Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Posts

OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#1

OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Well it's been three weeks since the symposium, I had time to relax and settle down a bit. I almost burned out from it but feel recharged enough to order more steel. Now the questions;

Last month I gave some short blanks out to be made into a 3 point tool... did anyone make one yet? Did they work? Are the worth making? I rarely read about them or a round skew or are they not worth the time. Should I order steel to make them?

Any thoughts or ideas?

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#2

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Colin

>Doug

I wasn't a recipient of one of your pieces of rod (unfortunately as I live in Spain). A point tool is an acquired taste, personally I really rate them, I use mine regularly. I find it useful for making beads and grooves and use it for making dovetails for my chucks, it can be used as a skew and a scraper too. Mine is ground with a longer bevel on one face and I think that this makes it more versatile. I have found that 10mm diameter suits my use the best (I do have smaller and larger). I have given up using my round skew as I find the oval type better for me. I certainly wouldn't give my point tool up BUT I can't see them being as popular as your gouges. The other thing is as they are sharpened with a diamond file I can't see you getting a lot of repeat business ;-)

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#3

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Doug

I make and sell them to fellow club members. I use drill blanks that I buy from ENCO. The 3/8 size are the most popular. I like using them to form small beads on the bottom of my bowls.

Terry

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#4

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Ron in Drums PA

>I use a 1/4" round skew allot. I really like it. I made a 3/8" 3 point tool and turned it into a round skew, I like it better that way.

Signed

Still waiting for your skews

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#5

3 Point tool advocate

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Doug,

I use a 3 point tool just about every time I step up to the lathe! In fact I was using it last night when I was turning a couple replacement knobs for my hand planes.

As a detail tool it's just about perfect. I use mine for forming beads (that border areas I texture or burn) on sides of bowls. It also works as a shear scraper for flatter surfaces (like the bottom of bowls).

I made a 1/4", 3/8", and a monster 1/2". I use the 3/8" version the most. But the 1/4" one comes in handy when I need to get a tiny bead into a tight spot.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#6

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

john lucas

>Doug when I'm making ornaments I use the round skew a lot. Actually anytime I need a small skew I use mine. I've made the up to 3/8" but I find the 3/8" tool too thick. The shoulders of the bevel get in the way when cutting deep beads. I like the 1/4" the best. Actually my favorite round skew is a 3/8" spade bit that I reground into a skew. It has a longer cutting edge and works better for long curves and planing cuts.

I've made a 3 point tool. I think it's an aquired taste. Once you learn how to rub the bevel and use the cutting edge like a skew it works pretty well an leaves a much better cut on a bead than using a scraper or skew on it's side. After using it a while I find that I go back to the detail gouge more than I grab the 3 point. If I did vessels with nothing but beads on the side I would probably use the 3 point more often. I think you need to have a good set of instructions to go with it if you make them. It's counter intuitive to how you use scrapers because it's actually a cutting tool.

I sharpen it with nothing but fine and ultra fine diamond hones. To regrind which it does need every now and then I have ground a flat on on side of the tool. I took a hex nut and drilled and tapped it. I put this on the shaft and then lay every other flat on the tool rest and grind. I thought the flat would get in the way of turning but it really hasn't caused a problem.

Here is a bowl I that I did the beading with the 3 point tool.


img

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#7

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

James McClure

>I make them out of 3/8" HSS extended length drill bits that I get at HD. I score just below the flute of the drill bit and snap it off. It leaves about 7 or 8 usable inches of length to work with. They work great. They are a little bit difficult to shape and sharpen. After shaping, I usually touch them up with a diamond hone. There was an article in the journal about a jig to use to sharpen them, but I do it by hand. I made an MDF disk with a 50 grit 12" zirconia alumina PSA disk on it. It is much easier to shape these against a flat disk than a grinding wheel.

As far as usefullness of the tool, I find it to be useful in a few instances. Usually those difficult cuts that you know can be done with a skew, don't feel comfortable making those cuts with a skew.

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#8

Steven Antonucci

Made one after looking at Dominic's

steve antonucci

>I don't use it a lot, but I do use it. As others have said, when you doubt one tool, it's a safe tool to make most cuts.

I have ground mine very different than most people. I've seen folks here aim for axial symmetry with jigs and such. Mine is actually somewhat like Colin's, in that I have three different facets ground. By rotating the tool to the right facet, I have three different profiles across the top- from "fat" point to "skinny" point and one in between. I can get in tighter spots with Mr. Skinny.

It started as an accident, since I ground the facet on an old belt on the belt sander held in a vice. A piece of O1 from Enco was under $2, and enough to make one for at least 6 people. As others have pointed out, they're easy to make, so I don't know how you'll do selling them.

