Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Holdfast on sale *LINK*

Posts

Holdfast on sale *LINK*

#1

Holdfast on sale *LINK*

Rick Davenport

>I know this has been discussed before.

Hartville Tool has the Holdfast Vacuum Chuck System on sale.

It's tempting.

Anybody have/use one?

Updated opinions?

R


http://www.hartvilletool.com/product/12964?sc=TS0805

Re: Holdfast on sale *LINK*

#2

Re: Holdfast on sale *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Rick,

I'm not familiar with it, but I see that to generate a vacuum it uses "a pair of unique high efficiency venturi elements". This means you have to run compressed air through it so I would wonder about the noise. Venturi systems I am familiar with are quite noisy and need a continuous air stream so the compressor may be running a lot which may add to the noise. As I said, though, I haven't seen or heard this one in action so maybe it's quiet.

I'm sure the lathe components could be used with an alternate vacuum source, some of which are pretty quiet. You might find the article below interesting.

JKJ


Al Crandall's DIY vacuum system

Re: Holdfast on sale *LINK*

#3

Re: Holdfast on sale

John K Jordan

>BTW, I see if you search google for Holdfast Vacuum Chuck you will find a lot to read, especially on the AAW forum.

JKJ

Re: Holdfast on sale *LINK*

#4

Re: Holdfast on sale

Curly Smith

>For the $169 that the Vacuum Generator costs you can buy a vacuum pump and not have to run your compressor. If you have an idle industrial sized compressor with an auxiliary storage tank then venturi vacuum "pumps" are great but they don't really work all that well on a lathe with small shop compressors

If you're just looking for a cheap way to determine if vacuum chucking is for you then might look at these configurations for using your shop vac:

Vacuum Chucking using a Vacuum Cleaner

cheap alternative

Both of the links tell you how to connect the shop vac without buying an adapter but the Vacuum Adapter that's on sale might make things easier. The downsides of the shop vac method are low vacuum and a skull shattering high-pitched whine. The upside is that it's an inexpensive way explore vacuum chucking.

Re: Holdfast on sale *LINK*

#5

Re: Holdfast on sale

JohnKyler

>I got the same thing at Rockler on closeout for $65.

And yes it was the whole kit.

John

Re: Holdfast on sale *LINK*

#6

Re: Holdfast on sale

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Rick,

I use the gast rotary vane vacuum pump from Surpluscenter.com. I bought one of the members of our club the one that you are inquiring about. It is excellent. It requires a compressor, but uses very little air. Also, the venturi system is very quiet. Every Tuesday night about 15-20 turners meet at my friends shop and and do some turning and brain storming. Everyone chipped in to make a gesture of thanks for using his shop. Since he got his, I think 5 or 6 others guys have got one as well. If I didn't have my vacuum pump(which requires 220) I would definitely get the Holdfast system. This opinion is shared by all the members who have seem it work and also used or bought one.

Mike

Re: Holdfast on sale *LINK*

#7

Thanks for the info Gentlemen.

Rick Davenport

>