Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

My 'nucci Hollower Broke

Posts

My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#1

My 'nucci Hollower Broke

Jerry McCaffrey

>My small hollowing tool, designed and fabricated by noted Wood Central toolmaker, Steve Antonucci broke today. I wad doing a small osage orange hollowform at a NJ Woodturners demo today. While undercutting the rim the tool snapped like a stale breadstick. Fortunately I was able to finish the piece with a Bob Rosand hollowing tool and the bowl gouge used was from Doug Thompson. Certainly Bob and Doug would warranty their fine products. So after giving workshops and demo's to his club, does Steve stand by his design? His response here will tell whether Steve can make it in this competitive tool making market :)

Jerry


img

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#2

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

John K Jordan

>Jerry,

Have a torch or know someone who does? You could braze the two pieces back together and they will probably be strong as ever.

JKJ

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#3

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

Jerry McCaffrey

>Yes I have a torch and will just heat, bend, regrind, retemper and have a slightly shorter tool. Thanks for the suggestion though. I'm just doing some friendly busting on Steve.

Jerry

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#4

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

Dick Coers

>Have you done that John? Seems to me the heat treat will be impossible to hold with the torch heat, and brazing material in the joint would limit any heat treating after the bar was repaired. I would also be curious if the braze joint would hold up to all that vibration of the cut.

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#5

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

John K Jordan

>Yikes, I didn't realize the shaft itself was hardened and part of the cutting tip - from the picture I thought it was mild steel with a small hardened insert. Is it HSS? When I first started welding I thought of brazing more as a second-class patch, but I found out it is actually incredibly strong and can be done such that it can leave less stress in the surrounding metal than electrical welding. I haven't tried brazing any HSS, but if it's anything like carbon steel I think it would probably hold up to use on the lathe. However, I think you're right that it would create future heat treatment problems.

I especially like brazing since it's the only good way I have to fix cast iron, to join dissimilar metals, and to fix small things cleanly.

JKJ

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#6

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

Jerry McCaffrey

>FYI it's 01 steel that was bent, ground, and then heated and quenched in oil. There was no tip of dissimilar material. The shaft fractured almost straight across clean. Osage Orange is tough stuff!

Jerry

It's all of a $3 tool that worked well - until today.

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#7

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

john lucas

>He must leave them harder than I do. I anneal my hollowing tools at 425 degrees and haven't had one break yet. I think Steve should give you at least 2 as a replacement. :)

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#8

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville

>For what it is worth, Bob Rosand silver solders the HSS tips onto his hollowing tools. Incidentally, he will put a new tip on the tool for you if the original becomes too short due to sharpening. How's that for a warrenty!

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#9

Steven Antonucci

30 day money back guarantee-

steve antonucci

>Oh, wait, it was free ;-)

As you have indicated below, a quick regrind to get an edge, bend in a vise, and heat treatment and you're back in business.

I still haven't see a hollowform at one of the club meetings?

Steven

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#10

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

Jerry McCaffrey

>I don't think I could take Bob up on a replacement tip. When he was demoing at our club he ran out of tools for sale and gave me the one he was using for free as a "used tool." That's a real nice guy. If it wears down, I think I'll just buy another

Jerry

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#11

Re: 30 day money back guarantee-

Jerry McCaffrey

>Yes free, after I paid a $15 workshop fee and drove 120 miles round trip! See if you had come to the Essex County Fall Festival for the demonstration you would have seen one in action (at least for a few minutes).

I also know why it shattered. I was hollowing into osage orange pith that had some radial cracks and I'm sure it hit one. It seemed to break near the tempering boundry.

Jerry

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#12

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

John K Jordan

>Brazing with sliver solder makes the nicest joints of all, and super strong.

I have a confession: when I started welding I went to a local welder supply house to buy a bunch of supplies and some gas and wire equipment and I told them I was interested in silver soldering as well and asked for recommendations on rods. The guy went in the back and brought me a container full of a variety of sliver solder rods to try at no charge! That was perhaps 15-20 years ago and I still haven't used them up. (save them for special things) I need to make amends with them someday or at least remember them in my will.

JKJ

Re: My 'nucci Hollower Broke

#13

Steven Antonucci

I was at Millbrook Days with 4 kids

steve antonucci

>The wife had play tickets with the women folk, so I took the kids to Millbrook Day at Millbrook Village. Otherwise, I might have prevented such a tragedy!

The picture you show is a clear indication of a hardened fracture. When you reheat the end, make a much shorter bend at about 30 degrees. The short tipped (1/2")ones never break...and I only use the really long bent ones for undercutting across the top of a vessel.

You can call me if you need help with it, or just bring it to the next meeting and I'll pack the stuff we need to harden it...

Steve