Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Oneway commercial

Posts

Oneway commercial

#1

Steven Antonucci

Oneway commercial

steve antonucci

>Last night, the Water Gap Woodturners host an "open mike" night- that is to say- we had no topic for the meeting, or particular plan. The idea was to have someone (me) lead off with a short demo of something (I decided cutting techniques with a bowl gouge) and then have people try it and see where it went from there.

The WGWT meetings are held at the Peters Valley Woodworking Studio. Short of there being no air conditioning (being installed today), it is a studio boasting 8 Oneway lathes. I started on the 1640, but also used a 1220. I have never been so impressed with a lathe as I was with these.

Aside from the smoothness and quietness of the Oneways, I also noticed that there way a ridiculous amount of torque. I couldn't bog the lathe down no matter how heavy of a cut I took. During the "demo", I demonstrate cutting the interior of a bowl one handed to try to get beginners past the "fear" of a catch. I took a one-handed pass on a small 4" bowl that was almost flawless!

I love this lathe. Rock solid. Quiet. Smooth. More power than I expected.

I want one.

Anyone have $4K. Will turn for food?

Steven

Re: Oneway commercial

#2

Re: Oneway commercial

Barou

>Steven,

I agree with you. My 1640 is great; it performs flawlessly with plenty of power and smooth as can be. Believe what you read about the customer service at Oneway - they can't be beat.

Sorry, wish I could help you with the $4K but I'm too busy buying lathe peripherals. Good luck on your quest!

Re: Oneway commercial

#3

Re: Oneway commercial

Mark Strang

>Try the 2436. You'll sell your firstborn son to get one of these. I had a PM 3520B for about a year which was a good upgrade from my Nova 3000 until I tried a friend's Oneway. That was all it took. I got one and never looked back. The price paid doesn't even enter my mind anymore. I cannot explain why it is is so much better but it is. It seems as if everything works in harmony to make turning a real pleasure. I can put a 150 pound unbalanced piece in the unit and the lathe doesn't even know it is there. Sort of like a diesel vs. a gas engine. Lots of torque. Seems to be safer also with the chucks that can be fastened to the hardned spindle with the grub screws, large handles that you can get a grip on to tighten, lots of weight (820 pounds), great speed control, convienent pendant that allows a person to have the controls at their fingertip at all times, etc. No need for me to ever get another lathe. It is better than I will ever be. I will need years and years of additional turning to ever use all of it's features even though I have been trning for 35 years.

Re: Oneway commercial

#4

What size...

Steven Kubien

>...motor did the 1640 have? I ask because it is sort of my list as the next lathe and I wonder if the torque is related to the 1.5 or 2hp motor.

Glad you had fun.

Steve Kubien

the 2436, Stubby s750 and a whoel bunch of others are also on my list but.....

Re: Oneway commercial

#5

Steven Antonucci

Honestly don't know-sorry.

steve antonucci

>I didn't look. My test protocol was simple. When I turn my Nova 3000 Lathe off, I can use my hand to slow the momentum by running it against a chuck or the handwheel (carefully).

When I did that on the oneway, it didn't slow at all and I couldn't stop it. At no point at all while cutting did I notice any degradation in power. This was one either the 1220 or 1640, didn't matter.

Steve

Re: Oneway commercial

#6

When I had the Nova 3000

david

>I would complain to myself about the lathe bogging down turning large pieces of NIP endgrain. What I didn't know or take advantage of until later was I should have changed the belt on the pulleys to get a better mechanical advantage by engaging the smaller pulley on the driving end. Much better after that...

Re: Oneway commercial

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Oneway commercial

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Steve, I teach at Brookfield Craft Center in CT., which has seven 2436 Oneways....lucky me. The instructor model is 3 HP, the rest are 2 HP. Sweet. I turn on a General 26020 VS, which is a dinosaur in comparison, but just as smooth and strong. I'll never get rid of it...after five years, it's an old friend. The Powermatic 24" lathe is a great machine, worth checking out. I'd take a Stubby in a heartbeat, and spoke with Brent English while in Richmond about a custom-made "Tompkins" model Robust....hmmmmm. One can never have enough lathes.

