Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

MYRTLE TURNING

Posts

MYRTLE TURNING

#1

MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>I am pretty new to turning,my wife bought me a mini lathe for my birthday back in March. Since that time I have found turning a great joy in my lathe. Since my surgery in Jan my pending retirment from the Navy after 33 years I have been very fortunate that my health is now great, but I find I have allot of time on my hands while I wait for my offical retirment date. So I spend about 7 hours a day on my new toy.

I have been trying all sorts of wood and a few days ago I bought a new piece of Myrtle wood from my local wood store. Never having turned Myrtle I thought I would try turning a lidded box since it had a very nice color to it with some VERY nice rays as well.

I turned the 4 x 4 x 10 piece of wood to a cylinder and then proceded to part it for my lidded. Once I that was completed I decided to stop for the day.

This morning I went out to the shop and my heart sank. The lid portion of the box had cracks from the out side to the center and the base had a large amount of cracks as well. Before I started I noticed some small cracks in the piece and I had cut several inches off both ends thinking that would elevate the cracks from the rest of the peice.

So my question is what did I do wrong? Was the wood not cured? I have no idea what I can use this wood for now other than practicing with my tools on the piece.

Carl

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#2

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

John K Jordan

>Congrats on your coming retirement! I retired about a year and a half ago and I highly recommend it. :)

Bummer on your cracked wood experience. I suspect the wood simply wasn't dry enough. A thick piece of wood can take years to dry. Often you can feel a slight coolness from evaporation when wood is not dry, but I use a small electronic moisture meter to be sure.

If you see cracks/checks in the end grain of a block before starting, beware since they can go much deeper than you can often see. What I do is cut of successive thin slices from the end and bend each one to test. If the crack continues into that slice, it will break easily.

I haven't turned much myrtle but what I had was very dry and stable. But other woods, such as dogwood, persimmon, apple, etc, can warp and crack violently. I usually coat both ends of blocks of wood with end grain sealer (Anchorseal, etc) and set them on the shelf for a couple of years. If I want to make things like boxes and the wood is not dry, I'll turn the box to a relatively thick wall thickness (1/2" or so), and let it dry for a few months before finishing the box. Another thing you can do is slow the drying of a wet piece when you stop for an evening, for example, by wrapping it in plastic or placing it in a bag.

Often pieces will dry nicely without cracking, although they might warp considerably (which is bad for lidded boxes!) One thing that can make bowls and boxes crack is if the bottom is considerably thicker than the sides. Pieces that are turned uniformly and especially if they are relatively thin tend to survive.

Perhaps myrtle is especially difficult to dry. You might try some other wood, such as walnut (very stable) cherry, maple, box elder, holly, mesquite, or even oak. Where do you live? I've got a lot of very dry walnut.

JKJ

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#3

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

Harry In beautiful downtown Kulpsville

>Carl, that wood was not dry when you turned it. I've never turned Myrtle so I don't know if it is a wood that is prone to cracking. I suspect that by turning the lid, you reduced the thickness and that increased the speed of drying.

Wood looses most of its moisture from the ends and especially from the pith (center of the piece). When the center dries and shrinks, it causes the radial cracks that you see. Anytime you turn a piece and include the pith you are taking a chance that the wood will check.

The solution is to slow the drying process. You can rough turn the piece and coat the endgrain with a sealer such as AnchorSeal. Put the piece in a paper bag or wrap it in several thichnesses of newspaper. After a couple months it should have dried enough to turn safely.

Typically the wood will warp in the drying process so you must make the rough turning thicker than the final dimension. With bowls a good rule of thumb is to make the wall thickness equal to 10% of the bowl diameter.

I'm afraid the wood you have left may end up in the fireplace or just turned into shavings as you practice your tool technique.

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#4

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

Ron McKinley

>Myrtle is a very stable wood once it's dry and I've turned many lidded boxes out of dry myrtle. I've never turned wet myrtle so I suspect yours was wet. According to Richard Raffan you can turn boxes out of green wood if you rough turn them, leave them thick, and finish turn after they're dry. He tapes the the top of the lid to the bottom of the base with the hollowed out sections facing out.

Congratulations on your retirement and thanks for serving.....Ron

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#5

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>John,

Thank you, it seems like I am already retired since I go to work at 7am and get home by 8am very day. There is nothing for me to do at the command I am currently located. Only 40 sailors, on Master Chief, 2 Senior Chiefs and 2 Chiefs and they do not need this ole 33 year vetran Master Chief telling them how it sould be done. So I go ome clean house and turn all day. :) But I think I will get me another job at the local Home Depot two blocks away. I can walk there and back, stay in shape and keep in contact with others.

I currently live in Virginia Beach, VA. I suspect you might be further away, but I thank you for the offer of the walnut. I have tried other woods and they have turned out very nice. I tried Quina (South Ameican wood) the other day and it turned out very nice. It was the first time I had the walls of the box very thin and the color of the wood is nice as well. The price was great $12, for 3x3x12.

Unfortunitly I ust came in from the shop and I had a blow out on the lid of the current box I am doing out of Big Leaf Maple. I cut the walls a little tooooooo thin. Everything else about te box is great,but now I have this big hole in the top. I stopped for know and I am thinking I just might plug the hole with another type of wood or a stone of some sort. My wife is a geologist and has all kinds of stones and rocks I just might be able to use. :)

Thank you for the advice and I will keep those ideas in mind the next time.