Steve

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#9

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Bill Neddow

>Doug, please make up a batch. I am one of the people who got a piece of steel from you and made up a 3-point tool. I was curious about how it keep its edge in relation to the two other 3-point tools I have. Well, it holds a FANTASTIC edge for a very long time. The other two tools have been relegated to the bottom drawer. I have all three facets sharpened the same -- a little longer than the commercial ones, and I like the results. However, i am now going to experiment with making the facets at different angles after reading the comments here. I sharpen mine on a 1" x 42" vertical belt sander with no difficulty. I have made a template that lets me set the angle I need on the adjustable table of the sander in seconds. Then I line up the tool facet with the sandpaper as closely as possible and, holding it LOOSELY, push on the handle end of the tool. The tool will rotate in the fingers holding it on the table to perfectly align the flat with the sandpaper. No multiple facets on the face of the tool. I use the tool constantly, on everything from bottle stoppers to 20 inch bowls. I like the finish I get because it is cutting, not scraping. And it is the only tool with which I can finish a bead on the rim of one of those big bowls that starts to go slightly out of round while you are still turning it.

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#10

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Greg Haugen

>Doug,

I have a 1/4" "pyramid" or "point" tool I use a lot for beads and other tiny details on the lids of my boxes or for adding some "rings" to the bottom in which I sign in between. It makes life much easier. It started life as a "round" skew from Bob Rosand, but got a new life and grind. Sorry Bob. :-) It's more useful as a point tool than round skew.

They can be made relatively easily but often in softer steels-drill rod and drill bits. I'd be interested in an A11 since I'm turning more Corian and that dulls M2 as if it was carbon steel. So from that stand point I'd say, "yeah that's a good idea. On the other hand I know some like round skews. The "business side" of my brain says the best option would be to carry 1/4" and 3/8" round blanks-the two popular sizes. The customer can decide if they want it as a point tool or round skew. Plus, that's one less tool that you'll have to grind. Less grinding has to be a good thing. :-)

If I may make one suggestion. I'd like to see a "Thompson 3/16 Diamond Parting." Recently a friend asked about Diamond Parting tools. They mentioned they would just go to "Thompson's". But then later emailed me back saying they were disappointed that there wasn't an option.

Great tools Doug!

Greg Haugen

www.greghaugenwoodturning.com

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#11

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Ed Karch

>Doug

I made a three point from a HHS square bit glued into an O1 drill rod. I use it for detail work and beads on bowl bottoms. I also have a 1/4" round skew that I only use on ornament icesicles and havent done one in the last three years.

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#12

Re: Made one after looking at Dominic's

john lucas

>Steve I like that idea. In fact I like is so much I may make one tonight. I'm thinking about 2 long facets and one skinny facet. This would let me turn long skinny beads. It also might be handy finishing the bottom edge of some things although I tend to use the skew for that.

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#13

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

john lucas

>Ditto what greg said. Just sell the blanks. I also think a diamond parting tool would be a good option.

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#14

Dick Hines

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

Dick Hines

>Doug as long as you keep making those detail gouges who needs a round skew. I used one when i turned finials for ornaments now I use the daitale gouge.

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#15

Steven Antonucci

Out of failure comes opportunity

steve antonucci

>I couldn't see obsessing over making the thing an equilateral pyramid, so I just ground three quick faces with my belt sander until there was a point. Total time: 2 minutes (including putting the sanded in my bench vise and changing off the "good" belt for a beater...)

S

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#16

Yes, make some...

Ron McKinley

>Hi Doug: I've always wanted to try a 3 point so if you make some put me down for one.......Ron

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#17

Thanks, placed the order...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I really don't know much about a 3 point tool except it's basicly a scraper with a point. Maybe at Bill's this next weekend I could get a lesson, I'll bring a few blanks to grind.

Thanks again!

Doug

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#18

Re: Thanks, placed the order...

Greg Haugen

>Doug,

How about a 3/16" diamond parting tool?

Also, here's a nice link on the uses, as well as pros and cons of a 3 point/pyramid point tool.

http://www.davidreedsmith.com/Articles/PyramidPointTool/PyramidPointTool.htm

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#19

You'll be there?

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Doug,

You'll be there? Cool! I look forward to speaking with you at Bills! If you want, I can bring my assortment of 3 point tools with me.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#20

Re: Thanks, placed the order...

john lucas

>Actually I use it like a skew in a lot of cases. I put the point of the tool into the bottom of the bead. Then make sure the flat of the tool is on the side of the bead. This acts as a bevel. Then you pull the tool from the bottom of the bead around to the face keeping the bevel rubbing. The top cuts line a rather blunt skew (60 degree angle) but it does it quite well and it's easy to learn. You can also use it just like a scraper by tilting it so the 60 degree angle is sideways and it scrapes like a skew on it's side in this configuration.

The AAW had a really good short video on how to use the 3 point tool. I hated the tool until I watched the video and learned how he uses it. I tried to find it on the AAW site but they must have taken it off. I may still have a copy if you really want to see how it's used.

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#21

Re: You'll be there?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Dominic, I'll take a lesson and see what this can do, the way I see it now it's a safe way to add small details.

Greg, I have some 1/4 stock I'll do something with. BTW - I want to get on the pen turners site and ask for help making different tools.

John, I'll look for that video.

The boss say's I have to get off the internet...!

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#22

Technically, there's only 1 point and 3 sides.

James McClure

>

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#23

Pyramid tool is a better name :)

john lucas

>

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#24

Steven Antonucci

Technically, Pyramids have 4 sides :-)

steve antonucci

>How about we just call it "a pointed metal rod"?

Steven

Re: OT - Question about a 3 point tool

#25

Technically, it should be called "The Pointy Tool"

Ron in Drums PA

>;-)