Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Posts

Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#1

Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

john lucas

>I applaud Mr. Steussy for his invention. I think it has a place and he may work out a way to make it more functional for the masses. These kind of inventors are what has made our country successful.

I've seen lots of gadgets over the years, some very useful and successful and some not so. It got me wondering what you all have seen that didn't make it or at least wasn't as successful as it could have been.

There are some that actually are successful that I first thought were silly. The Resp-o-rator is one of those. I still think it's silly but he's obviously sold quite a few of those. I just don't think I want to wear snorkling gear when I turn. Shows how wrong I was about that. I should tell you I predicted the end of movie theaters 20 years ago when video became popular. We have since built a brand new 20 theater monster here in town. I don't bet in Vegas either.

I love Ron Browns new ornamental lathe attachment for the Jet mini. For those who don't know this is a $1500 dollar attachment to your $300 jet mini. I'd love to have one and hope he's successful. I doubt there is much of a market but time will tell.

I don't remember the name but the vacuum gouge was a dog waiting to happen in my mind. It's a neat idea, a round tube that is sharpened on one end and has a vacuum on the other. The idea was you could vacuum up the chips while you turn. The problem was it doesn't hold an edge very long and clogs too easily. Good idea and it may have sold more than I think but I don't ever see one in turners shops.

VicMarc had an electronic ornamental attachment to a lathe that apparently didn't sell very well. It had a sort of solenoid that would take cutters and you put a spindle locating sensor on the lathe. The cutter could then be programmed to touch the wood a certain number of times per revolution and produce what looked a lot like ornamental work. Cool idea, expensive, and apparently not successful.

I can't remember any more off the top of my head but I know they are there.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#3

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Cyril Griesbach

>I'll take a shot at this, John, but I could be wrong. I'm thinking of the tailstock swingers by Oneway, Vicmark and the aftermarket one for the Powermatic. While being able to move the tailstock out of the way rather than having to lift it off is a mighty fine thing. None of these actually get it "out of the way". They're just "on the side" in my opinion.

Now the Robust is an entirely different matter. It's down and away so when turning at the end of the ways the turner has lots of room to swing the tools. Not so with the others.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#4

I agree, The Robust is the right idea.

john lucas

>

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#5

Hey, I liked the Corvair

john lucas

>Ralph Nadar killed that one.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#6

Re: How About The Edsel And Corvair?

Ron in Drums PA

>The Edsel came out as a high priced car in a time of recession and was more a marketing disaster than a engineering failure. Many of the new features that Edsel introduced where used in the Comet, one of Fords most popular selling cars. The original name for the Comet was the Edsel Comet and the first cars off the line had an embossed "E" in many of it's components such as tail lights and keys. A mint condition Edsel can fetch $100,000 and convertible up to $200,000 today.

Many of the Edsel's features, such as transmission lock on ignition, adjustable brakes, gear selection as steering wheel buttons etc, which were considered "too impractical" in the late 1950s, are today standard features of sports cars.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#7

Re: Hey, I liked the Corvair

GalenV

>I have a friend that has two Corvair.

One he has had since high school and he is over 60 now.

They(car AND friend) are not dead yet. :-)

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#8

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I'll never forget when they adapted the Flow-bee hair cutting attachment for the vacuum cleaner to operate for roughing bowls on a lathe. I thought for sure it would work. That's the last time I trust Ron Popeil when it comes to turning tools! ;-)

Tom

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#9

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

mfoster

>I was recently browsing to price a gadget that, in my mind, really did make it but seems to be no longer available. I was looking for a box threading jig (not thread chasers) and could not come up with one. Bonnie Klein used to make one for her lathe, but I believe it also had adapters for Jet mini's. Seems like someone else used to make one as well.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#10

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>You're probbly thinking of the Baxter Threadmaster. It's Marketed by Bestwood tools.

Wally

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#11

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

john lucas

>Bonnie Klein still makes her threader but it does require spacers to fit other lathes. Bestwoodtools makes the Baxter threader and Vic will make it to fit any lathe. There are also plans to make a wooden one floating around on the web. I think Fred Holder has a photo of a homemade theader in his book on threading.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#12

Re: Hey, I liked the Corvair

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>There are two of them still cruisin' the streets of Sunny Saint Cloud.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#13

Re: How About The Edsel And Corvair?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>My youngest brother had two of the convertibles and one hardtop. Not all at the same time. My mother always liked him better then me.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#14

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Cyril, I have a shortbed Oneway lathe. I have the tailstock swinger and it sure works for me. I do most of my turning on an outboard bed, but with the tailstock in place on the inboard bed, it's difficult to use a long handled tool. The swinger takes care of this. Also, a plus...the swinger effectively adds several inches to the bed, which allows me to turn, drill, etc. longer pieces.

