I agree 100% John
keith zimmerman, Normal IL
>
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
I agree 100% John
keith zimmerman, Normal IL
>
Re: I have a couple of cents too...
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>John, "his conclusions might be similar since he based them on wear of a magnified edge" This is one part that's subjective too.
A test that we could all understand could be done for about 5- 6 thousand. I could make a machine to do the testing, steel can be bought then have the same flute shape milled in each type (example; M2, M4, 2030, 2060 and A11) BTW - Heat treatment would be very expensive unless we get companies to help. Let the testing be done by 3 people willing to work for a couple weeks running the machine and gathering the data. When all the data is in let it out to the public.
Russ, this is a good example how advertising sells a product and a good reason to raise the price 20 bucks.
I believe in science... *LINK*
steve antonucci
>Here's a link that explains what cyrogenics do with regards to steel. It's not marketing, but actual science. I can tell you that my ATS34 knife blades are not only very good steel, but get sharper and stay sharper than any steel I've ever seen. They were cryo treated before I had them shipped...
Re: cryogenic
Russ Fairfield
>Note that my comments relate to M2 High Speed Steel only. Cryogenic treatment doesn't do very much for this steel.
There are many grades of steels whose alloying metals and their percentages permit them to exhibit a significant improvement in mechanical properties with the cryogenic treatment. The M2 used in our basic turning tools just isn't one of them.
Re: cryogenic
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>The marketing is that they cryogenically treat a piece of steel then say it will last 2-3 times longer which doesn't happen from cryogenics alone. Raise the price and market the heck out of it.
The elements in the steel, the proper heat treatment and cryogenics all work together. There's a reason for everything in the process and the starting point is good steel.
That not true.
steve antonucci
>Read the article at the link below from a the ASM handbook.
Excerpt:
Resistance to abrasive wear was investigated in a parametric study. "Five tool steels were tested after conventional heat treatment, after cold treatment at �84 �C (�120 �F), and after being cryogenically treated at �190 �C (�310 �F). Figure 1 and Table 1 show the results of these abrasive wear tests. Cold treatment at �84 �C (�120 �F) improved the wear resistance by 18 to 104%, but the cryogenic treatment results show 104 to 560% improvement."
If you look at the table in the article, you'll notice that the fourth column represents M2 steel and that it's wear resistance almost doubles after cryo treatment.
It's a good read and discusses the many benefits cryo seems to offer. Highly recommended.
Steven
Re: That not true.
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>Steve, I do understand what your saying, cryogenics works and is worth the extra cost. The marketing is when they say 2-3 times which is not going to happen from cryogenics alone, I could see the edge lasting longer but not like the claims.
We really do need a real world test... steel against wood and thousands of bowl blanks.
Marketing people are funny...
steve antonucci
>They get one data point out of 1000 and make it say whatever they wanted to say before the test, and then they throw away the other 999 data points that refute their claim.
If you read the link in the post below, it suggests two things: Cryo absolutely works (on many levels) and a bunch of data around how much. I'm not so much concerned about how much better it makes the steel, just the fact that it does.
Somewhere in my chaos, I have all of the textbooks from my Material Science curricula that explain all of this in theory and calculation. I think it would be fairly difficult to divise a test with a human driving it, since I think that the rate you cut at makes a huge difference and not every piece of cherry can be considered equal. However, I was using one of your gouges at a club function this past weekend and we just kept cutting bowl with a light honing in between...
Steven