Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

soap soaking

Posts

soap soaking

#1

soap soaking

Sam McGarrity, Cape Coral, fl

>has anyone tried the new dish washing soap from costco or the new

dawn that costco now has- thanks

Re: soap soaking

#2

Dick Hines

Re: soap soaking

Dick Hines

>I tried it a few years ago. I don't know if it worked or not. I did not use it long term. After soaking a few bowls I had a piece of plywood fall and hit the plastic vat the soap was in. Punched a hole about 2" off the floor. Soap every where. I just happened th have a big pile of shavings in the shop. I covered to soap with them until they soaked up the soap.

Floor was so slippery it was hard to walk around the shop with out falling.

Shop did smell good for weeks though. ORANGES!!

Re: soap soaking

#3

Re: soap soaking

david

>If you want to work with an old, dried-out piece of softwood (like pine or cedar), I recommend liquid detergent soaking because it will bring back a lot of the qualities of turning green wood.

Re: soap soaking

#4

Re: soap soaking

Bill Howatt

>I don't believe that the brand of soap has anything to do with the process. I'm not even convinced it really is worth the bother and mess after trying it several times.

Bill

Re: soap soaking

#5

why soak in soap? *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Sam,

I'm curious: are you soaking to stabilize wood, speed drying, or as a turning aid? I'm making notes of various wood treatment methods and the results people report - if you have experience with this and can comment it would be helpful.

I've read where people report the soap provides some lubricating action, making turning a little easier. Some soaked in soap to try to reduce warping and cracking. A little searching shows soap soaking was all the rage a few years ago but seldom mentioned today. According to Dave Smith, soaking in alcohol works better than soaking in soap to speed drying and minimize degrade.

It's interesting that Dave Smith attributed his focus on using alcohol from finding the consensus among soap soakers was the key agent in treating wood was the surfactants, and that the surfactants in common soaps were listed in the MSDSs as alcohols. (article in link below) This seems a trifle odd since soaps themselves are surfactants made from fats and acids, and the alcohols defined as components of synthetic detergents are fatty alcohols, far more complex than ethanol as far as I can tell (8-32 carbon atoms vs 2 carbon atoms in ethanol) and with different properties. A real chemist could set all this straight, but even then it still probably wouldn't explain the interesting part, how it affects wood drying.

I've been turning some very very dry wormy American chestnut. The reason David mentions for soaking dried out wood sounds like something I need to try.

JKJ


alcohol article

Re: soap soaking

#6

Re: soap soaking

robo hippy

>After reading an article about the DNA soaking years ago, I gave it a try. After all, anything that might keep Madrone from cracking was worth a try. After several hundred bowls soaked, I couldn't tell that it did anything at all. I then heard about the LDD soaking. So I tried it. The only thing that I noticed that it did was it made sanding a lot easier, expecially on woods that tended to burn or glaze over when power sanding. I still soap soak today, after several thousand bowls.

I turn green to final thickness (1/4 to 1/2 inch), then soak and let them dry and warp. I once did a test with 3 sets of bowls (Madrone), turned to the same thickness. One set was DNA soaked, one set LDD soaked, and one set air dried. They dried (reached equilibrium) in the exact same amount of time, and I weighed them daily for 10 days on a gram scale. There was no measurable difference in movement, or cracking, which supported obesrvations made over the years. The only difference was the LDD ones sanded out easier, and the DNA ones were harder to sand. I haven't tried this on thick turned bowls that you return later. Any one want to try this and report?

Why some people claim to have so much better success with the DNA soak baffeled me. The only difference in the process was that they would wrap the outside of the bowl with a layer or 3 of newspaper, then tape it to the rim, and remove the paper on the inside of the bowl. I didn't wrap because it is fairly humid here in western Oregon, even in the summer, our dry season. The theory is that this would cause the inside of the bowl to dry faster than the outside, and this would pull the outside in towards the inside, kind of drying the bowl in the compression mode. Well, I applied this method to my bowls. I modified it by using the 6 inch plastic film that you use to wrap boxes on a pallet to wrap the paper over the rim. I wrap it a couple of times around, and stretch the plastic to put some pressure on the rim. I did this with some Madrone that was thicker than I normally leave it (3/8 inch) and with knots. Normally, I would expect cracks off each knot, as well as in the knot itself, but almost all of them dried crack free. This seems to work very well. The bowls still move, and I can't tell if there is any more or less movement. I have done them with just the plastic on the rim, and no paper. Again, better results than normally. Add to this some thing that I have heard from several turners, Dale Larson, Eli Alvesera (spell?), and Christian Burshard (spell again?) about rounding the sharp edges over because a sharp edge will tend to start cracks, and it makes a lot of sence. Protecting the rim with the wrap, and rounding over slightly seems to work. Observation and testing is continuing, and the results show promice.

robo hippy

Re: soap soaking

#7

JL

Only to wash dishes (works well).

