Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

tools for turning finials

Posts

tools for turning finials

#1

tools for turning finials

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>Amid the current conversation regarding spindle gouges and skews, what does the collective brain trust here have to say about turning tools for the elusive 'perfect' finial.

I now have Doug Thompson's 1/4" detail gouge and 3/4" skew. The skew has lost its mystery for me. I just need more practice with it, but it is not the scary tool it had been make out to be. And I can wait until the first quarter of next year for another skew if need be.

So...the question is, what tool[s] should be on my wish list in my quest to turn elegant finials someday?

Re: tools for turning finials

#2

Re: tools for turning finials

Greg Haugen

>Carol,

I'd say you have a pretty nice set there. For really fine details, ornament finial details, I'll use a 1/4" round skew. I do also like my 3/8" Thompson detail gouge. In general, I prefer small gouges and skews for finials. As the turning gets smaller and finer the more practice is required.

See ya again in a little over a week.

Greg H.

Re: tools for turning finials

#3

Re: tools for turning finials

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I like to use a 1/4" detail gouge and/or a 1/4" skew, depending on the style and look of the finial I am turning.

keithz

Re: tools for turning finials

#4

Re: tools for turning finials

Michael Stafford

>Carol, first of all let me write a disclaimer by saying I was not able to turn a finial that looked much better than a bumpy stick until I had the opportunity to spend some time with Ed Moore at John C. Campbell a while back.

Ed uses a 1/4" Packard 2030 bowl gouge, a small 1/2" spindle roughing gouge, a 1/4" round skew and a 3/8" spindle gouge. I learned to use those tools or similar ones by watching him and he also gave my some personalized instruction. In one week I went from bumpy sticks to something that resembled a pretty decent icicle on an urchin ornament. I have continued to make progress but I don't think anyone will mistake my work for Cindy Drozda's. The 1/4" bowl gouge is very easy to control and I was amazed at how easy it was to control the 1/4" round skew.

The moral of this story is that good instruction allows you to make progress in much less time than you would trying to teach yourself.

Re: tools for turning finials

#5

Re:I turn most of my finials with a........

Jamie Donaldson

>....1/2" spindle gouge with a long rounded over bevel, and sharpen it with my Wolverine jig. The jig settings are different from the bowl gouge settings, and the hard part is to remember to reset the jig for the proper tool! In some places I have also been using Ed Moore's 1/4" round skew with some success, and I thank him for his instructions at the recent notorious Folk School gathering of the box clan!

Re: tools for turning finials

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: tools for turning finials

keith tompkins

>Carol, You can always buy new tools as the need arises. I would recommend focusing on technique, using the tools you already have. Begin to study successful finials, and arrange to learn to turn finials from the very best. Form and proportion are just as important in finials as they are in bowls or hollow forms, maybe even more so. Begin to keep a sketch book of pleasing finials, then study to find out what it is about the finials you like that make them successful. I think you will discover that beads and coves are crucial to good finials, as are filets to separate the elements within the finial. Remember that finials are simply spindle turnings, and the techiques for good spindle work must be mastered.

Re: tools for turning finials

#7

Re: tools for turning finials

John K Jordan

>Carol,

I use a 1/2" skew a lot and a 1/4" skew some, especially for deep groves and to add very sharp detail and for smooth tapers and near-vertical steps. However, the smaller spindle gouges are more useful in general. You usually don't have enough working room on a finial to make the best use of a 1/2" skew.

One thing about using a spindle gouge on very thin spindles - if you try to cut with the tip there is a danger of the wood flexing downwards and causing a dig-in and possibly snapping the piece. When transitioning from coming down the steep side of a cove into the bottom or a flat or when planing down the shaft, if you push the tool a little further forward you can cut with the edge instead of the tip, almost exactly like, you guessed it, using a skew! In this orientation the tool is almost impossible to catch.

What I DON'T like in a small detail gouge is a long shaft from the handle. For tiny work many times it's best to hold the tool one-handed while using the other hand to steady the work or support the tool with the thumb. Six or seven inches from the handle to the tip is way too much for me but many tools are built that way. I have a variety of 1/4" spindle gouges and the one I reach for first is the one with perhaps 4" of metal. Even the smaller Thompson detail gouges are a little too long for me so I plan on cutting some of the tip.

The little round skew you can make yourself from a piece of rod is very nice for little things, but the same thing about length applies. I got one from Ed Moore a while back and it is nice, but again, too long and very hard to control. I ground another from a 1/" rod and made another handle with a collet I got from Frank Penta. This handle has an 7" hole down the center and allows me to sink most of the rod in the handle and extend just a few inches of working length. The handle itself is only about 8" long and it is very easy to use and control.

