Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

skew advice, please

Posts

skew advice, please

#1

skew advice, please

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>I have an opportunity to get some instruction with the skew.

All my turning tools are in Arizona, and I am not, if I even own a skew!

So I need to get one. I'd rather get a good one to begin with. I spend less money that way in the long run.

I am polling your collective wisdom. Which one and why?

I need it by October 4.

If it is part of the equation, my intention is to learn how to turn finials. Someday.

Re: skew advice, please

#2

Re: skew advice, please *LINK*

Ron McKinley

>Doug Thompson has the best I've come across........Ron


Thompson Tools

Re: skew advice, please

#3

Bill Blasic

Re: skew advice, please

Bill Blasic

>Carol,

I have one of Doug's skews and it is the best! Holds an edge well and can be sharpened to that very very scary edge.

Re: skew advice, please

#4

JL

Re: skew advice, please

JL

>I like an "oval" skew as opposed to a "rectangular" one. It slides well over the tool rest. I'm used to it, which may be a reason why I like it :).

I use a small skew to get into close spaces and a larger skew for planing cuts.

Re: skew advice, please

#5

Re: skew advice, please - more info

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>Please include the size.

I suspect one wider and one not so wide, but which one first?

Doug is currently out of the widest one. I would need to order quickly so I can get it sharp and get a handle on it.

Thanks for your input.

Hey, Doug, if you're reading this, is the handle end a tang, or does one of Dave Peeples' handles fit it?

Re: skew advice, please

#6

Re: skew advice, please - more info

john lucas

>Carol I learned on a Sorby oval skew that is 1". I like it a great deal. I have a 1/2" Sorby rectangular skew that I really like for smaller work. I have a 3/8" skew made from a spade bit that I love and use it constantly on my ornaments. I also own a 1/4" Rosand round skew and like that almost as much as the 3/8 for small work. I now have a Thompson skew and it is fabulous. It is a really good skew for things the side of chair legs and even moderate size ornaments but I think it's a little too large for ornament finials and even some cuts on wine stoppers. I tend to use it a lot because it really holds and edge but occasionally it is too thick to reach into tight places. It is fabulous for chair legs because it is thick enough to not vibrate and I really like the feel.

I'd have to say the Sorby Oval is my favorite overall. It's thick enough to hang over the tool rest fairly far and thin enough to reach into tight areas like tall beads placed close together.

There is a lot to be said about how to sharpen. I prefer a straight grind and the angle from bevel to bevel is about 45 degrees. I know some people say 25 but I find that angle really grabby. I grind a hollow ground bevel on it and then use my diamond hones to get the edge. I take it up to the ultra fine and then use a strop with green compound.

Re: skew advice, please

#7

Re: skew advice, please - more info

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Carol -- I'd suggest you go ahead and get a 3/4" Thompson if that's what he's got available right now. I have one and use it on porch posts up to 6" diameter and wouldn't hesitate to use it on larger. I do have a larger skew but don't find it any advantage. I've seen Alan Lacer do wonderful small stuff with one of his 1-3/8" but I don't feel the additional size would gain me much. I feel like I have better control wsith a smaller tool, and with a skew, control is always a big issue.

Mine is sharpened to 45 degree included angle, which some folks might think of as too fine and thus more likely to catch, but you can get used to it.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: skew advice, please

#8

Re: skew advice, please

Greg Haugen

>Hi Carol,

Oval skews seem to "glide" the best for planing cuts. Their downfall, to me, is that can't do a peeling cut very well and it's difficult to grind them on an 8" grinder. Nick Cook and Alan Lacer recommend not grinding oval skews on a 8" grinder. The main issue is the grind on them is often long. If it gets too long, there's not enough heft and the hollow grinds can get pretty close in the center of the grind. Now this does vary on the skew and the grind but it's something to watch out for. Nick Cook, in my opinion one of the best oval skew technicians, only will grind on a Tormek and the hone the rest of the time. I know some do grind it on a 8" but I have seen students show up with "holes" in the grind. The rounded edge skews, most often offered by Hamlet or Henry Taylor are ok. They do have some heft but not too much. Since the profile isn't oval they're grind doesn't get as long as the oval skew's does so grinding them isn't an issue. The rule of thumb, except ovals, is a grind one and a half times the thickness of the the steel. This is a guideline. A 1/4" thick skew "should" have a bevel of 3/8" roughly (1/4 plus 1/8). For learning a skew, I'd avoid round skews. Once you get the hang of a standard skew then play around with round skews. Also as a guideline the angle is usually 70 degrees from toe to heel, point to point, if it's a straight grind or radiused grind (Raffan and Lacer first 1/3 flat and then radiused-point to point 70 degrees). So do like the 45 degree grind, a good friend of mine Brian Simmons who apprenticed under Nick Cook. I don't like it as much since it's a bit long. I like to use the "heel", the short point, for rolling beads. 45 deg. moves it too far away for me.

