Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Tapping threads in homemade tools

Posts

Tapping threads in homemade tools

#1

Tapping threads in homemade tools

James McClure

>John mentioned homemade tools the other day and tapping threads in them. I have made a few tools myself and find tapping to be an inconsistent process at best. My success rate is pretty good when tapping holes for 1/4" bolts, but when I try to tap smaller holes, I have problems and end up breaking the tap. I am tapping for the set screw to hold an HSS cutter. It's a #10 - 24 thread screw that holds the cutter in place. I have broken at least 3 taps and a on one of the holes that was successfully tapped, it is very hard to get the set screw in. In addition to breaking taps, I have bent the tap holder and now it doesn't hold the tap without slipping so I switched to using a cresent wrench. I am using 3 In 1 oil in the process. I have tried to tap O1 drill rod and some zinc plated cold rolled steel from HD. Any ideas???

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#2

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

john lucas

>2 things. Use a lubricant. 3-1 is OK cutting fluid is better. I've used a mixture of kerosene and oil for years. It's been so long I don't even remember the mix.

You absolutely must keep the tap straight. A crescent wrench won't do that. It applies a sideways force. That's why the 2 handles tap handles are so good.

Don't forget to back the tap up a 1/4 revolution or so every single time you make a cut. This breaks the chip and lets the tap cut better with less force. Don't try to take too big of a cut. On taps that size a quarter to half revolution is all you get without too much binding.

Last but not least switch to a 1/4x28 thread tap. These have plenty of thread in even a thin piece of metal and it's a much beefier tap. 1/4x 20 may not have enough threads in thin metal.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#3

Steven Antonucci

Agree with John

steve antonucci

>I broke one tap once before I read a little bit about it. The key I found was to actually back out the tap and remove the shavings (WD-40 or similar). I hand thread the cutter and make another pass (1/2 turn or so). Repeat until done. It's a little slower, but my holes are a lot cleaner. Since I usually only cut a single hole, I don't mind.

Steve

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#4

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

arkie

>In addition to John's good advice, use the proper tap. There are 3 standard tap tapers available for commonly used thread sizes - starting, plug, and bottom. The starting tap has a longer lead-in and is used for startng the thread. The plug tap is a general purpose tap with a shorter lead-in, and the bottom tap is used for the last threads in a blind hole.

As soon as the tap starts to bind, back off until it eases, then proceed until it binds again. Wax also makes a good lubricant if you don't have oil.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#5

how to keep the tap straight

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>All the advice so far is spot on. The tap will raise a burr as it cuts and this burr can start to bind so when you back the tap out you only need to back it out enough to cut the burr off and then you can advance it to start another.

What john said about keeping the tap absolutely straight is the most important advice you will ever get for small holes, how to do it is another matter. For the home hobbyist there are two ways. If the work is flat and you have a drill press you can use a point tool mounted in the press to register in the depression on the end of the tap wrench. That is what it is there for. DO NOT TURN THE DRILL ON. The piece being tapped must be held in a vice or clamped in some way because one hand will be used on the drill press handle to keep LIGHT pressure on the tap wrench and the other hand will be used to turn the tap wrench. With this method the drill press in only used to keep the tap wrench centered not to apply any "cutting" pressure. I should have also mentioned that in theory you will have used the drill press to drill the correct sized hole and left it clamped in the exact same place to tap the threads.

A second method to keep the tap straight is a bit more advanced but much easier. Once you get the tap to catch one thread you apply a slight upward pressure as you turn it. As it catches a bit more on the first one or two turns you can give it more upward pressure as it turns. I am not sure why this works but it is something I learned as an apprentice.

Robin

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#6

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

GalenV

>Everyone has given good methods. 1/4 turn and back up. I find the lighter cutting oils or John's dilute oil best as the chips do not cling to tap as bad.

Whenever possible set the tap up on the drill press. There is just enough round shaft above the tap t-handle to stabilize it in the drill chuck. Just tighten the chuck enough to allow the tap handle to turn in the jaws. Use the right tap drill size and in harder materials you can use the next larger number drill and still get enough thread to hold.

This method worked fine for the five taps on my home made hollowing tool and jig to sharpen.


img

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#7

Robin, Beat me by two minutes :-)

GalenV

>

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#8

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

Greg Earley Brentwood Ca

>Hi James

The size of the drilled hole diameter is important. If the screws are going in too tight, the drilled hole may be to small. For a #10-24 the drill hole size should be a #21 drill. You can get the tap drill size from charts look at "mscdirect.com" supply they should have them or find one on the internet. You can also get excellent quality taps from them also. I calculate my drill hole diametrs. I've used spray lube before for tapping. Cutting fluids work best.

Start with drilling the tap drill hole first as straight as possible. Start the tap until it starts to grab, remove the wrench and place a square against the tap and your work piece to see if it's going straight. If it's tilted adjust it square. Continue cutting threads by going a quarter of a turn at a time with reversing the tap to break the chip. When you break the chip, be carefull not to twist the tap out of square. Keep checking for square to make sure the tap is going in straight. Once it's down in the material there not much of a way to adjust. The main thing is, keeping the tap straight, and if the tap starts to bind and get tight, stop and see what is causing it to bind. Don't force it thats when the taps break. If the flutes are getting full of chips remove the tap and clean them out.

Good quality taps and thread cutting fluid are your best shot.

