Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

More Compressor talk...

Posts

More Compressor talk...

#1

Steven Antonucci

More Compressor talk...

steve antonucci

>Now that I may be in the market for a new compressor, what do you all recommend? I will be doing a fair amount of carving with rotary burrs and blowing out shavings from hollowforms, so I think I need a big tank?

In addition, I want to be able to hear myself think when the compressor is running, and I assume that there is probably a way to buy a quiet unit? I know I can put it in a different room if necessary.

What is a good budget for a quality unit going to be?

Steve

Re: More Compressor talk...

#2

Re: More Compressor talk...

Bill Howatt

>I believe the quietest ones tend to be the oiled, cast-iron compressor types. Oiless is generally quite a bit noisier. There is not such thing as a quiet compressor.

You match the compressor to the air-flow of your tool. The tool that requires the most air-flow at the highest pressure is the one. Compressors are capable of delivering more volume of air at 40psi than they are at 90psi. This makes sense because there is actually more air jammed into the cubic foot when the pressure is higher. You will notice that these two pressures are usually specified for the compressor.

A bigger tank is a good buffer but if the compressor is delivering less than your tool requires the tank will gradually empty and then the compressor will kick in to fill it. If you keep using the tool the compressor never will fill the tank and turn off. Most operations, especially with high-volume tools, will never be done with one tank of air.

You can spend a lot of money for a quality industrial compressor compared to the "home" compressors of roughly the same specs. The industrial ones will last longer and possibly might be quieter.

Bill

Re: More Compressor talk...

#3

Re: More Compressor talk... *LINK*

david

>Growing up in my father's carpenter shop, from anywhere on the property you would know when the compressor cycled on. Andi Wolfe posted a while back about getting her 'dream compressor' (or something like that), which caused me to look up the company. This was my first exposure to compressors that were relatively quiet, but it does come at a price. This is a piece of equipment that for me will have to be a lot of compromises. A remote location may also mean that a neighbor will suffer the noise consequences. A smaller tank will mean the motor will cycle on more often. Some equipment, such as an air powered ROS, will gobble up air like there is no tomorrow. I was using a pancake tank on a unit set up primarily for driving nail guns, and recently picked up a used 22-gal upright unit originally sold at Sears that is not particularly quiet. Another case where you get what you pay for.


Sil Air Compressor

Re: More Compressor talk...

#4

Re: More Compressor talk...

Pete LaBelle

>My shop is in the basement. Compressor (oil sump type) is in the garage. A 3/8" line feeds the basement, which is hard plumbed. In the garage, I made a gizzmo that permanently leaves a male coupling on the wall. Thus, the air system for the basement is a permanent thing. I just couple up the hose on the compressor to the coupling on the wall, and the basement is now on-line. Just gotta remember to turn the compressor off at the end of the day.

Also, if you use an oil sump compressor in a cold garage, get some synthetic oil & change out the petrolium-based oil in the compressor. At temperatures less than 20F, I used to keep a trouble light on the compressor head to keep it warm, else it would trip the breaker. With synthetic, it starts easily at -10F with no pre-heating.

Dry sump compressors NEED to run intermittently to keep them from overheating. Wet sump compressors don't care.

Re: More Compressor talk...

#5

Re: More Compressor talk...

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>A rotary compressor is very quiet but comes with a big sticker shock.

Re: More Compressor talk...

#6

Re: More Compressor talk...

jwoodwright

>I have a Serious Duty Model Campbell Hausfeld oil lube due to cast iron head on compressor. It's rated 5hp w/20 gal tank (6.5 scfm @ 40psi and 5.7 scfm @ 90 psi) I don't run a ROS, however, I love air tools and haven't outgrown this compressor. Be careful as a lot of compressors are alloy with a cast iron sleeve. Compared to my Porter Cable pancake, it's damn quiet... My neighbor has an oil-less, basically same size. When he fires that up, the neighborhood knows... John

Re: More Compressor talk...

#7

Re: More Compressor talk...

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Campbell-Hausfeld makes an upright 26 gallon 2 stage 175 psi compressor that runs on 110v. This machine is suprizenly quite. The output is 6.4 cfm @ 40psi and 5.1cfm @ 90psi... The brands that they mfg under are Sears, Portercable and Dewalt to name a few. These sell for around $400.00 If you need more air go to a 5hp 220v 2 stage machine, they start around $600.00. 2 stage commpressors run about 40 db quieter than single stage universal motor machines. 175 psi has 50% more air volumue than 150 psi. I have had a Sears model for several years and have been very satisfied

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: More Compressor talk...

#8

Re: More Compressor talk...

don lewonczyk

>Steve, I have 4 air compressors, three are oil lubricated and one is oiless, all are single stage and max PSI is 125 for all of them. They are all noisy the oiless one being the worse. My farm reguires two of them the other two are in my shop. The first one I bought was in 1970 a sears 3HP and it still works great. The oiless one is a black Max I picked up at a yard sale for $37 bucks, the regulator was leaking and wouldn't shut off so for $40 more for the regulator kit I have a 5HP air compressor. If I had my chice right now to buy one I would go with the 2 stage with everything simple on it, everything accessible easy to work on, etc. The low end 2 stage isn't much more then a solid single stage and you get more for your buck. Most air tools eat up big volumes of air and the extra pressure will help along with a bigger tank (60 gallon). It seems that they all take about the same amount of time to build up and shut off. The troble with putting a compressor in a remote location is that the farther you are from the regulator the more air PSI drop you have. Im talking 100 plus feet. My porter cable has a control panel which you remove and put where you are working might not make any difference to you but thought I'd mention it. On your tank now the vibration can be causing your intermitten troubles just may have a connection coming loose and needs resoldering. Good Luck, DonL

Re: More Compressor talk...

#9

Re:For sake of us compressor dummies,...

Jamie D

>.. what are the differences and advantages between single stage and dual stage compressors?

Re: More Compressor talk...

#10

Re:For sake of us compressor dummies,...

Bill Howatt

>More air at higher pressure and less heating of the compressor which also means higher efficiency.

Bill