>I am interested in acquiring a bowl coring system. At this point my choices seem to be either the Woodcut or the McNaughton systems. I have seen Bill Grumbine demonstrate the McNaughton system both on his DVD and in his shop. I�ve seen a demonstration of the Oneway coring system and while it is impressive, the system is beyond my budget. I know nothing about the Woodcut system and am hoping that some of the WoodCentral folks can give me some advice or information about it.
>I think it depends upon what lathe you have and its horsepower, what type of coring you want to do (i.e., shapes)and the sizes of bowls you wish to core.
The McNaughton is the most flexible and also the most difficult to learn to use. You have a choice of the shape you want to core with this system where as both the Woodcut and the OneWay make circular cuts into the blank. I have been told that the McNaughton requires a lathe with more than one horsepower to work properly. I got my McNaughton about two years ago and it works great on my Nova DVR 3000. It does require a learning period and I recommend practicing on wood that you don't mind ruining.
The Woodcut, which I purchased in 1997 at the AAW symposium after watching Lee Carter coring bowls all day with the system is my favorite. There were a couple of reasons for purchasing it. At the time, I had a Record CL-3 lathe with a 3/4 hp motor and Lee said that that would be enough to core with the Woodcut. He was right, it worked very well. I personally use this system the most because I've had it a long time and am comfortable using it. The learning curve was very short.
I have no experience with the OneWay except having seen it demonstrated a few times. It appears to be a pretty easy to use system although I understand that is the most expensive of the three choices.
One further thought on coring, wet wood cores much easier than dry wood. I cored a piece of dry elm a couple of years ago and the Woodcut system simply beat me severely. However, the screwed up neck that I had at the time was fixed with the beating and I named the bowl my chircopractic bowl.
>Thanks Fred. I'm leaning towards the McNaughton system. I also have a Nova DVR 3000. I've seen Bill Grumbine guide the McNaughton tool through a bowl blank just using his thumb and forefinger. He told me that he had a very slightly built woman who used the McNaughton with no problems. Hopefully, I'll get a few more opinions.