What size hollowing tool for ornaments?
wilbur
>I was going to make some ornaments, about 2-3 " in diameter.
How do I know what size of a hollowing tool I would need for this?
Is there a problem with using a hollowing tool that's "too big"?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What size hollowing tool for ornaments?
wilbur
>I was going to make some ornaments, about 2-3 " in diameter.
How do I know what size of a hollowing tool I would need for this?
Is there a problem with using a hollowing tool that's "too big"?
Re: What size hollowing tool for ornaments?
john lucas
>Wilbur The only problem with a tool that is too large would be the entry hole. I usually make my finials out of either 3/4 or 1" stock. I make my entry hole about 1/2" so using a tool that is 3/8" thick makes it hard to reach all the areas. On ornaments from 2 to 3" deep I like to use a 5/16 tools. It vibrates much less than 1/4" at this depth. You can use a 1/4" tool but you have to take smaller cuts. I use my 1/4" tools for 1 1/2 to 2" deep.
Re: What size hollowing tool for ornaments?
Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville
>Bob Rosand makes and sells a hollowing tool that is ideal for small ornaments. He sells them for $20 + shipping. They are a High Speed Steel cutter silver-soldered to a mild steel shaft and a handle that Bob makes. And best of all, if (or when) you sharpen the cutter away, return the tool and he will replace the cutter for the cost of shipping. Now that is a true life-time guarentee!
No affiliation, I just like the guy.
Re: What size hollowing tool for ornaments?
Fog Tanner
>A couple of years ago at our club Retreat, I was in a class making ornaments the size you describe. For hollowing, the instructor had made up several hollowing tools. They were made from 1/4" allen wrenchs glued into a handle. The "short end" had been ground unto a scraper and worked quiet well. A drill to set the depth and get some working room and the Allenscraper for the rest.I made several using that tool and they all came out OK. For a couple of bucks at the local hardware store, you can't go wrong. You can make some smaller ones using smaller Allen wrenchs if you want to try some really small ornaments or hollow forms.
Fog
Re: What size hollowing tool for ornaments?
Greg Haugen
>Wilbur,
I have Bob Rosand's hollowers and like them alot. Dealing with Bob is an absolute pleasure. I'd recommend two of them. I have two, one has a shorter bit than the other. I use them in sequence, start with the shorter bit and then go to the longer bit. $40 plus shipping you'd have the bent tools covered. In conjuction with these tools I also use a 1/4" square scraper that is ground to a round nose profile for the "straight" work. Packard sells this scraper as part of a set but you can buy it seperately but I also have one that's "Homemade" from a blank of 1/4 square HSS that's handled.
Allen Wrenches are another option that are handled and sharpened. They do work. Dick Sing is the turner that should be credited for it.
If you also think you'd like to make "mini" or smaller hollow forms, more than a 2" squat sphere, I'd recommend investing in a set of Kelton Mini Hollowers with the small handle. You'd have a straight and two different "hook" tools, along with the additional handle I know some turners turn up to 4-6" inches with them. If you're mindful of tool rest position and the hook tools-these won't "torque" at all. They other two previous do torque since they're cutter isn't in line with the shaft but at that size the others work just fine.
Don Derry has a pretty interesting "hollower" for ornaments too.
Greg H.
Allen wrenches
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I use 3/16" and 5/32" Allen wrenches held in a drill chuck mounted on a handle. The 3/16" is good for deep, the 5/32" is good for inside by the opening. I hollow through a 3/8" hole.
Get them here *LINK*
Mike Cunningham
>Great tools at a great price, perfect for ornaments.
Rosand tools
Re: What size hollowing tool for ornaments? *LINK*
John K Jordan
>Wilber,
A couple of years ago I bought the set of three small HSS "Mini Hollow-Form" tools that Sorby sells - straight, bent, and swan (link below). These work very well, but the price is outrageous. The one Rosand sells looks like a much better deal. However, both the straight and swan-necked are very handy at times. Fortunately, no one can see the inside of an ornament.
The one at the bottom of the picture below was the most challenging to hollow for me. (These are some I made last year, my first attempt at ornaments. The biggest I did were about 2" in diameter.)
Re: Using Key Stock
gtwilkins
>I have been making scrapers (bent and straight) out of square key stock that I have been buying from Napa Auto Parts. They had it in sizes from 1/8 to 1/2 inch and 12 inches long for just a couple of dollars.
Easy to sharpen and bend cold and holds an edge well, don't now what kind of steel it is. I have been using file handles with the wire wrapped spring ferrule for the smaller sizes.
Trevor
Everything you need to know
steve antonucci
>When hollowing any enclosed form, there are only a few things that you need to know (and you probably already know them).
1.) The entry hole dictates the maximum diameter of the tool stock. You cannot put a 1/2" bar through a 1/4" hole, no matter how hard you try.
2.) The smaller the hole, the smaller the bar. You will get to a point where the bar is not sufficiently stiff enough to cut without vibrating. The longer you overhang, the more likely the vibration will occur. In addition, if your tool is "bent" in any way (alan key, bent O1, small Ellsworth, etc) where the cutting tip is not in line with the shaft, you will start to encounter rotational forces through the tip. If you have a small hole, a minor catch can easily damage the entry hole and ruin the piece.
3.) For ornaments in particular, I think 3/8"-1/2" holes are fine, and I commonly use a 1/4" tool in O1. Almost the entire globe can be hollowed out to 1/8" with a single bent O1 tool, although I sometime undercut with a 3/16" allen key just because I have more clearance at the entry hole and less of a chance of damaging it. It pays to blow out chips frequently, as they tend to pack up and force the cutters off centerline, which can cause bad things to happen.
4.) You do not need to buy anything. Start with two allen keys. Cut the bend off of one (1/4") and sharpen it like a fingernail profile scraper. Cut most of the bend off of the second(3/16"), leaving about +/-1/2" and sharpen it the same way. Drill two holes in two small dowel and a drop of CA, and you are ready to turn ornaments.
Hope this helps.
Steve
Re: What size hollowing tool for ornaments?
robert davis
>i use a 3/16" allen wrench cut off and ground as roundnose scrsper
Re: An old Phillips screwdriver with....
Jamie D
>........a 1/4" round shaft makes a very serviceable hollowing tool, and it already has a handle.
And they hold an edge very well.
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I made one many years ago and still use it - a club member did a tool making demo on that after he attended a David Ellsworth class. Cheap ($1) screwdrivers work very well.