As well as buying a skew, I'd strongly recommend a diamond hone in the "fine" grit. They can be purchased at Rockler, Woodcraft, or any turner's catalog for about $30 or under. A skew is not sharp enough off of the grind.

I prefer the 5/8" Alan Lacer skew, with the Lacer grind, the best. I can do my peeling cut, I can plane, I can roll beads like they're going out of style. It has heft so it doesn't vibrate. It's one "con" is the heft. In very tight places, I'll go to a 1/2" Henry Taylor rolled edge to "sneak" into deep "v" cuts or tight places. Large skews are good for planing but I find them not as user friendly as smaller skews for rolling beads and details. I'd recommend a 5/8" to 1" for a "first" skew that's good for all around proformance.

Depending on your budget.

As I said I like the Lacer 5/8" the best, should be $65ish for a M2. If you go that route, shop the prices. I won't say who, since I think they're a supporter of WC, but the prices vary alot.

Thompson tools, are my favorite "tool line". He does have skews coming if they're not back already. You'll just need to make a handle. Which if you're turning with someone else, it's a great time to try their skew and grind as you make the handle for yours. Pound for pound the best tools for the price, and the best person to deal with. My next skew will probably be a Thompson, but I'll radius the grind.

Hamlet/Henry Taylor tools, rolled edge, are a good option as well.

If you have the means to make a handle, Thompson's is the way to go. If you don't, Lacer's and the English skews are good as well.

A few "Tunings" that I like on a skew, a radiused belly-the lower side, and a flat top. Rolled edge skews could use a belt sander to flatten the top. It's a comfort thing for rolling beads on a radius or v cuts on the flat. Lacer and Thompson skews have that done already.

Hope that helps Carol. Any questions you know where I am....

Greg H.

Re: skew advice, please

#9

my $0.02 *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Carol,

For finials, tops, wands, and other small spindles, I use prefer a 1/2" skew. I do have some Thompson skews coming, and others by Crown, and Sorby, but guess what - my favorite for now is an old Craftsman! The skew is about the simplest tool - except for the differences in steel, thickness, and handle, what makes the skew is the way it is sharpened and you can resharpen any skew any way you want. A skew is nothing but a flat bar of steel with a handle (and truth be known, for small things you don't even need the handle! - I often hold the steel of the skew with my right hand up near the rest and use my left hand to support the work and my left thumb to stabilize the tip.)

In fact, do you have an old 1/2" scrape that you don't use much? Resharpen it and you have a skew. Darlow recommends a straight edge, 25 degrees when viewed down the edge, with a point 70 degrees from the long side. To grind, use a flat rest set to 1/2 the edge angle and draw a line on the rest to judge the point angle, then just slide the steel back and forth. After sharpening once, I use a fine or ultra fine diamond paddle hone to resharpen it repeatedly before regrinding.

It's nice to round over the "back" edge of the tool so it will slide more easily along the rest and rotate smoothly when turning beads.

Darlow has an excellent DVD set out all about the skew. It amounts to a college course in skew preparation and use. I just got my copy yesterday but from what I've viewed so far it is outstanding. His book, Fundamentals of Woodturning, also has excellent instruction on sharping and using the skew. Raffan's intro book is also a great learning resource.

One thing about the edge sharpening angle. Darlow recommends 25 deg and I've sharpened them with both smaller and larger (blunter) angles. This is a tradeoff - the smaller angle will cut more easily, especially in hard or tricky wood, however it can initially be more "grabby". The smaller angle will also dull more easily. The larger angle is more stable and the edge "tougher" but does not cut nearly as well. When people have trouble with the skew, I'll sometimes switch them to one with a larger angle until they get the hang of it then switch back. With a bit of practice the sharper angle is not a problem. If you switch between skews a lot, what you normally DON'T want is every skew with a different angle - that way when you pick up a new one instead of just driving it into the wood you have to spend a moment remembering how that one cuts.