Re: Oneway commercial

#8

Re: Honestly don't know-sorry.

Peter Teubel

>All Oneways have a ramp-down circuit. They will slow at one of two rates (5 sec and 11 sec, I believe). Grabbing the handwheel to slow it down faster does no good whatsoever. When it's set for 5 (or 11) seconds, it takes 5 (or 11) seconds...no more, no less.

Re: Oneway commercial

#9

electronic braking

john lucas

>My powermatic has that as well. I know there is a way to change the time it takes to brake but you have to go through some programs on the inverter. I wish you could do that with a switch so when your turning small stuff you could just turn it off or speed up the brake time. I know the lawyers would have a field day with that when you forget to reset the brake time and a 20" bowl comes unscrewed because the brake was set to 1 second instead of 11.

Re: Oneway commercial

#10

It simplfies things...

Peter Teubel

>The one thing a big Oneway will do for the turner is to simplify everything. No longer do you have to think about overpowering the lathe with an aggressive cut, moving the banjo so more of it is on the bed because it might slip, or cranking the tailstock too much and causing it to creep. Everything works as designed. Tighten the banjo down, and it will NOT move. Tighten the toolrest and it not pivot. Crank away on the tailstock...it will not creep. Put it in low gear and your toolrest will bend before it will stall.

It lets you concentrate 100% on your work/technique. It took awhile before I could afford a Oneway and I had 6 other lathes prior. Needless to say, I've no need to upgrade...ever.

Re: Oneway commercial

#11

Re: Honestly don't know-sorry.

John Kyler

>I thought it was an option on the standard configuration for the breaking?

Re: Oneway commercial

#12

Steven Antonucci

Thanks all

steve antonucci

>I never thought a "better lathe" would make someone a better turner, but after using it, I might change that tune. It wasn't set up for me, and all of the buttons were in the "wrong places" for the way that I turn, but I can tell you that I experienced a finish on my rough cuts that was better than my finish after a finishing cut on my Nova.

I plan on spending some quality time at Bill Grumbine's Robust at Five Barns for comparison, but a plan is already being hatched to cost justify it with the wife and upgrade to something bigger and better.

If not bigger, at least better...

Steve

Having lathe envy for the last 24 hours...

Re: Oneway commercial

#13

Re: Thanks all

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Steve, I had the same plan... the Robust looks like the best lathe on the market. The question is how much power does it really have. When your there I need you to try a tool out to see how it cuts.

Re: Oneway commercial

#14

Re: Honestly don't know-sorry.

john lucas

>Someone will have to correct me but I seem to remember that Oneway did have a switch for 2 different brake settings. Powermatic doesn't. When I programmed the last inverter I installed it had 3 different parameters that all sounded like they did the same thing, electronic braking. I'm not sharp enough to know the differences so I used the one that sounded the most like what I call electronic braking and it seemed to slow the lathe down. You could adjust the rate at which it does this. It's not something you would just do on the fly, you have to go through 3 or 4 steps, like trying to change the time settings on your video camera or something similar.

Re: Oneway commercial

#15

Re: Honestly don't know-sorry.

Peter Teubel

>Nope. It's standard. The option is a braking resistor. The electronic braking circuit basically turns the motor into a generator (actually an alternator). Instead of applying power to the motor, the inertia of the work spinning down spins the motor. The motor can now generate power (electricity) and if a load it placed on it (electrically speaking), it will slow the motor. Of course, you have to dump/dissipate that generated electric power somewhere. Hence the resistor...which gets HOT. Up to a point, the bigger the resister, the greater the braking force.

Re: Oneway commercial

#16

George Balock

Re: Thanks all

George Balock

>Steve,

I also had the Nova 3000 and thought it was a great lathe...until I got my 2436. I think one of the things that makes you a better turner with this lathe is something I heard Dave Lancaster say at a demo, "Vibration is the enemy of the woodturner." Nothin vibrates on this machine unless you want it to. Nuff said.

George