BTW, Doug Thompson sells 3/8" rods of that very good steel he uses for people who want to grind their own tools. He may have some 1/4" later and if so, I'm going to try to get some.

JKJ

Re: tools for turning finials

#8

It depends...

davidwalser

>Carol,

Finials come in different shapes and sizes. Just as you might use different tools to turn different parts of a table leg, so, too, you're apt to use different tools for your finials. I prefer using my skew for beads and tapers and a gouge for coves. Others are more comfortable using a gouge for all these shapes. I prefer using as large a skew (or gouge) as will fit. I've large hands and I find larger tools are steadier and more comfortable for me to use -- even on fine details. Again, others might feel differently.

I strongly recommend Cindy Drozda's video: Fabulous Finial Box. She spends a lot of time showing and explaining how she turns a finial. If I recall correctly, she never picks up a skew. Here's a link to Craft Supplies description of the video: Fabulous Finial Box

Good luck!

Re: tools for turning finials

#9

Re: tools for turning finials

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carol, the 1/4 in. detail gouge and the skew will be all you'll need. I use a 1/2 in. skew, a 1/4 and a 3/8 spindle gouge for my finials.

Many of us think in terms of too many tools. Of course, as you know, I have about 40 tools on my tool rack, and even more stashed away. However, many of those tools are from way back, 20 or 30 years, and are seldom used.

I agree with Keith on the sketch book. I have drawings of a lot of finials that I like and others that I thought I liked when I drew the sketch. A sketch book is something that every turner should have. Ideas and thoughts come and go but if you get sketches of your ideas it'll always be there.

Wally

Re: tools for turning finials

#10

Re: tools for turning finials

john lucas

>Carol I use 4 tools. A rough out gouge, parting tool, detail gouge and skew. It depends on the size of finial which size tools I use. For xmas ornaments I use an off brand mini rough out gouge, a Sorby mini rough out gouge that I reground to resemble a continental gouge which is somewhat like my Detail gouge, a 1/4" skew and 3/16" parting tool.

Re: tools for turning finials

#11

Mike Stafford has accurately described...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>the tools except for one. Doug Thompson sent me a 3/8" round tool that had been ground like a "skewchigouge". I sharpened it some more on the Jet Wet Grinder, honed it, and it has become a "go to" tool. It is great for finish cuts on finials. It is less grabby than either the detail gouge or the skew. I have also switched from using a Thompson 3/8" regular spindle gouge to a Thompson 3/8" detail gouge. I use the detail gouge for most rounded cuts and the 1/4" round skew for vee work.

I recommend the Thompson 3/8" detail gouge and the Thompson "skewchigouge" to anyone beginning to turn finials.

Ed

Re: tools for turning finials

#12

About Finials...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>A few things that I have learned about turning finials.....

For most purposes most turners seem to make them too large and bulky for the piece it's being turned for. I want a finial to appear graceful and almost fragile. My early finials were much too heavy looking.

I find that getting a good match with the right proportions on the piece and on the finial is quite difficult and requires some experimenting. I have a supply of finials that I've decided didn't work. I usually am able to use them on other pieces later.

I turn my finials using very small chuck jaws and using the tailstock center very lightly for support.

I turn finials working toward the headstock instead of the tailstock as many turners do.

Use well defined coves, beads, fillets with sharp corners etc.

Keep it simple. Many finials suffer from too much detail.

I like the idea of having no two dimensions the same.

I, like many turners use ebony for most of my finials. I buy pen blanks, 20 at a time for a good price. They are just about the perfect size for most finial blanks.

Wally

Re: tools for turning finials

#13

Dick Hines

Re: Mike Stafford has accurately described...

Dick Hines

>I use one of Dougs 3/8" detail gouges that I have changed the grind so it is more pointy. It works a lot like a shew. I will rough turn the blank with a 5/8" bowl gouge to get it to the shape I want.

The detail gouge is my go tool for finials, big or small.

Re: tools for turning finials

#14

Re: tools for turning finials-Wow!

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>A bunch of really good info. It goes into my files.

I do have a sketch book, and use it. I use it to sketch bowl profiles as well! And all those pictures that are posted that represent really good proportions are also saved.

I have Cindy's DVD, and I am working on absorbing it.

I have a bunch of cut-offs to rip into practice stock.

I'll go with the tools I have until the opportunity presents itself to learn something new.

I have a great club here as well. So I will get a few opportunities to make shavings during the next two months as I have time available.