For tiny spindles, a 1/4" skew made from a round rod is great. I just started using one of these after an introduction by Ed Moore and expert instruction by Frank Penta. It can get in places other skews cannot.

Darlow recommends getting a 1" skew as your first skew which works well for things the size of table legs and rolling pins. You CAN use it to cut and smooth small cylinders and tapers, deep v-grooves, and edge planing cuts, but I find it less versatile in tighter places on smaller work like finials than the smaller skew, especially on the headstock end where the chuck often gets in the way. A smaller skew is also easier to use to cut coves, but that's not too important since a detail gouge is better for coves anyway.

I have a couple of oval skews and I don't like them as much - one thing is they are harder to sharpen. I also sharpened one skew with a curved edge and while it does seem more stable than the flat edge, after a bit of practice that isn't important.

One thing about the Thompson skews - I've got some coming so I haven't tried them but the steel on his gouges is excellent so I expect the skews to be the same - they come without handles so you have to buy or make your own. Since the tang is rectangular, you can't just jam it into a round hole in a wooden handle and expect it to hold well. It would be best to use a method described in the document in the article linked below.

When I started turning, everyone told me to run and hide from the evil skew! Instead, I was determined to learn how to make it work. This actually didn't take long after reading the books mentioned above. One thing I started doing which helped me a lot (and I still do) - when turning down a spindle, I'll smooth it with the skew for practice even if the final diameter and shape will be much different. I'll even cut a few v-grooves and maybe practice a bead or two (where I still need the most practice) before turning it on down to size. This does take a bit of time but the extra practice is very helpful.

BTW, I've recently had three turning students, one with turning experience (mostly bowls), one with just a brief self-guided introduction, and one who had never touched the lathe. I started each with the skew on a piece of pine or cherry and all of them "got" it very quickly. One secret is to cut with the skew while someone (that would be me) is turning the lathe by hand. You can do all the basic cuts this way. This allows all the successes AND mistakes to happen in ultra-slow motion so you can see exactly what is happening, why, and what to do differently.

JKJ


turning tool handles

Re: skew advice, please

#10

that was 12 cents worth :)

john lucas

>

Re: skew advice, please

#11

I have a couple of cents too...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>Regardless of what brand or size skew you get, I highly recommend steel that has been cryogenically treated. I have a Henry Taylor Kryo 1/2" skew that holds its edge so well that it has been sharpened once in the two years I have owned it (and that is because I dropped it and damaged the edge). It does, however, get honed every time it is used.

keithz

Re: skew advice, please

#12

Re: Why not ask the instructor

Russ Fairfield

>If I were the instructor, I would prefer that you asked me this question.

There are many different sizes and configurations for the skew. Which one we use is a personal preference, and that preference is often determined by which was the first one we purchased and learned to use.

I am sure the instructor who will be teaching you has a preference. I would suggest that your learning experience will be better if you learned to use the skew they prefer, rather than one they don't like. You can always buy that special skew for turning those finials after you have learned to use the tool, and when you are better able to determine which one you will need to do the job. You will always be better at using a tool that was selected to suit your turning style, rather than forcing your turning style to fit the tool.

If I were your instructor, I would tell you to buy any skew that is rectangular, 1" or 1-1/4" wide, and 1/4" thick. Who made it is of no importance. What is important is that it be made of an M2 high speed steel, and that it be 1/4" thick. Don't worry about the shape of the cutting edge, and I would prefer that the edges not be rounded, because the first thing we will do is grind the skew to the cutting edge configuration we will be using, and we will round the bottom edge only, leaving the top edge square, because that is the way I will be teaching you to use the tool. But I am not your instructor, someone else is, and you should follow their recommendation.

Re: skew advice, please

#13

Re: I have a couple of cents too...

john lucas

>Keith That's interesting because the guy who gave the talk at the AAW symposium went into great detail about cyrogenic treatment of tools and his final conclusion was that if the tool was heat treated properly 3 times (and he went into GREAT detail on that) then cryogenic treatment didn't do any more to the edge. I forget all the details but it had to do with converting the steel to the hardened state. I believe it was converting Austinite to Martensite but I might have that backwards.

I don't have experience with cryogenic tools other than Thompsons and his are heat treated 3 times with Cryogenics between the 1st and 2nd. The gentleman giving the lecture said that cryogenics might improve the edge holding capability if the heat treating was not done properly but if it is done properly then the Austenite was all converted to martensite and cryogenics won't do any more to the metal.

