Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Taking pictures of other's work

Posts

Taking pictures of other's work

#1

Taking pictures of other's work

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>While on vacation last week I made a quick stop at a location that featured, among other things, a craft shop selling work of area artists. The turnings were very nice, well beyond my current ability, and accompanied by a sign forbidding the taking of pictures. I wasn�t wanting to take any anyway but the sign surprised me.

While on one hand I guess I understand the reasoning behind this, making it harder to steal ideas, it still doesn�t make a lot of sense. The work was good but there was nothing truly unique. Even if there had been something unique, those able to duplicate it are few and far between and probably already turning similar objects.

Do any of the fulltime or semi-fulltime turners here have a no pictures policy? If so, why? Personally, I would be honored if anyone thought so much of something I�d turned that they wanted a picture of it.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#2

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Greg Haugen

>Randy,

Part of it is the "copying or stealing" the idea but most of it is "ownership" of the piece as well as "rights" to it and it's photographs. While talking with a well known, big name, turner he mentioned that even though he hasn't one certain piece of his signature pieces it has paid for itself 10-fold by being photographed for publications. Some times there are "royalty" and other "payments" for the rights to publish a photo of one's work. As soon as someone has taken a picture of that work and there was no "agreement" of it's usage. All of that is lost.

There are reason's to allow it or not to allow it. When in doubt, EVEN if it's not stated -ALWAYS ASK!

If someone wants to take a picture of my work-go for it.

Hope that helps,

Greg H.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Rob Wallace

>If the "ask before taking photos" policy is to become the 'standard', than a signed statement from the participants in the AAW's annual Instant Gallery (...and that of other regional woodturning meetings/symposia) is needed... think of the HUNDREDS (or thousands) of photos taken during the IG in Richmond! Getting permission from all exhibiting artists would be functionally impossible.... an 'a priori disclaimer that frees spectators to take photos would be necessary....just a thought... Rob Wallace

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#4

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

john lucas

>Randy It's becoming quite common among craft artists. They percieve and maybe rightly so that people are stealing their ideas and then selling the work. I do know of one instance where it has happened and they are still in court. I also know of another instance where the design was copied and then appeared at the discount stores made by the Chinese. In that case the artist simply couldn't afford any legal battle and hoped that her clients would simply not shop in the same stores and see the work at grossly low prices.

I learned about this when I volunteered to take photos for the Tennessee Association of Craft Artists. I was trying to take a photo in a booth and was told not do do so. I told them I was there for official reasons and he said fine and then explained why he was doing that. Apparently it is becoming a real problem and the artists are simply trying to protect themselves.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#5

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

john lucas

>I forgot to mention that it's almost impossible to stop someone from taking a photo. First, if you any good at all you can get the photo when they aren't looking or use a long lens from outside the booth. With todays digitals you simply hold the camera down at your waist and point it taking the photo inobtrusively without flash.

I don't think any of us would do that sort of thing and ideally you should ask before taking a photo. These are hard times for artists and they are trying their best to protect their interests. My point is, the bad guys will do it anyway and you are really powerless to stop them so putting a sign up really doesn't accomplish anything.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#6

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Greg Haugen

>Rob,

I completely agree large events like that have to or should do something. Either have a written disclaimer, "by submitting work you're giving premission for it to be photographed" or have the photography be monitored and controlled-which would be difficult to do.

On the other side of this topic is the internet. There are very few, if any, pieces that have never been put online in photographs. So the statement of "being for the purpose of being copied" could only truely have weight if the piece has never or will never be online. Once it is, someone in any country and any market, could use it for reference or out right copy it. If someone has a site with works posted or a gallery and they're no allow photos for the reason their work may be copied they have no idea of what their site can do.

I could see it for the reasons of "controlling" the photography as far as publications and owning the rights to the piece and it's photographs. But for the sake of "copying" the internet hasn't helped that situation.

Greg

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#7

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Russ Fairfield

>The answer to the question becomes obvious when you look in a magazine, or a gallery on the Internet, and see a picture of something you made with someone else taking credit for it. The only control we have is not letting that first picture be taken.

