I dont have one and I probably never will. I am sure that you guys will beat it eventually.

Good luck and keep us posted.

Norm

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#4

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>I just bought mine. I tried it today with the brief instructions from AAW. Grumbine also has instructions on his web site. I was successful in removing a small core from a 13" wet hackberry blank. I ordered Mike Mahoney's video on using this system, but it hasn't come yet. Looking forward to trying it on more demanding wood AFTER watching the video several times.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#5

Steve, sorry

Norm Smith

>

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#6

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Texian

>Steve,

I repacked mine in the original shipping materials and sent it back within a few days of its arrival. Too long a ways to go, and too short a time to get there.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#7

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Allen Neighbors

>I watched Bill Grumbine use it, and wrote down his instructions.

I've cored quite a few bowls with it, but it still doesn't work as easy for me as it did Big Bill.

I wish I had gotten the smaller tools with it, since I can't seem to use it on the smaller bowls.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#8

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Lan Brady

>I guess, I was just lucky. I saw Mike Mahoney and Bill Grumbine both demonstrate in person. It was several more months before I bought one. My first 2 bowls, I just cut one core to save the shavings on the floor. After that, I got a little braver each time. I added a 3rd core and then a fourth. My last bowl set has 5 curly maple cores from the one blank.

I would not send my tool back for anything. It is a great tool.

One thing I did was to sharpen the bits before use with a diamond hone. I wish you the same success, I have enjoyed.

Lan

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#9

Insanity Later

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Steve,

Remember the accompanying line to "Serenity Now", is "Insanity Later"!

I had to laugh when I read this for I too am a KM Coring Systems failure! :>) When I first got this tool several years ago, I tried numerous times to get the process "down". But alas, I never developed the knack and this tool has sat in my tool cabinet unused since then.

I have the Mike Mahoney DVD as well as Bill G's but I just don't have the urge to try that tool again (mostly because I don't have any large blanks that I want to core). But I'm sure that SOMEWHERE on the internet there is a written tutorial on this tool!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Insanity Later

Dick Hines

>I have had one for years. I watched the DVD acouple of times and then cut through a couple of blanks. I got the chance to watch Bill in Nc acouple of years ago. Great help! I still cut a core a little thin once in a while but would never send on coreing system back.

I got a ambrosia blank that was 18"x18"x6". Paid $150 for it. I got 4 bowls from the blank. $200,$175,$75, and $45. I think I will keep the coreing tool.

Keep trying and one day the light will come on and you will not want to give it up.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#11

Steven Antonucci

I knew it wasn't my fault :-)

Steve Antonucci

>I've seen Bill G do the coring in person, and it is obviously a parlour trick of some kind, because he stands there with one hand and carries on a conversation!

How anyone could hear over the squealing of belts is beyond me!

The funny thing is, I don't even really want the extra bowls. I had planned on giving them away to friend and/or at club events. No good deed goes unpunished...

Steve

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: I knew it wasn't my fault :-)

keith tompkins

>Did you ever see the forearms on Mr. Grumbine? Perhaps that's not his secret, but I'm not gonna' arm-wrestle him to find out!!

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#13

Re: I knew it wasn't my fault :-)

Eric Knutsen

>Steve, no one in the club (NJWT) has experience with it? I would think Dennis would have some insight on this.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#14

Steven Antonucci

You paid $150 for ambrosia maple?

Steve Antonucci

>I've been burning it all winter. :-)

Can't find a maple around here without the holes and beetle markings...

Steve

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#15

Good grief ! 

Chip in Plano

>

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#16

Steven Antonucci

Just the cut-offs Chip ;-)

Steve Antonucci

>and spalted maple too (cut-offs), unless they are too pretty to burn, then I save them!

When I was in Hawaii a few years back, there were stacks of koa, milo and kamani outside one restaurant on Maui. I wanted to cry.

Steve

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#17

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Barry Irby

>I have had one for years. When I got it it had the knives that were cut straight across like chisels. I was convinced the blades were not bent correctly. Posted here about it and their rep had me send it to him. Without asking, he reground the knives to the V shape they sell now. Said the knives were bent well enough. I was slightly miffed that he reground the cutters without telling me first, but they seem to work slightly less badly than they did before. The knives still were not correctly shaped so a friend of mine and I repent them. That helped a lot. I recently lent the setup to a friend and he returned it with all sorts of modifications, none of which he explained. I am sure I have not run enough blanks through it to make friends with it. Or maybe it is just not the friendly type.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#18

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Gordon Seto

>Steve,

Is your Nova a DVR?