Re: skew advice, please

#14

Steven Antonucci

and no change due...;-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: skew advice, please

#15

John, all I know is...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>that the tool works and holds an edge very well. What you are sharing is probably true. I don't know the metallurgic details of the process, but I do know that it works for me. Whatever brand, I recommend these tools highly. My experience with cryo tools is limited is the Henry Taylor Kryo and Thompson tools.

keithz

Re: skew advice, please

#16

another perspective...

GaryG in MD

>Cindy Drozda turns her finials with a detail gouge. ...Gary

Re: skew advice, please

#17

Re: Why not ask the instructor - I did

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>His personal preference is the 5/8" Lacer skew. But he said any skew was acceptable.

I am leaning towards Thompson because his tools hold an edge really well. The issue now is, which size.

Re: skew advice, please

#18

Re: John, all I know is...

john lucas

>Keith I find it all very interesting. There are a lot of inflated claims but I do know that the tools are better than they used to be and do hold an edge longer.

Re: skew advice, please

#19

Re: Why not ask the instructor - I did

John K Jordan

>If you've got the moola, consider getting both a 1/2" and a 1" or 1.25". From what I've seen of the Thompson tools so far, it will be a good investment for you and your grandkids. Note that his supply of skews and scrapers is limited. I ordered four skews and some scrapers since who knows if or when they will be available again. (Doug told me he very much dislikes making skews and scrapers.)

BTW, he also carries 3/8" rod of the same steel if you want to make a round skew. I'd prefer 1/4" round but that size is not yet available.

JKJ

Re: skew advice, please

#20

different alloys?

John K Jordan

>>...cryogenic treatment didn't do any more to the edge.

>I forget all the details but...I believe it was

>converting Austinite to Martensite but I might have that backwards.

On Thompsons web site he mentions his tools are "triple tempered with a cryogenic treatment between the first and second temper to form more "eta" carbides."

I haven't read up on the metallurgy involved, but could it be that both are correct? The Thompson tools use a steel he refers to as CPM-10V, a powder steel with a 10% vanadium content. Perhaps the guy who gave the talk at the AAW symposium had experience with a different kind of steel. Perhaps one type benefits from a specific treatment where the other doesn't.

All I know about it is so far I'm impressed with the edge-holding ability of the Thompson tools I've used.

JKJ

Re: skew advice, please

#21

Re: skew advice, please - more info

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Carol,

Handles - the 3/4 skew has a 1/2 inch wide tang on it so you can go with a 1/2 inch diameter handle and grind the corners off the tang to fit or go with a larger bore in the handle and don't grind the tang... the set screws are going to lock it in the handle no matter what you decide.

Re: skew advice, please

#22

Re: I have a couple of cents too...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The study done with the results given at the symposium this year was very good for what they had to work with. A Ring Master was the test machine and they only had so much steel to work with so basically it was under funded like so much in our world... I give them an "A Plus" for effort and Jim did a great job presenting the results. Maybe the AAW could fund a project like this.

Cryogenics won't make a super steel but it makes the steel better than tempering alone.

My subjective results from side by side testing done a while ago was this; I could tell the difference between a tool that was cryogenically treated and one that wasn't by how long that really sharp edge lasted... there was a difference.

Re: skew advice, please

#23

Re: cryogenic

Russ Fairfield

>There is a bit of advertising psychology in the use of the word, "Cryogenic", to describe these new tools.

I agree with the demonstrator that the Cryogenic treatment will do very little to an M2 high speed steel, BUT the manufacturers did something else at the same time. They were forced into control of a process where there was little to none before. That tighter control of their process did more to improving the steel that the Cryogenic.

The market forces them to advertise the Cryogenic part of the steel. How many of you would pay a higher price for a tool that was "manufactured with an improved process control"? I doubt anyone would. We would expect them to be doing that already.

Using the word "Cryogenic" means this steel is different in everyones mind, even though cryogenic part of the process didn't add much to the quality of the steel.

Re: skew advice, please

#24

Re: I have a couple of cents too...

john lucas

>Thanks Doug His test was not conclusive in my mind but was very interesting. I thought the angle he chose was not representative of normal lathe tools but his conclusions might be similar since he based them on wear of a magnified edge. Still it would be interesting to see a really complete test.

Re: skew advice, please

#25

Good point Russ

john lucas

>I thought the best thing about the guys lecture was his description of the heat treatment process at the microscopic level. This allowed us to see how easy it would be for manufacturers to do a half ass process thus producing tools of inferior quality made from the same material.