There is no comparison between taking pictures at the AAW Symposium gallery and a gallery that is open to the public. At the AAW, we have the expectation that the photos will be takem by honorable people with good intentions that are the same as ours. We can assume nothing when the gallery is open to the totally unknown public at large, and we have no idea who is taking the picture and why. For that reason, I see it as being reasonable to permit taking pictures at one and not the other.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#8

Steven Antonucci

It depends on the place and time

steve antonucci

>I think it's fair to say that the law somewhat covers pictures in a public space. If the work is exhibited in a public forum, I don't think the artist has anything more than "his/her wishes". I understand that they may not want the pictures taken, but I don't think they have the legal right to forbid it.

If the space is private (such as a gallery), I think the gallery has the right to enforce whatever policy it wants, including photography.

If you want to protect the sanctity of your work, you should never take a digital picture or post it online. A right click is all I need to "own" your image, no camera necessary...

Steven

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#9

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Like yourself I am flattered if someone asks if they can take photographs. The people who annoy me are the ones who feel they have a right to tell me to get out of the way at a show for example!

Peter.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#10

not always a bad idea to allow pics

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I do the ACC and similar shows with my furniture and get asked more times than I can count if I will let someone take a picture. I do not have a sign prohibiting it but I always appreciate being asked. I always allow pictures to be taken. Most of the time it is someone with a camera phone and they tell me they "just have to show this to so and so". In my book this is the best kind of advertising- the free kind. Last year I had a gentleman who explained he really enjoyed craft shows but his wife didn't have as much patience so he does a preview run and then goes over the pics so his wife can chose where she would like to go. I have had people take a picture so they can go home and look at the picture in their home and think about it and then come back and make a purchase. I have to wonder with my prices if I would have made the sale if I had not allowed a picture to be taken. I think it is acceptable to not allow pictures to be taken of your work. It is just one more decision we have to make when confronting the business end of craft.

I am very outspoken about copyright protection and have expressed that on the main message board on more than one occasion when someone wanted to make a copy of something for their own personal use and was looking for help. I don't think that prohibiting pictures is the best way to protect our designs. The biggest hurdle is to educate other wood workers( turners are way ahead of the curve in respecting intellectual property rights) but most of the hobby people think it is their born right to be able to make one copy if they don't sell it, after all they paid a lot of money for their tools. Of course these same people don't think it would be ok if I walked into their office and copied all the papers and files they worked on all week, even though I spent a lot of money on my copier.

Robin Corell

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#11

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Peter Hyde

>I find this whole thing ridiculous. I had it happen at a local craft fair. I was taking pictures as a personal memento thing and asking before hand. One wood turner refused me and said "I am an artist, the only way you are going to get a picture of my stuff is to own it"

If I had wanted to copy I could easily do a sketch from memory. Also if a famous turner posts a new idea on the internet what do they expect? Property rights and copyrights are all very well for the monetary well endowed but is my signature on a copy of his work going to sell? If I copied his signature that is then a forgery so I am stealing. We have all said and read there is nothing new in turning or art. So if you want to sell you need to advertise and that means putting out pictures and that means....... well you get the picture.:-) Most of the really successful crafters I know recognized a long time ago that to be successful you need to stay ahead of the game. What was new on your table this show will be on everyone else's next show, and cheaper. So you try to be the originator and pull the most money while you can. Dog eat dog? Maybe but that's free enterprise and capitalism.

As for the AAW symposium, who is responsible when any attendee can post all of the IG and other stuff to any of the turning sites and be thanked profusely by other members. Property rights? Yes pull the other one.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#12

Rob Wallace

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Rob Wallace

>Greg:

Just this past Friday (July 11th) I submitted a piece to the jury for the 2008 Iowa State Fair Fine Art Exhibition. One of the disclaimer statements included in the submission materials (that must be signed by the artist when submitting work) is that photographs would be allowed for publicity purposes. This permission includes use of the photographs by the sponsoring agency (the Iowa State Fair), but does NOT necessarily include photographs taken by perhaps thousands of people who view the artwork at the Fair over the span of 11 days.

Last year I received first place in the sculpture category, and my piece was professionally photographed for inclusion in the Exhibition's catalog, and for exhibit cards to be made (which were given to all of the winners). Although I have some idea of what went on by the event's sponsor and how the photograph was used by them, I have absolutely no idea how many people from the estimated 200,000+ who visited the Exhibition could have photographed my piece. Thus, it is hard to set limits in some cases, depending on the venue.