JL

>

Re: soap soaking

#8

Re: soap soaking *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I've never had any luck with the soap soak and didn't care for the mess. I did have some pretty good success with the DNA soak and I always wrapped the bowls after soaking with brown grocery sack material and taped the rim, leaving the inside open. I also stored them with the top down on stickers so that the air could get to the inside to dry. I posted the results on rec.crafts.woodturning newsgroup and some guy named George said it wouldn't work any better than not soaking. So, I ran a test, I split a piece of walnut root into two halves. I turned two identical bowls, rough turned to about 3/8" wall thickness. I soaked one in alcohol and the other I didn't. I wrapped them both in brown grocery sack paper and taped the rims, leaving the center open. I weighed them both and recorded the weights each day. In about 10 days they were both dry. Neither cracked. The alcohol soaked bowl seemed to turn better than the un-soaked one. Otherwise, there was not change.

The thing that I've had the best luck with is CedarShield from Cedarside in Texas. It always makes the wood turn better, whether it is soaked wet or soaked after drying. It reduces warping and normally prevents cracking. You can final turn in about 72 hours after soaking, but I generally wait at least a couple of weeks.


More Woodturning Website

Re: soap soaking

#9

John, I used soap.

Allen Neighbors

>I couldn't buy Costco's soap here, so I used clear, concentrated Ivory dish washing detergent. I tried different dilutions, and ended up using 2/3 water 1/3 soap, because the concentrate was too thick.

I tried different times, from 24 hours to 1 week, and finally ended up at one month. I soaked roughs and some smaller blanks. I tried about everything I could put in it... Walnut, Apricot, Peach, Sweet Gum, Bois d'Arc, Ash, Pecan, Sycamore. I had less cracking with wood I soaked in soap, than wood that I did nothing to. It works for me.

It does add a little lubrication to the wood... and I say that because it's my experience after turning both soaked and unsoaked... it's not a scientific study.

I tried Alcohol, once, with Sweet Gum. When the rough-out dried, it was harder than Pecancrete. I never tried alcohol again. That could be because Walmart (only place that sells it here), won't sell me but one quart per day. Because some idiots decided to use DNA to make meth, they punish the lot of us.

I am now soaking in plain water, after suggestions from some of my friends in Australia to try it. I have no results from that yet; I'm still drying my roughs. But I have a feeling that I'm going to go back to the soap; don't know why, just a feeling I have. It's more expensive than the water, of course, and lasted longer than the DNA. Of course, my DNA soak was in a 3 gallon container, and my soap was in two 20 gallon vats.

Re: soap soaking

#10

Advantage....?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Allen, with all of the time, effort and mess that goes into what you're doing, what exactly do you accomplish? Not a wise-guy question, I'm really interested in knowing.

I've never tried any of that and can't come up with any reason why I should. I don't think that I need a lubricant for the wood that I turn and I have very little problem with wood cracking. Wood dries quite fast here in Arizona.

Wally

Re: soap soaking

#11

Also, John, I dried them,

Allen Neighbors

>the soap soaked, just like I finally started drying the unsoaked roughs. I paint anchor seal all around the outside and inside, and put them in my refrigerator kilns (I now have three of them). I use fan, light bulb only, fan plus light bulb. When, or if, mold mold shows up, I use fan almost coninually.

I'm not interested in a lot of speed. I just hate cracks.

Re: soap soaking

#12

Re: soap soaking

John K Jordan

>Thanks for relating your experience, Fred. When discussing this a few years ago, George also wrote to me and presented some compelling arguments casting doubt on the technical basis behind the holy alcohol grail. My own experiments were not comprehensive and inconclusive. Personally, I've had very little loss by simply coating with anchorseal on either end grain or all over a roughed bowls. I'm never in a hurry, though.

The problem with either success or failure stories for ANY method is they are mostly meaningless without controls - who is to say that particular piece would have dried worse or better if treated another way? Even a good test such as yours comparing similar pieces from a single piece of wood has a sample size at least an order of magnitude less than needed for a statistically significant result. I still hope to do some more comprehensive experiments some day.

In the mean time, I'm collecting all drying stories I find. The files are getting interesting to read. BTW, I have one note from a guy who soaks in alcohol but quit wrapping the outside in favor of using anchorseal on the outside and rim only. His initial report was of fewer failures this way, but admittedly had only been using that method for a short time, and of course, hasn't reported back in the two years since his first note.

JKJ

Re: soap soaking

#13

Wally, the advantage for me...

Allen Neighbors

>is that I get fewer cracked bowls.

The average afternoon temperature, here, in the summertime, is near 90 degrees. In my shop, it averages 100-105 degrees almost daily in the summer, and because of that I have fans blowing all the time, so there is a lot of wind, (inside and out). The relative humidity gets down into the teens for weeks on end.

When I roughturn bowls, they crack, almost invariably. They all warp, some worse than others, you know that; but when I first began rough turning bowls, they were cracking right and left. It almost made me quit turning. Then I read about soap soaking. I tried it, and it gave me more bowls to turn... I had less bowls crack.

That's why I soaked in soap, and that's why I'm trying the water now, and may go back to the soap, if the water doesn't work as well.