Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Wood ID

Posts

Wood ID

#1

Wood ID

Carole Valentine

>A friend brought me these sample of a wood he is trying to identify. The little dark things at the base of the leaf stems should be a clue I would think. Any one know?


img

Re: Wood ID

#2

Bark

Carole Valentine

>Bark pic


img

Re: Wood ID

#3

End grain

Carole Valentine

>Very tight grain. Some picks and lavender shades.


img

Re: Wood ID

#4

Long grain

Carole Valentine

>Rough cut


img

Re: Wood ID

#5

Re: Wood ID

Sean Troy

>From all the pictures, it looks like Walnut to me.

Re: Wood ID

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wood ID

keith tompkins

>HI Carole, Look at the base of the leaves, notice the starting point is not symmetrical....an reliable indication of elm. The wood appears so also.

Re: Wood ID

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wood ID

keith tompkins

>Forgot, look closely at the grain pattern...elm has a zig-zag pattern. That would be the clincher.

Re: Wood ID

#8

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Wood ID

Leo Van Der Loo

>Siberian Elm looks exactly like that, I have turned lots of it, and have a big tree growing behind my house.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Wood ID

#9

Re: Wood ID

Carole Valentine

>My guess was some type of Elm, but I am trying to figure out which one. I hope it is not Siberian...I think they are considered invasive. My guess is Dutch or American. I am in Eastern VA.

Re: Wood ID

#10

Re: Wood ID

Ron in Drums PA

>I have some red elm that looks like that

Re: Wood ID

#11

Re: Wood ID

arkie

>Does look like red elm in the grain. Red elm that I know is also known as slippery elm. Should be easy to slip the bark off if still green, and a real slimy layer between bark & wood. Old timers used to chew that slimy layer as a sore throat remedy.

Re: Wood ID

#12

Re: Wood ID

Carole Valentine

>The piece that I have is too dry to slip the bark off. One of the things that has me a little confused is the little black buds at the leaf stems and along the twig. Do you see those on slippery/red elm?

Re: Wood ID

#13

Leo

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It has been my observation over several years that Leo Van Der Loo knows more about wood and wood identification than anyone else around. At this point I would go with what he says.

Re: Wood ID

#14

Re: Wood ID

arkie

>Fellow once dropped a pickup load off green and dripping wet, but it was cut to firewood length. If I've ever seen with the leaves on, I didn't know it.

The other clue would be the smell, but it is greatly abated when the wood dries. Not near as much fun as red box elder, which I'm finishing up a truckload. (drie-by gloat)

The attached is a lousy photo, but it is definitely red elm.


img

Re: Wood ID

#15

Leo - question

Carole Valentine

>Everything I have read says one of the main differences between American Elm and Siberian Elm (which is now considered invasive) is the size of the leaf. The larger leaves on the twig I have measure 4-5". They are doubly serrated. What size are the leaves on your tree? And does yours have those dark buds at the leaf junctions and elsewhere on the twig? I need to go over there and look at some of the others that are live and see if they have the slippery characteristic under the bark. I don't have any of the wood to turn. The guy just wanted me to ID the tree for him (he just got a sawmill.) It was apparently very large and died from disease (Dutch Elm disease probably) Thanks.

Re: Wood ID

#16

leaf size?

John K Jordan

>Carole,

How big are the leaves? The leaf size is a major distinguishing feature in the elms as is the serrate nature of the edges.

Siberian Elm leaves are usually under 2" in length, sometimes up to 3" according to my references. American and Slippery Elm (Red Elm) leaves are usually larger, 3" or more and can reach 6-7".

Leaves of Siberian Elm are singly saw-toothed; Slippery and American Elm leaves are usually doubly saw-toothed.

Siberian Elm leaves are nearly symmetrical at the base; Slippery and American Elm leaves are strongly asymmetrical at the base. The leaves in your picture don't look asymmetrical enough to me for American Elm.

Are the twigs smooth or hairy? American Elm is smooth, Slippery Elm is hairy.