Carl

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#6

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>Thank you all for the comments. I just knew I should have bagged the wood once I turned it to a round shape. It was still about 3 1/2 in DIA when I stopped for the night. I saw two small cracks and said to myself I should bag it, but I did not listen, next time I will listen to that little voice. It was such a nice peice of wood too. :(

It was very nice talking to you all.

Carl

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#7

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

Don at Central Illinois

>Speaking of not listening to yourself, I heard of a fighter plane instructor giving a critique on a new pilot. He mentioned that the pilot talked to himself a lot. The down side was, he didn't listen to what he was saying. As for lid blowouts, cracked boxes,etc. It's all part of the learning curve. Good luck and lets see some photos.

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#8

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>LAUGHING...... well I have been LEARNING allot since March when I bought my lathe. But still, I have been turning out some nice stuff as well. My MIL loved my 9in segmented bowl I sent her for mothers day It had over 300 pieces and everyone who see's it now wants one. So I guess I am doing not too bad.

I need to buy a digital camera so I can post some pictures. My oldest daughter says she wants to start a web site for me so I can show off what I do. That would be nice to have, but she stull has not made it for me.

I am still mulling over how to fix the blow out. I have a big chunk of big leaf maple left over that I might be able to turn and fit it to the top of the blow out. It might not look all that great, but on the other hand I just can not find it in my heart to throw the whole project away. I might have to have a few beers tonight and think it over a bit more.

Carl

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#9

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

robo hippy

>I turn a lot of Myrtle (California Bay Laurel) because it grows out here. Most of the time I am turning green bowls. I love it. I would put it in the fairly easy to dry category, but care must be taken to keep it, or any wood from drying too fast. Since the best of it grows in the coastal range, it tends to have a bit of silica in it, and can dull the tools fairly quickly. Colors can be spectacular, and when sanded and finished, it glows like Mahogany (but a different color). As said by other, a thick piece like yours will take years to dry. For lumber, at least a year per inch (which gets the wood to equilibruim, or as dry as it will get outside the house, in the 10 to 12% moisture range, plus 6 months in the dry/dehumidified shop which gets it dry to 6 to 8% which is good for furniture making. This holds fairly true for boards up to 2 inches thick. Over that, and it never seems to totally dry, unless you live in Arizona, and let it sit for many years. With a project like yours, rough turn in one sitting, then seal the ends and let it dry for a month or 2, then return it. Depending on how deep and wide the cracks are, you can practice filling the cracks. Do take care in turning cracked wood, as it is more prone to flying apart while turning than solid wood. If you have to leave the piece unfinished on the lathe, super glue any cracks, and plastic bag it.

robo hippy

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#10

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

Don at Central Illinois

>Could you make the top from a different wood? Make it a contrasting color. Just a thought.

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#11

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>A different wood is an option as well. I am thinking about that option as well. I thought about some bloodwood or ebony, I just need to think about the options.

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#12

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>Robo,

Thank you. I do love the color of myrtle. The peice I had some light colored rays in it that I knew would look wonderful. At least I learned some valuable lessons from this event.

Carl

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#13

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Hey Chief...welcome to woodturning and to WC. I joined the Navy shortly after the beginning of WW2. Before the end of the war (and my Navy career) I had made chief.

As others have said, your myrtlewood was no doubt still wet...so it cracked as it was unprotected (woodsealer or wax). To turn a box, the wood must be dry. Otherwise, the day after you finish the box, the lid won't fit. Wood moves. When turning boxes it's best to use endgrain wood to minimize wood movement. If the wood isn't completely dry, it's best to rough turn, coat it with wax, then finish it after it dries in a few weeks or months, depending on how wet it was.

I've turned a lot of myrtlewood. It's very nice to turn and is quite stable. It even smells nice as you turn.

Wally

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#14

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>Wally,

Thank you very much for the advice. Where did you serve and what ships? I spent 22 of my 33 years on ships, all on aircraft carriers. I was on the USS Washington and was supposed to be with her when the ship went to Japan recently. But I got really sick back in NOV and they took me off the ship and slap my rear end in the hospital. All seems to be well now, but I sure do miss the action of being at sea. But after so many years at sea I am very happy to be home with the family but I do find myself a bit out of sorts not having a job right now. The wood turning helps and keeps me busy. I give most of my stuff away to family but everyone says I should sell my stuff online, but I find it hard too do so. Maybe one day I might fell that I am good enough to do so, until then I know the famliy enjoys the stuff I make.

By the way, I am ( at least until this coming JAN) an Aviation Ordnanceman. What did you do?

Take care

Carl

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#15

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carl, I was in the Pacific aboard the Cassin Young, a DD destroyer. Went through 5 invasions. Got clobbered by Kamikazes twice at Okinawa, in April.'45, then afer being repaired and back, again in August. We operated with carriers for a while. Picked up some shot down pilots when acting as plane guard. I was a CSK.

The Cassin Young is a national historical monument and is in Boston.

Wally

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

#16

Re: MYRTLE TURNING

CARL BARTON

>Wally,

WOW, that is some history. Me, I never was that close to the enemy, except once in the Gulf a few years back when there were Dowds loaded with explosives trying to get close to us, I was on the USS Wasington at the time, we fired on them and they turned away. We were also out there when terrorist blew up the big oil transferstaion, that was a site to see when it exploded at night. After we were relived the carrier who releived us had a Dowd blow up close to their bow.

Thank you for sharing.

Carl