Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Risk Aversion or Go For It?

Posts

Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#1

Risk Aversion or Go For It?

charlie belden

>So I'm turning a long, delicate "onion" finial - in Blackwood. And rather than chuck it up and start at the delicate tip and working my way back to the tenon I turned the little tenon on the end - checked the fit in the hole it's to go in - then chuck it up and start from the tenon and work my way back towards that delicate tip.

After far more time than the finial warranted, I'm down to almost parting the piece off - almost - but not quite at a point. Everything's sanded and finished as I went so I'm THIS CLOSE to a surprisingly nice Drozda-esque finial - one light tapering cut and I'm done.

But things don't look just right. I need to make the tip just a little tiny bit longer - which means going back a little to adjust the taper.

Cut. That looks better - but not QUITE right.

Longer tapering cut. Better - BUT - only ALMOST right.

Longer tapering cut begun and things are going swimmingly (what an odd phrase). And seeing the finish line so close - I relax, about to congratulate myself on a job well done - and done right.

Of course that's where that delicate tip twisted off - leaving a diagonal tear down the side of the remaining formerly delicate tip - of the formerly near perfect onion finial. OK - so the "neck could've been a little bit longer and thinned a little more - but I was SO CLOSE.

Now I've got about 16 "spokes" to turn for an earings, bracelets, necklaces and rings "tree" to turn - and they're all going to be a tad over 3/16" diameter - max. Since they need a little ball turned on the ends of their points - don't want the recipient stabbing herself trying to retrieve a piece of jewelry - I'm asking myself "Should I avoid a possible mini-disaster and leave things FAT - or Go For It and shoot for nice and small and delicate - with the possibility of blowing it and having to start all over?

So that's my question.

Are you willing to risk losing the piece in order to get it right - or a bit better - or do you play it safe and quit Close Enough?

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#2

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

Paul Zerjay

>If it leaves the shop, it has to be the absolute best I can do at the time. No "Close Enough" allowed. I don't want my name saying this is the turner that turns stuff "Close Enough". Saying that, the things that have left my shop this year, are a lot better than the things that left my shop 2 years ago.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#3

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

John K Jordan

>Keep on until it's "right", regardless. Blow it, consider and learn, redo, perhaps smarter.

A marginally related question: when making that delicate/perhaps risky cut who else holds their breath?

JKJ

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#4

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

Texian

>Charlie,

Some people say "Good enough isn't", and "Close enough isn't". But it is your call. So are you feeling lucky?

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#5

Go for it!

arkie

>Think of it as a learning opportunity, not a production run.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#6

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

Carole Valentine

>My thought is why did you do it that way - start at the tenon and work to the tip when you could obviously have lowered the risk by working from the delicate tip back???

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#7

Go For It.................

jake Niedling

>I am always much happier with the results when I think things need to be adjusted and go for it. Usually it is with making things that are too thick, or finales too large in diameter. Gor for it and re-shape it. In the long run, you will be personnally happier with the end product.

Jake

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#8

Go For It

Steven Kubien

>

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#9

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

charlie belden

>Carol asked:

My thought is why did you do it that way - start at the tenon and work to the tip when you could obviously have lowered the risk by working from the delicate tip back???

Embarassed to admit it - but I have trouble getting the tenon's diameter to match the hole it's to go in - when I caliper the drill used and then turn to that diameter. That usually ends up either tool loose - or more often - too big.

The misfit is only discovered AFTER the piece has been parted off. Too big is a PITA to fix since the part with the hole in it is already finished and redrilling - to an odd size - can be a problem. The parted off finial is too small and delicate to hold - let alone return.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#10

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

charlie belden

>John K Jordan asked

A marginally related question: when making that delicate/perhaps risky cut who else holds their breath?

I guess you don't make any reall LONG cuts. Passing out with a sharp tool against a spinning chunk of wood could be a bit of a safety problem.

I turn with a dead man's foot switch. After each successful risky cut I step off and step back - sort of like a musician often does after a tricky riff.