How big is the trunk? Siberian Elm is usually smaller than 1.5'; most other elms can reach 2-3'

Is the white band below the bark soft and springy? A piece of Slippery Elm I had looked very much like that. The bark and wood of some American Elm I had did not look like that. One reference indicated the inner bark of Slippery Elm is slightly fragrant, edible and gluelike. I've never seen a slice of Siberian Elm.

I couldn't find any stems that had leaf buds that looked like that and I've never seen any myself. Are you sure they aren't snails? The latin name for Slippery Elm Ulmus rubra refers to the large brown buds covered with rust-colored hair. Got any rusty hair? Another reference indicates the leaf buds of Siberian Elm are 1/4" in diameter and look like miniature basketballs. Got basketballs?

JKJ

Re: Wood ID

#17

Re: Leo - question

John K Jordan

>If you can slice a bit of end grain you might narrow it down with a hand lens. All the elms have distinctive wavy bands of tiny pores in the latewood, but the three types of elms in Hoadley's book have different earlywood pores - the Slippery Elm has a band 2-6 pores wide (deep) while the American Elm has a single, continuous row of large pores.

I thought I read somewhere that the Siberian Elm (and others from across the sea) was resistant to the Dutch Elm disease while the American is strongly susceptible.

JKJ

Re: Wood ID

#18

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Leo - question *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Carole

The small brown buds are next years buds, and yes my Siberian Elm has them, the patio behind my house is covered with the scales of them in the spring.

Leaf sizes are variable but the Siberian has smaller leave in general, but it depends a lot on the trees health and location, the American Elm has larger leaves again usually, the biggest difference is that the American has unequal leaves much like the hackberry, the Siberian leaves are much more equal.

American Elm wood is much lighter in color than the Siberian, which can be as dark as Black Walnut

Siberian Elm has a rougher bark than the American of the same size, size wise the American can get very large, but my Siberian needs two tall grown-up persons to reach around, well I HTH

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum30.html

Re: Wood ID

#19

Re: leaf size?

Carole Valentine

>John -

Leaves: Most of the leaves are 4-5", some smaller. They are double-serrated. They are slightly asymetrical, some much more than others.

Twigs: smooth

Trunk size: Don't know - he said it was big.

Inner bark: soft and spongy. No fragrance. He said the tree was dead...if that's the case where did he get the leaves? Stump suckers? I am going to go see for myself.

Snails? LOL Not hardly. Didn't look like basketballs to me either and no rusty hair.

Wonder if these two species can hybridize?

I going to see if I can slice a piece thin enough to look at the pore structure.

Re: Wood ID

#20

Re: Leo - question

Carole Valentine

>John, what does Hoadly say about the pore structure of the Siberian Elm?

Re: Wood ID

#21

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Wood ID

Lyle Jamieson

>I looked it up in two of my wood books. Seldom do we have all the information you provided. The leaves are the telltale item. In walnut the leaves come off the branch symmetrically. In elm the leaves come off the branch alternating or unsymetrrical. It looks to me that it is elm. Either Rock elm, it has smaller leaves 2-4 inches long or Slippery elms leaves are a little bigger, 4-7 inches long. Both have natural ranges in your area. Another hint to identify elm is the barnyard smell when turning. The good news is that these varieties are not as susceptible to the dutch elm desease that affects Americam elms. We dont have any Americam elm left in Michigan. I like to use elm for my torso sculptures because of the strong grain character. It is very forgiving in the drying process too. Lyle

Re: Wood ID

#22

Re: leaf size?

John K Jordan

>>...Wonder if these two species can hybridize?

In reading about the Dutch Elm Disease, there seems to be much effort in creating hybrids from a variety of Elm species in search of disease resistant plants. Some references list many elm cultivars by commercial name but don't indicate their lineage. A Wikipedia entry indicates: Early efforts in the USA involved the hybridization of the Siberian Elm Ulmus pumila with the American Elm, and produced a resistant tree, but one that lacked the beauty, traditional shape, and landscape value of the American Elm; few were planted.