I agree with the desire to retain "creativity rights" if copyright of the actual image is hard or impossible to enforce. This is quite a slippery slope issue!

Cheers,

Rob Wallace

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#13

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Copyright of a photo of your work is separate from the copyright of your work. You do not own the copyright of a photo of your work unless you are the photographer or you hired the photographer and the photos were taken as "work for hire". If you allow your work to be photographed by someone else they then own the copyright of that particular photo and can do anything they want with the photo. It does not entitle them to reproduce the object in the photograph in any way other than as that exact photo.

Robin Corell

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#14

Re: not always a bad idea to allow pics

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>If anyone wants to copy my ideas that's fine with me. Let's face it, we all get ideas from other turners. But I'd hate to see a photo of my work with with another turners name on it. Worse yet would be to see my work's photos being used for jurying some-one's art show entry. And how could you stop that? When I had my Photography Studio, I copyrighted all my photographs and still do it today, even if it's just my photo of my turnings, or my dog licking his chops.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#15

Rob Wallace

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Rob Wallace

>Robin: Thanks for that clarification - ....fortunately for the world I'm a biologist and not a lawyer - I'm severely "legal knowledge challenged", and appreciate learning about these nuances of legal terminology and concepts.

Rob

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#16

Re: not always a bad idea to allow pics

Marvin Ewing

>pictures don't worry me I had the wife of another booth standing outside my booth telling people there's was better and cheaper once.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#17

Steven Antonucci

That's funny...

steve antonucci

>Next time, send your wife down to their booth and announce that they're selling their work to fund terrorism or support Neo-Nazis.

That'll learn 'em.

Steven

Better AND cheaper... you must be doing something wrong... :-)

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#18

Re: That's funny...

Don in Ellensburg,WA,

>Had a fellow turner tell be about a expensive pepper/salt grinder

double booth turner who came to his booth and verbly got in his face about how he was to low in his sale prices and undercutting his! almost two blocks a way . My friend laughted in his face and told him to get lost. his four units we no threat to him.I took a walk down the street later and wow! was he proud of his work. enough said.

Don

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Keith Tompkins

>A turner, or any other artist, may apply for copyright protection, but there are automatic protections built into copyright law. If you are fortunate enough to have your work published in a book or magazine, you will certainly discover the editors take copyright law very, very, seriously. No signature, no publish. If you are accepted into the bigger craft shows, you will be required to sign a form stating your work is either copyrighted or copyrightable. Much copyright law has to do with intent; taking a photo is one thing, seeking to profit from another's copyrighted work is something quite different. Many people think that an artist loses their copyright protection when they display their work in public, on the net, or have their works published....not so. In many cases, its quite the opposite, publication becomes verification of ownership. Some believe that making subtle changes to another's work makes it their own....again, not so. There are several books written on copyright law as they pertain to artists....a quick read will make one aware of just how serious copyright infringement can be...copyright protection is much easier to enforce that patent protection, in my opinion. Silly? Consider this....the rights to publish your photograph is purchased by say....hmmmm....Hallmark Cards. That photo is now worth several millions of dollars. Do you think they will act to protect their investment?

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#20

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Barry Turner

>Nobody ever wanted to take photo's of my work........

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#21

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>The Hallmark example is probably the best response to how taking a picture of a one-of-a-kind object could shaft its maker out of serious bucks. I still can't buy into a concern over copying - at least where turning is concerned because I feel what makes the really good stuff good is impossible to copy. Even for the original artist.

But then, no matter how hard I try, I've never been able to hear any similarity between He's So Fine and My Sweet Lord.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#22

Re: Copyright without registration .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... is virtually useless- you can possibly win back lost profits if you have the resources to litigate. However, registration grants the prevailing plaintiff not only statutory damages, but court costs and attorney's fees, and for an artist that definitely levels the playing field when prosecuting a deep pockets defendant for willful infringement. I sued 3 publishers and spent 5 yrs. in Federal Court prosecuting, and in the end 2 settled pre-trial and the 3rd made a sizeable contribution toward my retirement! But I was represented by a well known attorney who was a client from my photography business, and he represented me on a contingency basis or I would not have had the resources to prosecute national publications with legal staff on retainers.

Re: Taking pictures of other's work

#23

because they can't improve on perfection :)

john lucas

>