You can program the speed control to "soft". If the blade ever got jammed, the lathe would stop softly. After 3 stops in a row, the lathe will need reset. The blank won't fly off the lathe. Don't ask me how I know it.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#19

ambrosia maple...

John K Jordan

>Trade for dogwood? Sassafrass? Cherry? Walnut?

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#20

Steven Antonucci

No DVR :-(

Steve Antonucci

>Just a remote off switch that I bump when necessary.

Steve

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#21

Bill Grumbine -Help these poor folks out. :)

Stephen Mushinski

>Happy New Year to All!

Should your family have the 5 Barns this summer, you might have to break out the bowl splitters out and show everyone how you do it. Seems like a couple of the regulars need help!

All the best in 2009!

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#22

I fought with it as well

Steven Kubien

>Steve, I had mine for just shy of Lee Valley's 90-day no-questions-asked return policy. I successfully cored 2 sets but ruined several blanks in the process. I absolutely hated using that thing! I had the height set correctly. I tried slow speeds. I tried slightly faster speeds. No love. I took it back. When I think back on it and look at roughed cores others have made (often with their Oneway rig) the one thing I notice is that they used a wide tenon/foot for theirs. I cannot help but wonder if I was using too small a foot (as big as my #2 jaws and Nova bowl jaws would allow).

Just keep changing your shorts and good luck!

Steve Kubien

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#23

From Mike Mahoney's demo this year..

Randy G

>Mike Mohoney was at the Rocky Mountain Woodturners Symposium this year and I caught one of his demo's on this unit. Now I don't have the coring jig (still think I want it, but am not sure now based on these responses), but I do recall him saying you needed to have the biggest foot possible when coring. At that point he was of the opinion that Oneway chuck's didn't have big enough Jaws for anything but maybe a 10" bowl, but the largest Nova ones were adequate for up to about 15-18 inches. I have since seen the #5 and #6 jaws for the oneway and wonder if they may be big enough for the size foot he feels is necessary.

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#24

Steven Antonucci

I've seen Bill do it at Five Barns

Steve Antonucci

>I think he's got a special supply of "butterwood" to core for us unsuspecting fools...

Steve

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

#25

Re: Serenity Now. Serenity Now.

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Oh my, what a discussion we have going on here! I used to have that tool beat me up all the time, but once I got it figured out, I only get beat up half the time. ;-) Seriously though, once the thing is set up properly, there are only a few other items to observe to get a nice core without all the stress involved.

Make sure the tool tip is on center, with the top of the knife against the gate. If this is not observed, it does not matter how strong you are. If it is observed, it does not matter how frail you are, if you at least have the strength to stand and hold the weight of the knife. I have had little old ladies get successful cores in my shop.

Widen the kerf at the top if you need to do so. Sometimes the knife will bind in the kerf as it gets further in, and that will squeal the belt. Move the tool rest in towards the center just a hair, and widen the kerf. I have done this with the lathe running! But it is a good idea to stop it first, at least until you get the hang of it. Along with this, back the knife out to clear shavings often. Clearing the shavings keeps the knife from binding in the kerf.

I core at pretty high speeds, usually between 700 and 900 rpm, and mostly at the higher end of that range. This is especially true of natural edged pieces, where I don't want a sudden jump in the knife to dismount the piece or shear the tenon off. I also regularly core bowls with a tenon that is 25% of the total diameter. If they are tall, I will use a steady rest to help keep them from breaking off at the tenon.

If the knife is cutting smoothly, don't stop! Keep it going. A lot of problems arise on reentry into the kerf, especially if you hit the core where it starts to cut again too fast. It causes a catch and often dismounts the bowl with varying degrees of damage to the tenon. And remember, the closer you get to the center, the slower the wood is moving, so you have to slow your feed rate down or speed up the lathe.

With all this, I can safely say that there is not a lathe out there that I have not stalled with this tool. Most of the time it works like an extension of my arm, but every now and then, it gives me fits. I have a short section on my second DVD that deals with the basic usage of this tool, but if you want to see a comprehensive treatment, Robohippy, aka Reed Gray has a full length DVD that I think is exceptionally well done for the content on how to use this tool effectively.

If anyone has specific questions to direct to me, I will be glad to try and answer them.

Bill