>...what does Hoadly say about the pore structure of the Siberian Elm?

Unfortunately, Siberian Elm is not included in Hoadley's book or another book I have with wood structure photos. With the many thousands of native and imported species, I'm sure resources limit photos to the most common.

Here is Hoadley's chart of the Elm/Hackberry Group, but to get a good look at the rays requires a higher-power microscope. Remember, this is based on the wood alone and not the other features you are fortunate to have (leaves, twigs, buds, bark!):

A: Earlywood 2-5 pores wide, pores generally visible with hand lens

-- A1: Heartwood cream to light brown or yellowish grey. Largest rays up to 10-12 serate, always some rays wider than 7 serate: Hackberry, Sugarberry

-- A2: Heartwood brown to reddish brown. Largest rays generally -5 serate, never wider than 7 serate: Slippery Elm

B: Earlywood with a single row lf largest pores that may not be visible without lens

-- B1: Earlywood pores visible to eye (maximum pore diameter more than 200um), mostly in a continuous row: American Elm

-- B2: Earlywood pores not visible without lens (maximum pore diameter less than 200um), mostly in a discontinuous row: Winged Elm, Cedar Elm, Rock Elm

Another feature of Slippery Elm: it fluoresces a dim yellow-green under blacklight.

Hoadley also mentions that the location of the tree can be helpful. American and Slippery elm are found all through the US and in parts of Canada. Rock elm is mostly in the north-central states, winged elm in the south-central and southeastern states.

BTW, note that to look at the structure you don't have to pare a thin slice. Take any chunk showing the end grain - I usually saw off a little piece 1/2" thick so it will fit on the microscope and at least 1/2" square. Using a straight razor blade (or even an x-acto knife), shave the end grain until you cut away any roughness from the sawing. If the wood is very hard and dry, soak it first in water to soften. If you want to send a sample in the mail, I'll be glad to give it a look.

All of my reference books say Siberian Elm has small leaves, singly-serrated, and a small diameter trunk, rarely over 1.5' If these leaves are large, doubly-serrated, and the trunk is "big", it probably isn't Siberian Elm, or at least not "pure" Siberian!

With the seemingly infinite number of varieties out there including native species, imported species, and crossbreeding between species, it may be difficult or impossible for even the experts to tell the exact species from the wood even with leaves in hand. Hoadley makes this clear as does the US Forest Service's (free) wood ID program. If you recall, some months ago Joanne Alder sent me a wood sample and also sent a sample to the Forest Service. She wrote: "At last! I just got my wood ID back from the Forest Service. Took a bit longer than they said. Guess everyone in the country is asking them to ID wood! Indeed, they were nowhere near as thorough in their answer as you were in yours, but you will be delighted (with your own skills) to know that they agree: Ulmus--a species of Elm (that's all they said about that, word for word!)...

Attached below is the photograph I took of Joanne's wood sample by holding a digital camera up to the microscope eyepiece so the photo isn't all that great. However, it shows the wavy latewood bands characteristic of the elms and hackberries. If your sample has these wavy bands (and especially since you have the leaves) you can probably safely tell your friend he has some elm. :)

And considering that a large percentage of wood sold and used (even by woodturners) is not identified or named correctly, whether accidentally or on purpose, tell him to just pick a name and go with it!

JKJ


img

Re: Wood ID

#23

Re: Wood ID - response to Ron

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I found this on a wood identification web page. It's from a Red Elm.

My contribution. :-)

Ray


img

Re: Wood ID

#24

Re: Another PIC 

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>


img

Re: Wood ID

#25

zelkova?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>another possibility is zelkova. It was widely planted as an elm substitute and can grow to similar size. The leaf size and shape are consistant with zelkova. I would have agreed 100% with the siberian Id exceopt that I have never seen siberian with such a narrow band of sap wood.

Robin