Good luck

Greg Earley

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#9

Thanks guys! Great advice.

James McClure

>I will definitely try these suggestions. Hopefully my tapping will improve.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#10

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools *LINK*

Dick Coers

>Best $75 I ever spent for tapping. You can get some great torque on this, or be very gentle. Always square to the work. You get some collets for each tap size, so just plug in the tap of choice and cut. Only takes seconds to do and I haven't broke a tap since I bought one of these. I even was able to adapt it to one of my Beall wood taps for making desk toys of 1 1/4" bolts and nuts.


hand tapping machine

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#11

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

Ed in Leaside

>"I have tried to tap O1 drill rod and some zinc plated cold rolled steel from HD. Any ideas??? "

I think maybe you're using HD taps? I spent 5 years as a printing press field tech. My kit had taps from 2.5mm - 10mm, and I never broke one (German made taps). Last year I had to tap some(4) 10-32 ~5/8 deep in hot rolled from HD and used HD taps. Note the plural HD taps ... I went through 3 of them. As mentioned above, in addition to the other advise, use good taps. ;)

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#12

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

Pete LaBelle

>Taps are one of those things that "you get what you pay for". Cheap taps are often not very sharp and the steel is of questionable quality. Thus, they are more prone to breakage just as they jam up in the hole.

Remember, most taps are as hard if not harder than HSS drill bits, thus, if you break one off an can't grab it with pliers, you have a problem.

Good tools, proper sized holes & tap point, good lubricant, and a steady hand & good eye are needed for tapped holes.

Good luck !

Pete

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#13

T-handle, and where to buy good taps?

John K Jordan

>I dislike the long handle often included in tap and die sets. I far prefer a t-handle (similar to the picture below) when tapping by hand.

Ed, do you have a good source for quality taps? I rarely break one because I'm extremely paranoid and treat them like an egg shells, but I would love to get some better quality sets than what I found at the local Northern Tool.

JKJ


img

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: T-handle, and where to buy good taps?

keith tompkins

>HI John, I'm partial to the ratcheting tap handles...they used to cost about $50.00 each, but the cost has come down. Hansen taps are decent, they used to be carried by any hardware store. The lathe can be used to tap absolutely straight....the tap can be held in a chuck int the tailstock, the work can be rotated in the headstock while maintaining light pressure with the tailstock.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#15

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

Chuck Engstrom

>I don't own one of these but worked in a shop which has one, and it is a BIG help if you are doing a lot of this stuff.

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#16

John, I've used Vermont American

Allen Neighbors

>for several years with good results. Once in a while I do break on, but it's because of stupidity, not inferior tools. :)

I get them from Ace Hardware, sometimes. Other times I see them at flea markets.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#17

Re: I have a Craftsman set plus a few......

Jamie D

>... additions that I have been using for 30+ yrs. and they're still in great shape because I don't force anything. Using proper matching drill bits is a very important part of the successful project.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#18

Re: Thanks guys! Great advice.

Stephen Mushinski

>James,

The cutting fluid is use as a lubricant. 3 in 1 is very light, the best ones are more of a paste. One of the best is something called Anchor Lube, comes in a small bottle and is green in colour. But for the at home jobs something that works ok is shaving cream. A company called LPS sells stuff for metal cutting called Tapmatic Edge Cream which I swear is just come Gillette in a tube. Give it a try next time.

BTW: It is freezing rain with snow and cold wind in my neck of the wood just about every day now. Sure it is not time for a visit north and I show you everything you need to know about tapping! :)

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#19

Re: Tapping threads - one more thing

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>After you have drilled the proper sized hole, chamfer the edges of the hole

I use a single flute countersink bit and take only a slight amount off, no more than 1-1/2 times the depth of one thread. Just get rid of that sharp edge.

That helps center the tap and begin right for tapping a straight hole and it allows someplace for the little mushrooming of the material to go.

Metal machinist friend taught me this. Also looks great in threading other materials.

BTW, the single flute countersink bit is the best! It leaves no facets. Found in tool stores that specialize in tools.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#20

Re: T-handle, and where to buy good taps?

Ed in Leaside

>I haven't needed to buy a good tap for years, but if I did I'd ask my local machinist. I have a similar T-handle, with forward/reverse ratchet. Very handy for tight spots. ;)

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#21

Re: Spirals help also.

A.C.

>A spiral point configured tap will curl the chips around each other ahead of the cutting action and help to reduce friction and breakage. Let the chips get long or you are liable to have multiple chips vying for space in the same flute. They are great for through tapping but a bear in a blind hole. Spiral fluted taps will make a long curly chip in each flute which will flow up the flute like magic and eliminate the need for reversing to break the chip. Use them when machine tapping under power. You can drive them all the way to depth in one motion with a good cutting lubricant like Tap Magic. These type taps won't be hanging out at the borg beside the stuff they sell there.

The only countersink I like better than the single flute style is the Weldon which has a hole through it which forms the flute. If you are countersinking a larger diameter hole in steel with a multi-fluted tool, fold a piece of an old shop rag into four thicknesses and put it over the hole before power c'sinking on a machine. Just cut right through the cloth and let it spin with the tool to get a chatterless finish.

Re: Tapping threads in homemade tools

#22

Re: Spirals help also.

bill Crommett

>What a great tutorial on machine shop practice. It is something you won't find on a wood turning site -- NEVER.