When sharpening I find I bite my tongue a bit while on the wheel (or disk is using the WorkSharp). Only way I can keep myself from clenching my teeth - it's sort of a fingernails on a blackboard thing.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#11

Never Say "That's Good Enough".....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#12

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>When turning finials I always turn the tenon first at the tailstock end. Then work toward the headstock to turn the tip of the finial. The small point of the cup center is secured in the tenon but is only holding it, with no pressure. Can't recall the last time I twisted a small turning off. When in doubt, curl your fingers around the small turning.

Wally

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#13

Why not?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Woodturning is a hobby for most people.

The primary purpose of a hobby is enjoyment.

Perfectionism is the antithesis of relaxation and pleasure.

Turning for sale in an Art Gallery is a different story.

That's no longer a hobby, it's a business.

Not every one wants to go there.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#14

Re: Why not?

john lucas

>Brian I'll agree with you to a point. It is a hobby and as such most people do it for pure enjoyment or relaxation. You stop at what ever point you wish to stop. However it's kind of like golf. You always sort of keep score and want to improve that score each time you go out. sometimes you do and sometimes you don't. However if you always stop early you never know if you succeed.

I still enjoy my turning but I always look at the piece and ask myself if I could improve it. I break a few or screw a few up but then it is a hobby so I'm not killing the company profit line if it takes 3 times as long to make something.

The final line is, when you do the best you can you are much more proud of that piece so take a little risk and go for it. Now granted we all draw the line somewhere. It's close to Christmas, I only have limited time to finish this and it's the only piece of ebony I have left. I certainly understand that. I'm up against that line for every step of the project I'm working on right now. There are a lot of little errors I would do differently if time weren't a factor but I have to look at the project and say this is good enough, not perfect but the best I can do under the circumstances.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#15

Another side of the coin

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I have a strong streak of perfectionism. It eventually destroyed most of the enjoyment I once found in woodturning. Several years ago I started learning to throw pots. I started from ground zero. Perfection was so far out of reach that it wasn't relevant. I enjoyed the process and the results were merely a by-product of the process. The pots have gotten better as my skill has improved. They've gotten good enough to sell, and I've sold a number of them. I've also trashed a lot of them. I'm going to the studio today to throw, because a) I enjoy throwing, and b) I need some new breakfast cereal bowls. (I'll eventually get the ones I'm after, but I'm not going to worry about that.)

I managed to transfer that same attitude to turning. Being more relaxed during the process and viewing the result as just a by-product of the process gave me a new freedom. My focus shifted to the journey and process. The perfectionism pressure disappeared.

Turning is enjoyable again.

I enjoy the process and the challenges.

Mistakes don't matter, they are simply intrinsic parts of the process and journey.

My turnings have become much better.

"It's only practice for the next piece."

"It's the journey, not the destination."

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#16

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It? *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Or may be use string steady to increase your chance if you have not done so.


String Steady

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#17

Re: Why not?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Long ago I made myself a promise that I would never say that's good enough. If I look at a piece and know that with a little extra care I could have done it better, it bothers me. Matter of pride in what I do I guess.

Wally

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#18

Re: Never Say "That's Good Enough".....

John K Jordan

>I watched a video of Richard Raffan turning boxes. At least once he said "that's good enough" after quickly cutting a surface that I would fuss with for five minutes.

But he is a very speedy turner. I am not.

JKJ

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#19

Re: How good is good enough???

Russ Fairfield

>We all have to say, "that's good enough", or "that's the best I can do for now", at some point. Otherwise, we would never get anything done. The difference is what we are willing to accept and our perception of how good is "good enough".

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#20

Steven Antonucci

"good enough is forever"

Steve Antonucci

>and in the future, may no longer be good enough...

It's only wood.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#21

Re: Never Say "That's Good Enough".....

Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville

>That is one of my New Year's resolutions, never say "That's Good Enough." Instead, I'll try to say, "That's the Best I Can Do!" I may ruin some passable pieces but by the end of the year I'll bet I'm a better turner. And...that would make me happy.

Re: Risk Aversion or Go For It?

#22

See subsequent post Close Enough

charlie belden

>I've completed a Drozda-esque inlay rimmed finial lidded box based on earlier illustrated instructions for turning such a piece. The piece was merely a test of a procedure and taken a little farther than what was to be tested. It's an example of a Close Enough piece.