And, I'll see Mike week after next. I'll bring my camera, Mike!

And Jamie, I will try to get to Oshkosh in November, weather permitting.

Finally, the brain trust that resides here never fails. Thanks, all.

Nine and half weeks and I will be home! With a file folder of stuff to do!

Re: tools for turning finials

#15

Same tools here Wally, but

Carole Valentine

>I am considering trying one of Doug's detail gouges because my spindle gouge is getting so short!

Re: tools for turning finials

#16

Steven Antonucci

You already have them

steve antonucci

>As Wally indicated, most turners have too many tools. I'm guilty too, but luckily I made most of mine, so they're not real expensive.

To turn an elegant finial, you need a skew or a spindle gouge. Either one works and both can produce the results you want, but they both require an eye for detail and the proper use of the tool. Most turners assume that they can't do something because they don't have one more tool, and that's really way off base.

At a recent club function, I was working with some new turners on "the basics" and we were turning bowls. For the entire day, I used only one bowl gouge. One of them looked at me and mentioned that I never switched tools (he was somewhat perplexed by it), so I put down my bowl gouge an grabbed a detail gouge to sharpen up a dovetail for a bowl, then went right back to the bowl gouge.

If you own a spindle gouge and a skew, you can turn a finial. Practice on scraps, then practice some more. Turn sticks. Roll beads, cut coves. Once you know how to make the shapes, you can start applying it to design.

Steve

Re: tools for turning finials

#17

The "skewchigouge" is excellent on...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>the inside of Bowls! In a larger diameter with the same grind will give a very nice clean cut. Tearout from the side wall to the bottom doesn't occur because it's a different type cut. I'll have some time to work on this tool after SWAT.

Re: tools for turning finials

#18

Re: The "skewchigouge" is excellent on...

davidwalser

>Doug,

I went to your website yesterday looking for the skewchigouge and could not find it among the tools listed. (No doubt this is a matter of user error. I keep trying to get a better user, but they're always out of stock.) Where should I have been looking?

Re: tools for turning finials

#19

ebony pen blanks

John K Jordan

>>I, like many turners use ebony for most of my finials.

>I buy pen blanks, 20 at a time for a good price.

Wally,

Denis Yoder was looking for a source of ebony pen blanks. Can you recommend a source?

JKJ

Re: tools for turning finials

#20

Re: ebony pen blanks

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The last bunch I bought was from Craft Supplies...

Wally

Re: tools for turning finials

#21

you can also try... *LINK*

Steven Kubien

>...William Woodwrite. Bill carries ebony blanks, though since I do not use ebony, I cannot comment on his prices. HTH

Steve Kubien


ebony pen blanks

Re: tools for turning finials

#22

"skewchigouge" is made from...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The 3/8 blank is purchased to make a round skew, 3 point tool and the skewchigouge. Ron in Drums PA (Sardo)has a picture of the way he ground the tool posted on another site... hopefully he can post it here.

In two weeks everything should settle down so I'll have time to start working again. Last weekend my youngest daughter was married, this weekend we place my mom in a nursing home and next weekend SWAT. Life is busy...

Re: tools for turning finials

#23

Here you go Doug  *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>


"Flute"less gouge

Re: tools for turning finials

#24

The "skewchigouge" is made from ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>3/8" round steel that Doug provides. Start by grinding a "flat" on the "top" at one end so that you are left with 1/4" or more of tool thickness. Then I put it in my Varigrind and Wolverine just like I was grinding a detail gouge. You end up with a tool shaped like a detail gouge, but without a flute. Check Packard which carries the Crown skewchigouge.

I ground my skewchigouge on a Jet Wet Grinder after Doug rough-ground it to shape. After grinding, I honed both surfaces. What I wrote above is what I would do if I didn't have the Wet Grinder. I felt that that description would relate to more people.

Ed

Re: tools for turning finials

#25

Re: Ron a question

GalenV

>Ron:

Read your info on the link. Being "green" I am not sure I follow how tool is used on the inside of a bowl. You say:

"I start cutting at the outside edge at around 45 degrees with the tip pointing at around 1:00 o'clock (I never really measured it) and by the time I'm at the center, this tool is almost at 3 o'clock. I never had a problem with the tool skating."

Looking into a bowl do you mean you start at the 45 on the upper left quadrant? The "tip pointed" at 1 or the "top flat" (fluteless top)pointed to 1? Move in and down to center of bowl and top flat of tool at 3 or just about facing out of bowl? Is this just the tip riding the surface?

Am I confussed?

Galen Trying to learn bear with me PLEASE.