Wally

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#15

Studebaker Avanti

john lucas

>Now that was a classic that died. I still like those. I see one around town every now and then.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#16

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Paul Waddle

>Bonnie still makes the threading jig, and Baxter does too. They are round parts and very easy to make on a cnc machining center. Price is what is holding them back,as well as price on the articulaing hollow forming tools. Quality,price,availability,marketing and,not the least,timing. Say what ever happened to the 50miles per gallon carb GM and the oil companies bought up?? Its not what was patented,it what was invented.. and thats the rest of the story..... pw

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

keith tompkins

>Hi Paul, The 50 mpg carb is a myth, I believe. An internal combustion engine needs a correct air/fuel ratio to run effeciently, about 17:1 . Much leaner, the engine self-destructs; either a valve burns, or the heat generated by the lean mixture will burn a hole through a piston, or the engine will detonate itself to death. 1950's technology couldn't create materials cabable of withstanding such a lean mixture for any length of time, even with a water-injection system. Also, carburetors are notoriously inefficient, accurate to perhaps 20 percent under ideal conditions. Modern computerized fuel injection systems, with feedback controls, are accurate within 1/10 of 1 percent...my Toyota Yaris with variable valve control with a tiny 1.5 liter engine gets 42 mpg on the highway. I cannot imagine a 50's or 60's engine in a typical body/frame configuration getting anywhere close to that.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Studebaker Avanti

keith tompkins

>Hey John, One of my favorite cars is the Studebaker Hawk series designed by Raymond Lowry....still beautiful and modern looking today.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#19

Re: How About The Edsel And Corvair?

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>My dad owned an Edsel and that is the car I used for driving lessons. There was nothing mechanically wrong with the car, the front end was just ugly. Ours was a powder blue with wood panel sided station wagon.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#20

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Paul Waddle

>Don't forget me John,I will be glad to help anyone make a threader, and, of any practical threads per inch. People get the wrong impression and compare wood threading to metal-metal is tedious,wood threading is a breeze. pw

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#21

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Paul Waddle

>You are much more knowledgeable on the subject than I,BUT,we really don't know the inside story... What is that about GM wrecking the mass transit system in California in the 30's? Having been involved with the human race for some 69 + yrs,I really don't believe the corporate good,is the mainstreet good.

I really believe it will take techological advances to support man kind in the future and outstrip the manipulation of big business.JMHO,pw

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#22

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Cyril Griesbach

>I understand your point, Wally but I still see it as being in the way with a long handled tool because it's still up above the ways.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

keith tompkins

>Hey Paul, We are in complete agreement here. I don't recall seeing the word "corporation" in the Constitution or bill of rights.

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#24

Re:My Dad's Flight Hawk Studebaker...

Jamie Donaldson

>...was one of my favorite cars to drive- it had a great overdrive for long distance gas saving on the open road. But then my wife also had an early Corvair, and I spun it off an Interstate ramp once when the rear end suspension overloaded w/o sway bars. Sure didn't corner well like my Austin Healey Sprite!!!!

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

#25

Re: Woodturning gadgets that didn't make it

Fog Tanner

>That number is really around 12.5:1 to 13.5:1 for power going down the highway. 16:1 would be on the upper end for fuel economy but less power. That is also on the highside where you can start to fry parts. Lean only makes power up to a point, then you start loosing power and generating excessive heat. A lot of street cars use something in the 14:1-15:1 range and let the computer adjust the mixture to control the heat. The air temp will have a lot to do with the mixture. My Stihl came with the EPA settings that were borderlin lean in cool weather and lean on hot days. It no longer has the EPA settings and runs like it should, has more power, can run on hot days and will last longer.

There is a lot more to it than just the fuel delivery. You can get good milage from a carb that is adjusted right and have the correct intake and exhaust manifolds (runner lengths and shape). There is also a lot that goes into performance with different camshaft grinds, combustion chambers, valving arrangements, even the spark coils. With the junk they sell for gasoline these days, you are pretty much stuck with the compression ratios.

In the '60s, Hot Rod Magazine built what they called the Pollution Packer, which was a street rod that used aftermarket over the counter parts. They got less pollution than was mandated in California and achived with all the smog pumps. They also got up around 30 MPG out of a small block Chevy V8 with a carb.

I remember the story about the carb, it was designed built by either Fireball Roberts or Junior Johnson, but I never heard the actual milage associated with it. There was another part, which was written up in Popular Science in the early-mid sixties. The guy designed a head which fit on a Ford striaght 6, that had a preignition chamber. It would run on anything that would burn, gasoline, diesel, kerosene, - whale blubber if you could melt it and pour it in the tank. It got decent milage depending on the fuel and you ddin't need to change things out when switching fuels. Texaco bought it up and it was never seen again.